Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

Trentwray, are you expecting the current pope to tell publicly that marys virgin immaculate conception is a made up story to push an agenda?
Only if he can share in Dan Brown's profits ...

Yeah, Check the Askatic Records.
Are those online yet? :)

Knowledge that enabled Cayce to successfully treat individuals who had not been treated successfully by medical doctors.
Like when my mother would make me blow my nose when I had a cold and drink OJ? She must have been a walking prophet ...

Rodney: will you admit to any failures on Cayce's part at all?
 
i've mentioned several cases that i don't think can be realistically explained through normal means. But even if you disagree, i'm still interested in exploring joethejuggler's general point that, "even if we couldn't explain something (what cayce did for example), it would still not argue in favor of any explanation, including the paranormal one."
unexplained=unexplained
unexplained=/=magic
 
I've mentioned several cases that I don't think can be realistically explained through normal means. But even if you disagree, I'm still interested in exploring JoeTheJuggler's general point that, "even if we couldn't explain something (what Cayce did for example), it would still not argue in favor of any explanation, including the paranormal one."

theres several names for that argument, God of the Gaps/argument from ignorance are the ones that spring readily to mind
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance
thats where for instance someone sees something that they can't explain and jumps to a paranormal explanation as the only possible answer.
Most commonly this is seen with Ufos, someone sees a light in the sky that they can't explain, so before they think about venus, or aircraft, or atmospheric phenomena they jump straight to aliens.

of course whats actually happening is that they have seen something that they can't explain with the data they have at their disposal, this does not make the light they saw an alien spacecraft anymore than your inability to see the truth makes Cayce a psychic

Common sense dictates that until you have all the facts an identification should remain in limbo, but the mistake that you are making is in thinking that the source for your information, namely the A.R.E. are telling the truth

they aren't as I will prove to you, and if they arent anything that seems unexplained is immediately discredited because its actually fraud for profit.

Your problem Rodney is in thinking that if you accept the new data I provide you with as factual and decide that Cayce is nothing to write home about that people will judge you badly for believing it in the first place. They won't as most of the critical thinkers here were once woo believers who have had the strength of character to finally smell the BS and know what it is when they smell it.

That is called progress.
;)
 
Last edited:
I've mentioned several cases that I don't think can be realistically explained through normal means. But even if you disagree, I'm still interested in exploring JoeTheJuggler's general point that, "even if we couldn't explain something (what Cayce did for example), it would still not argue in favor of any explanation, including the paranormal one."

It's an informal logical fallacy called the appeal to ignorance.

Just because we don't know why something works, doesn't argue that any explanation is correct. For many years, for example, we didn't know the cause of lightning. That ignorance did not argue in favor of ANY explanation. It was merely ignorance.

It is very similar to the God of the Gaps type of arguments. (Or rather, I would say the God of the Gaps is one type of appeal to ignorance.)

But it doesn't matter, because with Cayce there's nothing that we can explain through ordinary means. (And coming up with an anecdote or two where he seemed to hit spot on in an extremely unlikely way doesn't cut it either. We can explain how extremely improbable things happen given enough chances. Further, Cayce's "errors" demonstrate clearly that he wasn't doing what he claimed to be doing.)
 
unexplained=unexplained
unexplained=/=magic

Same thing I was trying to say, but much pithier.

ETA: And I see Marduk also beat me to it.

What I find troublesome, is that I'm fairly certain this is not Rodney's first exposure to this concept.
 
Successfully treating individuals with life-threatening conditions after unsuccessful treatment by medical doctors is mundane?

Yes. I do it all the time as do other doctors.

If it had been me that told the stories of Tommy House, Aime Dietrich or Gertrude Cayce, would you believe that I had paranormal abilities?

Linda
 
Yes. I do it all the time as do other doctors.

If it had been me that told the stories of Tommy House, Aime Dietrich or Gertrude Cayce, would you believe that I had paranormal abilities?

Linda

You mean. . . .doctors. . . .DON'T???!!!! :eek:


;)
 
Yes. I do it all the time as do other doctors.

If it had been me that told the stories of Tommy House, Aime Dietrich or Gertrude Cayce, would you believe that I had paranormal abilities?

Linda
I've done it a few times as well. Diagnosed a lady presenting with headaches and weakness with chronic Carbon Monoxide poisoning after it was missed by her primary doctor, 2 other ER doctors and a neurologist.

What paranormal ability do I have?
 
Yes. I do it all the time as do other doctors.

If it had been me that told the stories of Tommy House, Aime Dietrich or Gertrude Cayce, would you believe that I had paranormal abilities?

Linda

I know you asked this of Rodney, but I just want to point out that if you did this without having gone to medical school it might seem a little more odd. :)

Cayce wasn't a doctor. It seems to me that Cayce became newsworthy in his time because people could not figure out how a man with little formal education and no medical training (which is what he claimed) could go into a trance and successfully treat diseases that even the doctors of the time in some cases could not treat.
 
I've done it a few times as well. Diagnosed a lady presenting with headaches and weakness with chronic Carbon Monoxide poisoning after it was missed by her primary doctor, 2 other ER doctors and a neurologist.

What paranormal ability do I have?
You are a duck with a stethoscope and a twinkling eye ... that's pretty spiffy :)

And on a similar note, I suppose that when ACLS drugs aren't enough to do the trick it takes "paranormal hands of the Akashic Records" to perform chest compressions (outside the body, directly over the third shakra and above the holding place for apple-brandy!!!!) and RESURRECT THE DEAD !!!!
 
Cayce wasn't a doctor. It seems to me that Cayce became newsworthy in his time because people could not figure out how a man with little formal education and no medical training (which is what he claimed) could go into a trance and successfully treat diseases that even the doctors of the time in some cases could not treat.
Was it even ever verified if Cayce was in a genuine "trance"-like state, and if it was, how was it?
 
I know you asked this of Rodney, but I just want to point out that if you did this without having gone to medical school it might seem a little more odd. :)

Cayce wasn't a doctor. It seems to me that Cayce became newsworthy in his time because people could not figure out how a man with little formal education and no medical training (which is what he claimed) could go into a trance and successfully treat diseases that even the doctors of the time in some cases could not treat.

We have no evidence that he ever treated anyone succesfully that isn't both anecdotal and directly from the A.R.E.
they are the only documentary source

don't you think thats a little odd ?


and Would these be people who couldn't afford medical treatment or insurance then ?
i.e. poor uneducated people who didn't know any better
 
Last edited:
I know you asked this of Rodney, but I just want to point out that if you did this without having gone to medical school it might seem a little more odd. :)
Odd? You mean how his "medical knowledge" seems strangely limited to the medical knowledge of its time? I'd be amazed if he started using his powers to treat an easily treatable fatal genetic diseases like PKU.
Cayce wasn't a doctor. It seems to me that Cayce became newsworthy in his time because people could not figure out how a man with little formal education and no medical training (which is what he claimed) could go into a trance and successfully treat diseases that even the doctors of the time in some cases could not treat.
What diseases and what treatment?
 
Odd? You mean how his "medical knowledge" seems strangely limited to the medical knowledge of its time?
Just to correct you there, his medical knowledge seems strangely limited to the beliefs of 30 years before his time.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthroposophic_medicine
You may have heard about the "wonder" cures they used to effect in Switzerland around the same period, it was the same type of complimentary medicine which today we call quackery
They way that the A.R.E. scores it is to record every example of someone getting better as "due to Cayce" and if they died "due to not getting Cayce quick enough", so its win win for them on every case

;)

And I'm an unsinkable.
thats why there were no Ducks on Noahs Ark, they were the only creature that doesnt need God to save them from a flood.

:p
 
Last edited:
Was it even ever verified if Cayce was in a genuine "trance"-like state, and if it was, how was it?

Yes and no. It's an anecdote, a story told many times in various books in which he claims to have been tested by some Medical Society, where a group of physicians sliced into one of his fingernails and did a few other things that he did not respond to while in trance but hurt like heck when he awoke. (Please don't ask me to find that source, it will take me awhile! It's a story told several times in various books)

We have no evidence that he ever treated anyone succesfully that isn't both anecdotal and directly from the A.R.E.
they are the only documentary source

don't you think thats a little odd ?

No, not odd. Unfortunate, though, for anyone trying to build a solid case that Cayce had paranormal abilities. Assuming he was at least sincere, I don't suppose he had much reason to think he needed affidavits and such at the time (IIRC he had one from the Dietrich case, but I think that was it).

Odd? You mean how his "medical knowledge" seems strangely limited to the medical knowledge of its time? I'd be amazed if he started using his powers to treat an easily treatable fatal genetic diseases like PKU.
What diseases and what treatment?

Well yes, in the case of PKU odd would be an understatement. As far as diseases, I'm referring to the cases he was well known for, such as those Rodney mentioned. Regarding those cases, I wonder what the diagnoses might have been had they been assessed by a physician in 2010. At any rate, it's all stories. How can we know anything for certain about Cayce, beyond what has been written about him and what he wrote himself half a century ago? We have only the word of Cayce and those close to him to go by, and that's about all we can discuss in a thread like this. It's either sufficient to allow one to believe he had paranormal abilities, or it's not.
 
Last edited:
No, not odd. Unfortunate, though, for anyone trying to build a solid case that Cayce had paranormal abilities. Assuming he was at least sincere, I don't suppose he had much reason to think he needed affidavits and such at the time (IIRC he had one from the Dietrich case, but I think that was it).

Khufu didn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Julius Cesar didn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Houdini didn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Randi doesn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Its not unfortunate, to anyone familiar with doing research on any subject its very suspicious, with anecdotal evidence being the worst kind there is as well, it makes Cayces achievements more folklore than documented.

Think about how many other paranormal claims you would take seriously if only documneented by one source
crop circles
Ufos
Miracles

now remember that the one source you are relying on is heavily biased towards the paranormal
how credible is your source now ?

this is whats known as critical thinking, if you arent using it when attempting to analyse a claim you're not analysing anything but your own "belief"
;)
 
Last edited:
Khufu didn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Julius Cesar didn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Houdini didn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Randi doesn't need affidavits yet his work is documented from numerous sources

Its not unfortunate, to anyone familiar with doing research on any subject its very suspicious, with anecdotal evidence being the worst kind there is as well, it makes Cayces achievements more folklore than documented.

Think about how many other paranormal claims you would take seriously if only documneented by one source
crop circles
Ufos
Miracles

now remember that the one source you are relying on is heavily biased towards the paranormal
how credible is your source now ?

this is whats known as critical thinking, if you arent using it when attempting to analyse a claim you're not analysing anything but your own "belief"
;)


Please explain what you mean by documentation, as in the examples you list above.

Do you mean documentation by contemporaries at that time in history? Books written by the individual themselves? Other?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom