Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

Don't know. Do you have any citation beyond what you regurgitate from your Bible? Are you now going to use the "hey cayce didn't get sued/houdini never exposed Cayce therefore he must be super magic man" argument again are you?
So what did this nobody do again for anyone to care?
Apparently, in September 2000, Virginia Beach Mayor Meyera Oberndorf didn't think Cayce was a nobody because she proclaimed an "Edgar Cayce Day." See http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-65314310.html. With regard to Houdini, even if he didn't meet Cayce (and, what, do you think Sidney Kirkpatrick made that up?), why didn't Houdini show the world how easy it would be to do what Cayce did? Cayce had been written up in several newspapers, including The New York Times, by 1921, so why didn't Houdini expose Cayce the way he exposed so many other apparent practitioners of the paranormal?
 
Five pages? I'm bone lazy. Did anybody ask about Cayce's MANY :rolleyes: hits? ANY hits?
 
Apparently, in September 2000, Virginia Beach Mayor Meyera Oberndorf didn't think Cayce was a nobody because she proclaimed an "Edgar Cayce Day."
And you cannot see why a MAYOR might want to draw in the money of the rubes people who believe in Cayce by announcing a day celebrating the town's favorite con artist?

ETA: Remember that Virginia Beach has been a tourist trap since the late 19th century.

ETAA, since many people cannot add 2+2: It is in the financial interest of the City of Virginia Beach, which bases its economy on tourists, to draw in as many suckers tourists as possible, especially in September, which is after the vacation rush but before the climate gets so bad that the vendors move to Florida.
 
Last edited:
Maybe because no one can explain how he did what he did? If you can explain it, feel free.

He faked at going into a trance, and made up "readings" about people whose names were given to him and offered a bunch of silly pseudo-medical advice.

There. It's explained.

However, I should point out yet again that even if we couldn't explain something (what Cayce did for example), it would still not argue in favor of any explanation, including the paranormal one. That is the fallacy of the argument from ignorance.
 
Apparently, in September 2000, Virginia Beach Mayor Meyera Oberndorf didn't think Cayce was a nobody because she proclaimed an "Edgar Cayce Day." See http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-65314310.html. With regard to Houdini, even if he didn't meet Cayce (and, what, do you think Sidney Kirkpatrick made that up?), why didn't Houdini show the world how easy it would be to do what Cayce did? Cayce had been written up in several newspapers, including The New York Times, by 1921, so why didn't Houdini expose Cayce the way he exposed so many other apparent practitioners of the paranormal?
And Stephen Colbert was given the keys to the city of Charlotte, NC. So what?

Rodney ... will you admit to any errors that Cayce made?
 
Trentwray, are you expecting the current pope to tell publicly that marys virgin immaculate conception is a made up story to push an agenda?
 
Last edited:
Perhaps he had the sort of range of knowledge that could have been obtained through, say, a few years worth of browsing in bookshops, followed by some time associating with osteopaths or homoeopaths?

It seems the claim that he couldn't have that range of knowledge is equivalent to saying he never read a book.
 
Apparently, in September 2000, Virginia Beach Mayor Meyera Oberndorf didn't think Cayce was a nobody because she proclaimed an "Edgar Cayce Day." See http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-65314310.html. With regard to Houdini, even if he didn't meet Cayce (and, what, do you think Sidney Kirkpatrick made that up?), why didn't Houdini show the world how easy it would be to do what Cayce did? Cayce had been written up in several newspapers, including The New York Times, by 1921, so why didn't Houdini expose Cayce the way he exposed so many other apparent practitioners of the paranormal?

Why not ask Houdini?

You know, go to sleep go into a trance and check the Records. The A.R.E should have this down pat by now.
 
He faked at going into a trance, and made up "readings" about people whose names were given to him and offered a bunch of silly pseudo-medical advice.
There. It's explained.
So Cayce was a fraud? If so, why do you suppose Martin Gardner did not come to that conclusion?

However, I should point out yet again that even if we couldn't explain something (what Cayce did for example), it would still not argue in favor of any explanation, including the paranormal one. That is the fallacy of the argument from ignorance.
If something can't be explained through normal means, what conclusion should be drawn?
 
If something can't be explained through normal means, what conclusion should be drawn?

you have yet to give one example of anything that cannot be explained
until you do that, theres nothing to talk about,
;)
 
Knowledge that enabled Cayce to successfully treat individuals who had not been treated successfully by medical doctors.

you have provided no evidence that that ever happened from an unbiased source, so again, until you do, theres nothing to talk about
;)
 
Oh, Linda, we've been through this many times: The Amy Dietrich case, the Tommy House case, his wife's case, Dr. Wesley Ketchum relying in large part on Cayce's diagnoses to treat patients, etc.

What I mean is, his activities are pretty mundane. Even if you buy the idea that the knowledge existed but there's no way that Cayce could have obtained it, or that the knowledge didn't exist at that time, there isn't anything particularly miraculous about treating disease. If Cayce had been an MD, no one would have taken his activities as paranormal, even if he was having success with novel treatments. What he did would have been considered normal and mundane if it had been performed by someone else. Compare this to something like levitation, where the activity is remarkable no matter who undertakes it.

Why show interest in someone whose only claim to fame is that he seems to have skills that you would expect to see in others?

Linda
 
you have yet to give one example of anything that cannot be explained
until you do that, theres nothing to talk about,
;)
I've mentioned several cases that I don't think can be realistically explained through normal means. But even if you disagree, I'm still interested in exploring JoeTheJuggler's general point that, "even if we couldn't explain something (what Cayce did for example), it would still not argue in favor of any explanation, including the paranormal one."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom