my personal view is that as usual the inflation truth probably lies somewhere between the two camps, but that for figures to be valid comparison,
you have to not compare apples to oranges.
certainly the
shadowstats view of real US GDP if anywhere near correct would give cause for the lack of real recovery, (as perceived by me) despite unprecedented and ongoing stimulus.
if you take the truth as right between the 2 lines now, growth is flatlining at best.
when you factor in that up to 15% of the GDP calculation itself, is actually
really, made up - its called "imputations" and it may or may not be absolutely perfectly correct.
but being as it
is basically made up, estimated as what they
think is happening, my bet would be that it is not 100% perfectly correct.
http://www.bea.gov/faq/?faq_id=488
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/178524ff008872260b.png[/qimg]
so it seems through the bear-tinted Oakleys that I wear, that real world inflation in any meaningful comparison is a few percent higher and that there is scant room for error on total GDP "growth" with the possibility for fairly large errors to be inputted into this calculation at any level.
whether the concept is valid or not, we are talking about the difference between 0.8% or 1.2% annual growth, while relying on what is almost certainly not
exactly what is
actually happening in the real world, for up to 15% of the figure.
the
meddling adjusting with time is done at every level.