It's all RIGHT THERE in front of you - if only you can see it!!!
I think you still possibly have the wrong idea about what it is I'm actually doing though. I get what you are trying to say with the second picture, but to continue with that scenario for a second, I actually agree with you, that is what most "retail" traders are doing, pretty much. (and by retail, lets only separate marketmakers from everybody else here.)
the actual story line, if I were to assume Crowe's role, is more like that after the first 8 months of trying to work it out from all the papers on the walls, my (make believe) best friend actually convinces me
this world
is all imaginary, and only the completely insane could ever think that could work.
It just so happens that my trading "best friends" are privy to some information about certain marketmaker techniques (since the dawn of time, but in highly efficient automated mode these days) which are
designed to elicit emotional and bad responses from traders looking at papers on their walls.
if we know that markets are a zero sum game (at best, spreads etc) and we know that 90%+ of retail traders lose money, so we can logically conclude that
somebody won that money? and we also know that the marketmakers win consistently,
(100% trading quarters) and a small percentage of retail traders as well.
so how can this possibly be done? what do they know, or do, that we don't? you didnt answer my question about whether this is actually technical analysis or not either?

clearly though, we want to be facing in opposition to the 90% L-O-S-
E-R-S at pretty much all times.
the gold trade above (
and the anti-Stolper Euro trade ) is a clear demonstration of doing exactly that. After 3 heavy falls over a week or so, at $1180, the whole retail world are the most bearish they've ever been, I started hearing idiots going on about $400 gold (on CNBC, the herd is most definitely always most bearish at the bottom) but anybody shorting there was clearly being mugged. If they did it on my broker, I actually mugged them, alongside the smart money who are
only buying down here (thus far)
how did I know that? we're at the end of SM push 3 and have seen the trend exhaustion candle, same ol' same old. it might pop a bit lower first and stop me out, but it might run and win 5 or 6 times my potential loss. it's not rocket science lads, but it's not T/A either.
and let me clarify this, it's not taking a trade from a candle pattern alone, you see those all the time, everywhere, in every direction intraday, it
only matters, when it's in the right place, at the right time, in the cycle context. It's pretty simple to know if we got it right, because the price will reverse, for at least one push higher. the trend reversal candle is in reality a sharp markdown of the price as SM exits their now profitable positions, triggering retail sell orders, to which they then close out their short positions into (a buy to match the retail sell) and then back into the level 3 accumulation zone, the next main move is then funnily enough, almost always higher.
I could live with "Retail Trader Analysis" because although we do have certain averages and pivots on there, its because we need to know what retail are looking at and where their orders likely sit. this is how the high probability manipulation points are picked out in advance, and then only take the trade if the manipulation is clear. occasionally I highlight when indicators say to take the trade, but that's only ever as a *confirmation* of a trade we are
already looking for and expecting in line with cycle.
the point being, that we are trying to identify the SM cycle, and if we do so correctly, at any point, we have the big move of the day in front of us, for a smaller potential loss. can it be done every day? no, of course not. does it matter? no, if you can maintain a 50/50 win loss ratio at 2:1 risk reward, you will be rich in a few short years.
the charts give us price history and the facade that retail attempts to trade with rearward facing indicators. they all lose doing that because something
else actually drives the markets on a day to day basis, and the evidence strongly suggests that attempting to identify and follow that is a much better proposition than what everybody else does.