Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

Does anyone out there know of any astronomical (as in obvious) errors in Edgar Cayce's psychic predictions and/or prophecy?

Also, I've heard about Cayce's prediction that in the 1960s, China would be a Christain nation. I was just wondering if this prediction was actually made by Cayce himself.

Thanks in advance.

For completeness sake, I did finally find the quote about China as I said I would. So the answer is yes the prediction was made by Cayce, but no he didn't say it would happen in the 1960s:

"This, here, will one day be the cradle of Christianity as applied in the lives of men. Yea, it is far off as man counts time but only a day in the heart of God - for tomorrow China will awake."
 
Except the example you provided is no more valid than claiming a stopped clock is "right" twice a day.

Similarly, Sylvia Browne correctly predicted the year Pope John Paul II would die. Of course, a great many other people expected his death that year, since he was old and frail. Also, Browne wrongly predicted his death for several other years. So her correctly predicting JPII's death was not really an example of getting a prediction (by paranormal powers) right.

(And dropzone used the term "prophecy" which I take to mean a prediction made by some sort of paranormal means.)
Regarding prophecy, how do you distinguish paranormal from non-paranormal means?

ETA: By the way, what do you base your belief in Cayce's paranormal abilities on? I have asked this several times before. Unless I missed something, your only response is an argument from ignorance (and a poor one at that, since we can explain everything Cayce did by mundane abilities).
The doctors Cayce worked with disagree with that assessment. The first one, Wesley Ketchum, stated in a pamphlet that he authored after his retirement that Cayce accurately diagnosed several cases that had baffled Ketchum. Ketchum concluded that "some of the things that he did were so uncanny you would scarcely believe them." See The Discovery of Edgar Cayce, A.R.E. Press, Virginia Beach, VA, 1964, at 17.
 
The first one, Wesley Ketchum, stated in a pamphlet that he authored after his retirement that Cayce accurately diagnosed several cases that had baffled Ketchum.


I'm not surprised. Ketchum was a homoeopath.

By the way, if the cases "baffled" Ketchum, he is probably not the best person to judge whether they were accurately diagnosed.
 
Regarding prophecy, how do you distinguish paranormal from non-paranormal means?
Aye, there's the rub.

How do you -- who claim paranormality about information available mundanely -- distinguish paranormal from non-paranormal means?
 
Aye, there's the rub.

How do you -- who claim paranormality about information available mundanely -- distinguish paranormal from non-paranormal means?
If the information is available mundanely, I assume that it was not obtained paranormally. For many of Cayce's medical readings, the information was not available mundanely.
 
If the information is available mundanely, I assume that it was not obtained paranormally. For many of Cayce's medical readings, the information was not available mundanely.

thats right, no one else was reccomending eating wood as a cancer cure
:D
 
If the information is available mundanely, I assume that it was not obtained paranormally. For many of Cayce's medical readings, the information was not available mundanely.
And how do you know that?
What information are you talking about?
 
And how do you know that?
What information are you talking about?
For example, at pp. 12-14 of The Discovery of Edgar Cayce, Dr. Ketchum describes a case where a Hopkinsville, KY construction worker named Jenkins collapsed, and Ketchum was called in to treat him. Ketchum says that he had no idea what the problem was, and so he called upon Cayce. Cayce diagnosed it as pellagra -- a severe case of malnutrition. That proved to be correct, although it was too late to save Jenkins. However, Ketchum spread the word to other Kentucky doctors about pellagra, and that led to a number of other individuals being successfully treated for that disease. One of these doctors, whom Ketchum knew personally (a Dr. Board), read a paper on the diagnosis of pellagra to the Kentucky Medical Society.
 
For example, at pp. 12-14 of The Discovery of Edgar Cayce, Dr. Ketchum describes a case where a Hopkinsville, KY construction worker named Jenkins collapsed, and Ketchum was called in to treat him. Ketchum says that he had no idea what the problem was, and so he called upon Cayce. Cayce diagnosed it as pellagra -- a severe case of malnutrition. That proved to be correct, although it was too late to save Jenkins.
Really? How? Because the stupid fella who couldn't diagnose a well known disease said so?

When did this event supposedly occurred and what was Cayce's supposed treatment for Pellagra and its underlying cause?
However, Ketchum spread the word to other Kentucky doctors about pellagra, and that led to a number of other individuals being successfully treated for that disease. One of these doctors, whom Ketchum knew personally (a Dr. Board), read a paper on the diagnosis of pellagra to the Kentucky Medical Society.
And why is this "diagnosis" not available through mundane means? Pellagra has been known since the late 1700s and was endemic throughout the entire south.
 
Last edited:
If the information is available mundanely, I assume that it was not obtained paranormally.
Then you must assume none of Cayce's readings were paranormal.

Rodney said:
For many of Cayce's medical readings, the information was not available mundanely.
You have shown none. The pellagra example you give, even if true, shows nothing that is not available mundanely.
 
Then you must assume none of Cayce's readings were paranormal.

You have shown none. The pellagra example you give, even if true, shows nothing that is not available mundanely.
Dr. Ketchum is clear that neither he nor Dr. Board had ever heard of pellagra until Cayce's diagnosis of Mr. Jenkins, and that Cayce linked pellagra to diet. Ketchum does not specify the year of this diagnosis, but it had to be prior to January 1912 because that's when he left Kentucky. Now consider what Wikipedia has to say about when pellagra was linked to diet:

"In the early 1900s, pellagra reached epidemic proportions in the American South. There were 1,306 reported pellagra deaths in South Carolina during the first ten months of 1915; 100,000 Southerners were affected in 1916. At this time, the scientific community held that pellagra was probably caused by a germ or some unknown toxin in corn. The Spartanburg Pellagra Hospital in Spartanburg, South Carolina, was the nation's first facility dedicated to discovering the cause of pellagra. It was established in 1914 with a special congressional appropriation to the U.S. Public Health Service (PHS) and set up primarily for research. In 1915, Joseph Goldberger, assigned to study pellagra by the Surgeon General of the United States, showed that pellagra was linked to diet by inducing the disease in prisoners, using the Spartanburg Pellagra Hospital as his clinic." (emphasis added) See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pellagra

So, even if Cayce somehow had read about pellagra prior to Drs. Ketchum and Board, how did he know no later than January 1912 that it was related to diet, rather than to a germ or toxin, which was the prevailing conventional wisdom prior to 1915?
 
Dr. Ketchum is clear that neither he nor Dr. Board had ever heard of pellagra until Cayce's diagnosis of Mr. Jenkins, and that Cayce linked pellagra to diet. Ketchum does not specify the year of this diagnosis, but it had to be prior to January 1912 because that's when he left Kentucky. Now consider what Wikipedia has to say about when pellagra was linked to diet:

"In the early 1900s, pellagra reached epidemic proportions in the American South. There were 1,306 reported pellagra deaths in South Carolina during the first ten months of 1915; 100,000 Southerners were affected in 1916. At this time, the scientific community held that pellagra was probably caused by a germ or some unknown toxin in corn. The Spartanburg Pellagra Hospital in Spartanburg, South Carolina, was the nation's first facility dedicated to discovering the cause of pellagra. It was established in 1914 with a special congressional appropriation to the U.S. Public Health Service (PHS) and set up primarily for research. In 1915, Joseph Goldberger, assigned to study pellagra by the Surgeon General of the United States, showed that pellagra was linked to diet by inducing the disease in prisoners, using the Spartanburg Pellagra Hospital as his clinic." (emphasis added) See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pellagra

So, even if Cayce somehow had read about pellagra prior to Drs. Ketchum and Board, how did he know no later than January 1912 that it was related to diet, rather than to a germ or toxin, which was the prevailing conventional wisdom prior to 1915?
Excellent. You've conceded that the pellagra itself is entirely mundane which leaves only the cause of it.

Let's assume that you're correct about no one anywhere at the time of the diagnosis knowing the actual cause.

Let's further assume that it happened exactly as your anecdote indicates.

Both of these are large assumptions, but let's go with it.

Answer these questions for me:

How many disease causes did Cayce come up with during his career?

How many were correct?

Most importantly: How many did he say were diet related?
 
Dr. Ketchum is clear that neither he nor Dr. Board had ever heard of pellagra until Cayce's diagnosis of Mr. Jenkins, and that Cayce linked pellagra to diet. Ketchum does not specify the year of this diagnosis, but it had to be prior to January 1912 because that's when he left Kentucky. Now consider what Wikipedia has to say about when pellagra was linked to diet:

"In the early 1900s, pellagra reached epidemic proportions in the American South. There were 1,306 reported pellagra deaths in South Carolina during the first ten months of 1915; 100,000 Southerners were affected in 1916. At this time, the scientific community held that pellagra was probably caused by a germ or some unknown toxin in corn. The Spartanburg Pellagra Hospital in Spartanburg, South Carolina, was the nation's first facility dedicated to discovering the cause of pellagra. It was established in 1914 with a special congressional appropriation to the U.S. Public Health Service (PHS) and set up primarily for research. In 1915, Joseph Goldberger, assigned to study pellagra by the Surgeon General of the United States, showed that pellagra was linked to diet by inducing the disease in prisoners, using the Spartanburg Pellagra Hospital as his clinic." (emphasis added) See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pellagra

So, even if Cayce somehow had read about pellagra prior to Drs. Ketchum and Board, how did he know no later than January 1912 that it was related to diet, rather than to a germ or toxin, which was the prevailing conventional wisdom prior to 1915?

Sorry Rodney. My search of my old medical texts (from 1880 to 1926) reveals that it was recognized that pellagra was associated with diet (although maybe mediated through a toxin or germ) and that the usual treatment was to change the diet.

To quote The Home Physician:

"The treatment of this disease is chiefly dietetic...The liberal use of milk, eggs, green vegetables, fresh fruits, cereal products made of the entire grain, and peas and beans used in the form of purees, will give excellent results in dealing with these cases."

Linda
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
You know.

This speaks very very badly to Ketchum and Board's reliability as to Cayce's medical diagnostic skills when some layperson could read a book and describe a disease that was getting popular in the medical psyche of the time and they could not; doesn't it?
 
For completeness sake, I did finally find the quote about China as I said I would. So the answer is yes the prediction was made by Cayce, but no he didn't say it would happen in the 1960s:


Thanks! Now back to that quote:
"This, here, will one day be the cradle of Christianity as applied in the lives of men. Yea, it is far off as man counts time but only a day in the heart of God - for tomorrow China will awake."

It sounds like Edgar Cayce is painting a huge target on a barn. Basically, what he is saying is that, "Someday, sometime, ten days, months, years or centuries from now there's be some more Christians in China". It doesn't really sound like much of a prediction.

I could say the same thing about Iran turning to a non-religious or Christian or Hindu etc. state, "Sometime down the road, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad will die (just like any other mortal, like you need a psychic or prophet for that!) and the new king will throw out the old order and replace it with the new one (insert desired philosophy/religion here)".

If Cayce really did make this claim, then I'm starting to have some real doubt towards his psychic abilities (I know that other form members have pointed out this medical quackery, diagnosis on patients who were already dead etc. but this bit is a gold mine for me).
 
Last edited:
Sorry Rodney. My search of my old medical texts (from 1880 to 1926) reveals that it was recognized that pellagra was associated with diet (although maybe mediated through a toxin or germ) and that the usual treatment was to change the diet.

To quote The Home Physician:

"The treatment of this disease is chiefly dietetic...The liberal use of milk, eggs, green vegetables, fresh fruits, cereal products made of the entire grain, and peas and beans used in the form of purees, will give excellent results in dealing with these cases."

Linda
What year are you quoting from?
 
Infamous and well publicized pellagra outbreaks from 1906-1907 in the United States.
http://www.jstor.org/pss/30075020
1906-1907? Your link says 1910.

Link between Pellagra and corn published in the Journal of the AMA in February 1910
http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/summary/LIV/6/452
This conclusion is dead wrong: "It is not good maize or good maize flour which produces pellagra; the disease requires for its production the habitual use of damaged maize in some form." That hypothesis is the one Dr. Goldberger discredited in 1915. Further, according to Ketchum, Cayce specifically linked pellagra to malnutrition.

Notice how his diagnosis seems strangely related to the pop diseases and to the knowledge of its time.
So yes Rodney, Cayce could read a book before 1912.
How mundane.
In what book before 1912 was pellagra linked to malnutrition?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom