gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
If this is the end of the secular bull then it's also been a particularly lame gold bull market, by average bull market standards

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/178524e450fd59d269.gif[/qimg]

we shall see.

Is there anything on that chart that's on there twice? Maybe the second time around it usually doesn't get so big. How about time-wise? How long does the average boom-bust cycle take? On Roger's graph, this one looks like it took longer to develop than the previous one, and may take longer to deflate too.

I agree with Fast Eddie that this time probably won't look exactly like the last time. The "classic" bubble shape in that graph is just a rough guess. If real bubbles followed that pattern exactly it would be too easy to make money. So I think asking whether we are in the "bear trap" or at the top of that graph is begging the question. Who says we're necessarily in that sort of pattern at all? Although it's also entirely possible that we are.
 
Any chart like this ignores "Black Swan" events, and shorting anything gives one virtually unlimited loss potential.
I agree, but past performance does show what can happen, which in this case is the exact opposite of what the gold shills keep telling us. None of them are predicting a long term slump - not because it's unlikely, but because that's not what they want to happen.

BTW, can anyone tell me why the "mean" line is drawn where it is? Seems arbitrary, in that it could (and should?) be drawn much steeper - would not the mean increase with price increases?
I think it was drawn there just to match the one in the 'typical asset bubble' graph. The price of a commodity should reflect the cost of producing it - therefore the mean value of gold should be up at around $1100 in 2013 (about where the chart says 'capitulation').

Puppycow said:
If real bubbles followed that pattern exactly it would be too easy to make money.
It's a remarkably close fit though - isn't it?

If I was a gambler then I would buy gold the instant it dropped below $1000. But since I'm not, I will leave my money in the bank.
 
Is there anything on that chart that's on there twice? Maybe the second time around it usually doesn't get so big.

Dow Jones bubble 1 1929 497%

Dow Jones Bubble 2 - 2008 1744%

common sense says that bubble size should grow along with the money (in circulation sloshing round markets - not the same thing) over time wouldn't it?

How about time-wise? How long does the average boom-bust cycle take?

secular markets (bull or bear) tend to last 5 to 25 years https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_trend

On Roger's graph, this one looks like it took longer to develop than the previous one, and may take longer to deflate too.

well, in fact in 1975-76 there was also a similar and thus far much more severe sell off, before the explosive action several years later
 
Last edited:
BIS Bears

the problem with the "this time its different" cliche is that it can often be applied to both sides of an argument.

the only version I have much confidence in over the longterm is this one

http://www.testosteronepit.com/home...ancial-lobby-for-25-years-its-never-been.html

"For 25 years its never been the right time to tighten"
Things move quickly at the G-20 when markets go south. The turmoil following Chairman Bernanke’s mere suggestion of a vague and slow taper of the Fed’s multi-year money-printing and bond-buying binge has already incited our illustrious finance gurus and central bankers at the G-20 to buckle, apparently.

At prior meetings, they might have palavered uneasily about the easy money, trying not to call it a currency war when Japan began to flood its land with it. But now, they suddenly fear the opposite, namely an exit, or even the mere suggestion of a taper, given the mayhem it had already caused in the markets.

So at their July meeting in Moscow, they will likely discuss how a taper might impact, say, emerging economies, according to unnamed Japanese officials, who leaked it to Dow Jones Newswires. And it would be “quite possible” that they will ask the IMF, if they haven’t already, to study the spillover effects of a taper. Because it’s not the right time to tighten.

“That’s the whole dilemma!”
said William White, one of the few central-bank economists who’d predicted the Financial Crisis with increasingly dire warnings when he headed the Monetary and Economic Department of the Bank for International Settlements (BIS). On its board, among other luminaries, sat the governors of the largest central banks in the world. Back then, his words were brushed off with that forced patience of the exasperated.

“For 25 years, it has never been the right moment,” he told the Spiegel Online. “It’s always: Yes, in the long term we need to stop with the policy of cheap money and just piling on debt. But please not right now; now the economy must first get back on its feet. That was the response to the 1987 stock-market crash, the 1997 Asian crisis, the internet bubble implosion in 2001, and the world financial crisis of 2008.”
He’d spent over two decades at the Bank of Canada before joining the BIS in Basel, Switzerland, in 1994. While at the BIS, he criticized Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan for his easy-money theories and the speculative asset bubbles and busts they engendered. At the Kansas City Fed’s annual meeting in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, in August 2003, he confronted the maestro, as the googly-eyed mainstream media still called Greenspan at the time, and challenged him: jack up interest rates when credit expands too fast and force banks to increase their capital cushions during fat years to use in lean years.

“We started worrying about this at the same time that Alan Greenspan started worrying about irrational exuberance,” White later told Bloomberg. “The difference was he stopped worrying about it, or at least he stopped worrying about it publicly, and we didn’t.”

Unlike Bernanke, who’d learned his lessons from the Great Depression, White learned his lessons from the vastly more relevant Japanese real-estate and stock-market bubbles in the 1980s, and their consequences, which he’d watched while at the Bank of Canada.

But didn’t the central banks, particularly the Fed, prevent an even worse worldwide recession with these easy-money policies? Yeah....

“But every time we fight the implosion of a speculative bubble with even more cheap money, we sow the seeds for the next even larger bubble,” he said. “All of the excess liquidity has to go somewhere.”

And it went somewhere. That “next even larger bubble” was already here, and we were in the middle of it, he said. “The stock market boom in Japan, followed by a sudden swoon. The prices of gold and other commodities, also with strong fluctuations. The gigantic flow of capital into emerging markets that is looking for investment opportunities there, and reacts very nervously at bad news. This volatility everywhere, that’s typical of a speculative bubble.”


recovery or mother of all (bond) bubbles, ( BB original ) that is the question.
 
I found this very intriguing chart on APF, comparing the gold price movement over the past few years to the famous 'typical bubble' pattern chart that we've all seen before.

One view says the gold bubble has already burst.

The other view says the gold bubble has just finished the bear trap phase and now prices will really take off!

What do you guys think is the more likely scenario?

If gold is in a bubble, why is it almost universally hated and despised? Why do "We buy gold" signs litter strip malls, and vastly outnumber tv ads hawking gold as an investment? Why do none of my friends and neighbors, save one, actually own any, or care to talk about the subject?

I refuse to read much into gold price/volume charts, because as I've claimed before I think the gold market is thoroughly manipulated, mostly via the issuance of paper/electronic gold promises. If gold is in a bubble, then it's the stealthiest, sneakiest asset bubble I've ever seen.
 
common sense says that bubble size should grow along with the money (in circulation sloshing round markets - not the same thing) over time wouldn't it?

That's the thing - the money isn't really in "circulation", it's sequestered by banks, and by the Federal Reserve. It's the same kind of folly as pointing to the "inflation-adjusted" price of gold and claiming that gold is vastly overpriced. Inflation as measured by what, and how?
 
If gold is in a bubble, why is it almost universally hated and despised? Why do "We buy gold" signs litter strip malls, and vastly outnumber tv ads hawking gold as an investment? Why do none of my friends and neighbors, save one, actually own any, or care to talk about the subject?

The reason why there are "We buy gold" signs out there is because there are a lot of less well off people who need money quickly to make ends meet. They have some gold jewelry they are willing to sell for pennies on the dollar. These people are not in the market for investments of any kind.

I refuse to read much into gold price/volume charts, because as I've claimed before I think the gold market is thoroughly manipulated, mostly via the issuance of paper/electronic gold promises. If gold is in a bubble, then it's the stealthiest, sneakiest asset bubble I've ever seen.

The price movement of gold over the last years certainly looks bubblish.
 
timeless analysis from Wall Street

talk about word for word..

Two years ago gold bugs ran wild as the price of gold rose nearly six times. But since cresting two years ago it has steadily declined, almost by half, putting the gold bugs in flight. The most recent advisory from a leading Wall Street firm suggests that the price will continue to drift downward, and may ultimately settle 40% below current levels.

The rout says a lot about consumer confidence in the worldwide recovery. The sharply reduced rates of inflation combined with resurgence of other, more economically productive investments, such as stocks, real estate, and bank savings have combined to eliminate gold's allure.

Although the American economy has reduced its rapid rate of recovery, it is still on a firm expansionary course. The fear that dominated two years ago has largely vanished, replaced by a recovery that has turned the gold speculators' dreams into a nightmare.

New York Times Aug 1976

This analysis provides a good representation of the current conventional wisdom. The only twist here is that the article from which this summary is derived appeared in the August 29, 1976 edition of The New York Times. At that time gold was preparing to embark on an historic rally that would push it up more than 700% a little over three years later.
 
Wow!

It almost seems they were unable to predict the future price of gold!

What are the odds???

Or maybe they just read the charts wrong!

the point is not that they couldnt predict the price of gold, but that word for word they were saying the same things about the economy recovery and inflation. interestingly, then, as now, it wasnt over yet.

the worldwide recovery. The sharply reduced rates of inflation combined with resurgence of other, more economically productive investments, such as stocks, real estate, and bank savings have combined to eliminate gold's allure.

Although the American economy has reduced its rapid rate of recovery, it is still on a firm expansionary course. The fear that dominated two years ago has largely vanished, replaced by a recovery

WRONG WRONG WRONG
 
the point is not that they couldnt predict the price of gold, but that word for word they were saying the same things about the economy recovery and inflation. interestingly, then, as now, it wasnt over yet.

So are you predicting that the price of gold will soar over the next few years based on the fact that some of the same economic signs are in place but ignoring others (like the fact that gold has risen significantly over the past 10 years).

Have the same economic signs been in place at any time outside the 1976-79 timefreme but failed to result in a significant rise in the price of gold ?
 
So are you predicting that the price of gold will soar over the next few years based on the fact that some of the same economic signs are in place but ignoring others (like the fact that gold has risen significantly over the past 10 years).

hmm, gold had already risen 600% when that was written, and then pulled back 50% hence the article?

Have the same economic signs been in place at any time outside the 1976-79 timefreme but failed to result in a significant rise in the price of gold ?

not in the middle of a gold secular bull market as far as Im aware? :D
 
hmm, gold had already risen 600% when that was written, and then pulled back 50% hence the article?

not in the middle of a gold secular bull market as far as Im aware? :D

I stand corrected, so are you predicting a n00% rise in the price of gold over the next few months ?

I'm not 100% sure the situations are analogous, we haven't had the inflation we had in the 1970s.

Peter Schiff is the author of the article. He is consistent in his "oh noes, teh sky is falling in" message. Eventually he will be correct but, IMO it will be right in the same way that a stopped clock is right twice a day.
 
I stand corrected, so are you predicting a n00% rise in the price of gold over the next few months ?

I'm not 100% sure the situations are analogous, we haven't had the inflation we had in the 1970s.

gotchya :D we have if you measure it the same way they did then.

Peter Schiff is the author of the article. He is consistent in his "oh noes, teh sky is falling in" message. Eventually he will be correct but, IMO it will be right in the same way that a stopped clock is right twice a day.

if Schiff is eventually right on his big call, nothing that's gone before will matter, and it can only happen the once. seriously, lets hope he's not.
 
the point is not that they couldnt predict the price of gold...

I suppose we can each look at repeated, numerous failed predictions over time and come away with our own conclusions.

You are still wired to see patterns - not unusual, since we all are genetically predisposed towards that sort of thing.

For now, you will continue to say, "this prediction was wrong because of x, and that prediction was wrong because of y" and so on, clinging to the assumption that markets are fundamentally predictable.

And maybe they are. For me the most elegant explanation of the virtual parity between correct and incorrect predictions is randomness. Maybe someone should write a book on the topic!

Then again, those most in need of its proposals are those least likely to read it.
 
if Schiff is eventually right on his big call, nothing that's gone before will matter...

Tell that to the investors that lost fortunes trying to follow his prior failed predictions.

If they were long every time he predicted an upswing and short every time he predicted a pullback, will they have anything at all left when the great bull finally awakes?

BTW, your above quote is classic "Confirmation Bias", which is often described as "Remembering the hits while forgetting the misses". You're primed to forget all his misses if he finally gets one big hit.

I'm not.
 
Last edited:
Tell l that to the investors that lst fortunes trying to follow his prior failed predictions.

If they were long every time he predicted an upswing and short every time he predicted a pullback, will they have anything at all left when the great bull finally awakes?

Schiff has been bullish on gold since 300, and the only time I ever heard him talk about a potential pullback was when Silver hit 45, I took his advice and rotated some out into gold, which then surged again later in 2011.

Schiff has been nothing but good, for me.

T
BTW, your above quote is classic "Confirmation Bias", which is often described as "Remembering the hits while forgetting the misses". You're primed to forget all his misses if he finally gets one big hit.

I'm not.

:) seriously? if we get the actual crash ($ collapse and bond market) he is shouting louder than ever about lately, I don't think much that happened before would really matter anymore, only how you fared in the endgame really. it would be like the dinosaurs all standing round arguing about yesterdays bones while the meteor strikes.

I don't know if that's going to happen or not, but I do know we have a whole lot of un-payable debt that needs to be written off worldwide and there will ultimately be a market clearing event and consequences from the great monetary experiment.

if not, it will be the first time ever.
 
I don't know if that's going to happen or not...

Grasshopper,

True wisdom comes from truncating thoughts. ;)

...but...

"There is either happen or not happen. There is no but."


YOda_900.jpg


BTW, my ear hairs definitely need a trim!
 
gotchya :D we have if you measure it the same way they did then.

No, not even close, even using the spurious Shadowstats measure. Inflation back in the 1970's was brutal.

We've already had this discussion and I've explained why I think you're wrong. The current inflation measure should reflect what we currently spend money on. It's as if the current inflation measure should include broadswords, chargers and Papal indulgences.
 
No, not even close, even using the spurious Shadowstats measure. Inflation back in the 1970's was brutal.

We've already had this discussion and I've explained why I think you're wrong. The current inflation measure should reflect what we currently spend money on. It's as if the current inflation measure should include broadswords, chargers and Papal indulgences.

hmm

http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/1970s-great-inflation.asp

This is the gruesome story of the great inflation of the 1970s, which began in late 1972 and didn't end until the early 1980s. In his book, "Stocks for the Long Run: A Guide for Long Term Growth" (1994), Professor Jeremy Sigel, called it "the greatest failure of American macroeconomic policy in the postwar period."

The great inflation was blamed on oil prices, currency speculators, greedy businessmen and avaricious union leaders. However, it is clear that monetary policies, which financed huge budget deficits and were supported by political leaders, were the cause. This mess was proof of what Milton Friedman said in "Money Mischief. Episodes in Monetary History" (1994): inflation is always "a monetary phenomenon." The great inflation, and the recession that followed, wrecked many businesses and hurt countless individuals. Interestingly, John Connolly, the Nixon-installed treasury secretary without formal economics training, later declared personal bankruptcy. (Read more about Friedman's contributions in Free Market Maven: Milton Friedman.)

Yet these unusually bad economic times were preceded by a period in which the economy boomed, or appeared to boom. Many Americans were awed by the temporarily low unemployment and strong growth numbers of 1972. Therefore, they overwhelmingly re-elected their Republican President Richard Nixon, and their Democratic Congress in 1972; Nixon, the Congress and the Federal Reserve failed them.

compare the oil price 70's to 80's with 2000 until today in 2010 dollars

of course it's all still (evil evil) speculators and big oil etc that have given us an $75-80 (WTI floor) the last 3 years though.

edit you might think Shadowstats is spurious, I would argue that it least its still apples and hasn't morphed into moonfruit.

and if this is closer to the truth, 8-10% per annum cumulative since the mid 90's has us ending up not far off back where we started in 1980
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom