Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

Cayces claims for a Hall of Records under the Sphinx were debunked
By his number one son Hugh Lynn



get that, his best work was in healing people, which theres no evidence he ever did from an unbiased source, which if it was true would be overwhelming. Whats actually true is that most of his remedies were baloney (or gelatin)
IMO his best work is as a figurehead for a woo organisation that makes its money from gullible people like Rodney.

I've met a few A.R.E. members before, they all have that smug superiority that comes from being spoon fed cherry picked evidence without the critical thought present which would allow them to analyse it

That smug superiority comes from knowing that god likes you, he really, really likes you.
 
Then I'm sure you will enjoy this on-topic Cayce prediction, which was given to a stockbroker on April 6, 1929. (Reading 137-117). The stockbroker requested an interpretation of a disturbing dream he had regarding warring factions on the Federal Reserve Board:

6. (Q) How are these factions divided?
(A) Materially, these are divided between those that would hold the Federal Reserve board as the criterion for activity and those that would use the moneys in the various centers for activity as related to the market. As individuals, these are members not so much of the board - for the board (Federal Reserve Board) is itself divided upon the issue; individuals who have had an IDEAL as to the functioning of the board being on the one side and those that would USE the ABILITIES of the board on the other, and these are fostered - EACH side - by money powers. BUT, were these to be allowed to run without a check in EITHER direction, there must surely come a break where it would be PANIC in the money centers - not ONLY of Wall Street's activity but a closing of the boards in many centers, and a re-adjustment of the actual specie and moneys in these centers. Then, while these variations and these changes may be expected - hence high and low quotations will continue for MANY moons - while these adjustments are being made - INDUSTRIALS, as has been given, being the leads in the high and low variations, rather than those of some other commodities.
__________________________________________________________________________

You may have read in a history book about a little bit of "PANIC in the money centers" in October 1929.

Seems a bit lacking on specifics.
 
:)
The enema of my enema is my friend ... ;)

The red dye in red foods (i.e. popsicles, jello, etc) can leave behind a residual coloring which tint the colon wall and appear like blood. Not consuming them is part of the colonoscopy pre-prep in general, regardless of the use of GoLytely ...

Not consuming anything is part of the pre-prep.
 
#62, #66 etc
I was thinking ofasking Rodney why he was so keen on Cayce's sayings being true, so was interested to find the reason.:)
 
#62, #66 etc
I was thinking ofasking Rodney why he was so keen on Cayce's sayings being true, so was interested to find the reason.:)

well hed look a bit stupid paying the A.R.E. for membership now if he accepted that hed been ripped off wouldnt he (mind you he did get a nice calendar worth $12.99). Far easier for his sense of self to pretend that everyone else in this thread is wrong and hes the only one who has it right. Lets not forget, because Cayce said eating raw wood was a cure for cancer Rodney demanded that someone discredit it to prove Cayce was wrong. Theres a word for that.......anyone
:p

I wonder if he likes Sylvia Brown and Uri Geller too, someone ask him eh
:D


The A.R.E. to this day are perpetuating lies and falsehoods, this is easily proven, Rodney isn't interested in that truth, the fact that they are perpetuating lies and falsehoods which can clearly be seen on their biggest money making venture doesn't leave Rodney and the poor saps paying for "special" access CD's in a very credible or tenuous position as theyre down at the other end of the spectrum.
 
Last edited:
#62, #66 etc
I was thinking ofasking Rodney why he was so keen on Cayce's sayings being true, so was interested to find the reason.:)

Yeah, I have to admit this has piqued my curiosity as well. Why latch onto Cayce? What distinguishes his arbitrary sayings from those of others?

Linda
 
Then I'm sure you will enjoy this on-topic Cayce prediction, which was given to a stockbroker on April 6, 1929. (Reading 137-117). The stockbroker requested an interpretation of a disturbing dream he had regarding warring factions on the Federal Reserve Board:

6. (Q) How are these factions divided?
(A) Materially, these are divided between those that would hold the Federal Reserve board as the criterion for activity and those that would use the moneys in the various centers for activity as related to the market. As individuals, these are members not so much of the board - for the board (Federal Reserve Board) is itself divided upon the issue; individuals who have had an IDEAL as to the functioning of the board being on the one side and those that would USE the ABILITIES of the board on the other, and these are fostered - EACH side - by money powers. BUT, were these to be allowed to run without a check in EITHER direction, there must surely come a break where it would be PANIC in the money centers - not ONLY of Wall Street's activity but a closing of the boards in many centers, and a re-adjustment of the actual specie and moneys in these centers. Then, while these variations and these changes may be expected - hence high and low quotations will continue for MANY moons - while these adjustments are being made - INDUSTRIALS, as has been given, being the leads in the high and low variations, rather than those of some other commodities.
__________________________________________________________________________

You may have read in a history book about a little bit of "PANIC in the money centers" in October 1929.

I don't understand the format. Who asked the question and who supplied the answer? Am I to assume that a banker who had a dream was asking a professed psychic about the differing factions on the Fed? My first response is to ask whether there really were warring factions and if it was publicly known? If so, then your quote is not evidence of psychic ability.


Secondly, was this prediction given to anyone other than the stockbroker? I would assume that someone who foresaw the destruction of the American economy would be trying to get the word out to everyone. Are there a lot of public statements documenting Cayce's prediction?

Thirdly, there were people who had absolutely no psychic ability that were recommending getting out of the market in 1929. The amount of stock purchased on margin measured in the billions. If you are going to convince me of Cayce's psychic powers, I'll need a much better example than this one.
 
Last edited:
If I write enough prophecies, especially with the usual wording, the odds are that some might later interpreted as correct by my followers.

So, what about picking all his prophecies and checking the % of the accomplished ones? Do not forget to select unbiased criteria and a repeatable methodology based on them.
 
Oh for pitys sake. This is from the Edmonton Sun ...this event took place here this weekend in Edmonton. I think this is the same reporter who wrote a story about the high end french inn where I am a chef...she wrote about the hauntings there....I will try and find a link there as well....but this is the old medicine show type stuff that I mentioned earlier. Are we regressing as a society?

http://www.edmontonsun.com/news/edmonton/2010/03/07/13148096.html

Here is the report of the haunting that attracked the woo

http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/WeirdNews/2009/11/06/11655451-sun.html

This is the Inn if you want to browse around.....you wont see a ghost lol

http://www.laboheme.ca/
 
Last edited:
Huh?

Linda
In Post # 55, you stated, regarding Cayce's claimed satisfaction rate of 85 percent: "If you consider that the average doctor fares much better than Cayce (patient satisfaction surveys tend to return rates of satisfaction rates in excess of 90 percent - often 99 percent), Cayce's rate starts to look remarkably poor."

To which I replied in Post # 56: "You would need to do an apples to apples comparison, which would not be easy. Again, many of Cayce's clients sought him out only after conventional medicine had failed them."

To which you replied in Post # 79: "I agree. When looking specifically at cases where the diagnosis has been uncertain, the patient satisfaction drops to 90 percent."

So, you seemed to be suggesting that patient satisfaction for comparable cases is 90% for the average doctor vs. 85% for Cayce.
 
Again, can't we leave off irrelevant arguments (how many lawsuits, percentage of patient "satisfaction" and the like) and cut right to the chase:

Rodney, do you believe Cayce had paranormal powers (as he claimed)? If so, what is the evidence for them?

The number of lawsuits and "patient" satisfaction (even though no scientific polling for satisfaction was done for Cayce, so all you've got is some kind of reconstruction) is NOT evidence of the claim.

For example, if I ask a believer in astrology if he or she is satisfied with the reading he or she just bought from the astrologer, the answer doesn't say anything about the validity of the claims of astrology. All it says is whether or not the believer was satisfied.

ETA: Note: this goes both ways. Even if the majority of Cayce's "patients" were dissatisfied with the reading, it doesn't offer any evidence for or against the validity of his claims. It's basically an appeal to popularity.
 
Last edited:
Why no answer Rodney?

he's cherry picking which posts to respond to in the same way that hes cherry picking which words of Cayce's to attach extra but unfounded meaning to. He hasn't responded to a single of my on topic questions preferring to ask new questions off topic questions based on his misunderstanding of psychic woo methods. I bet hes a big John Edward fan too

this probably answers your earlier question about "why Cayce"
two peas in a pod
:D
 
In Post # 55, you stated, regarding Cayce's claimed satisfaction rate of 85 percent: "If you consider that the average doctor fares much better than Cayce (patient satisfaction surveys tend to return rates of satisfaction rates in excess of 90 percent - often 99 percent), Cayce's rate starts to look remarkably poor."

To which I replied in Post # 56: "You would need to do an apples to apples comparison, which would not be easy. Again, many of Cayce's clients sought him out only after conventional medicine had failed them."

To which you replied in Post # 79: "I agree. When looking specifically at cases where the diagnosis has been uncertain, the patient satisfaction drops to 90 percent."

So, you seemed to be suggesting that patient satisfaction for comparable cases is 90% for the average doctor vs. 85% for Cayce.

Ah, I didn't read your post as saying that.

I am simply pointing out that Cayce's results don't seem meaningful. Also, the 85 percent only applies to half of the readings - there are no reports on the remainder (good or bad).

Linda
 
I am simply pointing out that Cayce's results don't seem meaningful. Also, the 85 percent only applies to half of the readings - there are no reports on the remainder (good or bad).
I wouldn't even give Cayce that.
What information is there for where this 85% was pulled from or generated?
 
I wouldn't even give Cayce that.
What information is there for where this 85% was pulled from or generated?

thats figures quoted by the A.R.E.
circular isn't it
there is no external evidence for any information about Cayce except that he was a convicted criminal. All his readings are tightly controlled by the A.R.E. who only make them available to members.

I know, its slap your forehead time that the sheep don't know what they are isnt it
:D

now Rodney, third time I've asked you this and people have seen you ignore the offer each time

would you like me to prove to you that the A.R.E. are in the business of lying to the public or not ?
big red letters so you cant later claim you didnt read it

ignore it this time and your Cayce credibility is over, I will simply link any future conversation you have about Cayce at this forum to this post to show that you, like the A.R.E and Cayce have no interest at all in the truth. Their motives are actually more understandable than yours, they lie for the money, whats your excuse ?
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't even give Cayce that.
What information is there for where this 85% was pulled from or generated?

It is a random sample of 150 of his readings - 65 of the reports are positive, 11 negative and for 74 there are no reports. 'Positive' means that the diagnosis was accurate and following the instructions was helpful.

Linda
 
It is a random sample of 150 of his readings - 65 of the reports are positive, 11 negative and for 74 there are no reports. 'Positive' means that the diagnosis was accurate and following the instructions was helpful.

Linda

a random sample from where ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom