gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
It's not looking good for gold. On Sept 3rd 2011 I predicted that gold couldn't maintain its meteoric rise, and was headed for a fall. Sure enough, just a few days later gold got knocked off its perch, and has yet to claw its way back. Several times gold attempted to regain its former glory, only to crash down again in despair. And now, exactly 1 year later, gold is still down 10.08%. :(

I never tried to hide the earlier price rise. Why would I, when to be in a bubble it must rise before falling. My point is not the fact that gold has fallen dramatically since Sept 2011, but that it fell when gold bugs were insisting that it would keep rising. And then when it did fall the denial kicked in... First they insisted it was just a short-term fluctuation, then every bump on the way down became a 'new all time high'! :boggled:

why do you pretend this is so difficult to understand? :boggled:

what I said:

since this thread began, Gold HAS made new highs in many (and all the important) currencies. since the very top when most of the herd (baaaah! ) got interested, of course it has corrected, thats what markets do.

since you arrived at the market top, a while later, your charts and nonsense are just silly, you know exactly what I mean, and that it is correct.

Sooner or later gold will bottom out. Perhaps it has already - or perhaps not.

bottom out or top out? it looks very much as though you are correct, it has bottomed out at 1525, but I dont think you meant to say that, did you?

But what cannot be denied is the fact that anybody who was fooled into buying gold 12 months ago "it's not a bubble!" and "the sky is the limit, fiat money is doomed!") has now lost 10% of their 'investment'. :mad:

nobody has lost anything unless they decide to sell because their investing plan is based around what happens from the 3rd Sept annually.

Oh no! Cover your eyes, it's the 'b' word! :covereyes

once again :rolleyes: I ask for a single shred of evidence of a bubble.

<tumbleweed>.........................................</tumbleweed>

seriously, if its in a bubble I want to be convinced, and get out. all the evidence I see says no bubble, by any usual measurement or characteristic of bubbles.

markets move up and down, people have been saying what you are now saying in every serious correction all the way up from $200.00.

they were wrong then, as you are wrong now, because they do not understand gold, nor what actually constitutes a bubble.

all you have done is prove that people who pile into something at the very top and have to sell exactly a year later deserve to lose their sheepish money.

question for you:

at what price would you concede to the *possibility* that actually maybe gold has been undervalued and is going to re-base much higher before the final bubble ?

and in what currencies? this is the funny bit, its like trying to accurately measure an engineering component with 50 different jelly rulers and micrometers.

answer of the same question in reverse for me.

- there is no "price" nor specific currency I am interested in pricing in.

when** the global economies' problems are over, and we are back at positive real interest rates and all the defaulting and failures to come are behind us, not before then.

however Sept 3rd does seems like a strangely interesting time to sell up. lol.

BTW since I bought my last tranche (layered in from $1535 down to $1528) I'm up about 10% on that. Silver is doing even better.

and this week Im going to buy a car, with real money saved in 2009/2010. it's £3995 (Spanish crisis sale, worth 2x more) and I only need £2500ish of 2009/10 money to buy it. :D

seriously, this is not difficult. you should try to get your head round it for your own sake.
 
Last edited:
however Sept 3rd does seems like a strangely interesting time to sell up. lol.

...
goldcore_bloomberg_chart1_04-09-12.png


and actually, looking at Gold in AUD terms..

178525045fe08ce4ab.png


and the potential Wile Coyote moment in the future for the AUD judging by Iron Ore prices (the only commodity not traded on Futures, btw)

..theres a good possibility these lines will cross back over at some point and gold will outperform in terms of AUD once again like in 08/09.
 
Last edited:
this is a daily chart, and it has started, although we're only in the $1620's, at this point this is quite significant because to get there it had to break out through several important moving averages (the cluster now below the price, which will now act as support, instead of resistance) and 2 longer term downtrend lines.

17852501504067fcb2.png


if we run through the 200 day MA (white above current price) and the last green downtrend line, it will be off to the races as all the hot momentum money piles in again.

Boom... so the daily squeeze above fired off..

178525049f013ae46f.png


and you can be certain the hot money is piling in right now, but the weekly squeeze has not fired yet

178525049eee060f88.png


there is no certainty it will fire up, a massive selloff could fire it downwards, but if it does continue we're easily looking at mid 18's again by the time the momentum wanes.
 
Long range analysis..

stepping back from the daily noise to check the big picture seems to further confirm the bullish argument.

if the daily chart squeeze above fires off followed by the monthly one, there is no doubt in my mind we will be looking at an attempt to make new USD highs, and if it breaks through and runs, €2000-€2350 are easily on the cards.

xaumonthly.png


its hard to imagine a much more bullish long-term chart, and because gold reacts primarily to negative real interest rates, this quote (and whole 2002 article) is as relevant today as it was 10 years ago, with the added benefit of hindsight to see that he was right, he was indeed calling successfully the start of the decade+ long gold rally

It is quite provocative above that the only signs of life gold showed during the whole decade, with the notable exception of the spectacular 1999 Washington Agreement spike on news European central banks would cap their official gold sales, occurred when real interest rates threatened to plunge below zero. Note the sharp 1993 gold rally in the graph above. It erupted the very month that real interest rates hovered right at zero!

Fast forward to early 2001. Our current young gold bull market today first started galloping when real interest rates merely threatened to plunge negative on the madness of the Greenspan Gambit of radical short-term interest-rate manipulation. I don't think it is a coincidence at all that the new gold bull was born exactly as the black 1-Year T-Bill yield above plunged in response to the Fed's Communist-style command-and-control economic manipulation of the price of money.

......

With real interest rates now unambiguously and undisputedly quite negative again, short-term bond investors are getting raped by our guns-and-butter government running the proverbial printing presses to pay for all of its ridiculous expenditures. They are losing their precious capital every year by merely owning short-term bonds! Negative real rates are once again almost certain to only accelerate the growing gold rally.

The Fed may be forced to continue the Japanization of the American economy by slashing nominal interest rates to zero, but I don't think there is much chance at all that the Fed will raise short-term rates and slaughter the already wounded US stock markets.

......

As the Greenspan Fed merrily inflates away so the politicians can have both their endless foreign wars to distract the American people and a welfare state to bribe their votes, the new dollars flooding into the guns-and-butter economy will inevitably breed inflation that even the CPI wizards can't hide. Monetary inflation far higher than the CPI's 2%+ levels will most likely drag the deceptive index even higher.

Will real interest rates remain negative? The Fed can't manipulate short-term interest rates up without gutting the struggling US stock markets. The CPI bureaucrats will have a harder and harder time hiding monetary inflation as it increases. With the 1y T-Bill rates unlikely to shoot higher and the CPI unlikely to crash lower, the dreaded negative real interest rates are probably going to be around for awhile.

From: Real Rates and Gold 3 - by: Adam Hamilton | Fri, Nov 22, 2002


Edit: I just received a call from the PBOC, they said to tell you that even though it is true they have now imported (not including direct output from all their nationalized mines) more gold in just 2012 than the ECB OWNS, there is still definitely, unreservedly, and truly honestly nothing to see here, please move along like a good comrade, kthxbaii!"
 
Last edited:
a long-ish term comparison between the master resource and the master money might be worth contemplating

crude.png


xaumonthly.png


oil still costs about the same as it always has, when priced in real money.

gold-oil-ratio-201203ytd.png
 
so how long do we think the Bernank can hold out against his primal Ctl-P urges when everybody else is playing without him? :D

haha I knew it

kevsta said:
we are only halfway through, I correctly anticipated Euro (and correlated commodity) weakness for the first half year, whether I have correctly anticipated a blitz of printing that would resurrect these predictions easily within 6 weeks remains to be seen.

obviously the whole financial world just revises their estimates when the previous ones fail all the time, but I think we should see what happens and how far out they are at year end really.

Silver in particular does look exceptionally hopeful at this point. Gold can put $300 in in 2 weeks easily, given reason. Oil.. market's seemingly forgotten about the Iran thing again at the moment, that could pop $100+ again in a day if it flared up, at any point.

he cant help himself QE4EVA (TM), ZIRP4EVA and this is all because the economy is "recovering" so well 39 months later. LOLOLOLOL!

new USD highs here we come.
 
so, now its clear to all we're back (still) in full debasement mode and the bull is out of the gate again, its time for an updated prediction

I have drawn in more bars, showing the approximate direction I think its going to go, we will push at the resistance we're at now, until we break through after one or more attempts, at which point that level will become the base, for further movement higher, it will probably consolidate (bounce around) between the resistance levels for a while before pushing on.

I am also being purposely conservative in this prediction, it is possible it surges much harder and tracks up trendline 4, for a while anyway.

gold has a habit of running further than anyone expects once it's off.

moving forwards the price will generally remain between uptrends 2 and 4, - hard selloffs could see us revisit uptrend 1 again (buy heavily if so)

goldfuture.png
 
more all time highs

[meanwhile in the Eurozone] they are currently taking their turn at devaluing their Fiatus Digitalis

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/17852500a83f00ca80.png[/qimg]

gold in Euros has set up an upside down head & shoulders and is at the neckline looking to be on the point of breaking out, if the Euro continues to weaken we will see new all time highs in Fiatus Euros pretty quickly, these patterns are usually powerful when they fire off.

..Powered by QE2Infinity&Beyond!! (TM)

today in Euros, Swiss Francs & Brazilian Reals

in Euros this is +17% from the OP (second time) in CHF approx +15% and USD approximately + 7.5% (again)
 
As the year draws to a close, how is gold doing?

Gold prices down
"An economic uptrend in the US has somewhat dried up demand for the precious metal in the global markets as a safe haven investment," Geojit Comtrade Wholetime Director C P Krishnan told PTI.

In London, prices declined to as low as USD 1,635.70 an ounce on December 20, after data showed the US economy grew by 3.1 per cent during the quarter to September.

Global gold prices are likely to fall further to $1,500 in the next few months, which will also affect the local bullion prices, Krishnan said.

Not what the bulls want to hear!

kevsta said:
I have drawn in more bars, showing the approximate direction I think its going to go, we will push at the resistance we're at now, until we break through after one or more attempts, at which point that level will become the base, for further movement higher...

[comment in graph, pointing to line at $1790] resistance, once cleared it's just blue skies above
Still waiting for that breakthrough?
 

Attachments

  • gold_2_year_o_usd 28 Dec 2102.gif
    gold_2_year_o_usd 28 Dec 2102.gif
    14.3 KB · Views: 3
As the year draws to a close, how is gold doing?

heh heh, just fine, but thanks for your concern :)

Quote:
"An economic uptrend in the US has somewhat dried up demand for the precious metal in the global markets as a safe haven investment," Geojit Comtrade Wholetime Director C P Krishnan told PTI. Gold prices down

ah, that well renowned expert.. wait, who? next year, Gold will outperform all the other major currencies. again.

gold-currencies.png


it will also make new highs in many different currencies. again.

In London, prices declined to as low as USD 1,635.70 an ounce on December 20, after data showed the US economy grew by 3.1 per cent during the quarter to September.

(cleverly?) written to imply cause, rather than just chronological order.

Gold declined because of year-end selling, because of tax hike fears and EOY profit taking as always. plus of course the "not for profit sellers" who are always about whether the news is good or bad, or even when there isn't any, but that's another story.

nor did the US economy "grow" 3.1% really, but that's also another revision story.

Global gold prices are likely to fall further to $1,500 in the next few months, which will also affect the local bullion prices, Krishnan said.

uh huh, based on what exactly? ..the violent rebound early 2012 following the 2011 EOY selldown?

..the $85billion a month of open ended unsterilized new money-printing starting Jan 2013 to buy (90% in 2013) of the bankrupt US government's unrepayable debt, until something entirely unrelated (employment, unless 41% of working age Americans can retrain to be an MBS trader) picks up?

the truth of course is that QEinfinity is still entirely for the benefit of the banks, and more specifically the continuing deflation in the shadow banking system. understanding this was how my favourite site knew in advance, not only that more printing had to come, but even knew how much

this is what they are terrified of - Chart, whatever nonsense they come out with about employment.

yup, can see how all this could be bearish for gold, whichever version of money printing excuses you prefer to believe. :D

you are aware, are you, that in 2013, the Fed will print enough new 1's and 0's money off it's keyboard to "buy" 11% of the world's above ground gold supply?

Not what the bulls want to hear!

intelligent bulls want to hear, see and read all informed opinions, and solid counter evidence always sought here. it's just scarce.

Still waiting for that breakthrough?

yup.

gold.png


and looking closer.. the weekly chart squeeze that fired off in Aug was worth about $210, when that monthly one above fires off from higher up to start..

gold-weekly.png


those of us who have always known QE wont solve the US' problems (adrenaline shots cant cure terminal cancer) have also always known that once started, all the market has to do is spit it's dummy out and they'll do it again. and again. and again.

each time has less effect and next time requires more, and more, and more, (like crack) - plus other countries have to join in to de(free)base their currencies back to weak enough to export again. now virtually every major CB in the world is in, or planning a(nother) money-printing blitz for 2013.

If you look here, you can see gold's price:QE relationship notice that since QE2.5 (OPTwist) price has been contained. In one day, Twist converts to "unsterilized" printing, plus another $45bn a month for good measure.

as it has been obvious to me since 2009 that we would end up here eventually, and well, here we are, I'm not seeing too many flaws in my thesis as yet.

qeinfinity.png


The Fed are trapped here, interest rates cannot (be allowed to) rise in the US because the govt cant afford the rising payments

Kyle Bass - Fallacies such as MMT..

As each 100 basis points in cost of capital costs the US federal government over $150 billion, the US simply cannot afford for another Paul Volcker to raise rates and contain inflation once it arrives

..meanwhile ZIRP kills pension funds, banks and funds that rely on fixed income, oh and (cash) savers.

Luckily however, one of the primary causes of powerful gold bull runs, is negative real interest rates, as pointed out here by somebody who did understand in 2002.

http://www.safehaven.com/article/302/real-rates-and-gold-3 and its gone up every year in a row since that.

might have had some idea, eh? ;)
 
End of a Golden Era?

Report Predicts End of “Gold Era”

“Against any sensible benchmark, gold still appears significantly overvalued,” says the report by analysts Tom Kendall and Ric Deberell. “It looks increasingly likely that [its] 2011 high will prove to have been the peak for the gold price in this cycle.”

The authors note that they previously had forecasted the gold price would hit a peak this year, but now think their prior forecast was too optimistic.
 
lol yes. these analysts are hilarious.

even if the price had anything to do with fear would be a start. if this were the case maybe somebody can explain to me why gold had actually rallied 00's of % and was hitting all time highs between 2002 and 2007, prior to to the problems (finally becoming visible to the herd anyway)?

because Europe is all fixed now : / ..and the global economy is all fully recovered, back on positive real interest rates everywhere, so nobody needs to print any more money, so yes of course if that's all true, then gold has peaked.

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article38829.html

personally Im just waiting for Gartman to say the same, (we probably need another little pop downwards first before muppet capitulates) and then its all in long again (on leverage)
 
Last edited:
even if the price had anything to do with fear would be a start. if this were the case maybe somebody can explain to me why gold had actually rallied 00's of % and was hitting all time highs between 2002 and 2007, prior to to the problems (finally becoming visible to the herd anyway)?

ermmmmm war, perhaps?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom