gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
stillicho didnt you say you work in mining or metals or something?

how's business? it's looking pretty bad for the miners now isnt it?

where are you on this distribution curve, left or right end?

No I am not a mining or metals guy at all. I spent some time in the energy sector but I have been in the financial services sector now for over fifteen years.

The funny thing is that metal commodities are no good but some of the mining ventures are still worthwhile looking at.

Ask psion: I like banks! Without them we are naked savages clawing at sterile soil as mere animals. :D

Oh, and Brazilian telecoms. Boy, do they ever honour their dividend obligations. Very similar in capital structure to nineteenth century American railroads.

EDIT: I think I know where you got that idea, though. One of our BUs does purchase gold but we are deep discounters so the price collapse simply means we pay even less although regulators sometimes make us hang on to the inventory longer than I'd prefer.
 
Last edited:
So the bad news about the downward revision of GDP growth means that it's less likely that the QE tap will be turned off which in turn means that interest rates will continue to be low and stocks will continue to be the best (or least bad) game in town.

more or less yes, stock markets still playing CogDis2013 and wanting to believe the dovishness Hilsenrath wants us to believe.

Bonds & High Yield credit are not believing it.

IMO (and IMO only) silver and gold still feel a little high priced at the moment and I think they will be oversold (in the same way they were overbought in the 10 year metal rally) so there may still be a considerable downside. That said, my unscientific gut has in the past shown itself to be rubbish so we should probably expect silver to be over $100/oz within the week :D

Re "oversold" its a technical term, and you are already correct, we're now more oversold than any time since 1996 and at similar extreme readings to the 2010/2011 topping period.

RSI.png


there is of course nothing to say that the RSI cannot hang around in this area bumping up and down (like the 2010/2011 topping RSI action) while price works lower.

but again I'd ask the question, how much lower than the cost to get it out of the ground can it go? and for how long? (assuming the whole world doesn't suddenly "realize" after 5000 years of confusion that it's entirely useless after all, in which case all bets are off)

The only other thing to consider with Oversold & Overbought is that the more extreme the condition, the more extreme the eventual reaction.
 
No I am not a mining or metals guy at all. I spent some time in the energy sector but I have been in the financial services sector now for over fifteen years.

ok, I wasn't aware of that, I thought you were an accountant in a mining company or something.

The funny thing is that metal commodities are no good but some of the mining ventures are still worthwhile looking at.

hmm. which ones?

Ask psion: I like banks! Without them we are naked savages clawing at sterile soil as mere animals. :D

lulz. and because of the more shadowy type, we may well be once again at some point ;)
 
so $1200 - have to say I didn't think we'd see that. wrong wrong wrong. wrongiest wrong'un ever.

I still think you should have bet me, although to be fair the postage for a 1 Oz silver coin would be worth more than the coin by the time you get it.
 
so $1200 - have to say I didn't think we'd see that. wrong wrong wrong. wrongiest wrong'un ever.

Don't feel bad.

Anyone trying to predict what a freely traded market will do is bound to be wrong about 50% of the time, overall.

So, hopefully, your next guess will be right - have to regress to the mean, after all!
 
so $1200 - have to say I didn't think we'd see that. wrong wrong wrong. wrongiest wrong'un ever.

I still think you should have bet me, although to be fair the postage for a 1 Oz silver coin would be worth more than the coin by the time you get it.

:rub:

I think that the main reason is that the central prediction of the gold bulls did not come true, or at least hasn't come true yet. You know, remember the reason that gold and silver were going to go through the roof? Remember Helicopter Ben was supposed to cause hyperinflation? Now QE has almost run its course, the economy is growing again, not great but growing; the unemployment rate is coming down in the US, and inflation, again in the US is still under 2%.

I think that if you want to figure out why the price of gold didn't do what you thought it would, you have to figure out why QE didn't lead to hyperinflation like you and many other gold bulls were sure, certain that it would.
 
ok, I wasn't aware of that, I thought you were an accountant in a mining company or something.



hmm. which ones?



lulz. and because of the more shadowy type, we may well be once again at some point ;)

Any mining venture that also has their hand in the energy sector is OK plus, of course, the extraction process supply chain (a couple good Korean heavy industry firms).

Randy Cass, of BNN's Market Sense, asked rhetorically yesterday just what gold is supposed to be anyhow. I think it's a good question and, although he didn't have an AAPL chart up there as you have, he might have found something of an answer there. He went through all the things it isn't: store of value, counterbalance to the USD, security against inflation, etc, etc.

I think you're right about AAPL in more than a few ways. A lot of its price appears to be due to fanaticism instead of any of the fundamentals. Its products are nowhere near as unique or indispensible as their promoters claim. Sounds a lot like gold (or silver).

The difference is that gold still has a lot of "true believer" priced into it while AAPL is still a competitive firm with a lot of smart people working at it to create new products for their customers. The chance of AAPL rebounding to its former glory is considerably better than that of gold.
 
:rub:

I think that the main reason is that the central prediction of the gold bulls did not come true, or at least hasn't come true yet. You know, remember the reason that gold and silver were going to go through the roof? Remember Helicopter Ben was supposed to cause hyperinflation? Now QE has almost run its course, the economy is growing again, not great but growing; the unemployment rate is coming down in the US, and inflation, again in the US is still under 2%.

I think the main reason that the central prediction of the gold bulls did not come true, is because the precious metals markets are highly manipulated, because there is simply no other way to sustain the fiat money/perpetual debt scam otherwise. Remember, all they have to do is scare the bejeezus out of precious metals investors, and they will flee and be herded back into paper, and that isn't counting the "gold" investors who merely have paper claims. In other news, it sort of did come true for me. Remember my cost bases are south of $300 and $6?

I think that if you want to figure out why the price of gold didn't do what you thought it would, you have to figure out why QE didn't lead to hyperinflation like you and many other gold bulls were sure, certain that it would.

I've explained why QE didn't lead to hyperinflation numerous times, you either did not understand what I wrote, or chose to ignore it. The inflation has found its way into asset prices, mostly bonds and other sovereign debt obligations, for which the supply of those is also practically infinite! So we have a case of savers (mostly the poor and middle class) who are being perpetually diluted such that financial assets (held mostly by the mega-wealthy elite banking class, the merely rich, and the upper middle class) grow nominally wealthier, even while the financial assets they hold are themselves being diluted. The banker class is the only one actually growing richer by this process, as they're the direct beneficiaries of the new money. The rich and middle class are only getting relatively less poor than the bankers, all of this at the expense of the poor, who are not only nearly priced out of food, but precious Manhattan real estate, and cash-flow producing financial assets as well. Take a look at the price of a prime Manhattan condo and talk to me about "hyperinflation".

If "QE" were actually progressive, it might result in everyone getting checks cut for them proportionally, and you would see consumer prices rise as consumers would have more money to spend. As it is, it is just a regressive tax resulting in nothing other than a series of asset bubbles, as rich bankers don't double their food consumption or buy more flat-screen TVs with free money, they just use it to acquire more real estate in the Hamptons, or bonds for which your tax dollars pay the interest. Understand now?
 
so $1200 - have to say I didn't think we'd see that. wrong wrong wrong. wrongiest wrong'un ever.

I still think you should have bet me, although to be fair the postage for a 1 Oz silver coin would be worth more than the coin by the time you get it.

Kevsta, I hope you do well with your charts. If you catch another bull market...forget about it!
 
Typically, the next steps for someone like kevsta would be...

1) Special Pleading

"The charts DID predict everything with their trend lines and moving averages and triangles and mean regression, but I just read them wrong. This time."

2) Cherry Picking/Confirmation Bias

Pour over the thousands of predictions (guesses?) by pundits of all stripes and point to the handful that "got it right". Use that to confirm that these market moves are inherently predictable, ignoring or discounting all the erroneous guesses.

BTW, I had a stop loss in for some of my APPL @ $400, and got stopped out. I do think "resistance levels" and the like are imaginary, FWIW.

Looking at GOOG, RGR and, yes, some physical silver for some of the proceeds.

AAPL still has potential, but needs to do something new to justify its valuation. GOOG seems to have all the mojo at the current time.
 
Typically, the next steps for someone like kevsta would be...

1) Special Pleading

"The charts DID predict everything with their trend lines and moving averages and triangles and mean regression, but I just read them wrong. This time."

no I don't think it's possible to say that, nobody can predict an event that statistically only happens as often as our Sun burning out.

whats happened since then was easier to predict, remember pirate bear market man?

Quote:
Big,classic descending triangles on dailies brokedown finally, this is not a time to be averaging down imo. Momentum players are back in heavy, pirates with knives between their teeth emerging from the waves and hacking away between the scapulas of the once proud metals.

Whats in play is the short side now. I am small short now and will short bounces, I am recalling Armstrong projecting 12-1300 areas and the weakness in the chart confirms that as a possibility, there has been sea change in perception of metal over the last year and many dissappointed investors who do not want to be left holding the bag after a long multi-year climb are understandably pissed off.

The race for the revolving glass exit door has begun and several hapless casualties were already squashed in the turnstiles as the pigmen grunted and squealed on their way out the other side. The game now is about capital preservation and survival pure and simple.

We are in Momentum Land now and the Market in M.Land is cruel and unforgiving. Silver headed to 22 now, triangle break just today. Pull up a monthly chart. Next targets are in the 22-18 zone imo and the pirates will be out in force i think on every bounce and leveraging every down move.

note, this was not macro or fundamentals forecasting, entirely unrelated, this is a careers worth of experience of how the big traders play.

and I'm in no way defending my chart reading or predictions, however mean reversion is just plain old boring scientific fact, in the same way that nature moves towards stasis markets revert eventually.

the gold price is in one way (timeframe) doing it right now. however as with all things observed, different timescales and views yield different results, and you could show a different mean for many different views.

to actually predict anything correctly, however would involve have any idea which mean is getting reverted to next, and its fair to say I wasn't expecting this one yet.

2) Cherry Picking/Confirmation Bias

Pour over the thousands of predictions (guesses?) by pundits of all stripes and point to the handful that "got it right". Use that to confirm that these market moves are inherently predictable, ignoring or discounting all the erroneous guesses.

no, I am and have been, well aware of all the commentary in both directions, all the way through.

BTW, I had a stop loss in for some of my APPL @ $400, and got stopped out. I do think "resistance levels" and the like are imaginary, FWIW.

I don't understand how you don't get this? If say I have bought 100 million Nikkei stocks of some sort back in January with a sell target of say (equiv) NKD 15500..?

when the market starts coming into my sell zone there are now 100 million stocks there that first need to be sold at my pre-targeted price, before the market can move higher? (discounting market maker tricks gapping higher etc)

So if buyers don't number more than say 10 million stocks per day, my selling will always overpower the buying up until all my stock is cleared at those prices, then allowing price to move higher? this is basic market mechanics, this much is not debatable really.

Looking at GOOG, RGR and, yes, some physical silver for some of the proceeds.

AAPL still has potential, but needs to do something new to justify its valuation. GOOG seems to have all the mojo at the current time.

hope you're reading Reggie M on this too?
 
Oh, and Brazilian telecoms. Boy, do they ever honour their dividend obligations. Very similar in capital structure to nineteenth century American railroads.

There are some American utility companies that are still in the widows and orphans category. TXU was awesome until it went private and I've got another that I've moved some .25% savings money into and getting a nice quarterly dividend.
 
kevsta,

Rather than counter my prediction of how you would react to failed predictions, I think you fulfilled it.

"These things are easy to predict, except when they're not".

"Look at this one guy that got it right! He must be prescient and these things ARE predictable!"

"If I look hard enough, I can tease out a time frame or time scale where a prediction was, in fact, correct."

And so on. Readers are free to label the above statements with their associated fallacies.

As far as me "not getting" trading ranges and resistance levels and the like, a lifetime of watching technical analysts throw around these concepts has convinced me they're bogus. As a hypothetical, let's say there was something mystical about Dow 15,000. As the Dow recently fell to that level, there are three things that could have happened:

1) It could have "met resistance" and gone back up, establishing 15,000 as the low end of a range.

2) It could have lingered in that area, establishing a new range and confirming "resistance" in that area, or,

3) It could have "broken a support level" and fallen further.

If you put forth a theory where every eventuality confirms the theory, it becomes unfalsifiable and is no longer scientific. It certainly has no predictive value.

Again, what do YOU think the charts predict about the prices of gold and silver, and in what time frame?

Also, I do not know who Reggie M is.
 
Last edited:
kevsta,

Rather than counter my prediction of how you would react to failed predictions, I think you fulfilled it.

"These things are easy to predict, except when they're not".

hmm. when did I say that? while I respect your lifetime of watching markets and charts, I wonder possibly if maybe your memory is not so good any more? :D

"Look at this one guy that got it right! He must be prescient and these things ARE predictable!"

no? that quote was in direct response to you asking me what was going to happen next in fact back then.

this was my response

what happens to "price" in the meantime is anyone's guess.

chart-wise, a good trader I know wrote this yesterday, this is what *should* now happen if you believe in technicals. maybe it will. - followed by the quote

"If I look hard enough, I can tease out a time frame or time scale where a prediction was, in fact, correct."

again, please cite?

As far as me "not getting" trading ranges and resistance levels and the like, a lifetime of watching technical analysts throw around these concepts has convinced me they're bogus.

in some ways I agree with you, they can be overcome when required, put it that way. however I'm interested in what you think actually happens at the business end of bid ask spread, to drive the price, if not volume of buys and sells? is it just a complete computer generated matrix farce after all then? there are those who think that too you know, which is why I ask ;)

As a hypothetical, let's say there was something mystical about Dow 15,000. As the Dow recently fell to that level, there are three things that could have happened:

1) It could have "met resistance" and gone back up, establishing 15,000 as the low end of a range.

that would be "support" then.

2) It could have lingered in that area, establishing a new range and confirming "resistance" in that area, or,

3) It could have "broken a support level" and fallen further.

If you put forth a theory where every eventuality confirms the theory, it becomes unfalsifiable and is no longer scientific.

It certainly has no predictive value.

I don't understand what theory you think I'm putting forwards? support / resistance? the eternal battle between buyers and sellers?

Again, what do YOU think the charts predict about the prices of gold and silver, and in what time frame?

again, and again

lulz, no, this is just standard tech analysis being explained as I understand it, and with a little SM manipulation principles thrown in occasionally wherever I can add to the more usual tech stuff with more specific trading principles (theories to be precise)

you'll notice I'm non-commital as to the eventual direction, because as I told you I'm trading manipulation at hourly or 15min levels in general, and I might get 10 or 12 separate shorts in the course of one monthly red downbar here.

and as I've clearly proved with gold that I don't know the next intermediate trend, so I'm staying off big predictions now, but just trying to showing the big picture as seen by trader world in general.

ie this question is going nowhere, so you may as well stop asking it ;)

Also, I do not know who Reggie M is.

well you did a few weeks ago because we had a decent discussion about his predictive powerz with Apple valuations, margin compression and Google into the future, in fact the day you put your stoploss on AAPL, remember?
 
In other words, gold bugs are right, reality is wrong. Surprise, surprise.

Gold is just a shiny, inert metal, with an illustrious history. Gold bugs aren't "right" because the price goes up, they're right because they correctly recognize that the path to a free, prosperous, and equitable society begins with money that can't be diluted.

Whether or not society-at-large recognizes this sooner rather than later will determine whether we destroy ourselves or not.
 
Is Gold in a Bubble?

I found this very intriguing chart on APF, comparing the gold price movement over the past few years to the famous 'typical bubble' pattern chart that we've all seen before.

One view says the gold bubble has already burst.

The other view says the gold bubble has just finished the bear trap phase and now prices will really take off!

What do you guys think is the more likely scenario?

Gold is a classic bubble - it follows the typical pattern precisely. Goldbugs. The time to panic... is now.

Gold_Bubble_Two_Views.jpg
 
Last edited:
One view says the gold bubble has already burst.
The current bubble has most definitely burst.

The other view says the gold bubble has just finished the bear trap phase and now prices will really take off!

What do you guys think is the more likely scenario?
It's not the first time. In 1980 gold peaked at the equivalent of $2451. The peak in 2011 was only a little lower, which makes a further peak of $9000 seem extremely unlikely. But more importantly, the reason for the peak was that gold bugs thought that the stimulus would fail, resulting in hyperinflation and collapse of fiat currencies. But they were wrong. The stimulus actually did what it was supposed to - stop the economy from stalling - and now it is gradually improving. Keynes was right!

Your first chart is closest to reality, however I suspect the 'mean' may be steeper than shown. The current cost of mining gold is around $900-$1100 per ounce, so that should be the base level. However the amount of 'above ground' gold in storage is sufficient to supply industrial and jewelery needs for at least the next 20 years, so the price could 'temporarily' drop much lower. If the previous cycle repeats, gold may slip down to ~$500 (in 2011 dollars) over the next few years.
 

Attachments

  • Gold vs inflation-adjusted Dollars.jpg
    Gold vs inflation-adjusted Dollars.jpg
    42.5 KB · Views: 6
Everyone here knows my take already, but...

...I do not believe that past price movements give us meaningful information about future price movements.

It will be interesting to take a screen shot of those charts and to compare them to whatever happens to gold prices going forward. If one had faith in this sort of thing, one should short as much gold as possible right now, and have a 4-bagger as gold returns to the "predicted" $300 level.

But given the accuracy of predictions in this and other threads, I'd tread very, very cautiously when considering any prediction. Any chart like this ignores "Black Swan" events, and shorting anything gives one virtualy unlimited loss potential.

BTW, can anyone tell me why the "mean" line is drawn where it is? Seems arbitrary, in that it could (and should?) be drawn much steeper - would not the mean increase with price increases?
 
Last edited:
I found this very intriguing chart on APF, comparing the gold price movement over the past few years to the famous 'typical bubble' pattern chart that we've all seen before.

One view says the gold bubble has already burst.

The other view says the gold bubble has just finished the bear trap phase and now prices will really take off!

What do you guys think is the more likely scenario?

Gold is a classic bubble - it follows the typical pattern precisely. Goldbugs. The time to panic... is now.

[qimg]http://i187.photobucket.com/albums/x308/LPShadow/Gold_Bubble_Two_Views.jpg[/qimg]

we've had this exact discussion before a few pages back, Mr Ramjets (who has been right thus far) is of the opposite opinion to me.

In my opinion it all depends on your world view, ie whether we can all print our way out of trouble and back to financial Nirvana or not, and if so, how long for.

I am still betting ultimately, not.

It boggles my mind that people cant seem to understand that every time stimulus actually stopped before things dived again, but can believe that with permanent open-ended QE of approx 1.5 billion per working day, 1.8% "growth" is a "recovery"

and the market imbalances from years of frontrunning the Bernanke Put are now huge, and the volatility in repricing these assets will be enormous.

and we have every major CB in the world printing (except China for the moment) in a situation that 10 years ago would have seemed like monetary insanity, and everyone just accepts it as the baseline now, from which we are "recovering"

If this is the end of the secular bull then it's also been a particularly lame gold bull market, by average bull market standards

178524e450fd59d269.gif


we shall see.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom