gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
It's rather easy to see what "smart investors" would have done in hindsight, isn't it?

always. my theoretical long gold short S&P would have actually bankrupted me over this weekend if I'd gone for it on leverage :D
 
because I am virtually certain that anyone that bought at $1650 and sold at at sub $1500 will have the pleasure of seeing it run again (without them)
Perhaps gold will always win out in the long run. But in the long run we are all dead.

So let's say you bought at $1650 after listening to all those gold bugs who cried "Mega Bull, the Sky's the Limit!!!", and 2 years later you want to actually use some of that 'investment'. Unless the thing you want to use it for is jewelry or electrical connectors, you are going to have to convert it into cash. But right now the price is appalling ($1408 according to goldprice.org). You bought at $1650 expecting it to achieve at least $2K by now, but instead of gaining 20+% you have lost 15%!

So what do you do? Put off that life-saving operation and try to stay alive until the price rebounds, or have the procedure anyway and risk sliding into bankruptcy? Miss out on that rare classic car you always wanted, and hope a similar deal comes up in the future when your gold is actually worth something? Or cash it in now and make the best of a bad situation?

I bet that right now there are thousands of 'investors' whose dreams are being dashed on the rocks of falling gold prices. People who want or need the money now, and don't have the time or patience to wait out the storm. Life is too short to have your fortunes determined by crazy speculators with a fetish for heavy metals.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps gold will always win out in the long run. But in the long run we are all dead.

So let's say you bought at $1650 after listening to all those gold bugs who cried "Mega Bull, the Sky's the Limit!!!", and 2 years later you want to actually use some of that 'investment'. Unless the thing you want to use it for is jewelry or electrical connectors, you are going to have to convert it into cash. But right now the price is appalling ($1408 according to goldprice.org). You bought at $1650 expecting it to achieve at least $2K by now, but instead of gaining 20+% you have lost 15%!

So what do you do? Put off that life-saving operation and try to stay alive until the price rebounds, or have the procedure anyway and risk sliding into bankruptcy? Miss out on that rare classic car you always wanted, and hope a similar deal comes up in the future when your gold is actually worth something? Or cash it in now and make the best of a bad situation?

I bet that right now there are thousands of 'investors' whose dreams are being dashed on the rocks of falling gold prices. People who want or need the money now, and don't have the time or patience to wait out the storm. Life is too short to have your fortunes determined by crazy speculators with a fetish for heavy metals.

yea yea. however with your short term horizons and immediate need for "investments" money now, I note you are not considering the +16% you could have made in 3 months from the OP to the top though eh? :D

re what actually caused it, now we are starting to get to the bottom of it, (yet another) full on Bear raid orchestrated by those with unlimited TBTF bank accounts.

The gold futures markets opened in New York on Friday 12th April to a monumental 3.4 million ounces (100 tonnes) of gold selling of the June futures contract (see below) in what proved to be only an opening shot. The selling took gold to the technically very important level of $1540 which was not only the low of 2012, it was also seen by many as the level which confirmed the ongoing bull run which dates back to 2000. In many traders minds it stood as a formidable support level... the line in the sand.

Two hours later the initial selling, rumoured to have been routed through Merrill Lynch's floor team, by a rather more significant blast when the floor was hit by a further 10 million ounces of selling (300 tonnes) over the following 30 minutes of trading. This was clearly not a case of disappointed longs leaving the market - it had the hallmarks of a concerted 'short sale', which by driving prices sharply lower in a display of 'shock & awe' - would seek to gain further momentum by prompting others to also sell as their positions as they hit their maximum acceptable losses or so-called 'stopped-out' in market parlance - probably hidden the unimpeachable (?) $1540 level.

The selling was timed for optimal impact with New York at its most liquid, while key overseas gold markets including London were open and able feel the impact. The estimated 400 tonne of gold futures selling in total equates to 15% of annual gold mine production - too much for the market to readily absorb, especially with sentiment weak following gold's non performance in the wake of Japanese QE, a nuclear threat from North Korea and weakening US economic data.

The assault to the short side was essentially saying "you are long... and wrong".

the question is, why now...? what do they know about, that we don't yet, that makes them so desperate to scare the public out and grab as much as possible for themselves? everything else is just noise.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-04-15/gold-crush-started-400-ton-friday-forced-sale-comex

Absolutely nothing has changed regarding the fundamentals of the gold market and bullion owners are advised to again focus on the long term and the vital diversification benefits of owning gold over the long term.

Although some Federal Reserve policy makers said that they probably will end their $85 billion monthly U.S. bond purchases sometime in 2013. The key word is ‘probably’ and it remains unlikely that the Federal Reserve will stop their debt monetisation programmes any time in 2013 or even in 2014.

Even if the Fed did end them, ultra loose monetary policies and negative real interest rates are set to continue as are competitive currency devaluations and currency wars - two other fundamental pillars supporting the precious metal markets.

Buyers are now presented with another very attractive buying opportunity. We always caution against trying to “catch a falling knife” and buyers should hold off until we get a few days of higher closes or a weekly higher close. Alternatively, they should consider dollar, pound or euro cost averaging into a position at these levels.

Sellers should consider holding off as if contemplating selling they may have missed their opportunity and if they have to sell they may be best placed holding off until prices bounce or recover. Sellers are now disadvantaged both in terms of price but also in terms of premiums that have spread on some physical bars such as one kilo bars.

In the course of gold’s bull market, vicious sell offs like this have often presaged material weakness in stock markets and this may occur again.

Gold’s ‘plunge’ is now headline news which is bullish from a contrarian perspective. Less informed money is again selling gold or proclaiming the end of gold’s bull market.

The smart money such as certain hedge fund managers, high net worth individuals, pension funds, family offices, institutions and creditor nation central banks and will see this vicious sell off as an absolute gift and will accumulate again on this dip.

A long term allocation to physical gold bullion to hedge systemic and monetary risk remains vital.
 
That was on Friday. It seems that there is an even bigger massacre happening today. Gold dropped another $118 and below $1400 so far today as I am typing.

yes, we're into purely technical trading now, the rout continued last night with the opening of the Asian session/s, remember lots of traders got margin calls over the weekend from Fridays action requiring stumping up more cash to stay in increasingly losing positions, or just liquidating instead, and it all feeds into itself.

this is why support is important, because traders place automatic stops underneath it and so if they can take the level out, the computers start a cascade down for them.

then in NY this morning you have the same thing from the overnight drops, plus (just like in the Silver smashdown) we have exchanges increasing margin requirements at the same time.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-04-15/shanghai-gold-exchange-hike-gold-silver-margins

the CME will likely follow, all part of the plan. talk about kick them while they are down lol
 
Last edited:
That was on Friday. It seems that there is an even bigger massacre happening today. Gold dropped another $118 and below $1400 so far today as I am typing.

Silver is down even more than gold: over 11%

http://www.bloomberg.com/markets/commodities/futures/metals/

Oil is also having a bad run:

http://www.bloomberg.com/energy/

Although cheaper oil is about the only good economic news lately.

Agricultural commodities also mostly negative:

http://www.bloomberg.com/markets/commodities/futures/
 

silver is gold's badly behaved little brother, outperforms on the way up, and on the way down.

Oil is also having a bad run:

http://www.bloomberg.com/energy/

Although cheaper oil is about the only good economic news lately.

Agricultural commodities also mostly negative:

http://www.bloomberg.com/markets/commodities/futures/

for sure, we are in major selloff territory now, US equities will probably only go up a % or 2 today :D
 
I'm sorry, what? I take it you don't mean coronal mass ejection (a solar flare).

:D er.. no..

http://www.cmegroup.com/

they raised the margins 5 times in 3 days while hacking silver down from 49 to 26 in 2011. not until it was already well on it's way down though..

just looking out for our wellbeing, obviously..
 
Gold slips below $1350 - the Strategists were Right?

Roger Ramjets said:
www.emergingmarkets.org/Article/3184068/Financial-Markets/Gold-price-to-fall-15-this-year-strategists.html

"Gold prices could average $1500 per ounce over the course of this year, gradually dropping to $1375/oz by the end of 2013, according to strategists at Societe Generale..."

It's only April and gold has already dropped to US$1550, a staggering 7.3% down from the beginning of the year. If this trend continues then the strategists may be right!
As of right now gold is at $1349.90, $25 below the strategists 'pessimistic' prediction!

Was their dismal outlook actually too conservative?
 

Attachments

  • Gold_drops_below_1350.jpg
    Gold_drops_below_1350.jpg
    42.7 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
As of right now gold is at $1349.90, $25 below the strategists 'pessimistic' prediction!

Was their dismal outlook actually too conservative?

if it continues falling at this rate goldbugs will have to pay people to come and take it away by end 2013. :rolleyes:

20130415_whosbuying.jpg
 
Last edited:
Predictions, to date, have in general been a colossal failure.

No surprise there.

Let the special pleading and post hoc justifications begin!

Oh, wait - they already have.
 
yes, we're into purely technical trading now, the rout continued last night with the opening of the Asian session/s, remember lots of traders got margin calls over the weekend from Fridays action requiring stumping up more cash to stay in increasingly losing positions, or just liquidating instead, and it all feeds into itself.

this is why support is important, because traders place automatic stops underneath it and so if they can take the level out, the computers start a cascade down for them.

then in NY this morning you have the same thing from the overnight drops, plus (just like in the Silver smashdown) we have exchanges increasing margin requirements at the same time.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-04-15/shanghai-gold-exchange-hike-gold-silver-margins

the CME will likely follow, all part of the plan. talk about kick them while they are down lol

oh look, what a surprise..

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-04-15/cme-hikes-gold-silver-margins-185

Anyone surprised, please raise your hands. And yes, it was fun when margin were hiked only on surges in the various futures contracts. Now, dumps works just as well. The logic, of course, is that gold shorts are also margined. However, judging by the immediate $15 drop in gold upon the announcement, those who are short the metals certainly have a much, much bigger balance sheet and cash hoard to satisfy any collateral requirements than those long. Next: expect the Shanghai Gold Exchange to hike margins in a few short hours once China wakes up and looks at overnight PM prices in horror.

the exact same MO as with Silver in 2011, first smash it with TBTF funny money, and then hike exchange margins to finish anyone hanging in there right off

nobody could have predicted this. :rolleyes:
 
Does low global inflation explain it?

The Price of Gold Is Crashing. Here's Why

Why is gold plunging? The most important factor is that global inflation is falling, reducing gold’s value as a hedge against rising prices. Gold bugs who were betting on an outburst of inflation are scrambling to reverse their bets and exit their gold positions at any price.

For consumers struggling to make ends meet, it may seem hard to believe that inflation is falling. But the evidence is clear from JPMorgan Chase’s (JPM) global consumer price index, which covers more than 30 countries that collectively represent more than 90 percent of world economic output.

According to the JPMorgan index, global inflation peaked at 4 percent in 2011 and has fallen steadily since. Global prices in February were up only about 2.5 percent from a year earlier, the bank’s index says.

JPMorgan has two scenarios for what happens next. Its main one is based on a “bottom-up” collection of analysts’ forecasted price trends sector by sector around the world. That shows inflation rising very slightly from its current level for the rest of 2013. In contrast, JPMorgan’s “top-down” analysis, which is prepared by the banks’ economists and takes into account prices of commodity futures contracts, among other factors, shows inflation moving down closer to 2 percent in the second half of 2013.

The headline on JPMorgan’s report: “The slide in global inflation may not be over.”

One example of lower inflation is China (the world's 2nd largest economy don't forget, also the 2nd largest consumer of gold), which had some high rates of inflation in recent years (around 6% annual) but has managed to tame inflation down to about 2% so far this year.

Inflation slows dramatically in China

Then, there's India, the world's largest consumer of gold:
India Inflation Dips to 40-Month Low, Boosting Rate-Cut Case

The India inflation rate is still pretty high by developed country standards, but moderate by India standards. There are cultural factors behind India's gold consumption, but also economic ones: In a country with persistently high inflation, gold is a hedge. If inflation eases, gold may become less attractive.
 
Does low global inflation explain it?

The Price of Gold Is Crashing. Here's Why



One example of lower inflation is China (the world's 2nd largest economy don't forget, also the 2nd largest consumer of gold), which had some high rates of inflation in recent years (around 6% annual) but has managed to tame inflation down to about 2% so far this year.

Inflation slows dramatically in China

Then, there's India, the world's largest consumer of gold:
India Inflation Dips to 40-Month Low, Boosting Rate-Cut Case

The India inflation rate is still pretty high by developed country standards, but moderate by India standards. There are cultural factors behind India's gold consumption, but also economic ones: In a country with persistently high inflation, gold is a hedge. If inflation eases, gold may become less attractive.

all possibilities, but none of it explains the standard MO of dramatic takedowns by huge not for profit sellers and the "unusual" margin treatment right at the worst time does it?

crude is on a heavy downward trend too, no margin hikes there, not platinum, nor palladium nor nor nor...

nobody is saying there *may* not be good reasons for gold to trend downwards rather than upwards.

what they might say is "WTF was that?" and "who the F did it??

if the actions of ONE major player can set off these kind of cascading waterfalls, and that ONE player has no regard for the price they sell at, in fact their sales seem to be designed to break price down, any rational person can only conclude that its the will of God or something..
 
Last edited:
all possibilities, but none of it explains the standard MO of dramatic takedowns by huge not for profit sellers and the "unusual" margin treatment right at the worst time does it?

When you say "huge not for profit sellers" are you sure this is the case? Why "not for profit"? Who would that be? The Fed?

How do we know this again? Do we know specifically who might be doing it and whether it's one group, several groups working together or several groups operating independently?

Was it possibly a panic situation, with many or (or a few large) longs simultaneously rushing for the exit, or a group of short sellers? I know you suspect it's the latter, but do you have any specific info (evidence) that that's what actually happened?
 
When you say "huge not for profit sellers" are you sure this is the case? Why "not for profit"? Who would that be? The Fed?

How do we know this again? Do we know specifically who might be doing it and whether it's one group, several groups working together or several groups operating independently?

Was it possibly a panic situation, with many or (or a few large) longs simultaneously rushing for the exit, or a group of short sellers? I know you suspect it's the latter, but do you have any specific info (evidence) that that's what actually happened?

you know what, I think this subject is probably deserving of it's own full market manipulation yay or nay thread. I'll get to it as time allows.
 
crude is on a heavy downward trend too, no margin hikes there, not platinum, nor palladium nor nor nor...

error here, platinum and palladium were included, but no other commodities outside of the precious metals.
 
you know what, I think this subject is probably deserving of it's own full market manipulation yay or nay thread. I'll get to it as time allows.

OK. For the time being I'd appreciate if you would simply clarify who you mean by "huge not for profit sellers".


Because if the government were manipulating the market in a way to favor certain private interests at the expense of other private investors, that would be a very serious charge. At this point I am not quite so cynical as to think that this is the case in the US, although I certainly wouldn't put it past some other governments that I can think of. I am well aware that there are kleptocracies in the world. Perhaps most governments are of this nature, but it tends to show up at a macro level. A nation ruled by a kleptocracy is not a wealthy, prosperous nation. Oh, all countries have some level of corruption to be sure, but the more corruption, the poorer the country overall. Just look:

http://www.transparency.org/cpi2012/results

The countries that score worst on corruption, are also the poorest countries. The same countries that have famines and such. Conversely those perceived as least corrupt are among the wealthiest on a per capita basis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom