Puppycow
Penultimate Amazing
Gold seems to be taking another beating today. One difference is that oil and commodities in general are actually up while gold and silver are down close to 2%. Copper is up too.
That's interesting. I think as I've said here before, I think there are a number of components to the price of a commodity, in particular gold:
- The underlying value of it as an industrial metal
- Its value as a jewelry metal/nice shiny thing
- Its value as a currency/inflation hedge
- Its value as a reserve of wealth in times of uncertainty
- Its value as an commodity for speculation - unlike the others, this can be positive or negative
I know it's asking the impossible but I'd love to see the current gold price broken down by someone knowledgeable into components like this.
At the $1800/oz price there seemed to be a large component of both speculation and as a reserve of wealth. With more promising economic indicators there is less economic uncertainty and money seems to have moved from gold to stocks and bonds. With demand a little less febrile, maybe the speculative money has moved out of the gold upside and either out - or to the gold downside.
For gold to decline a further 20% it would seem to me that Credit Suisse thinks that there is still a lot of "uncertainty" and hedging money to come out of gold.
For the record, I have no idea where the gold price is heading but it seems to me that pundits sometimes make some of these kinds of predictions to get their names in the paper.
Between 10 and 15 per cent of the annual gold production is used in the industry.
From 2008 until 2009 industrial demand for gold dropped by 13 per cent.
In 2010 the gold supply stood at 4108 tonnes (2659 tons from mine production, neg. 116 tons hedging, 87 tonnes central banks sellings and 1653 gold recycling). Demand from industry was 420 tonnes, or 10 per cent. This is 287 tonnes for the electronics industry, 50 tonnes for dentistry, and 83 tons for other industrial purposes. In contrast, jewellery demand stood at 2060 tonnes.
I wonder where the gold and silver prices will be 2 months from now, then 2 years from now, both in nominal dollars and in current 2013 dollars.
I don't think silver will dip far below $20 (and physical silver will almost certainly not be available at that price), and I will be surprised to see gold ever dip below $1K again...this is just my intuition though. We'll see.
Silver plunged to the lowest level since September 2010, sending its ratio to gold to the highest in 33 months, while bullion extended the longest slump in four years as investment holdings contracted and stocks rallied.
Silver for immediate delivery tumbled as much as 7 percent to $20.6985 an ounce, and was at $21.345 at 11:32 a.m. in Singapore. The ratio surged to 64.89, the highest since August 2010. Gold lost as much as 1.5 percent to $1,338.85 an ounce, the lowest price since April 18, and was at $1,347.23. Gold is down for an eighth session, the worst run since March 2009.
Is the double-bottom now the end, or will if fall to previous support levels of $1320 or even lower (with even more support) at $1250 ?
Only time will tell, but the real question is . . . Is this just the bull throwing off those who can't stomach it anymore, just before it runs again, or is the bull on it's knees and going down ?
“You can’t call it a ‘bear market’ when we see consistent $30 premiums in Shanghai, India, and the Middle-Eastern markets. You can’t call it a bear market when we see extended and increasing delivery bottlenecks and backlogs at the refiners.
You can’t call it a bear market when bullion banks are actively defaulting on an increasing number of clients who have the audacity to ask for the delivery of their bullion from these LBMA bullion bank vaults. If we were in a bear market they would be trying to rid themselves of this bullion.
We have a fractional reserve LBMA bullion bank system, and they were being drained of immediately deliverable, allocated supply. Bear in mind that this was happening before the April 12th paper market smash. So in March, when we spoke, we saw the beginning of the official intervention in the paper gold market. I remember speaking to you at the time about how we were threatening to trip extremely large, margined naked short stops above the $1,620 level.
But then Cyprus reared its head and tipped the entire balance, scaring both dollar and euro gold holders into racing to get their (physical) gold out of the paper market, to actually take physical delivery. Think about it, Eric, there was already large central bank and sovereign interest in the $1,600s.
And the rearward looking official data that we see now reflects hundreds of tons entering Asian markets at those prices ($1,600s). Now that the paper markets have distorted supply/demand fundamentals (even further) by adding hundreds of tons of synthetic gold supply. They have ended up accelerating this outflow of bullion.
This migration of bullion (from West to East) is, in reality, far in excess of the (roughly) 310 tons that was redeemed out of GLD. And on that subject, not all of what was redeemed out of GLD was long capitulation, which is not what you are hearing from the mainstream media.
Within these redemptions there were actually funds that I have met with which have redeemed shares to take actual delivery. And if they were doing it, there were others who were doing it. It barely costs more to vault (your own) gold, than it does to hold the ETF.
This is long-term money that is not fooled by the paper markets. The picture is not as it seems. So this ‘bear market’ is 100% in the virtual market. Yet this underlying physical market has diverged into a full-fledged ‘bull market’ as evidence by hard, official data showing the strongest physical demand in 18 months.”
http://mobile.bloomberg.com/markets/commodities/futures/
There seems to be a divergence between TOCOM silver and gold and COMEX as well as spot prices at the moment. The former are actually up.
...nobody is ever going to convince me that the actual value of the global silver supply swung down by 10% and back up 5-6% again in a couple of hours.
And yet it did.
Now how is this whole business about predicting future moves working out for you?
Glad you're in a position to separate value from price.
Sounds like a way to make money, since you know seem to know better than the market.
Good luck!
On May 17, 2013, in the final seconds of trading, the stock of Anadarko Petroleum Corporation (symbol APC, market cap $45 Billion) traded from $90 down to $0.01 in 45 milliseconds. Oops. This may just be a record - losing $1 Billion per millisecond. That's a rate of $1 Trillion per second. Now this is something Congress will be able to understand. Maybe NYSE should have kept their LRP circuit breakers after all?
Andarko has assets and earnings. Silver just is, it generates no revenue. I'd be interested in knowing what its true value is if it's not the price it fetches on the market.
So you're not telling, except that the current market price is all wrong?
...or are you arguing that the concept "undervalued" or "overvalued" is a fallacy?
I'm not timhau, but I would not say its a fallacy...
...I would say at best its useless, at worst its meaningless.
It shows a misunderstanding of what markets are and how they work.
un·der·val·ue (ndr-vly)
tr.v. un·der·val·ued, un·der·val·u·ing, un·der·val·ues
1. To assign too low a value to; underestimate.
2. To have too little regard or esteem for.
Google define:undervalued
undervalued past participle, past tense of un·der·val·ue (Verb)
Verb
Rate (something) insufficiently highly; fail to appreciate: "the skills of the housewife remain undervalued in society".
Underestimate the financial value of (something): "the company's assets were undervalued in its balance sheet".
"In 2001, Sprott judged gold to be undervalued"
In that particular market, at that exact time - yes, It was 'worth' that much to those who bought and sold it.what I said, is that the value did not change. ie the above ground silver supply at say approximately 500million above ground Oz was not fundamentally worth $1.1 billion less 2 minutes later and halfway back again 5 minutes after that.