Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

Why? There is no more reason to think this treatment would work than any of a hundred or a thousand folk/Chinese/ancient Greek/witchdoctor/random stuff I pulled out of my ass treatments. Considering that it will take decades, maybe even centuries, and millions of dollars to test them all, with almost no chance of reward, how do you choose where to start? You've decided to start with the 'C's', but you've never explained why.
About a decade ago, six individuals participated in a study that adhered to Cayce recommendations regarding psoriasis, with five reporting substantial improvement, and one dropping out. See http://www.meridianinstitute.com/psorias5.html. Also, I'm sure you will be interested in the one and only post of "Lurking" on the Randi Forums:*
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1518201&postcount=20

* To answer your question; no, I do not know "Lurking." ;)
 
I notice nobody has risen to my challenge to provide a well-documented, before the fact, example of Cayce having gotten a SINGLE prophecy RIGHT. There should be many, as the OP asks, "Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?"
 
About a decade ago, six individuals participated in a study that adhered to Cayce recommendations regarding psoriasis, with five reporting substantial improvement, and one dropping out. See http://www.meridianinstitute.com/psorias5.html.

Only two of the six people fulfilled the minimum standard for a clinically relevant improvement (at least a 50% reduction in PASI score, preferably 75%) and those two had mild/very mild disease to begin with. Despite attempts to misrepresent the data, a careful reading of the case studies shows you that substantial improvement was not seen by all five, especially taking subjective perceptions highly influenced by suggestion into account.

Patients on placebo in RCT's can also see substantial improvement, even though they are not receiving treatment. Here is an example where 50% (i.e. a greater percentage than was seen in your case series) showed improvement.

http://ard.bmj.com/content/63/6/718.abstract

And for psoriasis alone (taking into account relative severity of disease):

35% improvement in placebo group:
http://archderm.highwire.org/cgi/content/full/139/6/719#FIGDST20199F2

Also, I'm sure you will be interested in the one and only post of "Lurking" on the Randi Forums:*
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1518201&postcount=20

* To answer your question; no, I do not know "Lurking." ;)

I saw that post the first time round. I remember that I had a lot of sympathy for that poor physician who had to try to keep a straight face when Lurking bombarded him with nonsense.

Linda
 
Last edited:
I notice nobody has risen to my challenge to provide a well-documented, before the fact, example of Cayce having gotten a SINGLE prophecy RIGHT. There should be many, as the OP asks, "Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?"
So you don't think Cayce stating to a stockbroker on March 5, 1929 that there would be a "downward movement of a long duration" in the stock market qualifies as a well-documented prediction? See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5693973&postcount=97
 
So you don't think Cayce stating to a stockbroker on March 5, 1929 that there would be a "downward movement of a long duration" in the stock market qualifies as a well-documented prediction? See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5693973&postcount=97

Actually, Rodney, I hate to burst your bubble (OK, I lied) but this "proof" of yours has been nagging at me since I first read it a day or two ago. As a finance major one of my college classes delved deeply into the history of the market and I can dimly remember the professor discussing The Federal Reserve issuing warnings about possible calamity many months before the crash. My work schedule is heavy right now but I seem to recall from the class that the Fed was not the only voice sounding alarm in the winter of 1929, so I'm sure when I have the time I'll be able to find other examples.

This much I remember, and it was easy to track down - on February 2nd, 1929, the Fed met and issued warnings to their member banks that stocks were perched precariously on a thin bubble and action needed to be taken to stave off disaster. On Feb. 7 they issued another warning to the general public. There are many links to this Fed action, here's an excerpt from one such -

http://wallstreetwhiz.com/crash.html

"During 1929, the Call Market was being flooded with funds from several corporations. In early 1929, loans from non-banking sources equaled and later surpassed, loans from banks. On February 2, 1929, the Reserve Board, recognizing Broker's loans had gone too high issued a statement to individual Reserve banks regarding their position on speculative loans and insisted that Federal Reserve credit not be used for speculative purposes. On February 7, 1929, another statement, this time warning the public, was released by the board stating their concern for their ability to accommodate normal commerce and business activities. This resulted in an immediate break in the market. This action had only a temporary effect which reversed itself in early March. " [bolding mine]

So the Fed issued a public statement on February 7th which rattled the market. How clever of Cayce to notice this subtle occurrence!

Sorry, dude, in February of 1929 warning bells were sounding all over the place and the Fed had gone out of it's way to warn the public on February 7, 1929. Cayce's "special knowledge" would have come from picking up any newspaper in the weeks before his "prescient warning" to his client.
As I have said, the Fed was not the only predictor of gloom and doom at the time - I may still have my notes from that long ago class, I'll pull that box out and see what I have.

I'm not a Cayce expert, but after reading this I went to the A.R.E. site out of curiosity. They list this stock market "prediction" as a top "hit" for their boy. I find their lack of disclosure regarding the Fed's prior warning and the unstable February market conditions as extremely disingenuous. In fact, they are either unforgivably lazy (in their research) or outright liars.
 
So you don't think Cayce stating to a stockbroker on March 5, 1929 that there would be a "downward movement of a long duration" in the stock market qualifies as a well-documented prediction?

No.

I also don't consider psychic predictions of earthquakes and such to be of any consequence either.
 
Actually, Rodney, I hate to burst your bubble (OK, I lied) but this "proof" of yours has been nagging at me since I first read it a day or two ago. As a finance major one of my college classes delved deeply into the history of the market and I can dimly remember the professor discussing The Federal Reserve issuing warnings about possible calamity many months before the crash. My work schedule is heavy right now but I seem to recall from the class that the Fed was not the only voice sounding alarm in the winter of 1929, so I'm sure when I have the time I'll be able to find other examples.

This much I remember, and it was easy to track down - on February 2nd, 1929, the Fed met and issued warnings to their member banks that stocks were perched precariously on a thin bubble and action needed to be taken to stave off disaster. On Feb. 7 they issued another warning to the general public. There are many links to this Fed action, here's an excerpt from one such -

http://wallstreetwhiz.com/crash.html

"During 1929, the Call Market was being flooded with funds from several corporations. In early 1929, loans from non-banking sources equaled and later surpassed, loans from banks. On February 2, 1929, the Reserve Board, recognizing Broker's loans had gone too high issued a statement to individual Reserve banks regarding their position on speculative loans and insisted that Federal Reserve credit not be used for speculative purposes. On February 7, 1929, another statement, this time warning the public, was released by the board stating their concern for their ability to accommodate normal commerce and business activities. This resulted in an immediate break in the market. This action had only a temporary effect which reversed itself in early March. " [bolding mine]

So the Fed issued a public statement on February 7th which rattled the market. How clever of Cayce to notice this subtle occurrence!

Sorry, dude, in February of 1929 warning bells were sounding all over the place and the Fed had gone out of it's way to warn the public on February 7, 1929. Cayce's "special knowledge" would have come from picking up any newspaper in the weeks before his "prescient warning" to his client.
As I have said, the Fed was not the only predictor of gloom and doom at the time - I may still have my notes from that long ago class, I'll pull that box out and see what I have.

I'm not a Cayce expert, but after reading this I went to the A.R.E. site out of curiosity. They list this stock market "prediction" as a top "hit" for their boy. I find their lack of disclosure regarding the Fed's prior warning and the unstable February market conditions as extremely disingenuous. In fact, they are either unforgivably lazy (in their research) or outright liars.

And now for an alternative opinion: "The Roaring Twenties, the decade that led up to the Crash, was a time of wealth and excess, and despite caution of the dangers of speculation, many believed that the market could sustain high price levels. Shortly before the crash, economist Irving Fisher famously proclaimed, 'Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau.'" See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wall_Street_Crash_of_1929

The problem with your logic is that, if the public as a whole had believed the stock market was seriously overbought in February 1929, the crash would have occurred then. But the market merely had a slight downturn at that time and then recovered to new highs in September.
 
And now for an alternative opinion: "The Roaring Twenties, the decade that led up to the Crash, was a time of wealth and excess, and despite caution of the dangers of speculation, many believed that the market could sustain high price levels. Shortly before the crash, economist Irving Fisher famously proclaimed, 'Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau.'" See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wall_Street_Crash_of_1929

The problem with your logic is that, if the public as a whole had believed the stock market was seriously overbought in February 1929, the crash would have occurred then. But the market merely had a slight downturn at that time and then recovered to new highs in September.

So are you saying that because only some people heeded the Federal Reserve warnings that it's reasonable to presume that Cayce wasn't one of them?

Linda
 
Also, what if Cayce had predicted the market was going to go down and stay down and it hadn't happened? Would we just ignore that prediction and focus on one that happened to be right?

Sorry, Rodney, there is no evidence of Cayce having paranormal abilities. There is, in fact, evidence that he did not. (And that goes beyond the argument that it's not reasonable to assume Cayce has paranormal abilities since such an explanation is unnecessary.)
 
Actually, that is a BEAUTIFUL example! Guy who has been reading the newspaper makes an obvious "prediction" that is set to come true on some undetermined future date but because he's a "mystic" his shills tout it as a special big coup. Lordy, lordy, Alan Greenspan is a mystic, too!

This is the sort of tripe woo-ists bring to the party. Maybe it's disguised as menudo and maybe as andouille, but it's still tripe.
 
And now for an alternative opinion: "The Roaring Twenties, the decade that led up to the Crash, was a time of wealth and excess, and despite caution of the dangers of speculation, many believed that the market could sustain high price levels. Shortly before the crash, economist Irving Fisher famously proclaimed, 'Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau.'" See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wall_Street_Crash_of_1929

The problem with your logic is that, if the public as a whole had believed the stock market was seriously overbought in February 1929, the crash would have occurred then. But the market merely had a slight downturn at that time and then recovered to new highs in September.

And where in my "logic" did I say that everyone heeded the Fed's advice and lived happily ever after?

You're grasping at straws here, Rodney. Man up and admit that Cayce's advice required no special knowledge, no uber-human talent. Cayce read the newspapers. He read an assessment of the market's health and drew the right conclusions. He then parroted the fed's warning to a client.

And by the way, where did you get the idea that "if the public as a whole had believed the stock market was seriously overbought in February 1929, the crash would have occurred then"?
Do you know how long the market was seriously overbrought just in the past decade? Years. And there were many voices warning that the bubble would eventually burst, just like in 1929. But people stayed in, didn't they? Just like in 1929. Funny how the recent past completely contradicts your assertion. Warnings were issued , people ignored them, the market continued to soar, reached 14,000, then dropped like a stone to half it's value and many people lost their shirts. Even though they were warned.
 
So are you saying that because only some people heeded the Federal Reserve warnings that it's reasonable to presume that Cayce wasn't one of them?

Linda

What I'm saying is that, however the stock market is doing at any given moment in time, there are bulls and bears. The question for any investor is, should I be in or out of the market? For the most part, the best strategy is to buy and hold, rather than jump in and out. The biggest exception to that strategy in the United States is what happened between September 3, 1929 and July 8, 1932, when the Dow Jones Industrials fell more than 89%, despite a number of bear market rallies. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stock_market_crash_of_1929

Sure, there were reasons to be worried in March of 1929, just as there were reasons to be worried both before and after then. But the bottom line is that the market continued to rally strongly between that time and September 3, 1929, which sucked a lot of investors back in. Ironically, that appears to be what happened to stockbroker Morton Blumenthal, for whom the reading was given. Despite his own interpretation of his dream -- that he should sell everything, including what he considered to be a very safe ("box") stock -- and Cayce's clear warning that there would be "a downward movement of a long duration, gradually sliding off, with fitful conditions of sudden rises and drops . . . not allowing, then, those that apparently even are VERY safe, too much latitude . . . dispose of all those held - even those in box" -- Blumenthal couldn't quite believe there would be a stock market crash, what with the market making new highs throughout the summer of 1929.
 
And where in my "logic" did I say that everyone heeded the Fed's advice and lived happily ever after?

You're grasping at straws here, Rodney. Man up and admit that Cayce's advice required no special knowledge, no uber-human talent. Cayce read the newspapers. He read an assessment of the market's health and drew the right conclusions. He then parroted the fed's warning to a client.

And by the way, where did you get the idea that "if the public as a whole had believed the stock market was seriously overbought in February 1929, the crash would have occurred then"?
Do you know how long the market was seriously overbrought just in the past decade? Years. And there were many voices warning that the bubble would eventually burst, just like in 1929. But people stayed in, didn't they? Just like in 1929. Funny how the recent past completely contradicts your assertion. Warnings were issued , people ignored them, the market continued to soar, reached 14,000, then dropped like a stone to half it's value and many people lost their shirts. Even though they were warned.
SonOfLaertes, you appear to be one of the innumerable stock market analysts who can predict what will happen -- after it's happened. Again, Irving Fisher -- the most prominent economist of his time -- was confident that the stock market would continue to rally in the fall of 1929. "Fisher stated on October 21 that the market was 'only shaking out of the lunatic fringe' and went on to explain why he felt the prices still had not caught up with their real value and should go much higher. On Wednesday, October 23, he announced in a banker’s meeting 'security values in most instances were not inflated.' For months after the Crash, he continued to assure investors that a recovery was just around the corner." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irving_Fisher
 
Does anyone out there know of any astronomical (as in obvious) errors in Edgar Cayce's psychic predictions and/or prophecy?

Also, I've heard about Cayce's prediction that in the 1960s, China would be a Christain nation. I was just wondering if this prediction was actually made by Cayce himself.

Thanks in advance.
Yeah........All of them.
 
SonOfLaertes, you appear to be one of the innumerable stock market analysts who can predict what will happen -- after it's happened. Again, Irving Fisher -- the most prominent economist of his time -- was confident that the stock market would continue to rally in the fall of 1929. "Fisher stated on October 21 that the market was 'only shaking out of the lunatic fringe' and went on to explain why he felt the prices still had not caught up with their real value and should go much higher. On Wednesday, October 23, he announced in a banker’s meeting 'security values in most instances were not inflated.' For months after the Crash, he continued to assure investors that a recovery was just around the corner." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irving_Fisher

First of all , I am not a stock analyst. I have a 401K and some investments. I have never worked the equity sector, I just took some classes many years ago.

Rodney, I got out of the market well before it dropped a while back. So I predicted what was going to happen - before it happened. Imagine that. I informally advised friends and co-workers at the time to get out. Some agreed, some didn't. But that's the way these things always go. The point is, Cayce did no more than I did. He listened to the competing opinions at the time and chose a side.

Please, stop obfuscating with your Irving Fisher's and lunatic fringe's. It's a market, Rodney. What do you think the definition of a market is? People who are buying, and people who are selling. Irving Fisher was a buyer, and he was wrong. Many other people were sellers, and they were right. The fact that Cayce chose the right side doesn't make him unique, or psychic, or special - it just groups him in with the tens of thousands of investors who correctly interpreted the warning signs and didn't let greed get in the way of their better judgement. Yes, many people did get out of the market before the crash. Once again, that's what a market is. Can't have buyers without sellers.

The ones who sold to Irving Fisher were not advised by Cayce. How can that be, Rodney? Let me think - I believe I know the answer. The question is, do you?
 
Rodney, you are have a classic case of confirmation bias.

You only cite the hits, and you consider misses to somehow support the idea that Cayce had paranormal powers.

What evidence would you expect to see if Cayce did NOT have paranormal powers? Wouldn't you expect some of the things he said (just made up, through normal human abilities, like repeating folk wisdom or reading the newspaper) to be correct and some glaringly wrong?

In fact, if Cayce did NOT have paranormal powers, wouldn't you expect the pool of evidence to be pretty much just what it is?
 
Rodney, you are have a classic case of confirmation bias.

You only cite the hits, and you consider misses to somehow support the idea that Cayce had paranormal powers.

What evidence would you expect to see if Cayce did NOT have paranormal powers? Wouldn't you expect some of the things he said (just made up, through normal human abilities, like repeating folk wisdom or reading the newspaper) to be correct and some glaringly wrong?

In fact, if Cayce did NOT have paranormal powers, wouldn't you expect the pool of evidence to be pretty much just what it is?

Yeah, I should just give up. Rodney's so desperate to hold on to this cherished "example" of Cayce's powers that he'll simply ignore any facts that get in the way.

"Rodney, warnings about the market's condition were coming from many sources, all of them before Cayce made his prediction".

"But there were other people who didn't heed the warnings! So Cayce is psychic!"

How can you argue with someone who talks at right angles to the point being addressed?
 
Rodney, you are have a classic case of confirmation bias.

You only cite the hits, and you consider misses to somehow support the idea that Cayce had paranormal powers.

What evidence would you expect to see if Cayce did NOT have paranormal powers? Wouldn't you expect some of the things he said (just made up, through normal human abilities, like repeating folk wisdom or reading the newspaper) to be correct and some glaringly wrong?

In fact, if Cayce did NOT have paranormal powers, wouldn't you expect the pool of evidence to be pretty much just what it is?
I've never based my belief in Cayce's paranormal powers on his predictions. However, in post # 262 on this thread, dropzone stated: "I notice nobody has risen to my challenge to provide a well-documented, before the fact, example of Cayce having gotten a SINGLE prophecy RIGHT." So, I was simply providing such an example.
 
I've never based my belief in Cayce's paranormal powers on his predictions. However, in post # 262 on this thread, dropzone stated: "I notice nobody has risen to my challenge to provide a well-documented, before the fact, example of Cayce having gotten a SINGLE prophecy RIGHT." So, I was simply providing such an example.

Except the example you provided is no more valid than claiming a stopped clock is "right" twice a day.

Similarly, Sylvia Browne correctly predicted the year Pope John Paul II would die. Of course, a great many other people expected his death that year, since he was old and frail. Also, Browne wrongly predicted his death for several other years. So her correctly predicting JPII's death was not really an example of getting a prediction (by paranormal powers) right.

(And dropzone used the term "prophecy" which I take to mean a prediction made by some sort of paranormal means.)

ETA: By the way, what do you base your belief in Cayce's paranormal abilities on? I have asked this several times before. Unless I missed something, your only response is an argument from ignorance (and a poor one at that, since we can explain everything Cayce did by mundane abilities).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom