Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

so are you going to deny that the A.R.E. lies to the public now like you did earlier ?
because that would be just another lie wouldn't it
why don't you just admit it, you were wrong to join this organisation and fund their lies to the public, having to admit that they were lying the whole time would show very clearly that you were one of the gullible people taken in, so your claim that they werent lying was told for the sole reason of a face saving exercise on your part
and quite frankly thats disgusting. its just the same as giving your full support to Sylvia Browne when you found out she was lying, and you did that too for a while didnt you
:(

now in light of this you should go back and read my posts which you said were insulting, you'll find that theyre not insults, theyre accurate descriptions of your behaviour

1. Your posts do contain insults.
2. If I were worried about "face saving" in this regard I would not be here openly posting as ExMinister, admitting to and willing to discuss one of the stupider choices I have made in my life in order to try to help keep others from doing the same.
3. If I cared about "face saving" I would not be here admitting to having once been a big Cayce fan.
4. Your accusation of me continuing to support Browne after I found out she was lying is what is actually disgusting. That type of personal attack against my character IS something I care about, though I hesistate to respond to you since it seems to accomplish nothing more than encourage you to insult me further.
5. I would rather poke myself in the eye with a sharp stick than re-read any of your above posts.

EM decided not to comment did you, theres a surprise
:rolleyes:

Save your surprise. Your posts to me in this thread are just not worth commenting on, with the exception of the genetic material, which I found of interest. If you wish to attack my arguments, that's fine and welcome. If you wish to provide me with evidence to look at, that's nice, too. If you continue to insist on attacking me personally, I will try to ignore you as much as possible. If you choose to address me like an adult in the future and quit with the insults, I'll be happy to respond to you again.

Obviously you have that backwards, A.R.E. haven't published anything that shows that the treatments don't work; Therefore they do.

Step right up folks, everyone's a winner!

Good point. Funny, too.

Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

:D

He failed to heal his own wife and infant son; both died.

http://www.indopedia.org/Edgar_Cayce.html

Orphia, this is all good. I just want to point out that he did not fail to heal his wife, as mentioned earlier in the thread. He was already dead when she died with cancer a short while later. I only mention this in case there are any Cayce fans lurking who will catch this discrepancy.

So what? None of the relevant information was collected or made available. In most cases of harm (other than fairly obvious poisonings), discovery requires the careful collection of information and access to that information, neither of which was the case for Cayce's cases.

Linda

There is one thing I've taken away from this thread so far, and that is the point you and Pax have made about how dangerous it is to promote unproven cures that could potentially be dangerous.

That's such an important point. People like Jenny McCarthy, with her anti-vax claims, and Suzanne Somers, with her cancer claims, get my blood pressure up, that sort of thing makes me so mad. Homeopathy and chiropractry can also get my blood boiling.

I had not thought of it in terms of what Cayce's followers are doing. It strikes me that medicine and medical cures are especially risky in this sense. If Cayce were providing nothing more than spiritual inspiration, I suppose that could be construed as harmless enough (though I suppose we could debate that, too), but when it involves medicine and the treatment of medical illness, it's so much more risky. Whether it interferes with a person seeking the right kind of medical treatment for their cancer, simply wastes their time (which obviously with some cancers can be a big deal), or has undesired side effects, it's a big risk, and therefore actually potentially very harmful.
 
There is one thing I've taken away from this thread so far, and that is the point you and Pax have made about how dangerous it is to promote unproven cures that could potentially be dangerous.

That's such an important point. People like Jenny McCarthy, with her anti-vax claims, and Suzanne Somers, with her cancer claims, get my blood pressure up, that sort of thing makes me so mad. Homeopathy and chiropractry can also get my blood boiling.

I had not thought of it in terms of what Cayce's followers are doing. It strikes me that medicine and medical cures are especially risky in this sense. If Cayce were providing nothing more than spiritual inspiration, I suppose that could be construed as harmless enough (though I suppose we could debate that, too), but when it involves medicine and the treatment of medical illness, it's so much more risky. Whether it interferes with a person seeking the right kind of medical treatment for their cancer, simply wastes their time (which obviously with some cancers can be a big deal), or has undesired side effects, it's a big risk, and therefore actually potentially very harmful.
What pisses me off is the complete and utter refusable to accept any responsibility for their actions and claims. When I recommend or prescribe a treatment, it is MY responsibility to make sure it is safe and effective. It is MY responsibility if they are harmed by it.

Cayce supporters who go about recommending unproven treatments from a irrelevant nobody are unethical and irresponsible.
 
I had not thought of it in terms of what Cayce's followers are doing. It strikes me that medicine and medical cures are especially risky in this sense. If Cayce were providing nothing more than spiritual inspiration, I suppose that could be construed as harmless enough (though I suppose we could debate that, too), but when it involves medicine and the treatment of medical illness, it's so much more risky. Whether it interferes with a person seeking the right kind of medical treatment for their cancer, simply wastes their time (which obviously with some cancers can be a big deal), or has undesired side effects, it's a big risk, and therefore actually potentially very harmful.

I agree. I think that unless you see things in perspective, you don't really see how unlikely it is that something might work. How often do we hear the excuse, "why not try it? It's not going to hurt you and it just might work?" On its face, that doesn't sound unreasonable. But we don't really picture a 1 in 10,000 chance of it working - maybe more like 1 in 2 or 1 in 10. And we don't really picture something harming us by doubling our risk of heart disease or being responsible for the kidney or liver failure which finally shows up 6 months to a year from now. We picture a more immediate, more obvious effect. When you put it in the perspective of what the evidence shows us we can really expect, then it becomes more apparent that this advice is unconscionable.

Linda
 
Your posts to me in this thread are just not worth commenting on, with the exception of the genetic material, which I found of interest.

Youre quite right of course, I did go too far and if anything I said personally upset you then I apologise and withdraw the comment, I do get far too vitriolic sometimes and I'm sorry you got the brunt of it. I do realise that youve come a long way and thats commendable. Youre "righteous" now as they say
;)



but you gotta admit now that the A.R.E. does lie to the public, thats the only sticking point I have with you. Claiming they don't in the face of evidence to the contrary is support for their methods, in the same way standing up and saying "I believe Sylvia" is support for her, in my opinion the A.R.E. is far worse than Sylvia could ever be, in a way you can imagine if Sylvia happened to be in the position that Edgar Cayce was now and an organisation grew up around her protecting her errors and lying about her successes, thats exactly what the A.R.E. is
A dangerous woo organisation that lies to protect a criminal

and as you may have noticed, it pisses me off that people don't see that. You were getting hit by the mud I was slinging at them, best not to stand next to them in future eh

I hope this post means we can sort out our differences. I am certainly willing to try

cheers
Steve
 
Youre quite right of course, I did go too far and if anything I said personally upset you then I apologise and withdraw the comment, I do get far too vitriolic sometimes and I'm sorry you got the brunt of it. I do realise that youve come a long way and thats commendable. Youre "righteous" now as they say
;)



but you gotta admit now that the A.R.E. does lie to the public, thats the only sticking point I have with you. Claiming they don't in the face of evidence to the contrary is support for their methods, in the same way standing up and saying "I believe Sylvia" is support for her, in my opinion the A.R.E. is far worse than Sylvia could ever be, in a way you can imagine if Sylvia happened to be in the position that Edgar Cayce was now and an organisation grew up around her protecting her errors and lying about her successes, thats exactly what the A.R.E. is
A dangerous woo organisation that lies to protect a criminal

and as you may have noticed, it pisses me off that people don't see that. You were getting hit by the mud I was slinging at them, best not to stand next to them in future eh

I hope this post means we can sort out our differences. I am certainly willing to try

cheers
Steve


Thank you, Marduk/Steve. I would be happy to try to sort out our differences.

I have gone back and re-read your post #408, the one that I found so offensive at the end (apology accepted) that I did not even bother to go back to carefully read what you had said at the top. This time, with that out of the way, I have focused on the haplogroup claims of Greg Little.

By the way, it is very helpful to have it broken down the way you did. I work 10-hour days and don't always have time to immediately go and do that kind of thing myself. At any rate, I do see now what you mean about his claims seeming to be outright lies, especially with the difference being tens of thousands of years and even the locations being a misrepresentation of the facts.

You said you have quite a few more examples and I'd be interested in seeing those, too. And if you have the time to break them down that way, it is very helpful.

Thanks again for the kind words. :)

ExM
 
Last edited:
Orphia, this is all good. I just want to point out that he did not fail to heal his wife, as mentioned earlier in the thread. He was already dead when she died with cancer a short while later. I only mention this in case there are any Cayce fans lurking who will catch this discrepancy.
Like being dead is an excuse for not healing her!? Pshaw!
 
And we don't really picture something harming us by doubling our risk of heart disease or being responsible for the kidney or liver failure which finally shows up 6 months to a year from now.
Let me know when you find even a shred of evidence that any of Cayce's treatments ever caused these problems.
 
Let me know when you find even a shred of evidence that any of Cayce's treatments ever caused these problems.
Let me know when you find even a shred of evidence that any of Cayce's treatments ever worked and is safe.

Until then, your continued propagation of quackery is truly disgusting.
 
Let me know when you find even a shred of evidence that any of Cayce's treatments ever caused these problems.

Why? Without any way to consider his treatments different from any other unselected treatment, it would only make already abyssmal advice worse, not better. You should be asking me to let you know when I find some evidence that Cayce's treatments were safe, instead. And I think that could be done, as some of what he recommended (in particular, some of his dietary recommendations I should think) probably have enough safety data now to make that call. I'm not inclined to do it, but it seems like a reasonable project for someone with access to his readings.

Linda
 
That's it? Out of all of the hundreds (thousands?) of readings this modern day prophet made in the decades that he was active, that was the best example you could find? OK let's look at it:
Who had the prophetic dream? Was it Cayce? No, it was a Stockbroker. The Stockbroker also gave his own interpretation. "SELL, SELL, SELL!!!" OK. Not looking too good for your mate Edgar...


Then Cayce agrees with the stockbroker that he should sell everything including the box stock.

How in the name of the seven green pygmies of justice can you see this kind of thing as special, paranormal or prophetic? Did he warn anybody else about the approaching stock market crash and global depression? Just this one guy? This one guy who actually already saw the writing on the wall and was thinking of selling up anyway?

That's pathetic, not prophetic.


I don't know why BobR resurrected this thread, but I want to thank him for it.

I don't remember making the above post. Damn it made me laugh though.

He was a funny bastard that Brainache.

Whatever happened to him?


I think I need Wolfman's Doctor's number...
 
I don't know why BobR resurrected this thread, but I want to thank him for it.

I don't remember making the above post. Damn it made me laugh though.

He was a funny bastard that Brainache.

Whatever happened to him?


I think I need Wolfman's Doctor's number...
Ya got me. Cayce's errors are well known, so... What about 'em?
 
Thanks very much for the information, but I disagree that the chance that animated ash would work for at least lung cancer (the reading quoted on the A.R.E. website pertained to lung cancer) is as remote as your statistics would dictate. Why? Because (a) Cayce operated in a unique manner and many reputable individuals -- including medical doctors -- attested to his success rate; and (b) None of his treatments have been subject to controlled tests, and so you have no basis to assign a probability with respect to those treatments.

Now, if there were many individuals who operated in the same manner as Cayce (including similar testimonials to their success rates) and dozens of their treatments had been tested without success, I would agree with you. But there is no such baseline. So, perhaps none of Cayce's treatments will prove efficacious, but perhaps all of them will. We just don't know.

Did Rodney ever explain why none of these "doctor-attested" cures have ever been subject to controlled testing?

ETA:
My bad.
Post #402 implies that Rodney does not know why Cayce's treatments were never tested in a controlled manner.
 
Last edited:
Also searching those books does not show Cayce mentioned Bimini...
An oft-quoted Cayce reading says "A portion of the temples may yet be discovered under the slime of ages and sea water near Bimini…Expect it in ’68 or ’69 — not so far away."

As to whether the Bimini road discovered in '68 is evidence of temples in Atlantis, well, no. :)
 
As for why I resurrected this thread, I put something in, realized I was necroposting, tried to delete it, found I couldn't, and here we are.
 
I believe the thread topic is important enough to warrant the occasional resurrection.
 
An oft-quoted Cayce reading says "A portion of the temples may yet be discovered under the slime of ages and sea water near Bimini…Expect it in ’68 or ’69 — not so far away."

As to whether the Bimini road discovered in '68 is evidence of temples in Atlantis, well, no. :)

Does the exact quote go even further by predicting 68 & 69 as being the time when Parts of Atlantis a actually rise?

Poseidia [i.e. the sunken lands off the islands of the Bahamas and Caribbean] will be among the first portions of Atlantis to rise again. Expect it', he said, 'in sixty-eight and sixty-nine; not so far away!'
-Not yet confirmed as an accurate quote​
 
As for why I resurrected this thread, I put something in, realized I was necroposting, tried to delete it, found I couldn't, and here we are.

Another mystery solved.

It's good you did though, I like old jokes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom