Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

It would last one post, mine, Cayce was a bookseller during his youth, this was after he was a farm labourer and before he decided on a career as a photographer
have a guess at what sort of books he sold
:D

Theological works?
 
Yes. The evidence is that it would not have been possible for him to have the range of knowledge that he had while in trance.
Okay, suppose Cayce was the real deal. So what? He's dead.

Now look at his legacy: the ARE I assume. What are they doing other than adding more "woo" to the marketplace? Do they have any proof of anything to offer? Have they been able to prove any of Cayce's "rewritten history" claims? No. There is no Atlantis that rose. There is no Hall of Records under the Sphinx. So who cares?
 
Theological works?

He was a bookseller at the same time the Theosophical movement was at its height,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theosophy

a lot of his claims were stolen from Blavatsky
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helena_Blavatsky

which included Anthroposophic medicine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthroposophic_medicine
Anthroposophical medicine is a holistic and salutogenetic approach to medicine focusing on strengthening the patient's organism and individuality. The self-determination, autonomy and dignity of patients is a central theme; therapies are intended to enhance a patient's capacities to heal
sounds eerily familiar doesnt it
from the A.R.E. website
Edgar Cayce often recommended specific diets for persons requiring nervous system regeneration. He typically referred to such diets as "nerve and body building" or "nerve and blood building."
snap

;)
 
Last edited:
Okay, suppose Cayce was the real deal. So what? He's dead.

Now look at his legacy: the ARE I assume. What are they doing other than adding more "woo" to the marketplace? Do they have any proof of anything to offer? Have they been able to prove any of Cayce's "rewritten history" claims? No. There is no Atlantis that rose. There is no Hall of Records under the Sphinx. So who cares?
I asked Rodney twice so far. So far, he's done nothing but avoid answering this simple question.
Why should anyone care about this long dead crackpot that left absolutely nothing to medicine and has failed so miserably in his so called prophecies?
 
It would last one post, mine, Cayce was a bookseller during his youth, this was after he was a farm labourer and before he decided on a career as a photographer
have a guess at what sort of books he sold
:D
"Medical Cures they don't want you to know about"?
 
this is for the medically trained posting here, from the following Cayce quotation, please diagnose the illness
"[F]rom the head, pains along through the body from the second, fifth and sixth dorsals, and from the first and second lumbar ... tie-ups here, floating lesions, or lateral lesions, in the muscular and nerve fibers which supply the lower end of the lung and the diaphragm ... in conjunction with the sympathetic nerve of the solar plexus, coming in conjunction with the solar plexus at the end of the stomach...."
Woo Clue : he advised administering apple brandy as a curative
 
Last edited:
this is for the medically trained posting here, from the following Cayce quotation, please diagnose the illness

Woo Clue : he advised administering apple brandy as a curative
Everyone knows that apple brandy is the cure for TB (in this case, that would mean Total B******T)
 
He was a bookseller at the same time the Theosophical movement was at its height,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theosophy

a lot of his claims were stolen from Blavatsky
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helena_Blavatsky

which included Anthroposophic medicine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthroposophic_medicine

sounds eerily familiar doesnt it
from the A.R.E. website

snap

;)

Theosophy,that explains a lot.Why anyone would want to steal from that arch-charlatan Blavatsky is a mystery to me.
 
He was a bookseller at the same time the Theosophical movement was at its height,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theosophy

a lot of his claims were stolen from Blavatsky
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helena_Blavatsky

which included Anthroposophic medicine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthroposophic_medicine

sounds eerily familiar doesnt it
from the A.R.E. website

snap

;)
Nice try, but the bookstore where Cayce worked (Hopper Bookstore in Hopkinsville, Kentucky) for three years was an ordinary one, and probably didn't even carry Blavatsky's books. Rather, as An American Prophet explains, at p. 58: "The store not only carried Charles Darwin, but Henry James, Mark Twain, and Harriet Beecher Stowe. There were Latin and Greek classics, Gilbert and Sullivan operettas, New York Tabloids, and an ever-swellling inventory of dime-store novels . . ."
 
Nice try, but the bookstore where Cayce worked (Hopper Bookstore in Hopkinsville, Kentucky) for three years was an ordinary one, and probably didn't even carry Blavatsky's books. Rather, as An American Prophet explains, at p. 58: "The store not only carried Charles Darwin, but Henry James, Mark Twain, and Harriet Beecher Stowe. There were Latin and Greek classics, Gilbert and Sullivan operettas, New York Tabloids, and an ever-swellling inventory of dime-store novels . . ."
This fella is a failure and left an organization of woo. You haven't answered why anyone should care about this worthless crank yet?
 
Well the patient did die, it was his wife Gertrude

hows that for amazing powers
;)
Wrong again. Cayce gave a series of readings for Gertrude in 1911, when she was diagnosed with tuberculosis. She made a full recovery. According to An American Prophet, at p. 167, a Louisville, Kentucky tuberculosis specialist who was present at Cayce's first reading for Gertrude on August 2, 1911 stated that it was the "most remarkable" discourse he had ever heard on tuberculosis. "Your anatomy is fine . . . your diagnosis is excellent."

Gertrude outlived Cayce by three months, dying of cancer in April 1945.
 
This fella is a failure and left an organization of woo. You haven't answered why anyone should care about this worthless crank yet?
Maybe because no one can explain how he did what he did? If you can explain it, feel free.
 
Maybe because no one can explain how he did what he did? If you can explain it, feel free.
Didn't Cayce explain himself how he did what he did? What did Cayce attribute the origins of his words too?

If he claimed it was God ... well, proving that one should be very easy :)

If he claimed it was the Ahashic records that exist in a sort of universal library of consciousness or whatever ... well access it and prove some stuff from it. If you need to go into a trance like him, go for it. Shouldn't the A.R.E have perfected that technique by now?

If he claimed he was channelling Atlanteans and such ... and you can prove that, go ahead. Show the proof. Is it under the paw of the Sphinx? I'm all game for digging that sucker up. I've seen it in person and I was about as impressed with it as Napoleon supposedly was :)

Again ---- even if Cayce was 100% accurate and the real deal, he is dead. Did he pass his "powers" onto anyone that can prove them under scrutiny?
 
Nice try, but the bookstore where Cayce worked (Hopper Bookstore in Hopkinsville, Kentucky) for three years was an ordinary one, and probably didn't even carry Blavatsky's books. Rather, as An American Prophet explains, at p. 58: "The store not only carried Charles Darwin, but Henry James, Mark Twain, and Harriet Beecher Stowe. There were Latin and Greek classics, Gilbert and Sullivan operettas, New York Tabloids, and an ever-swellling inventory of dime-store novels . . ."

Thats a lie, he worked at a series of bookshops that sold what was popular, and at that time that was theosophy books
Hoppers bookstore actually specialised in occult and osteopathic works one of which "Isis unveiled" (Blavatsky) contained most of the mystical woo crap that Cayce was to spew out later.
http://www.experiencefestival.com/a/Edgar_Cayce_-_Sources_of_Cayces_Beliefs/id/1289375 (a pro cayce webpage admits that much)
now are you lying yourself or is that another lie from the A.R.E.
or do you want to explain how Cayce came up with methods taught by theosophy all on his own ?
sorry, were you going to say that his psychic powers which demonstrate pseudo medicine available in books at the time he was selling them is somehow inexplicable ?
lolol

Wrong again. Cayce gave a series of readings for Gertrude in 1911, when she was diagnosed with tuberculosis. She made a full recovery. According to An American Prophet, at p. 167, a Louisville, Kentucky tuberculosis specialist who was present at Cayce's first reading for Gertrude on August 2, 1911 stated that it was the "most remarkable" discourse he had ever heard on tuberculosis. "Your anatomy is fine . . . your diagnosis is excellent."

Gertrude outlived Cayce by three months, dying of cancer in April 1945.
thats another lie
follow the link
http://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edgar_Cayce#Vagueness
its actually cited on the wiki page as an example of Cayces vagueness
Critics also cite the vagueness of his language while in his supposed trance state. Martin Gardner gives several examples of this, including a reading Cayce did for his own wife, who had tuberculosis:

[F]rom the head, pains along through the body from the second, fifth and sixth dorsals, and from the first and second lumbar ... tie-ups here, floating lesions, or lateral lesions, in the muscular and nerve fibers which supply the lower end of the lung and the diaphragm ... in conjunction with the sympathetic nerve of the solar plexus, coming in conjunction with the solar plexus at the end of the stomach....

Cayce used the word lung, and this his followers take as a correct diagnosis; i.e., a psychic "hit." This technique is called shotgunning. Mrs. Cayce subsequently died of her illness.
just so you know, apple brandy does not cure tuberculosis any more than eating wood cures cancer and the fact that she had a disease thats symptoms are about the most obvious of all the pathogens that infect mankind shows that any claims made for Cayce being a miraculous diagnostician were rubbish, a 5 year old could diagnose TB which at that time in the US was more common than the common cold.

It was a year after her death in 1946 with the development of the antibiotic streptomycin that effective treatment and cure became possible. Prior to the introduction of this drug, the only treatment besides sanatoria were surgical interventions, there was no known cure
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuberculosis

so thats all you have, two A.R.E. sponsored lies
I'm going to start a new thread in a couple of days to show you how the A.R.E. are lying everyday for profit (note the spelling, not prophet)
i'll message you a link when I've done it
;)
 
Last edited:
Yes. The evidence is that it would not have been possible for him to have the range of knowledge that he had while in trance.

But his knowledge wasn't particularly remarkable. It reflects the sort of knowledge that was used at the time in the practice of medicine - now discredited ideas about the spinal column and nerve roots when he worked with an osteopath, now discredited ideas about magic water when he worked with a homeopath, the sorts of remedies which we now know to be largely ineffective, and the sort of often wrong ideas about physiology and pathology that reflected our own ignorance generally and his ignorance specifically. If he'd had some sort of pipeline to specialized knowledge, we would see something different from the sorts of things that a lay-person with a spotty knowledge base overlaid with a disregard for falsity that his streams-of-consciousness utterings produced.

That his range of knowledge reflected (poorly) only the knowledge of the day is what makes him unremarkable, not remarkable.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom