Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

It is a random sample of 150 of his readings - 65 of the reports are positive, 11 negative and for 74 there are no reports. 'Positive' means that the diagnosis was accurate and following the instructions was helpful.

Linda
Oh, so it's nothing more than a satisfaction survey.
 
BTW:
Who is this stockbroker and what corporation now bears his name?
Morton Blumenthal. No corporation bears his name, possibly because he chose to disregard his intuition and Cayce's advice. Blumenthal didn't fare too well during the 1929 stock market crash, although it's unclear how much money he lost.

Why didn't Cayce use his superpowers on the stockmarket on himself to make millions?
First, I don't think prophecy was Cayce's strongest suit, but he did seem to nail the stock market decline pretty well for Blumenthal. Second, Cayce never was very successful when he was trying to use his paranormal ability to make money for himself. I'm sure that suggests to you and most others here that he did not really have any paranormal ability, but you have to look at the entirety of his voluminous record before you pass judgement.
 
Hence my use of data from patient satisfaction surveys for comparison.

Linda

and the 74 for which there were no reports ?
why werent there any
if this was a satisfaction survey for a real doctor, wouldnt the absence of more than half the data raise an eyebrow ?
 
What is the difference between Cayce and a common or garden woo merchant?
 
And again, most quacks have pretty high "patient" satisfaction. In a way, what many of them are really selling is a willingness to listen sympathetically to people with really screwed up ideas of how their bodies work.

It's irrelevant, though, to the question of whether or not their claims are valid.

That's why medicine relies on things like randomized, placebo controlled, double blind studies to measure effectiveness of treatments.

ETA: So again, Rodney, do you believe Cayce had paranormal powers? If so, what is the evidence of those powers? (Lack of lawsuits and patient satisfaction figures do NOT comprise evidence of the paranormal abilities Cayce claimed.)
 
Last edited:
Morton Blumenthal. No corporation bears his name, possibly because he chose to disregard his intuition and Cayce's advice. Blumenthal didn't fare too well during the 1929 stock market crash, although it's unclear how much money he lost.
So one of your best evidence for a supposed prophecy was someone who did not follow Cayce's supposed prophecy?

First, I don't think prophecy was Cayce's strongest suit, but he did seem to nail the stock market decline pretty well for Blumenthal. Second, Cayce never was very successful when he was trying to use his paranormal ability to make money for himself. I'm sure that suggests to you and most others here that he did not really have any paranormal ability, but you have to look at the entirety of his voluminous record before you pass judgement.
What record?
We've figured out that he is irrelevant to medicine and is in fact harmful, according to you is also useless at prophecy and is also ineffectual at using his own powers for himself. What record is there?
 
Rodney, do you believe Cayce had paranormal powers (as he claimed)? If so, what is the evidence for them?
Yes. The evidence is that it would not have been possible for him to have the range of knowledge that he had while in trance.
 
and the 74 for which there were no reports ?
why werent there any
if this was a satisfaction survey for a real doctor, wouldnt the absence of more than half the data raise an eyebrow ?

Yes. It is likely that the group who chose not to send back a report would differ from those who did, and that these differences would likely depend upon the accuracy and usefulness of the given advice.

Linda
 
and the 74 for which there were no reports ?
why werent there any
if this was a satisfaction survey for a real doctor, wouldnt the absence of more than half the data raise an eyebrow ?
Not really. Most surveys will be lucky to get 60% back. But is isn't really relevant. Satisfaction surveys tend to survey a customer's satisfaction at how their EXPECTATIONS were met.

Woo believers with vague cold readings will have their expectations met.
 
would you like me to prove to you that the A.R.E. are in the business of lying to the public or not ?
Yes, and be sure to use an even larger colored font next time so that the whole wide world will be convinced. ;)

P.S. Proving "that the A.R.E. is in the business of lying to the public" will not necessarily prove that Cayce was either a fraud or deluded, but please have a go at it anyway.
 
P.S. Proving "that the A.R.E. is in the business of lying to the public" will not necessarily prove that Cayce was either a fraud or deluded, but please have a go at it anyway.
Yes. His lack of results is evidence enough.
 
Yes. The evidence is that it would not have been possible for him to have the range of knowledge that he had while in trance.

Ok are you aware of what Cayce did for a living before he became a fraudulent doctor ?

P.S. Proving "that the A.R.E. is in the business of lying to the public" will not necessarily prove that Cayce was either a fraud or deluded, but please have a go at it anyway.
thats the A.R.E. the company that you pay to read what they let you. How can you possibly say that it wouldn't prove that Cayce was a fraud, its his operation, are you going to claim it fell into unscrupulous hands after his death, its controlled by his family. So I could prove that his sons are a fraud and that the information they are letting people read was fraudulent and that the people they employ are fraudulent

but you wouldn't then reconsider your opinion of the only one of the lot who was actually convicted of a fraudulent crime

what planet are you from ?
:D
 
Last edited:
I'm saying that no one could have done what he did either fraudulently or by unconsciously regurgitating the knowledge he had assimilated.
We've concluded and closed the topic of OP of this thread and concluded that Cayce was worthless at prophecy.

Would you like to start a new thread at his supposed super-knowledge?
 
Yes. The evidence is that it would not have been possible for him to have the range of knowledge that he had while in trance.

I see no such proof of the claim that he had a range of knowledge that was inexplicable.

Did that "range of knowledge" include all the silly prescriptions we've been mentioning? He seems to be a storehouse of "folk wisdom" but his medical knowledge is not at all inexplicable.

At any rate, even if you prove he had knowledge that we couldn't explain (and you haven't proven any such thing), you're still just making an argument from ignorance. Our inability to explain something does not support the assertion that he had paranormal abilities.

So again, what's your evidence? (I assume now that you are at least saying that you do believe he had paranormal abilities, despite your reluctance to give a straight answer to the question.)
 
I'm saying that no one could have done what he did either fraudulently or by unconsciously regurgitating the knowledge he had assimilated.

That's absurd. And it's merely begging the question.

In other words, you're basically arguing thusly:

I believe Cayce had paranormal abilities.
I don't think anyone could do whatever Cayce did without having paranormal abilities.
Therefore Cayce had paranormal abilities.
 
We've concluded and closed the topic of OP of this thread and concluded that Cayce was worthless at prophecy.

Would you like to start a new thread at his supposed super-knowledge?

It would last one post, mine, Cayce was a bookseller during his youth, this was after he was a farm labourer and before he decided on a career as a photographer
have a guess at what sort of books he sold
:D
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom