gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
something big going on underneath the gold market

So if the price of gold doesn't soar in the next few days we can assume that zerohedge is once again like a guard dog barking at every shadow (I mean from time to time the shadow may contain a burglar but mostly it's just annoying pointless barking). :p
 
No, not necessarily. He might die first. He might need to cash it in first. Plus the price rise would have to be greater than cumulative inflation to be a real profit rather than just a nominal profit.

If he dies he's unlikely to care too much about his investments :D.

IMO cumulative inflation is irrelevant when discussing whether an investment was a good one, the only thing that matters is whether he could have done something better with the money. By this I mean that Gold (or cheese or art or cars or whatever) would be a good investment even if it lost money against inflation if most other investments performed even worse over the same period. I cannot berate someone investing in gold and losing 10% against inflation if my balanced portfolio of cash, stocks, bonds, property and commodities has lost 15% :D
 
...the only thing that matters is whether he could have done something better with the money.

I would say that there is virtually always something better one could have done with one's money.

Because its difficult, if not impossible, to know in advance which asset or asset class will out perform the others, the wisest long term strategy has to involve diversification.

When I set up my IRA years ago, I split it more or less evenly between different mutual funds. Some income oriented, some growth oriented, some small cap, some blue chip, some technology. Looking now at their relative performance, it's easy to kick myself hard for not having the foresight to put it ALL into the tech sector. But, of course, at any given time you don't know going forward what's going to happen - though it always seem so clear in hindsight.

But, of course, I do get your point. My advice would still be to invest in a broad spectrum of asset classes. And that what kevsta is attempting here is not really investing at all - even if he finds a scheme that makes him money over time, he's never really invested in anything - just in and out of markets short term. I'd still say he's (almost literally) chasing pennies while leaving the dollars on the table, but I've enjoyed watching his machinations and I hope he ends up on the right side of the bell curve that these kind of speculators fall upon and becomes very, very rich!
 
Last edited:
I would say that there is virtually always something better one could have done with one's money.

Well sure so maybe I should say "whether there is something that he could reasonably have done with that money". In my case, because I'm a lazy and risk averse investor, the alternatives to buying a bunch of silver would be:

- Leaving the money on deposit in the bank
- Investing it in UK government bonds
- Investing it in a mutual find which tracks one or more of the major markets
- (maybe) buying an investment property

If silver outperforms these, even if it doesn't generate a positive return against inflation then I'd have no reason to criticise.

As you point out however, diversification is good
 
I would say that there is virtually always something better one could have done with one's money.

Because its difficult, if not impossible, to know in advance which asset or asset class will out perform the others, the wisest long term strategy has to involve diversification.

When I set up my IRA years ago, I split it more or less evenly between different mutual funds. Some income oriented, some growth oriented, some small cap, some blue chip, some technology. Looking now at their relative performance, it's easy to kick myself hard for not having the foresight to put it ALL into the tech sector. But, of course, at any given time you don't know going forward what's going to happen - though it always seem so clear in hindsight.

But, of course, I do get your point. My advice would still be to invest in a broad spectrum of asset classes. And that what kevsta is attempting here is not really investing at all - even if he finds a scheme that makes him money over time, he's never really invested in anything - just in and out of markets short term. I'd still say he's (almost literally) chasing pennies while leaving the dollars on the table, but I've enjoyed watching his machinations and I hope he ends up on the right side of the bell curve that these kind of speculators fall upon and becomes very, very rich!

I had the same thought setting up my kid's college fund. Then I remembered Pets.com, and I spread things around.
 
I had the same thought setting up my kid's college fund. Then I remembered Pets.com, and I spread things around.

My "missed opportunity" was a little software company in the mid-80's that was going public. I forget its name, but I was using some of their software and liked it and thought it might be a decent "flyer".

My broker thought the IPO was a bit overpriced and talked me out of it.



Oh, and I just remembered the name - Microsoft. You may have heard of it? :mad:
 
My "missed opportunity" was a little software company in the mid-80's that was going public. I forget its name, but I was using some of their software and liked it and thought it might be a decent "flyer".

My broker thought the IPO was a bit overpriced and talked me out of it.



Oh, and I just remembered the name - Microsoft. You may have heard of it? :mad:

Ouch. But you can't beat yourself up over it. I almost bought 500 hundred shares of Ford, when it was trading around $2 in 2009. But I thought Ford was going under. Damnit! LOL.

If I had some money lying around, I would buy a couple shares of Google (a couple shares is what, two grand? WTF???). But all our money is going into improving the new house we bought. It sold for $435k in 2006, and we got it as a foreclosure last year for $200k.

I'm hoping in the next five years, with a lot of improvements, it might crack the half-million mark. If it does, I'm selling and buying a house half the size. No mortgage, and maybe $100k in cash. But who knows what will happen, and enough of my life story, lol.
 
My "missed opportunity" was a little software company in the mid-80's that was going public. I forget its name, but I was using some of their software and liked it and thought it might be a decent "flyer".

My broker thought the IPO was a bit overpriced and talked me out of it.



Oh, and I just remembered the name - Microsoft. You may have heard of it? :mad:

Could have been worse, you could have bought the shares, sold them a few months later for a modest gain and then watched for the next 30 years or so.

I on the other hand had the misfortune to ride a share price from £9 a share to 35p a share during a time when I was legally unable to sell the shares :(.
 
I've done well enough in the market overall, with a few big winners and lots of smaller ones. And lots of boring dividend utility stocks.

Then again, I bought some Pan Am at $5 hoping for a Chrysler-like turnaround - bought some more at $3. Lost it all.

Had some Enron as a result of a spinoff - rode it all the way down.

Bought some Exelsior-Henderson and some Polaris as Harley competitors. Excelsior-Henderson - gone. Polaris, on the other hand, doing quite well. Points out the benefits of diversification.
 
Gold is a weird critter. Amongst commodities the supply and grown is far in excess of it's uses and consumption.

Does the best in economic stress. It's a kind of fiat that people ascribe value to buttressed by, unlike other fiat, the fact it can't be created.

I think it is both overpriced and could well go up in spite of that.
 
I still allege that in a free market, "overpriced" is meaningless, except possibly in retrospect.

What exactly do you mean when you use the term?

Overpriced in reference to general purchasing power over, say, the last 100 years. It's purchasing power to a basket of comparable goods has been fairly stable over very long periods of time quite possibly because of it's widespread use as specie. It gradually lost that in the last century. At the same time banking crises decreased in frequency. I see no reason it won't regress to the mean at some point in the future when global debt load regresses to the mean. One way or the other.

Controlled inflation with fiat supports economic growth and also allows central banks more flexibility in aborting bank runs. OTOH, there are other and different risks associated with fiat and a bit less history to go by.
 
Last edited:
Gold is a weird critter. Amongst commodities the supply and grown is far in excess of it's uses and consumption.

Does the best in economic stress. It's a kind of fiat that people ascribe value to buttressed by, unlike other fiat, the fact it can't be created.

I think it is both overpriced and could well go up in spite of that.

Fiat means "by decree". Gold is not fiat at all. I don't know why otherwise intelligent people on this skeptics forum repeatedly try to draw that analogy, as if by making reference to the subjective aspect of valuation they can confer the notion that such a silly metal shouldn't be valued at all. There is no one decreeing from on high that gold is to be valued. It has value by consensus, and for the same properties that make it an independent, alternative form of money.

Fiat as it applies to fiat money specifically involves authorities and the use of force requiring society to accept such money. This has zero to do with gold at all.
 
Overpriced in reference to general purchasing power over, say, the last 100 years. It's purchasing power to a basket of comparable goods has been fairly stable over very long periods of time quite possibly because of it's widespread use as specie. It gradually lost that in the last century. At the same time banking crises decreased in frequency. I see no reason it won't regress to the mean at some point in the future when global debt load regresses to the mean. One way or the other.

You're making the same mistake that most critics of gold make, by assuming that "purchasing power" is limited to some government defined index, like CPI. How does gold compare to other asset prices, like bonds, stocks, or real estate? Bonds have more or less gone straight up as interest rates have been suppressed by the Federal Reserve, should gold have declined in this environment because the doctored CPI doesn't seem to budge much? I think not.

The only way "global debt load" is going to decrease, is by economic calamity, default, repudiation, or hyperinflation. Witness what the price of gold has done just in light of the Detroit bankruptcy. The problem with your concept of the "mean" is that your numeraire is the US dollar.

Controlled inflation with fiat supports economic growth and also allows central banks more flexibility in aborting bank runs. OTOH, there are other and different risks associated with fiat and a bit less history to go by.

Utter and complete nonsense. Monetary inflation is nothing more than a naked transfer of wealth, and the people who control the Fed and issue themselves the cheap/free money require society to believe that garbage in order that they may continue to perpetuate their scam.
 
And still the purchasing power of the citizenry has increased two-fold compared to inflation since all that monetary inflation began, lol.
 
And still the purchasing power of the citizenry has increased two-fold compared to inflation since all that monetary inflation began, lol.
Had wages kept pace with the growth in the money supply, the average worker would be on at least $100 per hour by now.

The shrinking wage is being masked by technological progress which makes electronics dirt cheap.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom