gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
I'm not sure what part of my statement regarding the brutality of 1970s inflation your link to investopedia was meant to counter.

Shadowstats shows an inflation measure of 8-10%, in the 1970s it was 15-25% (at least in the UK). Shadowstats is IMO bonkers and in no way aligns with my real-life experience. If Shadowstats was right (inflation at 8-10%, prices doubling every 8 years or so) , prices should be around 8x what they were when I started working and that simply isn't the case.


Specifically w.r.t. crude oil prices, If I understand it correctly, OPEC are highly influential in setting the oil price and they are a cartel. The main reason that crude is at the current price is that OPEC have balanced supply and demand and decided that it's the right price to extract the maximum return without completely knackering the world economy.

.....Edited to add......

Here's a cute site that allegedly gives prices of different foodstuffs over the years...

http://www.thepeoplehistory.com/90sfood.html

Considering shadowstats for reference prices should have:

- doubled since 2005
- quadrupled since 1996
- octupled since 1986
- multiplied roughly ten times what they were in 1980
- multiplied roughly twenty times what they were in 1976
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure what part of my statement regarding the brutality of 1970s inflation your link to investopedia was meant to counter.

well it was obviously some details on the US inflation which is what we're talking about primarily isn't it? implicit USD inflation in all things priced in USD.

Shadowstats shows an inflation measure of 8-10%, in the 1970s it was 15-25% (at least in the UK).

Im aware the UK was even worse, they had real currency problems too for a while, but being as all commodities are prmarily priced in USD their version seems more relevant?

Shadowstats is IMO bonkers and in no way aligns with my real-life experience. If Shadowstats was right (inflation at 8-10%, prices doubling every 8 years or so) , prices should be around 8x what they were when I started working and that simply isn't the case.

Considering shadowstats for reference prices should have:

- doubled since 2005
- quadrupled since 1996
- octupled since 1986 - multiplied roughly ten times what they were in 1980 - multiplied roughly twenty times what they were in 1976
[/quote]

Im not sure how you get the last 3 lines from the chart? not really, the divergence only started in the 80's and was a gradual couple of percent for a while, only reaching "doubling every ten years" levels from 96 onwards?

Specifically w.r.t. crude oil prices, If I understand it correctly, OPEC are highly influential in setting the oil price and they are a cartel. The main reason that crude is at the current price is that OPEC have balanced supply and demand and decided that it's the right price to extract the maximum return without completely knackering the world economy.

and if I understand it correctly they decided to jack up the prices to meet the inflation coming from the US deficit spending on Vietnam etc, and they also realized as they are sitting on a finite resource, once its all gone they'd rather be sitting on a huge pile of "the money of kings" than vulnerable inflating US paper.

but thats another story :D

.....Edited to add......

Here's a cute site that allegedly gives prices of different foodstuffs over the years...

http://www.thepeoplehistory.com/90sfood.html

Ive seen that before, it would be better if it had live updated current prices next to it.

and edit, of course none of this accounts for the inflation that's headed into financial assets since financialization, shadow banking and derivatives all got going around the same time.

edit some more..

doesnt seem like it's just oil, and think I can see some doubling and doubling again here too? its that same bottom left to top right drift that seems apparent everywhere for some reason :D (and I havent cherrypicked times either before you start, Ive just gone as far back as there are futures records on my trading platform for each commodity ;) )

moved image to link as its huge
 
Last edited:
with regards India's attacks on gold ownership because of their accounting or something, the latest from Sprott.

Silver is winning India's war against gold

these are the kind of unintended consequences that will blow up in their face for their arrogance to think they can control market forces.

As India continues to wage war with gold, investors are seeking out the yellow metal through any means available. Reports today suggest that there is not enough room on commercial flights into Dubai for all those investors seeking to purchase gold. “I cannot find a place for transporting gold on Emirates, on BA or Swiss Airlines this weekend,” lamented Tarek El Mdaka, the managing director of Kaloti Gold in Dubai adding he is shipping as much as 2 tonnes of gold every day.1 As we had suspected, it would appear that the Indian gold trade has moved offshore to avoid the restrictions on imports and extra taxes imposed. However, this is not the biggest change in the Indian precious metals market – silver imports have exploded.

Silver has not been exposed to the same import restrictions that gold has and recent silver import figures confirm that investors have flocked to silver, likely as a substitute for their desire for gold. And why shouldn’t they? With limited bank branches in the country, owning precious metals is synonymous with savings and security. While it seems that the larger investors have moved their gold purchases offshore, we suspect that the majority of Indian investors have turned to silver as a substitute for gold. The recent import numbers are staggering.

While India imported 1,900 tonnes of silver in 2012, in the first five months of 2013 alone, imports have touched 2,400 tonnes. According to industry estimates, silver imports during the January-March quarter stood at 760 tonnes. Imports shot up to 720 tonnes in April alone, and in May they further swelled by 920 tonnes.2

Let’s put these numbers in perspective, according to the Silver Institute, the world produced 24,478 tonnes of silver in 2012, implying that Indians have imported almost 10% of world production so far this year. If they continue to import at the same rate as they have in May, over the next 12 months India could import close to half of world silver production which is a truly staggering shift in demand for silver

Silver is the Achilles heel of the central planners unless the plan is to put all the miners out of business and claim their worthless mines. If the Comex blows up, it will be silver that sets it off.

and we'll soon know whether there's anything in this because if so, India will have to quickly tax it too, wont they?
 
Im not sure how you get the last 3 lines from the chart? not really, the divergence only started in the 80's and was a gradual couple of percent for a while, only reaching "doubling every ten years" levels from 96 onwards?

Back of fag packet calculation using the rule of 72

Inflation according to shadowstats was 5-8% on between 1986 and 1996 which means that prices would double every ten years or so.

Between 1980 and 1986 inflation was as high as 15% and as low as 3% which is why I (under) estimated a 25% increase in prices over that period.

Inflation was running at between 15 and 20% between 1976 and 1980 which means a doubling in prices in 4 years.

So overall,according to Shadowstats between 1976 and 2013 there will have been a 20-fold increase in prices.

According to the official figures it'd be more like a 4 fold increase.

Here's the Shadowstats calculator

http://www.shadowstats.com/inflation_calculator?amount1=100&y1=1976&m1=5&y2=2013&m2=5&calc=Find+Out

As a non-subscriber I don't have access to their final calculation but if the relative size of the green bar is an indicator, I'm not a million miles out.
 
with regards India's attacks on gold ownership because of their accounting or something, the latest from Sprott.

IIRC Sprott is always talking up the price of silver. His 2011 prediction that silver to gold would be a single digit multiplier didn't quite pan out:

http://www.zerohedge.com/article/eric-sprott-expect-gold-silver-ratio-hit-single-digits

His $100/oz "soon" didn't come to pass:

http://www.arabianmoney.net/gold-si...els-will-push-silver-to-100-says-eric-sprott/

Sprott is right as long as the price of silver is soaring. He could be right, silver could be about to soar in price to respond to Indian demand but he always has a reason for Silver to be about to soar.
 
I stand corrected, so are you predicting a n00% rise in the price of gold over the next few months ?

I'm not 100% sure the situations are analogous, we haven't had the inflation we had in the 1970s.

Peter Schiff is the author of the article. He is consistent in his "oh noes, teh sky is falling in" message. Eventually he will be correct but, IMO it will be right in the same way that a stopped clock is right twice a day.

Gold isn't a hedge against inflation. It's a hedge against negative real interest rates. It's also a hedge against deflation, because if that actually happens, your bank accounts are going to vaporize, and while gold will be worth nominally less, it will be worth relatively more.

I don't think Schiff accounts for the possibility of a debt-crisis induced deflationary collapse (I imagine he thinks it's a political impossibility, given the Fed), and I'm not sure he understands the effect of asset prices and trillions in Fed/bank sequestered money. But if you've taken his advice and simply bought gold when he started giving that advice, you've done quite well, despite the recent carnage in the paper gold market.
 
Gold isn't a hedge against inflation. It's a hedge against negative real interest rates. It's also a hedge against deflation, because if that actually happens, your bank accounts are going to vaporize, and while gold will be worth nominally less, it will be worth relatively more.

Maybe I've misunderstood deflation, maybe you're using deflation in a different way than other people. I thought that in a deflationary environment (like Japan has had for the last 20+ years), people kept their money in savings because the things they want to buy will be cheaper tomorrow. In terms of what they will buy, your savings will be worth more, they don't vaporise.
 
Maybe I've misunderstood deflation, maybe you're using deflation in a different way than other people. I thought that in a deflationary environment (like Japan has had for the last 20+ years), people kept their money in savings because the things they want to buy will be cheaper tomorrow. In terms of what they will buy, your savings will be worth more, they don't vaporise.

my take on his comment would be that given the amount of inflation that's found it's way into financial assets (and their derivatives on top on their derivatives leveraged [cubed] ) over the years, that if deflation ever arrives properly, the unwind will destroy the banking system.

If that is what he means, then I agree, it is, and always has been what QE is about, propping / reinflating the shadow banking industry before it can take the world down again.

otherwise how could my favorite bunch of drama queen CT bloggers have calculated exactly how much the next round of QE was going to be for, several months in advance?

The Fed Has Another $3.9 Trillion In QE To Go (At Least)
Submitted by Tyler Durden on 09/23/2012

It also explains why the Fed knew long ago, that it would have to engage in a relereving program that offset at least the continuing deleveraging in shadow aggregates: first $40 and then $85 billion a month sounds about right, and is an amount that will at best keep the system at its current state as opposed to actually growing it.

And while one does not have to be a rocket scientist to have grasped by now that all the Fed does is self-defeating, what the above analysis does do is provide a primer to all those Economy PhD's who still fail to grasp how the modern economy works, specifically why so far the inflationary surge has been deferred.

In short: the more the Fed actively relevers using conventional conduits that spur the threat of inflation, and the more that shadow conduits delever, the greater the risk that inflation will finally come to roost.

Because that $3.9 trillion in incremental reserves (and recall that already both BofA and Goldman, following our example, determined that the Fed will need to do at least another $2 trillion in QE, which means much more in reality) that will be created to offset the ongoing shadow deleveraging will simply pump up various asset classes, until the hard asset spillover finally hits, and no matter how much SPR jawboning, no matter how many CME margin hikes, no matter how many Saudi rumors of increase crude production, prices of hard assets will finally explode.

We can at this point say that an inflationary surge is an absolute certainty if not for one thing: if somehow the deleveraging in the shadow banking system is finally offset (and with the GSEs now in runoff mode this is a virtual impossibility), and Bernanke can take his foot off the gas, then there may still be a chance. However, as noted, 4 years in, this has not happened, and it will not happen for one simple reason: at its core, the market, which despite all of Bernanke's attempt to the contrary, realizes that a centrally planned system is ultimately unsustainable, and quietly, behind the scenes, those who have shadow credit relationships are promptly unwinding them while they still can, and using the proceeds to invest into hard asset for the inevitable T+1 moment.

The bottom line paradox here is that the more forcefully the Fed intervenes, the greater the implicit loss of confidence in the system, the greater the shadow deleveraging, and the more definitive is the ultimate destruction of the capital markets as we know them. Of course, there is still a chance that Bernanke will step back and realize what he is doing. However, since all Bernanke is, is a pawn of those whose wealth is conserved in the US equity tranche, it means that it is now, and has been for the past 4 years, impossible for him to stop.

watch what they do, not what they say.
 
my take on his comment would be that given the amount of inflation that's found it's way into financial assets (and their derivatives on top on their derivatives leveraged [cubed] ) over the years, that if deflation ever arrives properly, the unwind will destroy the banking system.

That's a deflation of the bubble, not deflation.

In a deflationary spiral, a loaf of bread costs a dollar today and 90c tomorrow.

In the situation you describe, it costs a dollar today but you cannot buy it with money tomorrow because the money is effectively worthless - that's super-duper-hyper inflation.
 
That's a deflation of the bubble, not deflation.

In a deflationary spiral, a loaf of bread costs a dollar today and 90c tomorrow.

yes, and surely this would apply to financial assets that require leverage to own too? deflation means assets fall, income falls, while debts remain = default likely?

In the situation you describe, it costs a dollar today but you cannot buy it with money tomorrow because the money is effectively worthless - that's super-duper-hyper inflation.

no, not necessarily, it can all be solved with a one-off wealth tax when the time comes? (first link in my signature) quick bail-ins and one-off tax to save the world and wee're sorted.

..presumably they'll still want currencies of some sort moving forwards?
 
Maybe I've misunderstood deflation, maybe you're using deflation in a different way than other people. I thought that in a deflationary environment (like Japan has had for the last 20+ years), people kept their money in savings because the things they want to buy will be cheaper tomorrow. In terms of what they will buy, your savings will be worth more, they don't vaporise.

Your savings in a bank account will vaporize, because banks will rapidly become insolvent. I'm talking about a hyper-deflationary debt crisis, when all the money creation music stops, including widespread bank failures like the great depression.
 
Your savings in a bank account will vaporize, because banks will rapidly become insolvent. I'm talking about a hyper-deflationary debt crisis, when all the money creation music stops, including widespread bank failures like the great depression.

Presumably these are bank failures so widespread that the bank guarantee scheme cannot compensate for them (so orders of magnitude worse than the Great Depression).

In that case I understand what you're on about, an almost complete failure of the banking system. I personally think that it is unlikely.
 
Gold flips Carney the Bird..

http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Pages/news/2013/007.aspx

1372937423-poundgold-55kb.png
 
The pound fell because hopes of an early(ish) interest rate rise, which were fueled by recent good UK economic news (GDP growth, service sector growth, house price rises, car sales) were dashed.

Gold rose in £ because the £ fell against the dollar. You could say the same about any commodity priced in dollars so equally......

Nickel flips Carney the bird
Coffee flips Carney the bird
Pork bellies flip Carney the bird
 
The pound fell because hopes of an early(ish) interest rate rise, which were fueled by recent good UK economic news (GDP growth, service sector growth, house price rises, car sales) were dashed.

Gold rose in £ because the £ fell against the dollar. You could say the same about any commodity priced in dollars so equally......

Nickel flips Carney the bird
Coffee flips Carney the bird
Pork bellies flip Carney the bird

I'm always skeptical of post hoc rationalizations of price moves.
 
Nickel flips Carney the bird
Coffee flips Carney the bird
Pork bellies flip Carney the bird

:D yea.. they all did..

except you can only trade most of them in USD as far as I'm aware, only seems to be metals that have FX crosses, that I've seen anyway..
 
I'm always skeptical of post hoc rationalizations of price moves.

In this case I think it is correct though.

Surely you don't think they are all simply random, do you? When a central bank issues a report like this, it often has an immediate and noticeable effect on exchange rates.
 
In this case I think it is correct though.

Surely you don't think they are all simply random, do you? When a central bank issues a report like this, it often has an immediate and noticeable effect on exchange rates.

Random enough that profiting from said reports or news is extremely difficult, if not impossible to do.

For instance, what financial headline would we expect to see after a coup in Egypt*?

"Egyptian markets plummet as uncertainty grips financial markets."

...or...

"Egyptian markets in a wait-and-see mode as coup drama plays out."

...or...

"Egyptian markets continue to soar to new highs, in spite of political unrest."

The same could be said for any jobs report or Bernanke reporting a hangnail or whatever.

Or let's say Apple announces a revolutionary new wearable computer that will kill Google Glass and change the very way we see computers, combined with record iPad/iPhone sales and record profits...

...and the stock goes down.

I'm not arguing for pure randomness - Taleb has already articulated the randomness inherent in markets far better than I. I'm arguing that free market mechanisms are just random enough to be unpredictable - or at least unpredictable enough that ending up with consistently profitable trades after commissions and taxes remains an elusive goal for many, if not most investors.


*I use this example because kevsta bemoaned the fact that he could not short Egyptian markets due to the coup, only to have those markets shrug off the coup and hit new highs. "Making predictions is hard, yada yada yada..." - Yogi Berra
 
Last edited:
In this case I think it is correct though.

Surely you don't think they are all simply random, do you? When a central bank issues a report like this, it often has an immediate and noticeable effect on exchange rates.

they're called "Tapebombs" and I find it impossible to believe that the top commercial and central bankers don't keep in very close contact about what's coming up.

Given that their main raison d'etre these days is saving the banking system, you can color me extremely skeptical that they hear about it as the same time we do in a conference or on Bloomberg.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom