gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
I used the same inflation calculator for the gold calculation as I did for the treasury bond calculation. Now, if you use Shadowstats, what does that say that $850 1980 dollars are worth in today's dollars?

That would only make gold an even worse investment than the official stats, wouldn't it?

if taking the start of an investment period as the very top of a parabolic panic spike is not "cherrypicking" I'm not sure what is? :)

it could also suggest its now fundamentally undervalued for unknown reasons, depending on your perspective?

my personal view is that as usual the inflation truth probably lies somewhere between the two camps, but that for figures to be valid comparison, you have to not compare apples to oranges.

certainly the shadowstats view of real US GDP if anywhere near correct would give cause for the lack of real recovery, (as perceived by me) despite unprecedented and ongoing stimulus.

if you take the truth as right between the 2 lines now, growth is flatlining at best.

when you factor in that up to 15% of the GDP calculation itself, is actually really, made up - its called "imputations" and it may or may not be absolutely perfectly correct.

but being as it is basically made up, estimated as what they think is happening, my bet would be that it is not 100% perfectly correct.

http://www.bea.gov/faq/?faq_id=488

Imputations approximate the price and quantity that would be obtained for a good or service if it was traded in the market place. The largest imputation in the GDP accounts is that made to approximate the value of the services provided by owner-occupied housing. That imputation is made so that the treatment of owner-occupied housing in the GDP is comparable to that of tenant-occupied housing, which is valued by rent paid.

178524ff008872260b.png


so it seems through the bear-tinted Oakleys that I wear, that real world inflation in any meaningful comparison is a few percent higher and that there is scant room for error on total GDP "growth" with the possibility for fairly large errors to be inputted into this calculation at any level.

whether the concept is valid or not, we are talking about the difference between 0.8% or 1.2% annual growth, while relying on what is almost certainly not exactly what is actually happening in the real world, for up to 15% of the figure.

the meddling adjusting with time is done at every level.

can't help it, call me dubious, cynical, skeptical, realist, CT, scumbag speculator, whatever.. :D
 
if taking the start of an investment period as the very top of a parabolic panic spike is not "cherrypicking" I'm not sure what is? :)

Sure, I totally acknowledge that point. But for the limited point for which I used the example to illustrate, I think that makes for an interesting data point.

The other which I tried to make though is the following:
If you use Shadowstats as a metric by which to measure the long term performance of an investment, you should apply the same metric to gold and silver. How about if you pick a starting date for a baseline but make it at least 10 years ago and the longer the better, and then calculate the performance of gold and silver using the Shadowstats cumulative rate of inflation to discount the end price. I'd be interested to hear what you think of the results.
 
Sure, I totally acknowledge that point. But for the limited point for which I used the example to illustrate, I think that makes for an interesting data point.

The other which I tried to make though is the following:
If you use Shadowstats as a metric by which to measure the long term performance of an investment, you should apply the same metric to gold and silver. How about if you pick a starting date for a baseline but make it at least 10 years ago and the longer the better, and then calculate the performance of gold and silver using the Shadowstats cumulative rate of inflation to discount the end price. I'd be interested to hear what you think of the results.

and I totally get this, of course, you're correct, its not good. but again, this still suggests to me that there is potentially a fundamental long term undervaluation there? and quite likely a very different perception of things by the global masses on the street, than is purveyed in western financial media?

and that at some point, free market forces will correct it and the historical mean will get reverted to?

..and here we are, at the root cause of my belief in precious metals as a very good bet at this point in history. :D

with every major CB in the world now in a race to the bottom, five years later and accelerating stimulus everywhere, it is against the laws of maths for general prices not to rise eventually, and with gold as the anti-money it should perform better than most options, IMO.

I really am open to being talked out of this you know, if anybody can do it with facts that make more sense. I don't want to lose money in any bubbles as much as the next man, but I have been all over this like a rash for the past 5 years and am not becoming any less convinced with time and events.

this guy, doesnt sound like your average goldbug does he?

Keith Barron PHD

About Keith M Barron PhD
Dr. Barron is an exploration geologist with over 27 years experience in the mining sector. He has consulted on all the continents except for Antarctica, searching for such commodities as gold, silver, diamonds, uranium, copper, platinum, and industrial minerals.

He holds a Ph.D. in Geology from the University of Western Ontario and a BSc. (Hons) in Geology from the University of Toronto. In 2001 he privately co-founded Ecuador gold explorer Aurelian Resources Inc., which was listed on the TSX-V in 2003 and made the colossal Fruta del Norte gold discovery in 2006. The company was bought by Kinross Gold in 2008 for $1.2 billion. He is the founder and a Director of Guyana uranium explorer U3O8 Corp. (UWE:TSX-V).

At the PDAC convention in March 2008 he was awarded the Thayer Lindsley International Discovery Award for his role in the discovery of the Fruta del Norte gold deposit and he was also jointly named the Northern Miner’s Mining Man of the Year 2008. Dr. Barron continues his activities through Solidus Resource Capital Ltd. and Urania Ltd. in the search for worldwide gold, silver and uranium mining and exploration opportunities.

Today a legend in the business told King World News there is a massive run on physical gold and silver at UBS in Switzerland and Scotiabank in Canada. Keith Barron, who consults with major gold companies around the world and is responsible for one of the largest gold discoveries in the last quarter century, spoke about this remarkable situation and what it means for investors. Below is what Barron had to say in part I of this exclusive interview.

Eric King: “Keith, KWN has been reporting on shortages of bullion that are already developing. What do you make of the run on physical gold and silver that’s happening here?”

Barron: “There is absolutely no question that this was an orchestrated takedown in gold and silver the last few days. We already know that ABN AMRO had gold missing, I believe it was out of allocated accounts, and they wanted to give people cash instead of returning gold bars to them.

At the Bank of Nova Scotia in Toronto the gold window has been absolutely swamped. I have confirmed there were people lined up in droves recently for multiple-hours at a time to buy gold and silver bars and coins....

“I then confirmed with UBS today in Zurich, Switzerland, that they are experiencing exactly the same thing. They told me people are waiting in long lines for bullion related bars and coins. The physical market is incredibly tight, and there is a huge buying opportunity right here.

The damage in gold will not be long-term because physical supply is already drying up. Asian countries have been aggressively buying gold. This really is an unprecedented opportunity for investors. This takedown in the metals has created incredible demand for both gold and silver, and anyone who wants to unload dollars or euros and put them into gold because they don’t trust the currency, now is the time to do it.”

KWN or not, do we think a guy like this with all his life in the business is really just making this all up? IMO there is so much smoke pouring out all over the place, that there's just got to be some flames somewhere.
 
KWN or not, do we think a guy like this with all his life in the business is really just making this all up? IMO there is so much smoke pouring out all over the place, that there's just got to be some flames somewhere.

He's not making it up but given his background then it's likely that he's going to be pro-gold. My Uncle sells gold and silver bullion, his advice is now, and has always been, "buy gold and silver". Given that Keith Baron is deliberately mis-characterising the ABN AMRO letter it seems to me that he is pushing a particular view.

I'm sure there are a lot of retail investors out there buying gold and silver, after all there's a message out there to do so and the recent drops in gold price make it comparatively good value (i.e. good value compared to recent highs - only time will tell whether it's good value in absolute terms). Then again the run on physical gold and silver doesn't compare to the run on the Northern Rock where there were tens of people outside every branch. I thought retail investors piling into something was a sure sign that the peak has passed by and the smart money has moved on to something else again.

Rest assured, eventually the buy gold people will be right. It may be tomorrow, it may be in 100 years time. There is definitely fire, it's just that we may all be dead before it is fully aglow.

Bear in mind I have no idea what the price of gold will do in any given timescale - I'm just sceptical that there are other people who do (and who aren't keeping this information to themselves). If I knew for certain what the price of any commodity was going to do in the future I'd just quietly got on with the task of exploiting that information - unless of course my attention whoring around the internet was part of a plan to influence the movement in price.
 
Last edited:
ooh. this looks interesting.. the plot thickens.. :D where's my popcorn?

http://www.cbc.ca/doczone/episode/the-secret-world-of-gold.html

http://silverdoctors.com/the-secret...ntary-to-take-metals-manipulation-mainstream/ (I know, last time, honest)

The CFTC is sitting on information that implicates JPMorgan as manipulating the futures market in Silver and Gold. The reason this is so damning is that the CFTC has evidence that incriminates JPM as having malicious short positions designed to influence the price action of Silver and Gold towards JPM’s favor; akin to the LIBOR scandal in which rates were manipulated down towards the banks favor.

-JPM Whistle-blower - The PM community has been waiting over a decade to see the gold and silver manipulation story go mainstream, as the LIBOR scandal did last summer. As of 9pm EST tonight, the wait is over…

At 9pm EST tonight, Thursday 4/18, the CBC is set to broadcast The Secret World of Gold, a detailed documentary exploring the co-ordinated manipulation of precious metals:

The Secret World of Gold is a documentary exploring the power and politics of gold, a precious metal with more allure and fascination than any other. Valued for its permanence, beauty and scarcity, people will lie, cheat, steal and kill in the name of gold.

To finance the Third Reich, the Nazis went after the gold of Europe. Allied countries stored their gold offshore to keep it safe. In the first months of the Second World War, the gold of England and France was secretly shipped to vaults in Montreal, Ottawa and New York.

Those ships made it safely to port, but throughout history, many were not so lucky. It is estimated that worldwide, 3 million shipwrecks loaded with treasure lie at the bottom of the ocean. Odyssey Marine, an American company listed on the NASDAQ stock exchange, spends huge amounts of money to search for that gold. But there’s always the risk they will have to hand it over to countries claiming ownership.

In recent years, economic uncertainty is giving gold a new lustre in the world of high finance. Whether it’s a few gold coins or gold bars stored in one of the many vaults around the world, many investors are taking a shine to gold. But there’s not a lot of it. It is said that, even melted down, there would not be enough to fill an Olympic swimming pool.

Some claim that much of the gold held by the Bank of Canada, the Bank of England, the Federal Reserve and Fort Knox is gone — that for every 100 ounces of gold traded, there exists only one ounce of real, physical gold. So, where is the gold — and who really owns it?

Directed by Brian McKenna for Galafilm with CBC-TV.

As the Montreal Gazette reports, the program was originally developed as a historical documentary, until the director discovered a whistle-blower :Brian McKenna didn’t predict the recent nosedive in gold prices, but he knows someone who did.

“Andy sent me an email early Friday morning,” recounted the Montreal director. “He said, ‘There’s a big event happening. Someone’s dumping 500 tons of gold into the market.’ That ended up driving the price down by $78 an ounce. And 500 tons is 16 million ounces — we’re talking about a serious intervention here. Who’s got that kind of money?”

“Andy” is Andrew Maguire, a key source in McKenna’s fascinating new film The Secret World of Gold, which premières Thursday at 9 p.m. on CBC-TV. The hour-long documentary plunges into the dramatically rich narrative of gold, unveiling some shocking facts along the way.“I was just going to do a history piece, until I stumbled over a whistle-blower,” McKenna said.

Those who would like a preview of the documentary can listen to this interview provided by the CBC of Director Brian McKenna. Portion on gold & silver manipulation begins at the 10:00 mark.

The explosive CBC documentary has been in the works for over a year, since a JPM whistle-blower on March 15th, 2012 alleged that JPMorgan was manipulating the price of gold and silver in a note posted on the CFTC’s website, and taken viral after it was posted by SD.

The whistle-blower was placed in contact with Andrew Maguire shortly after, who upon reviewing the information and documents the JPM employee had obtained documenting the alleged manipulation of gold and silver, assisted in making an official filing to the CFTC. At the time, Maguire believed the evidence of malicious price manipulation in the gold & silver market was so compelling that the CFTC would be forced to act on the information.

To no surprise however, the CFTC reportedly sat on the information, making no public announcements or actions over the past 9 months, while the whistle-blower left JPM & fled to China for safety. As a result, the whistle-blower has been left no other recourse than to pursue public exposure, resulting in the CBC’s The Secret World of Gold documentary.

The story was partially leaked through the PM blogosphere last August, with both GATA’s Bill Murphy and TFMetalsReport’s Turd Ferguson predicting an explosive and historic move in silver last August out of expectations that the information would be released and acted upon by the CFTC, as in the words of Andrew Maguire, the documentation provided by the JPM whistle-blower was damning evidence, & everything we could want to prove gold & silver are in fact manipulated.
August, September, & October came & went however without any action by the CFTC. In response, the (now former employee) JPMorgan whistle-blower who submitted the information to the CFTC alleged in October of 2012: The CFTC is sitting on information that implicates JPMorgan as manipulating the futures market in Silver and Gold. The reason this is so damning is that the CFTC has evidence that incriminates JPM as having malicious short positions designed to influence the price action of Silver and Gold towards JPM’s favor; akin to the LIBOR scandal in which rates were manipulated down towards the banks favor.
Now that the CBC documentary is scheduled to air tonight, and GATA has publicized it as well, the time has come to force exposure and bring the metals manipulation story into the mainstream- particularly in the wake of this week’s blatant & historic take-down of the gold and silver markets.
The documentary includes testimony from GATA’s Bill Murphy, Eric Sprott, CFTC whistle-blower Andrew Maguire, as well as the JPMorgan employee whistle-blower testimony among others.

Bullion bank silver shorts have most likely been covering in mass all week into the silver massacre, and we’ll soon have the data to make the case. Many have speculated that the bullion banks are going to switch to a net long position.
 
Sure, I totally acknowledge that point. But for the limited point for which I used the example to illustrate, I think that makes for an interesting data point.

The other which I tried to make though is the following:
If you use Shadowstats as a metric by which to measure the long term performance of an investment, you should apply the same metric to gold and silver. How about if you pick a starting date for a baseline but make it at least 10 years ago and the longer the better, and then calculate the performance of gold and silver using the Shadowstats cumulative rate of inflation to discount the end price. I'd be interested to hear what you think of the results.

If we've established, as we have in other threads, that the price of gold and silver has been suppressed in a "managed retreat" for decades since Bretton-Woods, how much utility do you think there is in trying to prove to us how terrible of an investment it is?

Not only hasn't it been terrible in spite of the manipulation, I suspect it will be far less than terrible once the source of the manipulation is exposed and removed.
 
If we've established, as we have in other threads, that the price of gold and silver has been suppressed in a "managed retreat" for decades since Bretton-Woods, how much utility do you think there is in trying to prove to us how terrible of an investment it is?

Not only hasn't it been terrible in spite of the manipulation, I suspect it will be far less than terrible once the source of the manipulation is exposed and removed.

unfortunately it doesn't look like last night's documentary is going to do much about that, the whistleblower testimony that the CTFC is sitting on didn't make the final edit. there must be some legal issues (JPMs lawyers lol) as the BBC backed away after 7 months and spending quite a lot of taxpayer money.

“I was just going to do a history piece, until I stumbled over a whistleblower,” McKenna said.

A veteran gold and silver trader, Maguire denounces the shady tactics of the industry, breaking down the ways in which precious metal prices are manipulated using insider trading.

“He was tremendous,” McKenna said. “It took me eight months to persuade him to come on camera, but I was willing to wait. I knew he was critical to the film. It turns out he was burned by the BBC. He spent seven months showing them everything, going online and showing them the way things worked. Then after all that, they said, ‘The show’s been killed.’

“Word on the street is that Tony Blair, who is on a retainer to JPMorgan for $2 million a year, made a call (and the story was dropped). Did that happen? I don’t know. It’s an opinion that people hold; it doesn’t make it so. But something made the BBC stop an important investigation into which they had probably invested three-quarters of a million dollars.”

http://www.montrealgazette.com/news...t+World+Gold/8255149/story.html#ixzz2QuJSA7g9

gold did pop $40 from 1385 to 1425 in the middle of the night though (coincidentally? I don't really believe in coincidences in markets, but it would be a stretch to try and assign causality to this either.) and its about $20 away from a 50% retracement of the whole down-move now.

there will be renewed shorting pressure from here up to 1440 and we are very likely to have another push down into the mid to low 1300's again before any sustained move upwards starts
 
I should say if 1320 holds, of course. markets starting to look a bit scared now, US equities rolled over fairly dramatically from all time highs a week ago..

they could be about to get monkeyhammered themselves now, S&P and Dow are carving out nasty looking topping formations and have given back the all time highs, plus a little in the last couple of days.

sandp-rolling-over.png


this could well be going substantially lower from here now. that massive volume spike at the end is telling of something, a large churn went on there, either all the BTFDers were absorbed (so its now going down) or the marketmakers reversed long again and there's another bounce first.

but given the declining macro and earnings season thus far, I have my suspicions. plus we've got the whole debt ceiling thing again soon don't we?

The S&P needs to drop from here to 1367 in 2 days to match the ferocity of the gold attack. and the Dow back to 12353 by Tuesday lol

can you imagine the national uproar if it did? :D

edit. I mentioned "distribution" above. those inclined can familiarize themselves with market principles, accumulation & distribution (p20) and how it all works a little better here http://vsa.pipbuilders.com/mtmv3.pdf

the first half of the document is a pretty decent overview of how the smart money and syndicates have been trading since Jesse Livermore first described it in the late 1800s in his 1923 book. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reminiscences_of_a_Stock_Operator

these days they have HFTs but nothing has changed.
 
Last edited:
Note however that this "frenzy" is coming from retail investors - who were previously lumped in with the herd but who have now become prescient.

ah, no, I should clarify this, when I'm saying "retail" or "herd" I mean in a trading sense, I am not talking about the global population of the world.

although on a larger scale of course they are the main herd and define retail, but as the vast majority of them are not even investors, and of those investors only a tiny fraction are traders, however over the short term, traders have a very over-sized influence on prices, given their small group size but massive leverage via unbacked derivatives, the tail can be made to wag the dog until local dealers just refuse to sell at those prices or whack the margins up by $7

in the trading sense "the herd" are both actual retail traders, plus the majority of institutional traders, hedge funds, pension funds, this group lose on up to 90% of all their trades combined. the herd lose, statistically. its not a slur on somebody's implied intelligence, its just a trading fact. and I have generally never meant to refer the general public as the herd in any of these trading type conversations.

although the greater herd is out there, given media sentiment Id be relatively confident its only the party faithful buying the dips at this point.

But if the greater herd suddenly all got involved on the long side, that would be a sight to behold. I'm not holding out for that for a while yet, they are more likely rushing to sell it at cashforgold before it drops any lower would be my understanding?
 
Last edited:
I should say if 1320 holds, of course. markets starting to look a bit scared now, US equities rolled over fairly dramatically from all time highs a week ago...

Lots of lines on a graph, what are you actually forecasting ?

Are you suggesting that stocks are at a crucial tipping point and are about to drop 10%, 20% ?

So far all I have seen is typical profit taking after a healthy rise but clearly you think that something significant is just about to happen.
 
Lots of lines on a graph, what are you actually forecasting ?

Are you suggesting that stocks are at a crucial tipping point and are about to drop 10%, 20% ?

So far all I have seen is typical profit taking after a healthy rise but clearly you think that something significant is just about to happen.

Im not forecasting anything past the next turn, as a trader that's not my job. but I'd like you specifically to read this when you have ten minutes?

edit. I mentioned "distribution" above. those inclined can familiarize themselves with market principles, accumulation & distribution (p20) and how it all works a little better here http://vsa.pipbuilders.com/mtmv3.pdf

what I am saying is that from 1554 and above there is zero doubt that professional money (the brighter kind) has been in distribution mode, and from there that only portends one direction in the intermediate term, back down to below where it started.

and here we are. whether they are not yet fully finished with their distribution needs and will need to support price for a while longer to induce further buying yet, or we are ready to get going with the markdown earlier, is anyone's guess.
 
Lots of lines on a graph, what are you actually forecasting ?

Are you suggesting that stocks are at a crucial tipping point and are about to drop 10%, 20% ?

So far all I have seen is typical profit taking after a healthy rise but clearly you think that something significant is just about to happen.


although its not just me that thinks this is looking likely. and re ZH credibility, this is where they kick proverbial butt, you don't see trading analysis like this anywhere else really.

major divergences here (point 6) something has got to give
 
Last edited:
although its not just me that thinks this is looking likely. and re ZH credibility, this is where they kick proverbial butt, you don't see trading analysis like this anywhere else really.

major divergences here (point 6) something has got to give

You're right, lots of graphs where various trends are overlaid with no indication as to whether these are truly two unique trends or two picked from tens of trends and no clear prediction no-one does it quite like Zerohedge

If they really could predict the next trend reliably they'd be billionaires.
 
Last edited:
You're right, lots of graphs where various trends are overlaid with no indication as to whether these are truly two unique trends or two picked from tens of trends and no clear prediction no-one does it quite like Zerohedge

If they really could predict the next trend reliably they'd be billionaires.

I gather they specialize in divergence / reversion arb trades. when regular correlations diverge / break away, its only a matter of time before they revert
 
I gather they specialize in divergence / reversion arb trades. when regular correlations diverge / break away, its only a matter of time before they revert

It's also only a matter of time before 32 comes up on the roulette wheel but it's not particularly helpful information.

Good luck to them I say.
 
It's also only a matter of time before 32 comes up on the roulette wheel but it's not particularly helpful information.

ah I see, you want the easily actionables.. :D

they do those too, the Stolper trade series (Goldman Sachs currency "expert") is the most reliable by far

Lightning Hits Again: Latest Anti-Stolper EURUSD Fade Closed Out With 317 Pips Profit In Two Weeks

here check his record out, its pretty impressive..

put it this way, if a "psychic" could perform with Stolper's (negative in this case obviously, as GS prop desk take the winning side as muppets lose) hit ratio, Randi would have lost his $million years ago.

and there's nobody else out there dedicating themselves to pointing out the daily fleecing of the muppets, quite as doggedly as ZH, that's for sure.
 
Any predictions about how it's going to go when markets open tomorrow morning or later this week?

for gold? no not really. I would expect to see some more downside pressure, as the shorts try to press their advantage. however there was another good push down in the Thursday asian (overnight for me) session last week and a decent rebound from 1340 to 1425 you have to assume the green/red channel at the lower end is where heavy buying comes in, or the shorts get scared and take profits, same thing effectively.

xau.png


the shorts will first try to break down through the rising lower channel, and then go for the most recent low at 1321.

can they break it down lower? I don't know. maybe. as a trader I should really be shorting it at 1420-1440 looking for another good push down at least and hoping the floor breaks.

however as I was actually doing that with real money (not much, micro account) and no stoploss in early 2012 as some Fed minutes exploded it skyward, I'm a bit scared of shorting PMs now :eek: sometimes they can take on a mind of their own, and in either direction.

and in my mind the collapse has been engineered on a propaganda campaign based on incorrect information, so to join in with the momentum players bashing it on the downside seems kinda risky when as we've seen so many times before things can reverse really fast.

like, I would really kick myself if i'm short as the Comex actually blows up, and if its going to happen, it would of course happen the moment I capitulate and go short.

when I am ad-lib trading (ie away from the strategy and plan) this is exactly what happens, almost every single time lol.

(US equities however, that's another story.. they're doing the Wile Coyote thing about now IMO)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom