Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

It's possible. Tests his so-called treatments. How many claimed treatments actually work?

That's just it. Difficult, if not impossible. Who is going to do it?

Not only that, but it would seem likely that most of the people who received readings are dead, so follow-up is impossible in that sense, too, even if we had more than case numbers (versus names) to go by, which we don't.
 
Can't. I stopped doing clinical research a few years back and just concentrate of teaching residents now. I really doubt that I could get it past the IRB...unless I get a ton of cash through the NCCAM :D

Damn...I have ethics.

Thank you for your answer, but I didn't ask if you can do this. ;) Let's say for the sake of argument that you can. Easily.

Would you be willing to do this?

Linda
 
Except he calls them "errors" and seems to think they're evidence of Cayce's claims being valid, presumably by way of the criterion of embarrassment.

I think, rather, these egregious failures are positive proof that Cayce could not do what he claimed to be doing (the farsight business, in particular).

I used to think that book represented sincerity on the part of the Cayce sons and only added to their credibility. Cayce had several explanations for his failures, which I used to accept, among them that the quality and accuracy of a reading depended on the sincerity and intentions of the seeker.

By all means let's divert time and money investigating the curative properties of gelatin rather than promising modern treatments!
</sarcasm>

ETA: By the way, doesn't the A.R.E. have money? According to their site:



So what exactly do they mean by "explore"? Apparently not a rigorous investigation that might falsify the claims by Cayce and his believers.

That's a good point. Maybe I'll write them and ask whether they fund any sort of research into Cayce's medical treatments, and if not, why not. I believe they have attempted to verify the date of the great pyramid and have paid to look closer at the supposed location of Atlantis.
 
By all means let's divert time and money investigating the curative properties of gelatin rather than promising modern treatments!
</sarcasm>

ETA: By the way, doesn't the A.R.E. have money? According to their site:

Edgar Cayce's Association for Research and Enlightenment, Inc. (A.R.E.®), is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1931 by Edgar Cayce (1877-1945), to research and explore transpersonal subjects such as holistic health, ancient mysteries, personal spirituality, dreams and dream interpretation, intuition, and philosophy and reincarnation.


So what exactly do they mean by "explore"? Apparently not a rigorous investigation that might falsify the claims by Cayce and his believers.


See here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2698037#post2698037

Believers are convinced that Cayce's treatments work and many put their money where their mouths are by using those treatments. In general, believers don't see the need to spend money on studies.


Again, most A.R.E. officials are convinced that Cayce's treatments do work and many use those treatments. However, I think there is a faction that would like to fund studies of those treatments, but they don't have the votes.
 
Can't. I stopped doing clinical research a few years back and just concentrate of teaching residents now. I really doubt that I could get it past the IRB...unless I get a ton of cash through the NCCAM :D

Damn...I have ethics.
o/t Do you enjoy teaching residents if I may ask, or do you find it frustrating ever? Some of the residents one tends to work with I wouldn't trust to identify a strip of VTach from a picture of a cemetary.

But I'm not one of those resident haters or hazers. I just think they're fun to poke and frustrate LOL :)
 
I believe they have attempted to verify the date of the great pyramid and have paid to look closer at the supposed location of Atlantis.

Oh I'd love to see more information on that, didn't anyone tell them that an extensive radio carbon dating project more than a decade ago firmly linked it to the Pharoah Khufu, just as orthodox egyptologists always said. Graham Hancock was the first off the blocks to attempt to save face on that one as he had already (pseudo scientifically) proved that the pyramids were built to mirror Orions belt in 10,500bce, by stating that of course that meant that they weren't built then but thats when the survey was done.
:D
(no I'm not making any of this up)

what bs did the A.R.E. come up with to explain their dating being incorrect by more than 7500 years
 
Thank you for your answer, but I didn't ask if you can do this. ;) Let's say for the sake of argument that you can. Easily.

Would you be willing to do this?

Linda
Hmmmm...interesting question. It depends on the claim but to tell you the truth I don't really know. If I could write an appropriate protocol, find that it is relative safe and get it past the IRB, would it be worth it?

Would it risk my reputation among my peers to use brandy or some other silly thing to treat TB for instance?

I don't really know. I'm willing to put work into it(or use resident slave labor) but am I willing to look silly to my peers or produce a negative paper that will never be published?

I actually don't know.
 
o/t Do you enjoy teaching residents if I may ask, or do you find it frustrating ever? Some of the residents one tends to work with I wouldn't trust to identify a strip of VTach from a picture of a cemetary.

But I'm not one of those resident haters or hazers. I just think they're fun to poke and frustrate LOL :)
It depends. Some are malleable and it is great to see the change as time goes by. Some are hopeless and one can hope that I can beat some sense into them before they graduate.

I don't mind the Interns or Transitional years too much but I watch them like a hawk.
 
How about reading the original article so you can see what the A.R.E. deliberately cut out and added from their edit which they spoon fed you
http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=9C06EFD71239E433A2575AC0A9669D946196D6CF
;)

I notice on neither occaison any mention was made as the Akashic records
and the testimony of the real newspaper article doesn't mention the claimed ability of the A.R.E. that he absorbed books by sleeping on them either, just the opposite in fact.

Here we see myth making in progress
Marduk, I'm really beginning to wonder about you. The link I provided has the full text of the New York Times article about Cayce! What exactly are you talking about when you allege the "A.R.E. deliberately cut out and added from their edit which they spoon fed you"?????
 
Hmmmm...interesting question. It depends on the claim but to tell you the truth I don't really know. If I could write an appropriate protocol, find that it is relative safe and get it past the IRB, would it be worth it?

Would it risk my reputation among my peers to use brandy or some other silly thing to treat TB for instance?

I don't really know. I'm willing to put work into it(or use resident slave labor) but am I willing to look silly to my peers or produce a negative paper that will never be published?

I actually don't know.
I really do appreciate you considering this issue, and I totally understand about risking your reputation. That, I think, has not changed since Cayce's time, which is why I'm not surprised that more medical doctors of his time did not go public in even tentatively supporting him. But, as Linda correctly notes, I would love to see Cayce's alleged cures examined by an open-minded modern medical doctor or team. For example, if a thorough and objective evaluation of Cayce's recommended treatment of his wife's apparent tuberculosis revealed that the treatment couldn't possibly have even assisted in curing tuberculosis, then so be it. The conclusion would have to be that she really didn't have tuberculosis. But what if the evaluation goes the other way . . .
 
Marduk, I'm really beginning to wonder about you. The link I provided has the full text of the New York Times article about Cayce! What exactly are you talking about when you allege the "A.R.E. deliberately cut out and added from their edit which they spoon fed you"?????
I can see that you have used all the powers of observation and critical thinking that you are famous here for
i.e. none

Try it again, this time read it while comparing it to the A.R.E. "copy"
 
I really do appreciate you considering this issue, and I totally understand about risking your reputation. That, I think, has not changed since Cayce's time, which is why I'm not surprised that more medical doctors of his time did not go public in even tentatively supporting him. But, as Linda correctly notes, I would love to see Cayce's alleged cures examined by an open-minded modern medical doctor or team. For example, if a thorough and objective evaluation of Cayce's recommended treatment of his wife's apparent tuberculosis revealed that the treatment couldn't possibly have even assisted in curing tuberculosis, then so be it. The conclusion would have to be that she really didn't have tuberculosis. But what if the evaluation goes the other way . . .
Rodney ... I seriously can't speak for anyone, but two things:

1) Is there a complete medical history on Cayce's wife? I'm assuming there is, but how trustworthy is it? Did she already suffer from any immunocompromised conditions when she supposedly got TB for example? Does she have reliable blood work to examine throughout her treatment? Would her records reflect documented physical assessments during her treatment? There are probably more things to consider than you realize for any kind of thorough investigation to take place.

2) What would any conclusion drawn by a modern day medical professional show you personally? If it negated what you think you already know, would you be content with that and accept it, or would you get multiple opinions? If it verified for you what you think you already know .... would you still get second opinions anyway?
 
Rodney ... I seriously can't speak for anyone, but two things:

1) Is there a complete medical history on Cayce's wife? I'm assuming there is, but how trustworthy is it? Did she already suffer from any immunocompromised conditions when she supposedly got TB for example? Does she have reliable blood work to examine throughout her treatment? Would her records reflect documented physical assessments during her treatment? There are probably more things to consider than you realize for any kind of thorough investigation to take place.
I don't know what kinds of medical records are available for this or other cases. However, we do have at least the general outline of several cases where seemingly amazing cures were effected -- for example, Amy Dietrich, Tommy House, Cayce's son. Also, there are specific assertions in Cayce's readings that could be evaluated, such as those about psoriasis and cough medicine.

2) What would any conclusion drawn by a modern day medical professional show you personally? If it negated what you think you already know, would you be content with that and accept it, or would you get multiple opinions? If it verified for you what you think you already know .... would you still get second opinions anyway?
To the extent that Cayce's alleged cures were found to be medically impossible, I would accept that. To the extent that they were found to possible, I would hope that would cause a more detailed study of his medical readings by modern day physicians.
 
I really do appreciate you considering this issue, and I totally understand about risking your reputation. That, I think, has not changed since Cayce's time, which is why I'm not surprised that more medical doctors of his time did not go public in even tentatively supporting him. But, as Linda correctly notes, I would love to see Cayce's alleged cures examined by an open-minded modern medical doctor or team. For example, if a thorough and objective evaluation of Cayce's recommended treatment of his wife's apparent tuberculosis revealed that the treatment couldn't possibly have even assisted in curing tuberculosis, then so be it. The conclusion would have to be that she really didn't have tuberculosis. But what if the evaluation goes the other way . . .
No Rodney. I don't believe Cayce's nonsense will work therefore there is no onus for me to risk anything to prove him wrong. His nonsense is not widely used therefore I find little incentive to "debunk".

If I was a believer in his treatments like how he and his proponents claimed then it would've been unethical for me to never write about it or attempt to show it to be true. Why have his followers not attempted to do so?
 
I don't know what kinds of medical records are available for this or other cases. However, we do have at least the general outline of several cases where seemingly amazing cures were effected -- for example, Amy Dietrich, Tommy House, Cayce's son.
Yup. Seemingly. We don't have any specific disease or diagnosis and we don't have any relevant details that can be used. In other words, his life saving treatments are useless.
Also, there are specific assertions in Cayce's readings that could be evaluated, such as those about psoriasis and cough medicine.
Wow. That's "impressively" life saving. What was his recommendations?

To the extent that Cayce's alleged cures were found to be medically impossible, I would accept that. To the extent that they were found to possible, I would hope that would cause a more detailed study of his medical readings by modern day physicians.
And if we showed that his cough "medicine" worked but everything else was harmful or useless. So?
 
I really do appreciate you considering this issue, and I totally understand about risking your reputation. That, I think, has not changed since Cayce's time, which is why I'm not surprised that more medical doctors of his time did not go public in even tentatively supporting him. But, as Linda correctly notes, I would love to see Cayce's alleged cures examined by an open-minded modern medical doctor or team. For example, if a thorough and objective evaluation of Cayce's recommended treatment of his wife's apparent tuberculosis revealed that the treatment couldn't possibly have even assisted in curing tuberculosis, then so be it. The conclusion would have to be that she really didn't have tuberculosis. But what if the evaluation goes the other way . . .

Here is the problem. These things can only be evaluated in light of what we already know, which means that we can't gain new knowledge from them, we can only determine whether they are consistent with our old knowledge. If you are talking about treating it as an all-or-none case series, whereby conditions which would be universally fatal show recovery, you run up against the issues I have already discussed with you in multiple threads. If the cases were such that recovery could not be expected, it becomes increasingly implausible that they wouldn't make their way into the medical journals, even taking reticence on the part of medical doctors into account. These sorts of opportunities are too important to pretend that they would get passed over every single time, and it is possible to present the information in a way that minimizes the more embarrassing part of the story. Plus the 'best' cases which you have presented have the problem of unknown diagnoses (maybe with the exception of Gertrude's TB). You can't use a case series for information if you don't know the prognosis. And you can't know the prognosis if you don't have a diagnosis.

Without controls or randomization, the information is useless for anything else. So what if someone's psoriasis got better? People with psoriasis get better without treatment, so how can we know whether this represents someone getting better because of the treatment or in spite of the treatment?

We already know that careful examination of what Cayce says shows that he was wrong. So we can't take what he says as universally inerrant, which means that we have to have some way of separating out what was false from what was true in what he said. But again, the only way that it seems that this can be done is by simply comparing it to information that we already have. So then we get back to Paximperium's original question. Of what use is Cayce's information if the only thing that can be drawn from it is what we already know?

Linda
 
Here is the problem. These things can only be evaluated in light of what we already know, which means that we can't gain new knowledge from them, we can only determine whether they are consistent with our old knowledge.
Are you sure? For example, in the Amy Dietrich case, Cayce prescribed osteopathic adjustments for a seizure-ridden and developmentally-delayed child whose case had been given up as hopeless by the best doctors her father could find, according to his affidavit. Amy then made a full recovery after those adjustments were administered. I believe that your position is that her recovery was just a coincidence, and would have happened even without those adjustments. But isn't it possible that modern medicine could be missing something, and that under some (perhaps rare) circumstances, osteopathic adjustments would be effective for a seizure-ridden and developmentally-delayed child?

If you are talking about treating it as an all-or-none case series, whereby conditions which would be universally fatal show recovery, you run up against the issues I have already discussed with you in multiple threads. If the cases were such that recovery could not be expected, it becomes increasingly implausible that they wouldn't make their way into the medical journals, even taking reticence on the part of medical doctors into account. These sorts of opportunities are too important to pretend that they would get passed over every single time, and it is possible to present the information in a way that minimizes the more embarrassing part of the story.
I'm not sure about that, although I would like to have more information regarding whether the doctors who dealt with Cayce made an effort to have articles published in medical journals.

Plus the 'best' cases which you have presented have the problem of unknown diagnoses (maybe with the exception of Gertrude's TB). You can't use a case series for information if you don't know the prognosis. And you can't know the prognosis if you don't have a diagnosis.
But we know the general outline of many cases, and in Cayce's time doctors were often shooting in the dark. In the Tommy House case, for example, the doctors weren't exactly sure what was wrong, but they agreed he was in serious jeopardy of not even surviving the night.

Without controls or randomization, the information is useless for anything else. So what if someone's psoriasis got better? People with psoriasis get better without treatment, so how can we know whether this represents someone getting better because of the treatment or in spite of the treatment?
I assume that's where controlled trials enter in. Do a controlled study of Cayce's recommended psoriasis treatment versus currently recommended psoriasis treatment vs. no treatment.

We already know that careful examination of what Cayce says shows that he was wrong.
Can you be more specific? For example, in the case quoted in the New York Times article, what did he get wrong? Also, to the extent you believe that he was wrong about certain things, do you have an opinion as to whether in the majority of those instances what he said was thought to be correct at that time by most medical doctors, or was it considered incorrect by most doctors even then?

So we can't take what he says as universally inerrant, which means that we have to have some way of separating out what was false from what was true in what he said.
True, but isn't this true of all authorities in all fields?

But again, the only way that it seems that this can be done is by simply comparing it to information that we already have. So then we get back to Paximperium's original question. Of what use is Cayce's information if the only thing that can be drawn from it is what we already know?
Again, you seem to be assuming that modern medicine can't learn anything from Cayce, but I don't see how you know that without a more detailed examination of his recommended treatments.
 
Are you sure? For example, in the Amy Dietrich case, Cayce prescribed osteopathic adjustments for a seizure-ridden and developmentally-delayed child whose case had been given up as hopeless by the best doctors her father could find, according to his affidavit. Amy then made a full recovery after those adjustments were administered. I believe that your position is that her recovery was just a coincidence, and would have happened even without those adjustments. But isn't it possible that modern medicine could be missing something, and that under some (perhaps rare) circumstances, osteopathic adjustments would be effective for a seizure-ridden and developmentally-delayed child?

First of all, you have quite grossly misrepresented the information that we do have (and you have been told this already). Second, that information is inadequate to tell us what condition(s) she had and so is inadequate to tell us whether her course was unexpected. It is also inadequate to guide us in recommending the treatment be tried on anyone. Let's pretend that it did work - who exactly can we recommend for it? It's not clear that Aime had seizures (they were described as convulsions or a form of 'nervousness'), she wasn't described as developmentally delayed, but rather had a subacute reduction in mental status. How would we know whether or not this description applies to any particular condition? Third, osteopathic adjustments cannot have the claimed effect. Even if we desperately wanted to believe that modern medicine is missing something, there isn't any way to fill in the blanks with the information provided.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2575325#post2575325

I'm not sure about that, although I would like to have more information regarding whether the doctors who dealt with Cayce made an effort to have articles published in medical journals.

That would be very useful information. Why isn't it already available?

But we know the general outline of many cases, and in Cayce's time doctors were often shooting in the dark. In the Tommy House case, for example, the doctors weren't exactly sure what was wrong, but they agreed he was in serious jeopardy of not even surviving the night.

Again, you don't know that. I agree that the doctors were often shooting in the dark in Cayce's time. But we really have no information about whether Tommy was in jeopardy of surviving the night. All we have is the say-so of someone who would profit from the story. And even if we had information from the doctors, because they were shooting in the dark, we wouldn't be able to trust their claims, even if we desperately wanted to.

I assume that's where controlled trials enter in. Do a controlled study of Cayce's recommended psoriasis treatment versus currently recommended psoriasis treatment vs. no treatment.

Why? There is no more reason to think this treatment would work than any of a hundred or a thousand folk/Chinese/ancient Greek/witchdoctor/random stuff I pulled out of my ass treatments. Considering that it will take decades, maybe even centuries, and millions of dollars to test them all, with almost no chance of reward, how do you choose where to start? You've decided to start with the 'C's', but you've never explained why.

Can you be more specific? For example, in the case quoted in the New York Times article, what did he get wrong? Also, to the extent you believe that he was wrong about certain things, do you have an opinion as to whether in the majority of those instances what he said was thought to be correct at that time by most medical doctors, or was it considered incorrect by most doctors even then?

I refer you back to the detailed conversation we had about he statements as to the cause of psoriasis as an example.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2604301#post2604301

True, but isn't this true of all authorities in all fields?

Exactly. Which is why their word is useless unless it is backed up by evidence.

Again, you seem to be assuming that modern medicine can't learn anything from Cayce, but I don't see how you know that without a more detailed examination of his recommended treatments.

How can we learn anything? We can't tell what conditions the treatments were prescribed for. We can't tell whether the treatments worked. His explanations of physiology and causes of disease are wrong. What exactly could a detailed examination tell us?

Linda
 
Last edited:
I don't know what kinds of medical records are available for this or other cases. However, we do have at least the general outline of several cases where seemingly amazing cures were effected -- for example, Amy Dietrich, Tommy House, Cayce's son. Also, there are specific assertions in Cayce's readings that could be evaluated, such as those about psoriasis and cough medicine.
In my opinion, for what it's worth ... without a fairly detailed and reliable medical history and/or documentation of various assessments of his "prescribed" treatments concerning the various individuals he "treated" during the actual course of the treatment, I don't think one will be able to reliably examine cases and provide conclusive evidence that it was his treatment, and his treatment alone, that either healed or resolved the medical issues he was claiming to focus on. Do you see what I'm saying?

It would be like trying to do detective work, relying on modern methods of forensics, DNA analysis, etc .... on an old case where no relevant forensic data was gathered. Filling in the gaps where the data is absent with even "educated assumptions" isn't conclusive of anything.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom