Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

What year are you quoting from?

That quote is from 1926, and I chose it just because it was longer and more detailed. But the other texts from before or at the time he said it say, "good nourishing food" (1915), and "fresh meat and eggs, fruit and vegetables" (1911).

Linda
 
How do we know Cayce linked it to malnutrition? Or linked it to malnutrition in a way which was different from the way that it was already linked to diet?

Linda
 
How do we know Cayce linked it to malnutrition?
Because the A.R.E. say so
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
Or linked it to malnutrition in a way which was different from the way that it was already linked to diet?

Because the A.R.E. say so
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

As usual there is no other documentary support for anything the A.R.E. says
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

lots of support that the disease was very well known though
After 1906, pellagra also became a serious problem in many southern parts of the United States, affecting tens of thousands of people. The great majority of the cases were women, mostly housewives, and typically with previously good health. The disease occurred mostly among poorer people whose diet consisted mainly of the cheapest available food, maize, supplemented with salt pork, lard, and molasses. Records showed that there were nearly 16 000 cases in eight states of the South from 1907 through 1911, with a death rate of 39.1%. It was the leading cause of death in hospitals for the insane
http://www.helid.desastres.net/?e=d...afc87-0-0-0&a=d&c=who&cl=CL5.47&d=Js2674e.4.1

:p
 
Last edited:
Also, Cayce apparently said "turnip greens" which aren't a good source of niacin. If he'd really been on to something, he would have said beef liver, instead. Plus, wasn't it standard for Cayce to link a large number of diseases to diet?
 
1906-1907? Your link says 1910.
The outbreaks occurred when?
This conclusion is dead wrong: "It is not good maize or good maize flour which produces pellagra; the disease requires for its production the habitual use of damaged maize in some form." That hypothesis is the one Dr. Goldberger discredited in 1915.
Yup. Isn't science great?
They made a great correlation. They were working on the causation.
Why? Did Cayce actually say anything about niacin?
Further, according to Ketchum, Cayce specifically linked pellagra to malnutrition.
Really? Where? When?
In what book before 1912 was pellagra linked to malnutrition?
"Malnutrition"? What does that mean? What was Cayce's "cure" for this mysterious illness?
 
Last edited:
Plus, wasn't it standard for Cayce to link a large number of diseases to diet?
Hence my earlier question (last but most important in a short list): "How many did he say were diet related?"

Curiously unanswered.

L-E-C-I-T-H-I-N
 
What I'm saying is that, however the stock market is doing at any given moment in time, there are bulls and bears. The question for any investor is, should I be in or out of the market? For the most part, the best strategy is to buy and hold, rather than jump in and out. The biggest exception to that strategy in the United States is what happened between September 3, 1929 and July 8, 1932, when the Dow Jones Industrials fell more than 89%, despite a number of bear market rallies. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stock_market_crash_of_1929

Sure, there were reasons to be worried in March of 1929, just as there were reasons to be worried both before and after then. But the bottom line is that the market continued to rally strongly between that time and September 3, 1929, which sucked a lot of investors back in. Ironically, that appears to be what happened to stockbroker Morton Blumenthal, for whom the reading was given. Despite his own interpretation of his dream -- that he should sell everything, including what he considered to be a very safe ("box") stock -- and Cayce's clear warning that there would be "a downward movement of a long duration, gradually sliding off, with fitful conditions of sudden rises and drops . . . not allowing, then, those that apparently even are VERY safe, too much latitude . . . dispose of all those held - even those in box" -- Blumenthal couldn't quite believe there would be a stock market crash, what with the market making new highs throughout the summer of 1929.

There will be wars and rumors of war and calamities will happen. Many will die of natural causes and some will die in accidents. There will be earthquakes in parts of the world and hurricanes in others. All this will come to pass.

For specifics:
Buy my book.
 
Hence my earlier question (last but most important in a short list): "How many did he say were diet related?"

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.

Curiously unanswered.

Curiously? But Rodney never addresses arguments which have the potential to demolish his own. I would have been surprised had he answered.

Linda
 
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
Sincerest, perhaps, but not most desired...


fls said:
Curiously? But Rodney never addresses arguments which have the potential to demolish his own.
And yet somehow still I like him.


fls said:
I would have been surprised had he answered.
Ayup. I withdraw the qualifier "curiously."
 
That quote is from 1926, and I chose it just because it was longer and more detailed. But the other texts from before or at the time he said it say, "good nourishing food" (1915), and "fresh meat and eggs, fruit and vegetables" (1911).

Linda
It's unclear when Cayce's diagnosis of Mr. Jenkins' condition occurred, but it could have been as early as 1906 or 1907. Dr. Ketchum refers to treating Jenkins' employer, Mr. Dalton, for a fall that Dalton suffered in either May 1906 or May 1907. Ketchum states that Dalton called him when Jenkins collapsed, and so that could have been not long after Ketchum treated Dalton. What is the earliest reference you have linking pellagra to malnutrition?
 
It's unclear when Cayce's diagnosis of Mr. Jenkins' condition occurred, but it could have been as early as 1906 or 1907. Dr. Ketchum refers to treating Jenkins' employer, Mr. Dalton, for a fall that Dalton suffered in either May 1906 or May 1907. Ketchum states that Dalton called him when Jenkins collapsed, and so that could have been not long after Ketchum treated Dalton. What is the earliest reference you have linking pellagra to malnutrition?

It was in 1930 that Cayce diagnosed Mr Jenkins condition, long after the effects of diet were realised by orthodox medics

prove it wasn't, from a source that doesn't habitually lie to make profit from gullible people
:p
 
Last edited:
It's unclear when Cayce's diagnosis of Mr. Jenkins' condition occurred, but it could have been as early as 1906 or 1907. Dr. Ketchum refers to treating Jenkins' employer, Mr. Dalton, for a fall that Dalton suffered in either May 1906 or May 1907. Ketchum states that Dalton called him when Jenkins collapsed, and so that could have been not long after Ketchum treated Dalton. What is the earliest reference you have linking pellagra to malnutrition?

My textbooks are from the US, Canada and England, so I don't see reference to pellagra until it showed up in the US. The first textbook I have after that point is the one from 1911. Since this pre-dates the collecting of more definitive information (such as the more detailed experiments into specific foods starting in 1915), it represents the various competing ideas which were prevalent until those points (i.e. new information wasn't available between 1906 or 1907 and 1909 or 1910 when the textbook would have been written). It's association with food is made clear (it was long supposed to be due to the Italian diet in the original region), but the more recent competing ideas were various infectious agents (e.g. protozoal), various toxins (e.g. ergot), and a lack of specific nutrients (e.g. assimilable proteins).

Even if we can somehow erase all the references to the diet of Italians prior to Cayce's involvement, it still doesn't make what Cayce said remarkable. His recommendation would be a poor treatment for pellagra, when better dietary treatments would be readily available, so if he had paranormal information, it was bad information. And since Cayce commonly attributed the condition of the body to diet, it is entirely expected that sometimes he would provide dietary recommendations in cases which could benefit from dietary recommendations.

Linda
 
It's unclear when Cayce's diagnosis of Mr. Jenkins' condition occurred, but it could have been as early as 1906 or 1907. Dr. Ketchum refers to treating Jenkins' employer, Mr. Dalton, for a fall that Dalton suffered in either May 1906 or May 1907. Ketchum states that Dalton called him when Jenkins collapsed, and so that could have been not long after Ketchum treated Dalton. What is the earliest reference you have linking pellagra to malnutrition?
Translation: "Don't know"
Everything else? Stories. As relevant to the world like anything else claimed about Cayce.

So we have concluded that
1)Pellagra was very well known in the area during that time and was a recognized diagnosis since the late 1700s.
2)There were multiple outbreaks which publicized the disease around that time.
3)Pellagra was well known to be linked to diet although the exact cause was unknown.
4)The account was written by an incompetent homeopath who did not even know about the diagnoses existence, who wrote this years after the fact and who is known to be bias.
5)We actually don't know if the fella even had Pellagra.
6)Cayce's recommendation for treatment is a poor one and still failed miserably.

How mundane.

Again I ask: Why should anyone care about this nobody quack who left absolutely nothing to medicine or society except woo?
 
Last edited:
For example, at pp. 12-14 of The Discovery of Edgar Cayce, Dr. Ketchum describes a case where a Hopkinsville, KY construction worker named Jenkins collapsed, and Ketchum was called in to treat him. Ketchum says that he had no idea what the problem was, and so he called upon Cayce. Cayce diagnosed it as pellagra -- a severe case of malnutrition. That proved to be correct, although it was too late to save Jenkins. However, Ketchum spread the word to other Kentucky doctors about pellagra, and that led to a number of other individuals being successfully treated for that disease. One of these doctors, whom Ketchum knew personally (a Dr. Board), read a paper on the diagnosis of pellagra to the Kentucky Medical Society.

I don't know if I missed it, but we've been talking about Cayce linking this to diet, but do they give specifics? In what way did he link it to diet (beyond just "malnutrition")? What cure did he recommend?
 
I don't know if I missed it, but we've been talking about Cayce linking this to diet, but do they give specifics? In what way did he link it to diet (beyond just "malnutrition")? What cure did he recommend?

He prescribed eating turnip greens as a wonder cure. This would have been completely innefective as Pellegra can only be cured by a Niacin supplement which is present in many fresh vegetables, apart from turnip greens which barely has any at all, compared with for instance carrots which have three times the amount of niacin. There is more Niacin in the turnip than in the greens, but he didn't mention that
;)
 
Last edited:
He prescribed eating turnip greens as a wonder cure. This would have been completely innefective as Pellegra can only be cured by a Niacin supplement which is present in many fresh vegetable, apart from turnip greens which barely has any at all, compared with for instance carrots which have three times the amount of niacin.
;)

How about that, Rodney? Was Cayce's recommended treatment specific as to which vegetables to eat? Did he recommend niacin-poor turnip greens? Expand, please, on what you know of Cayc'es recommended treatment. If in fact his treatment was not niacin-rich and only a generalized statment about diet, then I'm afraid we need to shelve this anecdote alongside the stock market "prediction" and move on to other areas in our discussion of Cayce's possible special powers.

We can keep this civil and focused on specific predictions. Right now his pellagra treatment is not looking so good, unless you can provide evidence that his "special knowledge" focused on niacin-rich foods. If you do, then we can try harder to track down the timing of the diagnosis.

Failing any of that, please don't bring up his 1935 "insight" into the Nazi German threat, No.2 on the A.R.E.s hit list. I think we can skip over that one without wasting anybody's valuable time.
 
Here is an excerpt from a reading Cayce did on pellagra. There were possibly half a dozen readings that mentioned pellagra that I could find on the CD-ROM. I am not sure how much I am allowed to copy and paste here of the full reading (for copyright purposes), so I have edited it a bit. This reading was done in June 1926.

"Now, these are conditions as we find them in this body, [4256] we are speaking of. First:

IN THE BLOOD SUPPLY, there we find that, in and under certain conditions as exist from time to time, the blood becomes overloaded with this dross, and in the blood it forms a toxin...

In the running or the continuation of this condition existent, without the proper eliminations being set up in the liver and kidneys, the recharging or reaction to the system set up inflammation in the intestines; first the lower portion of the small intestines. This then removed to the colon, through the same reason, through this condition. This being eliminated by the system being kept flushed, and an excess of the mucus secretions in the intestines, the condition not being removed (or seat of the trouble), came to the upper portion of the intestines, and to the stomach and duodenum. Hence, as we see, the VARIATION in how the blood becomes affected by the variation in the condition as becomes existent in this body.

IN THE NERVE SYSTEM, this - we find that, under stress and strain, those plexuses in the cerebro-spinal nerve system, especially those governing the digestive organs, through the nerve nutriment to same, became, as it were, exaggerated in their functioning, in attempting to supply sufficient of the incentive for the system to overcome or meet the needs of the condition. This brought on nerve depletion, and the strain became effective through pains in the head, low through the blood supplying in the pelvic organs, suppression of the normal functioning of the organs in the pelvis, and nausea, and pains through the right side of the body, along the track of the lacteal ducts, and to the organs in the pelvis, and nausea, and pains through the right side of the body, along the track of the lacteal ducts, and to the organs of the digestion, in intestines. In the reaction from this nerve condition, strain to the eyes, redness, and dimness to the vision. In the application of properties, and the administration of the adjustments and relaxing of the centers, this became subsided in a manner, yet the continuation of the inactivity of the emunctories, especially in liver, brought, and does bring still, this condition as existent in the stomach proper. Then, a nervous indigestion ensues...

The throat, bronchials, larynx, often show the effect of the ulcerations as are seen in the stomach proper, both in the upper and lower end of the stomach, especially in the upper end, or cardiac end; that in the pyloric end becoming more of a mass of conditions not acted upon, and hence the continual rolling to-gether, as it were, of the walls of the stomach, and the tendency for nausea, and of depression throughout the whole system. Tendency to vomit, and to cause the whole system to become flushed. Tendency to scale over the face and over the hands, through the extremities, see?...

The liver very torpid in its action, save when there has been those properties administered that has, for the time being, caused the excitement to the mucus lining, or of the intestine, rather than enlivening the liver in its functioning. With the over strain on the liver, and all of the hepatic circulation, naturally the kidneys come in for their part of the derangement - with the highly colored urine, and the pains at times across the small of the back...

To overcome these conditions in this body would be to first correct those conditions in the eliminations, and then give the incentive in the blood stream to keep same clear, giving sufficient assistance, as it were, to the nerve centers, in a vibratory force, as to overcome or to produce an equilibrium throughout the system; for the resistance in the system may be builded to where this condition may be ENTIRELY eliminated.

In this condition, we find this one wherein little vegetable foods should be taken in the system. Rather those of the dried, or of cereals and fruits. Not of vegetable forces or matter.

In the applications of medicinal properties, these should be given:

Keep practically all the water as is taken (and the body should take plenty of same) with small quantities of elm in same. Well that this be kept, but never allowed to become sour, by giving small pinches of the powdered elm bark in glass of water with ice in same, see? Just enough to make the water taste of same, or slick, as it were.

Then there should be taken REGULARLY Yellow Saffron Tea. The combination of these, as we see, is to soothe and to lessen this irritation as is kept up through the intestine and through the stomach.

For the eliminations, begin with small doses of Senna - SENNA. Half a grain first. Let this be taken one each day for five days. Then increase the quantity to the full grain, and after this has been taken for five days, still increase again to the one and a quarter grain, see? Not allow the system to become over nauseated from same, but if it should, then cut it out, or leave it off, see?

Well that as much PURE olive oil be taken as the system will assimilate. This both as food value and as the healing for the mucus coating of the intestine and stomach, which have been so lacerated, and will of necessity have to be healed before these conditions can be overcome.

AT ONCE begin and apply the vibrations from the Radium Active Appliance - RADIUM Active Appliance, using the heavy vibrator, see? Use this across the small of the back in the day. In the evenings, for a few minutes, well that this be laid across the breast, or just below the breast, that the inflammation, as is seen as is produced there from time to time, may be eliminated; or at times it may be laid for a few minutes across the throat, that the ducts and the glands in same may be stimulated - giving sufficient of the recharging for the pad, in the sunlight at least a few minutes each day, but wear this constantly, night and day, over some portion of the body.

Follow this in a consistent and persistent manner. We will eliminate these conditions from this body, see?

The diets, as is seen - not meats, but not great vegetables at the present, see? The soups or broths may be taken in MODERATION, but do not EVER overload the stomach. Won't be very apt to while the Senna is being taken, for it will produce nausea; but the liver must be aroused, but in the moderate way, until this is thoroughly eliminated, for this is that condition which has become termed (in name) pellagra. [GD's note: Her mother died with pellagra.]

We are through for the present."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom