Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

How about that, Rodney? Was Cayce's recommended treatment specific as to which vegetables to eat? Did he recommend niacin-poor turnip greens? Expand, please, on what you know of Cayc'es recommended treatment. If in fact his treatment was not niacin-rich and only a generalized statment about diet, then I'm afraid we need to shelve this anecdote alongside the stock market "prediction" and move on to other areas in our discussion of Cayce's possible special powers.

We can keep this civil and focused on specific predictions. Right now his pellagra treatment is not looking so good, unless you can provide evidence that his "special knowledge" focused on niacin-rich foods. If you do, then we can try harder to track down the timing of the diagnosis.

According to Ketchum (p. 14), Cayce "said Jenks [Mr. Jenkins] needed vegetables and a well-balanced diet." Again, bear in mind that the conventional wisdom at that time was that pellagra was caused by a toxin in corn. So, while there may have been a minority opinion in 1911 that pellagra was related to an improper diet, how would Cayce know that this was correct, when the average doctor did not? If he was simply reading medical books (that somehow managed to escape the attention of Dr. Ketchum and his friend Dr. Board), why didn't Cayce regurgitate the conventional wisdom that pellagra was caused by a toxin?
 
Here is another:

"EC: Yes, we have the body here, [304]; this we have had before.

As we find, the conditions are gradually on the improve, that have been disturbing the body as related to the effect in the lymph and capillary circulation, as to the effects of the overactivity of elements in butter, milk, and kinds of bread. For, these in excess produce that which may be very well termed that which brings about pellagra - and if examined by a physician, that's what the body would have!"

And from November 1928 (5536-1). I did not shorten it:

"EC: Yes, we have the body here. Now, we find there are those conditions as are hard to combat with, when they have reached the present outlook, or the bacilli has reached that condition where the numbers of same so OUTNUMBER the normal rebuilding or replenishing functioning of the physical being.

These (we don't find their name, but) in shape are that of the scorpion, and are attacking the vital forces, or through the blood supply, which in turn attacks the vitality of the body, taking from the serums of the system that which gives to the bone, to the vital forces, even in the return nerve energy in the system. Hence these are hard to combat with.

That as we find that would bring the better reaction and, perchance, give the vital forces the opportunity to gain in supremacy in the system - (and that of necessity would mean other conditions; that is, the air that is breathed, the foods as taken, the water as nourished with, would be in keeping with these administrations) - we would prepare, then, as this: This PREFERABLY given in capsule, and this in each dose, and not more than one dose every OTHER day, see?

Oil of Eucalyptus..........1 minim,
Canadian Balsam..........1/2 minim,
Rectified Oil of Turp....1/2 minim,
Benzosol.................1/2 minim.

This, as we find, will give the system the opportunity to see - through the change - the effect these various conditions internally have upon the system. Eucalyptol acting (internally) directly for the respiratory system. The Balsam as that of a clarifier of the blood, separating in its activity that portion which COMES to be in the system the ability to form the differentiation between white and red blood; while with the REST of the reaction of the Balsam and the Turp will act directly with the portions of kidneys that will AID the respiratory system as in reference TO the action of the lymphatic circulation and the hepatic circulation; while those of the Benzosol (Be sure it's this Benzosol, see?) will act WITH the other properties to assist the activity of the respiratory system, and heart stimulant, and also separating in the liver in the form that will assist in division in the eliminations and assimilation in system.

4. Then used (these same properties) in different proportion with these, as an inhalant, see? for the respiratory system. So we change these in a different vibration:

5. To 4 ounces of pure grain alcohol, add:

Eucalyptol................20 minims,
Rectified Creosote........10 minims,
Rectified Oil of Turp......8 minims,
BENZOIN...................15 minims,
Canadian Balsam............5 minims,
Tolu in Solution.........1/4 ounce.

Keep the solution in a container at least twice the size of the quantity, with a glass stopper. Shake solution when this is inhaled, and it may be inhaled either as the stimulant for the tendency of cold, congestion, or for the heart's reaction. So it may be inhaled through the nostrils and through the mouth, two, three, four times each day.

Let the diet consist of the JUICES of meats, especially of beef, - that is only lean - and only the JUICE, no flesh of same taken.

Take as much olive oil as the system will assimilate, beginning with only a few drops, and adding a drop or two each day, taking one dose each day.

Also use Scott's Codliver Oil, or Emulsion. This will of necessity (in the present condition) be better absorbed than taken internally. Massage this, then, in the arm pits, the groins, across the intestines, see? This will assist.

The food diets, other than that of the meat juices, should be nuts and fruits - but no apples. Especially pears, oranges and such. Especially pears. This will aid the system, as we find at present.

The water should carry small quantities of lithia and, alternately, small quantities of white sulphur. This may be obtained - much of that, as is seen - were it made half and half with pure water, or carbonated water - as the white sulphur from White Sulphur Springs; and the lithia may be taken once each week.

We would give further directions when these have been carried out for twenty-seven days. Do that at present.

Ready for questions.

(Q) What is this condition commonly called?
(A) This has been called VARIOUS conditions. This almost a true case of pellagra."
 
According to Ketchum (p. 14), Cayce "said Jenks [Mr. Jenkins] needed vegetables and a well-balanced diet." Again, bear in mind that the conventional wisdom at that time was that pellagra was caused by a toxin in corn. So, while there may have been a minority opinion in 1911 that pellagra was related to an improper diet, how would Cayce know that this was correct, when the average doctor did not? If he was simply reading medical books (that somehow managed to escape the attention of Dr. Ketchum and his friend Dr. Board), why didn't Cayce regurgitate the conventional wisdom that pellagra was caused by a toxin?
"I say dear man. Mr Zeebob. You have some problems with your airways and your black bile is way overpowering your yellow bile. You sir have Sponduferingdious.
Have some fresh air, a drink of brandy a day and a good well balanced diet with vegetables and fish. Now where is my top hat and buggy?"
 
Hi Ex-Minister. Have you found any references to the original Mr Jenkin's case. Do we even know it was Pellagra or was it assumed or claimed to be?
 
Regarding prophecy, how do you distinguish paranormal from non-paranormal means?
Merriam Webster defines "paranormal" thusly:

: not scientifically explainable : supernatural

Note well: not scientifically explainable is not the same thing as "unexplained" or even "scientifically unexplained". (Just to point out that the argument from ignorance you like to assert isn't the same as this definition.)

Since you are the one asserting the existence of a paranormal ability, how do you define the term?
 
Hi Ex-Minister. Have you found any references to the original Mr Jenkin's case. Do we even know it was Pellagra or was it assumed or claimed to be?

I did find a detailed reference of what I think may this case, by Ketchum. I will copy and paste it, as follows:

"R1. 11/62 Letter from HLC to Dr. W. H. Ketchum: "...Enclosed
is a copy of a diary written by my Grandfather [of EC
readings given] between October 22 and November, 1911..."
serving as a stimulus for memory recollection by Dr. Ketchum.

Dr. Ketchum begins to speak:

You know, that fellow Cayce - well, - you just didn't
know where he was going to hit you, that's all! He'd
come up with the darndest things after he'd get under
one of these hypnotic spells. We'd ask him questions,
sometimes; sometimes we wouldn't.

Case of (Boyetna?) [pellagra]. [5778] case diagnosed by
Cayce as a case of malnutrition. I was called to see this
boy - not a "boy", really, he was a man. He hadn't been
treated by any other doctor, but he was still sticking by
his work. He was doing shovel work in a pit for a brick firm
by the name of Dalton which employed about 400 men. ...Was
buried in the ground and they had to go down with a ladder
and set fire to all the coals down there. One day the phone
rang and Mr. Dalton asked me to come up and see [5778] as
he called him, for he said he had fallen over in the pit.
He had tumbled over a fainting spell, and there he was
unconscious. He was breathing, but he had had a "spell."
Two or three colored boys lifted him up and carried out and
laid him under a tree. Then we piled some straw on a road
wagon and took him to his home. That was the first case of
malnutrition that I ever saw. Cases like his were very rare,
and when I first saw him I had no idea what the diagnosis
was. Prior to this the only pellagra I had ever heard of
was in Italy. Italy was full of pellagra - in other words,
malnutrition - and it was brought about by improper foods.
This was the first case I ever saw and it had been overlooked
until Cayce explained the exact approach. Then it was very
easy to diagnose that it was exactly the same as a number of
cases at the hospital, but I didn't know about them at that
time. Up to then it was a puzzle; but every puzzle is simple
after it has been explained.

At this time Cayce was living in Hopkinsville, Kentucky,
where he had moved from Bowling Green, Kentucky. We set him
up in Hopkinsville - bought him an outfit - prettiest stuff
you ever saw! Dandy new camera and all, must have spent
the biggest part of five thousand dollars just to outfit
his office.

When I went in about this [5778] case, Cayce laid down on the
cot and after he laid there awhile he explained that it was
all a case of malnutrition. After going into detail, he
named the different foods needed in the process of bringing
him back to health. The next day after this Cayce reading
I saw Dr. Board coming down the street. I called to him and
said, "Dr. Board, you're quite the talk in western Kentucky
and I've got a fellow out here I want you to see. He's right
on the road on the way out to the hospital." He said he'd be
glad to go. I had gotten my new car just a few weeks before
- the first one I ever had - this was in 1905 or '06. So
we drove out to see this [5778] and we went in and looked
at him, and Dr. Board tried to get a line on him. After he
got through he said, "Have you got plenty of time?" I said,
"Sure." He said, "Let's go on out to the hospital. We've
got four cases out there exactly the same as this. My boys
have been wrestling with them for a year and they have never
diagnosed them."

"Now I had had Cayce's diagnosis, but Cayce didn't name it at
all. Cayce had said the man was "slightly off up here." He
had functioned with malnutrition and then they may go out
of their heads and they are skinny and simply a case of
malnutrition. This [5778] was one of the first cases
reported in the United States. Dr. Milton Board read a paper
before the Kentucky Medical Society and presented his cases
out there at the hospital. But he didn't tell anything about
Edgar Cayce, though! See the point?

Well, when Dr. Board and I were having lunch at the hospital
he said to me, "Did you say you had a diagnosis for this
case?" I said, "Yes, but I'm not going to tell you!
You're an old practitioner and I'm just an embryo!"

He said, "Well, where did you get it?"

I told him I picked up a new medical book the other day,
published by a Philadelphia concern, and the description was
a perfect description of my case, and also of the four cases
he had. He turned to his wife and asked her if he had a copy
of that book. She said he had and she went and got it for
him. He opened it up, and right here - "PELLAGRA"! He said
to me, "But how did you get..."

I said, "My 'boy', Cayce."

He said, "The hell you say!"

I said, "That's the truth."

He said, "You mean that fellow diagnosed that case for you?"

I said, "That's the truth."

Now, this Dr. Board was a member of the Kentucky Medical
Society when they had me on the spot. They had heard
of Cayce, but they were afraid of him because he was
"different." Like Billy Mitchell. Too far ahead of his time
to be acceptable. So Dr. Board read his paper and it was
published in the Kentucky Medical Journal, and from that
copied into the A.M.A. Journal. Then they began picking up
cases of Pellagra from all over where the people had been
eating nothing but hog and hominy. The papers were full of
it for months. Now-a-days you don't hear anything about it
anymore, but back then it was quite a problem. Just like
Cayce said right out in his reading, "Too much hog and
hominy!" Said he needed vegetables and a well-balanced diet,
which all pellagra patients respond to. [5778]'s case was
just as typical as I ever saw anywhere, and he finally died
because he was too weak to get well.

I got together with Cayce in good cases, bad cases, mediocre
cases, and all kinds. Surely if I had a case that I didn't
know what it was, or if it was different from the others,
I would go over and ask Edgar if he would "sleep" on it.
What he said wasn't written down in those days, but I
could remember it all."
 
Last edited:
The fraud said:
...we would prepare, then, as this: This PREFERABLY given in capsule, and this in each dose, and not more than one dose every OTHER day, see?

Oil of Eucalyptus..........1 minim,
Canadian Balsam..........1/2 minim,
Rectified Oil of Turp....1/2 minim,
Benzosol.................1/2 minim.

...


...So we change these in a different vibration:

5. To 4 ounces of pure grain alcohol, add:

Eucalyptol................20 minims,
Rectified Creosote........10 minims,
Rectified Oil of Turp......8 minims,
BENZOIN...................15 minims,
Canadian Balsam............5 minims,
Tolu in Solution.........1/4 ounce.

Keep the solution in a container at least twice the size of the quantity, with a glass stopper. Shake solution when this is inhaled, and it may be inhaled either as the stimulant for the tendency of cold, congestion, or for the heart's reaction. So it may be inhaled through the nostrils and through the mouth, two, three, four times each day.
Canadian Balsam was turpentine made from the sap of the Canada balsam, so most of what he suggested for pellagra was some variation on the theme of "paint thinner," consumed or inhaled. Yeah, he nailed THAT one. :rolleyes:
 
Thanks for the actual citation unlike Rodney's very bad habit of never doing so.

So we have a second hand account recounted years after that provides no details at all about the actual presentation or treatment of the illness or treatment in question.
I'm just curious as to where and what was in Board's actual paper that was supposedly published by the Kentucky Medical Journal.
 
I have access to the readings on CD-ROM, so that probably makes it easier to cut and paste and provide direct citations.

But I'm also curious if there are significant medical or other errors in any of the readings I posted above.
 
Canadian Balsam was turpentine made from the sap of the Canada balsam, so most of what he suggested for pellagra was some variation on the theme of "paint thinner," consumed or inhaled. Yeah, he nailed THAT one. :rolleyes:

Don't be so quick to dismiss the benefits of ingesting turpentine.

http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/d...gus-urine-farts-and-benjamin-franklin-part-i/
“Certain it is also that we have the Power of changing by slight Means the Smell of another Discharge, that of our Water. A few Stems of Asparagus eaten, shall give our Urine a disagreable Odour; and a Pill of Turpentine no bigger than a Pea, shall bestow on it the pleasing Smell of Violets. And why should it be thought more impossible in Nature, to find Means of making a Perfume of our Wind than of our Water?”
 
I already mentioned I am working on a post that I will put up in a couple of days which will show without a doubt that lying is common practice with the A.R.E. and specifically purtaining to their claims for Atlantis which is their biggest money maker.

So if I prove the A.R.E. are lying about that, their credibility for everything else is moot isnt it

;)
two days
Tick, tock; tick, tock . . .
 
Tick, tock; tick, tock . . .

Since that offer you made it quite clear that you weren't interested in facts, just in your belief, so seeing as you are the only one here who is incapable of critical thinking I didn't bother. You want to stay ignorant, thats up to you.

But if you have suddenly had a change of heart
This was written by Greg Little, the head of the A.R.E.'s search for Atlantis in the Bahamas project which is the organisations biggest money spinner
read it and tell me what he got wrong
http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/ciencia/ciencia_adn05.htm

and then tell me why he got it wrong
:p

btw did you check out if eating raw wood is a cure for cancer yet as Cayce claimed it was ?
 
Since that offer you made it quite clear that you weren't interested in facts, just in your belief, so seeing as you are the only one here who is incapable of critical thinking I didn't bother. You want to stay ignorant, thats up to you.

But if you have suddenly had a change of heart
This was written by Greg Little, the head of the A.R.E.'s search for Atlantis in the Bahamas project which is the organisations biggest money spinner
read it and tell me what he got wrong
http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/ciencia/ciencia_adn05.htm

and then tell me why he got it wrong
:p
I breathlessly await your opinion as to where Dr. Little went wrong, but how, exactly, is someone presenting an opinion that Cayce may have been right about Atlantis evidence "that lying is common practice with the A.R.E."?

btw did you check out if eating raw wood is a cure for cancer yet as Cayce claimed it was ?
No, but I have confirmed, contrary to your claim, that a Cayce-supportive website faithfully reproduced the October 9, 1910 New York Times article about Cayce. See again http://www.cayce.com/nytimes.htm
 
I breathlessly await your opinion as to where Dr. Little went wrong, but how, exactly, is someone presenting an opinion that Cayce may have been right about Atlantis evidence "that lying is common practice with the A.R.E."?
Greg Little is a higher up in the A.R.E. he is in charge of their most prestigious project, he is clearly lying about the genetic evidence. You'd know that of course if you knew anything about genetics, unfortunately you don't, thats not uncommon and its what Greg Little is relying on to succesfully spread this lie. In fact genetics completely destroys anything Cayce said about Atlantis, it has no supporting genetic evidence at all, rather the evidence is all to the contrary

No, but I have confirmed, contrary to your claim, that a Cayce-supportive website faithfully reproduced the October 9, 1910 New York Times article about Cayce. See again http://www.cayce.com/nytimes.htm

Uh no, all you've done there again is proved that you either didn't read the original or yourself are now lying about what it says. Even if they had reproduced the newspaper article as it was written, that would again just prove that they were selecting what evidence to use as support, and an article written by a homeopath isn't very credible
:p
 
Last edited:
Greg Little is a higher up in the A.R.E. he is in charge of their most prestigious project, he is clearly lying about the genetic evidence. You'd know that of course if you knew anything about genetics, unfortunately you don't, thats not uncommon and its what Greg Little is relying on to succesfully spread this lie. In fact genetics completely destroys anything Cayce said about Atlantis, it has no supporting genetic evidence at all, rather the evidence is all to the contrary

What genetics evidence completely destroys anything Cayce said about Atlantis?

Also, what exactly did Cayce say about raw wood and cancer? Do you have the exact quote? This is one I haven't heard of before.
 
What genetics evidence completely destroys anything Cayce said about Atlantis?
.
There should be evidence of a genetic founding group around the coast of the Atlantic where the survivors of the Cataclysm made it to safety and helped the thicko locals start civilisations, there isn't
there should also be a genetic lineage without an origin point
there isn't, all genetic lineages lead back to Africa.
This page is the Nat Geo Genographic project
https://genographic.nationalgeographic.com/genographic/lan/en/atlas.html
It was created from Data collected from all haplogroups that make up humanity enabling them to create a very accurate map showing how every group alive today got to where they are also showing where they came from. You might have to spend a little while understanding it, but its designed with young adults in mind anyway, so its well worth the effort, something which no one at the A.R.E. has bothered to do from what I can see.

If you were asking me for a line by line deconstruction of what the A.R.E. are currently saying I can do that too, but you'd need to understand genetics to a minimum level to understand it

Also, what exactly did Cayce say about raw wood and cancer? Do you have the exact quote? This is one I haven't heard of before.
From the A.R.E. website
http://www.edgarcayce.org/health/database/health_resources/ultraviolet_light_therapy.asp
which was also discussed earlier in the thread
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5692818&highlight=animated#post5692818
Rodney stated that he'd require evidence that this therapy has been discredited before he believed it didn't cure cancer
:D
 
Last edited:
There should be evidence of a genetic founding group around the coast of the Atlantic where the survivors of the Cataclysm made it to safety and helped the thicko locals start civilisations, there isn't
there should also be a genetic lineage without an origin point
there isn't, all genetic lineages lead back to Africa.
This page is the Nat Geo Genographic project
https://genographic.nationalgeographic.com/genographic/lan/en/atlas.html
It was created from Data collected from all haplogroups that make up humanity enabling them to create a very accurate map showing how every group alive today got to where they are also showing where they came from. You might have to spend a little while understanding it, but its designed with young adults in mind anyway, so its well worth the effort, something which no one at the A.R.E. has bothered to do from what I can see.

If you were asking me for a line by line deconstruction of what the A.R.E. are currently saying I can do that too, but you'd need to understand genetics to a minimum level to understand it


From the A.R.E. website
http://www.edgarcayce.org/health/database/health_resources/ultraviolet_light_therapy.asp
which was also discussed earlier in the thread
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5692818&highlight=animated#post5692818
Rodney stated that he'd require evidence that this therapy has been discredited before he believed it didn't cure cancer
:D

What an interesting link (National Geographic), thanks! I'll keep reading through it. I could see on page 1 that Cayce's Atlantis story as it pertains to the origin of man had problems - just in the discussion of the Toba eruption. At any rate, IIRC Cayce claimed that man was a "special creation," with the 5 races all created at once, so for this to be true there should be a significant missing link in the fossil record, as I think was discussed earlier in the thread.

As for the animated ash, how funny. I'm thinking "ash" as in the remains of something burnt - did not link this to wood.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom