gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
OK. For the time being I'd appreciate if you would simply clarify who you mean by "huge not for profit sellers".

with gold and silver its obviously *unknown* (as in no solid identifying evidence, just reports from the trading floor) bullion banks.

wrt to this, Chris Martenson sums it all up rather well.

however the subject is much, much bigger than just gold. I literally see it every single day across virtually all markets I watch on smaller timescales.

it is only with the identification of this phenomena and much practice that I've been able to perfect this, prior to understanding what I was looking at, it was hopeless, after the penny dropped, as you can see, it all got rather easy, that's +74.8% on a $100k base, in 10 weeks.

and not with one or two lucky trades either, but using a systematic approach based around identifying said manipulation.

so whilst I understand everybody's skepticism on the subject (although I personally have no doubt believing the parties would do it if they could, I didn't really believe it was possible on the kind of scale required) now I am certain, and even have a good idea how it is done, and why indeed it must be done, and I think that the figures above, somewhat back me up in the theory.

because I promise you, (anybody, I dare you, try it for yourself on demo) if you take that many trades in 10 weeks without understanding what I do now, it will be - (minus) $100,000
 
Last edited:
The countries that score worst on corruption, are also the poorest countries. The same countries that have famines and such. Conversely those perceived as least corrupt are among the wealthiest on a per capita basis.
That's just a perception. In reality the rich countries are no less corrupt, they are just better at it. That's why they are rich! :cool:

As for gold - I have inside information that a vast shadowy organization is deliberately suppressing the market by buying and selling huge quantities at artificial prices. It also has enormous influence on governments around the World, and is even responsible for many regime changes and putting puppets in power to do their bidding (Obama is one). Once they get all the politicians in a country in their pocket, there is virtually no way to break free of their influence. :mad:

How do I know this? Because I am one of them! In fact I am one of the top members of the organization. This latest price crash? That was me (and a few others). Perhaps you thought that I was just some anonymous poster who happened to make a lucky guess, but that's just what we want you to think. In fact, all this time I have been using my influence to crash the gold market! :eye-poppi

Don't believe me? Of course not. We are very good at staying hidden, disguising ourselves as private citizens all looking after our own personal self interests. Individually our influences seem puny, but there are literally millions of us, all pushing the markets exactly where we please. And we regularly crush those few rational investors who enter the 'free market' thinking that they will be treated fairly. :(

Yes, all us members of the general public - who appear to be just ordinary workers, business owners, investors and voters - actually control the World! :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Does low global inflation explain it?

The Price of Gold Is Crashing. Here's Why

One example of lower inflation is China (the world's 2nd largest economy don't forget, also the 2nd largest consumer of gold), which had some high rates of inflation in recent years (around 6% annual) but has managed to tame inflation down to about 2% so far this year.

Inflation slows dramatically in China

Then, there's India, the world's largest consumer of gold:
India Inflation Dips to 40-Month Low, Boosting Rate-Cut Case

The India inflation rate is still pretty high by developed country standards, but moderate by India standards. There are cultural factors behind India's gold consumption, but also economic ones: In a country with persistently high inflation, gold is a hedge. If inflation eases, gold may become less attractive.

apparently not, demand off the scale since the drops.

India's Response To The Gold Sell Off: A Massive Buying Frenzy

Because while apparently it is incomprehensible to the "sophisticated" financial crowd in the US that someone may have conviction in their beliefs, and not just lunge from extreme to another, merely riding momentum and technicals like so many "professional" investors, Indians are doing precisely what a buyer should do when the price of the desired product plunges: doubling down, literally.

Bloomberg reports of the immediate aftermath to the past few days' gold plunge: "Gold buyers in India, the world’s biggest consumer, are flocking to stores to buy jewelry and coins, betting a selloff that plunged bullion to a two-year low may be overdone." Wait, so instead of jumping out off high buildings, Indians are being cool, calm and collected and... buying more? Unpossible. Do they not get CNBC in Mumbai? Apparently not: "My daughter is just six months old, but I think it is never too early to buy gold,” said Sharmila Shirodkar, a 28- year-old housewife, while displaying a new pair of earrings she bought from a store in Mumbai’s Zaveri Bazaar. “I had been asking my husband every day if prices will go down more. I couldn’t wait anymore.”

Indeed - the buying frenzy in India has been unleashed:

While the drop in gold prompted investors worldwide to pare holdings in exchange-traded products, surging physical demand in India may help stem the 17 percent slide in prices this year. The plunge after rallying for 12 straight years may make bullion more affordable to Indians, according to Mehul Choksi, chief executive officer of Gitanjali Gems Ltd. (GITG), the nation’s biggest retailer of jewelry and diamonds by sales.

“This is a perfect time to buy as prices will only go up from here,” said Vishal Mehta, a 33-year-old garment dealer, while ordering coins from Choksi V. Naginchand & Co. in Zaveri Bazaar. “I usually buy one gold coin a month, but this time I am buying two.”

Gold Buying Frenzy Continues: China, Japan, And Australia Scramble For Physical

looks like rest of world no believe your broken pricing mechanism no more..

We noted here that the plunge in the paper price of gold (and silver) had prompted considerable renewed demand for physical and now it seems the scramble among the "more stable investor base" is increasing. The shake out of ETFs and futures has left the Australian mint short of deliverables and Japanese and Chinese gold retailers seeing a "frenzied" surge in demand.

The customers are not just the 'rich' or 'elderly'; in China "they tend to wear water shoes and come directly from the market...;" in Australia, "the volume of business... is way in excess of double what we did last week,... there’s been people running through the gate," and Japanese individual investors doubled gold purchases yesterday at Tokuriki Honten, the country’s second-largest retailer of the precious metal.

The panic selling by a weaker 'imminent inflation-based' investor base has sparked physical shortages - "there’s been significant sales made as people see this as great value." It seems our previous discussions of a rotation from paper to physical were correct and this physical demand will eventually leak back into the paper markets.

could get interesting :D
 
Zerohedge is not IMO a reliable source.

It is strange that a buying frenzy isn't affecting the price.
 
Zerohedge is not IMO a reliable source.

im sorry, this is entirely unacceptable when they are quoting from:

Reuters

China News

The Age (au)

and YCWB

you may as well put your fingers in your ears and go nuhnuhnuh. plus after Draghi answering a "couple of questions from zerohedge" at the press conference 2 weeks back..

they are IMO far more credible than most MSM "news"

It is strange that a buying frenzy isn't affecting the price.

no it isnt, thats what im trying to tell you. there is a disconnect between spot futures and the real world.

after a little while the buying (if real and reliable and continued) will feed through to futures, but not immediately.
 
there is a disconnect between spot futures and the real world.
There's a disconnect between spot futures and the 'real' world? Maybe futures traders are not time travelers who have been there and so know exactly what's going to happen...

But you do, of course! :boggled:

after a little while the buying (if real and reliable and continued) will feed through to futures, but not immediately.
The buying is real alright, but it's only temporary. When the price of something drops suddenly there is almost always a spike in sales as 'bargain hunters' take their fill. But normality will soon return and the price will stabilize. I'm betting it will stick at ~$1375, just as the strategists predicted. But who knows - there are still plenty of gold bugs out there who are willing send the market into yet another boom/bust cycle.

Maybe now is actually good time to buy gold. Or perhaps it is about to crash even lower. The only question you have to ask is "do you feel lucky..."?
 
well apparently for a change, we might not have to wait very long at all, to find out. :D

and please note I wrote that post above using these words before seeing this.

Submitted By Bill Holter, Miles Franklin Ltd,:

Last week Barrick Resources announced the postponement of their giant Pascua Lama mine. This was to be one of the worlds largest mines and is now tied up in litigation over true ownership as it appears to show that Barrick does not have clear title. The probale reserves were nearly 18 million ounces of Gold and almost 700 million ounces of Silver. Work on this mine was completely ceased last Wednesday.

“Last Wednesday” was also an important day for the Kennecott copper mine in Utah, the ground started to shift more rapidly prior to this weekend’s landslide. They knew this was coming as they closed the visitor center on April 1st and had all equipment and personel out of harms way. This mine produces some 400,000 ounces of Gold and over 3 million ounces of Silver as a by product of copper, this is the largest copper mine on the planet. Have you heard even a peep out of the mainstream media on this on? I didn’t think so.

Is it not strange that these two events came to a head last Wednesday? The same day that out of nowhere Gold reversed from being up and give up $40? And then of course there was Friday with $85 and another $75 this morning. Gold is now down $200 per ounce in just over 3 trading days. Between these two projects, one not coming online and the other going off line, a VERY significant amount of production is not going to happen. Does this make sense? Did you not learn in school that “less” supply meant higher prices? In the real world?
We don’t live in “the real world”, we live in a world where everything financial is manipulated.

Here is what I see happening. They knew that this mine was going to collapse and the production would stop. Then the ruling on the Pascua Lama mine was sent down. Last Thursday president Obama met with 15 heads of the biggest banks and brokers in the country, THIS was discussed as sure as the Sun came up this morning: we have hit the bottom of the barrel! Reserves that could be fed into the market are and have dried up at the same time that production has dropped and future production delayed.

The paper game is blowing up …RIGHT NOW and the topic of discussion at the White House was about “how it would play out”. The COMEX will default in the next week or several weeks and people will be “settled” with Dollars, no more metal will be delivered! So, knowing that “game over” has arrived, they are dumping a massive volume of paper contracts with impunity to push the metals prices as low as possible before the “default”.

This way the “shorts” do not have to and will not be “covered” when “supply” cannot be obtained because of “an act of God”. They will be settled in cash (at a profit no less) because these “unforeseen” disruptions in supply. “Who could have seen it coming?” will be the mantra. I would suspect that banking stress and “bail ins” will also become prevalent globally. The pricing structure” will now push any and all physical sellers away from the markets and the “door” to safety is effectively being shut. Either you own metal or you don’t.

I tried to “be nice” in my piece from last night talking to those who worry about price. What is now happening is exactly what I spoke of, you must count ounces because “availability” is going away right here and right now! After the closure of the COMEX and LBMA doors there will be no availability and “price” will be meaningless. Your ability to protect yourself is right now for all intents and purposes being eliminated.


given the statistical enormity of the gold move, the six sigma circuit breaker business in the Yen bond markets, the general schizoid twitchiness in Forex for the last month and the unstoppably stupid US equities in the face of declining everything, I do think something big might be brewing.

I wouldn't have said within the week though. whats several? 3?

edit. there might actually be something to this you know.

ABN AMRO (on the bullion bank list) defaulted on physical delivery on 3rd April

Largest dutch bank defaults on physical gold deliveries to customers

not sure how I missed that .. and from 2011

Shortly after the collapse take-down of MFGlobal in October of 2011, Ann Barnhardt walked away from Barnhardt Capital Mangement, and published a prescient prediction on the coming collapse of the paper futures markets, as the loss of confidence by arbitrageurs in the paper markets would result in a decoupling of the cash markets from the futures markets.

Barnhardt warned readers to:
Watch for the gold and silver futures to sell off as people walk away from paper, while the online cash dealers, seeing that market demand for their physical inventory is robust, begin to ignore the futures prices and hold their prices steady or even raise them. When you see this basis decoupling and absence of arbitrage, lo, the end is nigh. A parabolic spike is coming.

Exactly what we’ve seen in the physical silver market over the past week. Is the end nigh?
 
Last edited:
That's just a perception. In reality the rich countries are no less corrupt, they are just better at it. That's why they are rich! :cool:

As for gold - I have inside information that a vast shadowy organization is deliberately suppressing the market by buying and selling huge quantities at artificial prices. It also has enormous influence on governments around the World, and is even responsible for many regime changes and putting puppets in power to do their bidding (Obama is one). Once they get all the politicians in a country in their pocket, there is virtually no way to break free of their influence. :mad:

How do I know this? Because I am one of them! In fact I am one of the top members of the organization. This latest price crash? That was me (and a few others). Perhaps you thought that I was just some anonymous poster who happened to make a lucky guess, but that's just what we want you to think. In fact, all this time I have been using my influence to crash the gold market! :eye-poppi

Don't believe me? Of course not. We are very good at staying hidden, disguising ourselves as private citizens all looking after our own personal self interests. Individually our influences seem puny, but there are literally millions of us, all pushing the markets exactly where we please. And we regularly crush those few rational investors who enter the 'free market' thinking that they will be treated fairly. :(

Yes, all us members of the general public - who appear to be just ordinary workers, business owners, investors and voters - actually control the World! :rolleyes:

:D what a quaint notion ..nice idea though..
 
People who bought gold in 1980 (the last bubble) are still waiting to get their money back.

At $850 an ounce?

Yep. Adjusted for inflation, they need gold to hit around $2200/oz (IIRC), just to break even. After 30 years.

Now it has to hit over $2300/oz
http://www.westegg.com/inflation/
What cost $850 in 1980 would cost $2331.75 in 2012.

A thirty year treasury bond purchased in 1980 or 81 would have had a coupon rate over 10% (over 14% at one point in 81), so (and this is just back-of the envelope figuring so I'm probably off) $1000 invested in 30-year treasury bonds would have become $4000 or more by 30 years later. Discounting for inflation $4000 in 2012 money would be worth $1311 in 1980 money. I suppose a cumulative 31% profit after 30 years isn't much, but it's better than losing money, right?
 
Why? Everybody knows that when demand outstrips supply, prices go down.

In some bizarro alternate universe, maybe!

I suppose that the "powers that be" are opening naked short positions in order to counteract the upward rise in prices.

Note however that this "frenzy" is coming from retail investors - who were previously lumped in with the herd but who have now become prescient.

Please note that I am not being a smartass saying that I knew that this gold price correction would come and that the collapse of the bubble was inevitable and I am certainly not revelling in it. I personally have no idea what is going to happen to the price of gold in the short, medium or long term and I don't think anyone else does either (although man, many think they do).
 
The source for this story is the Voice of Russia twitter feed.

here's the original report with a copy of the letter sent out changing the terms from physical delivery to cash settlement (in Dutch)

http://www.marketupdate.nl/muwe/2013/weekendeditie-week11.pdf

and a Google translate..

Via Google Translate,

Changes in the handling of orders in bullion

On 1 April 2013,. ABN AMRO to another custodian for the precious metals gold, silver, platinum and palladium. This we your investments in precious metals otherwise handle and administer. In this letter you can read more about it.

What will change?

With the transition to the new custodian will include the following from 1 April 2013 for you to change.
• You can have your precious metals to your investment account no longer physically let us extradite
• Gives you order in precious metals via the giro ABN AMRO? Then the settlement of orders that henceforth performed at bid prices or at the offer prices prevailing on the market for precious metals. No longer based on the mid-price, as you used to.

• The bid price is the price that merchants offer for precious metals that are offered for sale, so if you sell.
• The ask price is the price at which traders want to sell precious metals, so if you buy.
• We are the positions in these precious metals in your investment statements against future bid prices appreciate

You can read more about investing in precious metals in Chapter 4 (Supplementary conditions for investing in precious metals) of the Conditions Beleggersgiro. You can find these at abnamro.nl / Conditions invest

Should I do anything?

You need do nothing. We ensure that we have your investments in precious metals now the new way to handle and administer.
 
here's the original report with a copy of the letter sent out changing the terms from physical delivery to cash settlement (in Dutch)

...and the reason for this is that they now hold the physical bullion in Switzerland rather than in the Netherlands and so for the 300 clients or so affected, it's no longer practical to offer physical delivery.

Of course the Voice of Russia and various goldbug sites have chosen to deliberately misinterpret this news.



edited to add..

And it ABN AMRO is defaulting and if there is a physical run on gold - where is the accompanying price spike ?
 
Last edited:
Now it has to hit over $2300/oz
http://www.westegg.com/inflation/

A thirty year treasury bond purchased in 1980 or 81 would have had a coupon rate over 10% (over 14% at one point in 81), so (and this is just back-of the envelope figuring so I'm probably off) $1000 invested in 30-year treasury bonds would have become $4000 or more by 30 years later. Discounting for inflation $4000 in 2012 money would be worth $1311 in 1980 money. I suppose a cumulative 31% profit after 30 years isn't much, but it's better than losing money, right?


using the BLS inflation figures, perhaps. <== skeptical :rolleyes:

the oil price in 1980 was at a staggering (at the time) $32-$39. http://www.forecast-chart.com/chart-crude-oil.html

one might say this was a bubble caused by mid-east tensions etc, having been at $3 a barrel in 1970? but we are now averaging 2-3x that currently, is anyone saying oil is in a bubble at $80-$100? so an approximate doubling every decade or so (give or take 5 years for the market swings) ?

..that's more like +7% per year, going into the cost of everything, whether the BLS counts it from 1980 onwards, or not.

a reminder of actual inflation in things we need over the last decade or so

17852505039d5b56f3.png



the alternative figure, is what the inflation rate would have been had they not started continually meddling with the methodology from 1980 onwards.

so (new) official, 29% in a decade, old way 158%. which looks more realistic, given the actual price moves in everything else?

also note the USD index has devalued by 30% over this same period. so as well as price inflation in USD terms, you're 30% down against the rest of the world. no wonder everything comes in from China now eh.
 
so (new) official, 29% in a decade, old way 158%. which looks more realistic, given the actual price moves in everything else?

How do you know that ?

Certainly food price inflation isn't anything like that, or the price of clothes, household goods, rents/mortgages or many other elements that make up the overall cost of living (although my experience is in the UK instead of the USA).

Sure the price of fuel us much, much higher but that's just a component of the overall inflation measure.
 
For those of us who are less familiar than kevsta with Shadowstats (I think the source for kevsta's preferred inflation measure) here is the rationale behind Shadowstats recalculation of inflation.

Prior to 1980, the inflation measure was based on a fixed basket of goods and services with a fixed weighting between them. So for example, housing costs would always comprise x% of the overall inflation figure and the basket of food shopping goods would always contain the same items (say, steak, bread, milk and so on - and presumably these would have the same weighting).

In 1980 the inflation measure was changed so that the weightings were variable and that substitution of items would be allowed. From the perspective of the government this meant that the inflation figures would more accurately reflect what people were actually spending their money on - from Shadowstats' perspective it's a cynical attempt to understate the inflation rate.

To me the continual rebasing of inflation figures make sense. Over the last 30 years the proportion of household income spent on different categories has changed.

I cannot easily find stats for 1980 but the differences on spending in different categories between 1957 (and 2006) are....

Food 33% (15%)
Housing 9% (19%)
Fuel 6% (3%)
Clothing 10% (5%)
Tobacco 6% (1%)
Alcohol 3% (3%)
Transport 8% (16%)

Source: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/7213462.stm

So it makes sense to me for the inflation figures to reflect those changes in spending patterns.

Another story that comes up from time to time is the constant tweaking of what is in the "shopping basket" that is used to calculate inflation. Last year eBooks and deli meat was added and champagne and taps (faucets) were removed.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-21753044

Again this makes sense to me. Back in 1980 Mummy Don used to by lard - I wouldn't dream of buying it now - and couldn't buy Thai curry paste.

In short it makes sense that inflation figures today reflect what we're spending money on today instead of a preserved in aspic picture - not least because as some goods become more marginal they become proportionally more expensive. I can appreciate that Shadowstats gets upset that hamburger meat is included for calculating inflation rates instead of steak but if that's what people are actually buying then it makes sense.
 
using the BLS inflation figures, perhaps. <== skeptical :rolleyes:

I used the same inflation calculator for the gold calculation as I did for the treasury bond calculation. Now, if you use Shadowstats, what does that say that $850 1980 dollars are worth in today's dollars?

That would only make gold an even worse investment than the official stats, wouldn't it?

ETA:
They have their own inflation calculator, but I'm not a subscriber so I can't see the answer, although eyeballing it it looks like approx. $8,000.
 
Last edited:
Prior to 1980, the inflation measure was based on a fixed basket of goods and services with a fixed weighting between them. So for example, housing costs would always comprise x% of the overall inflation figure and the basket of food shopping goods would always contain the same items (say, steak, bread, milk and so on - and presumably these would have the same weighting).

In 1980 the inflation measure was changed so that the weightings were variable and that substitution of items would be allowed. From the perspective of the government this meant that the inflation figures would more accurately reflect what people were actually spending their money on - from Shadowstats' perspective it's a cynical attempt to understate the inflation rate.

To me the continual rebasing of inflation figures make sense. Over the last 30 years the proportion of household income spent on different categories has changed.

I believe the new way is what they call "chained CPI". Even though they switched methods in 1980, they kept the old method for calculating cost of living adjustments (COLA) for Social Security. In the latest budget negotiations, Obama offered to change the method of calculation to chained CPI as a way to save money. This would probably be somewhat unpopular though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom