Here is the problem. These things can only be evaluated in light of what we already know, which means that we can't gain new knowledge from them, we can only determine whether they are consistent with our old knowledge.
Are you sure? For example, in the Amy Dietrich case, Cayce prescribed osteopathic adjustments for a seizure-ridden and developmentally-delayed child whose case had been given up as hopeless by the best doctors her father could find, according to his affidavit. Amy then made a full recovery after those adjustments were administered. I believe that your position is that her recovery was just a coincidence, and would have happened even without those adjustments. But isn't it possible that modern medicine could be missing something, and that under some (perhaps rare) circumstances, osteopathic adjustments would be effective for a seizure-ridden and developmentally-delayed child?
If you are talking about treating it as an all-or-none case series, whereby conditions which would be universally fatal show recovery, you run up against the issues I have already discussed with you in multiple threads. If the cases were such that recovery could not be expected, it becomes increasingly implausible that they wouldn't make their way into the medical journals, even taking reticence on the part of medical doctors into account. These sorts of opportunities are too important to pretend that they would get passed over every single time, and it is possible to present the information in a way that minimizes the more embarrassing part of the story.
I'm not sure about that, although I would like to have more information regarding whether the doctors who dealt with Cayce made an effort to have articles published in medical journals.
Plus the 'best' cases which you have presented have the problem of unknown diagnoses (maybe with the exception of Gertrude's TB). You can't use a case series for information if you don't know the prognosis. And you can't know the prognosis if you don't have a diagnosis.
But we know the general outline of many cases, and in Cayce's time doctors were often shooting in the dark. In the Tommy House case, for example, the doctors weren't exactly sure what was wrong, but they agreed he was in serious jeopardy of not even surviving the night.
Without controls or randomization, the information is useless for anything else. So what if someone's psoriasis got better? People with psoriasis get better without treatment, so how can we know whether this represents someone getting better because of the treatment or in spite of the treatment?
I assume that's where controlled trials enter in. Do a controlled study of Cayce's recommended psoriasis treatment versus currently recommended psoriasis treatment vs. no treatment.
We already know that careful examination of what Cayce says shows that he was wrong.
Can you be more specific? For example, in the case quoted in the
New York Times article, what did he get wrong? Also, to the extent you believe that he was wrong about certain things, do you have an opinion as to whether in the majority of those instances what he said was thought to be correct at that time by most medical doctors, or was it considered incorrect by most doctors even then?
So we can't take what he says as universally inerrant, which means that we have to have some way of separating out what was false from what was true in what he said.
True, but isn't this true of all authorities in all fields?
But again, the only way that it seems that this can be done is by simply comparing it to information that we already have. So then we get back to Paximperium's original question. Of what use is Cayce's information if the only thing that can be drawn from it is what we already know?
Again, you seem to be assuming that modern medicine can't learn anything from Cayce, but I don't see how you know that without a more detailed examination of his recommended treatments.