gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138

UndercoverElephant

Pachyderm of a Thousand Faces
Joined
Jan 17, 2002
Messages
9,058
Thoroughly unscientific, but I'm interested in the result anyway.

ETA: I'm talking medium and long term here, not where the price is going to be next week.
 
Last edited:
I think gold is going to reach a considerably higher price in the longer term (it still hasn't even reached historical highs yet in real terms), though I think overall it is a big bubble
 
1-2 years I think gold / silver are vulnerable to large declines.

3-5 years I think they will be higher, but there will eventually be a time the long side trade is over.


.
 
What happened to gold in 1980 wasn't a bubble. It was a response to geopolitical chaos at the time i.e. the Iranian revolution, Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and very high oil prices.

The difference this time is that the oil price rises are being driven by physical constraints rather than political chaos and that the general global chaos is primarily being caused by the inadequacies of the financial/monetary/economic system itself rather than global/national power struggles (although these are also contributing - see Libya).

Bubbles are driven by greed. The precious metal bull market is being driven by fear. People are being driven away from all sorts of paper assets rather than being lured towards precious metals. Gold is being viewed as the least bad (or only sensible) option in times of great uncertainty, not the best short-term route to easy profits out of many available possibilities. So I think it boils down to whether or not you believe the general level of fear currently being displayed in economic/financial circles is overstated or understated. Is it all a fuss about nothing, or is the whole thing teetering on the edge of collapse?
 
Last edited:
Yep. Adjusted for inflation, they need gold to hit around $2200/oz (IIRC), just to break even. After 30 years.
So what you mean is that they're still waiting to get their value back. Evidently, the trick is to buy gold before a spike in inflation rather than at a peak -- and the poll question can be rephrased as one having to do with inflation, the price of gold being a way of measuring that.
 
What happened to gold in 1980 wasn't a bubble. It was a response to geopolitical chaos at the time i.e. the Iranian revolution, Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and very high oil prices.

The difference this time is that the oil price rises are being driven by physical constraints rather than political chaos and that the general global chaos is primarily being caused by the inadequacies of the financial/monetary/economic system itself rather than global/national power struggles (although these are also contributing - see Libya).

Bubbles are driven by greed. The precious metal bull market is being driven by fear. People are being driven away from all sorts of paper assets rather than being lured towards precious metals. Gold is being viewed as the least bad (or only sensible) option in times of great uncertainty, not the best short-term route to easy profits out of many available possibilities. So I think it boils down to whether or not you believe the general level of fear currently being displayed in economic/financial circles is overstated or understated. Is it all a fuss about nothing, or is the whole thing teetering on the edge of collapse?

You sound like you've done a wonderful job of convincing yourself.
 
You sound like you've done a wonderful job of convincing yourself.

Convincing myself of what?

It would help if you'd respond to the content of what I posted - otherwise I don't really know what you mean. :)

I am personally not in a position where I'm financially secure and have some spare money to play games with. I'm unemployed and have a few tens of thousands of pounds to live on (proceeds from selling a house). I have to make a choice between leaving that money in a cash savings account, investing it in the stock market or buying precious metals, and I'm scared about both the future value of paper money and the stability/security of the banking system. I started this thread because I'm genuinely interested in how the numbers will split between people who think gold is going to go up, and people who think it is (pretty soon) going to go down. If everybody voted for it going up, maybe I'd start thinking it was about to go down...and maybe not.

It's been all over the place this afternoon. Rattling about like a pinball.
 
Last edited:
Yep. Adjusted for inflation, they need gold to hit around $2200/oz (IIRC), just to break even. After 30 years.

Depends on how you measure your value. An ounce of gold bought in 1980 is still an ounce right now. On the other hand, if you had stashed away $850 in dollar bills in 1980, it would only be worth $291 right now.

Sure, if you had bought government bonds in 1980, you'd have made a profit, but that's not always the case. What if you buy Greek government bonds right now, are they going to be worth more in 2040 ? No idea, but I know gold in 2040 will still be worth an ounce.
 
Convincing myself of what?

It would help if you'd respond to the content of what I posted - otherwise I don't really know what you mean. :)

I am personally not in a position where I'm financially secure and have some spare money to play games with. I'm unemployed and have a few tens of thousands of pounds to live on (proceeds from selling a house). I have to make a choice between leaving that money in a cash savings account, investing it in the stock market or buying precious metals, and I'm scared about both the future value of paper money and the stability/security of the banking system. I started this thread because I'm genuinely interested in how the numbers will split between people who think gold is going to go up, and people who think it is (pretty soon) going to go down. If everybody voted for it going up, maybe I'd start thinking it was about to go down...and maybe not.

It's been all over the place this afternoon. Rattling about like a pinball.

Convincing yourself that gold is not experiencing a bubble.
 
Depends on how you measure your value. An ounce of gold bought in 1980 is still an ounce right now. On the other hand, if you had stashed away $850 in dollar bills in 1980, it would only be worth $291 right now.

Sure, if you had bought government bonds in 1980, you'd have made a profit, but that's not always the case. What if you buy Greek government bonds right now, are they going to be worth more in 2040 ? No idea, but I know gold in 2040 will still be worth an ounce.

And if you bought $850 worth of KO, you'd have $40,000.

Your point?
 
If you bought $850 worth of KO in 1998, you'd have $650 right now.

If you bought $850 worth of gold in 1998, you'd have $4700 right now.

How long will it take before KO will pass gold again ?

During a hyper-inflation scenario, which we are currently undergoing, equities always under perform commodities.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom