gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
I'm by no means near as knowledgable on this as most here, but have seen so many technical analysis of gold that made such a good and convincing case that just did not materialise. Using these to make decisions seems like russian roulette. This gold market's behaving strangely indeed.

This makes me to seriously consider the position than Jim Sinclair expressed in his Thunder Report of 28 March 2012, but his position is on the other extreme and borders on CT. If he's even partially correct however, it won't be containable forever and will shoot off again so I should hold my gold.

The dip below various DMAs and the recent return into the wedge, after the seemingly false break out, with no indication of more QE points to a possible break to the lower side of this last few months' neutral movement, makes me want to sell off.

Gary North then makes a good case against deflationists here > http://www.garynorth.com/public/9871.cfm and if inflation is inevitable, then this means I must sit on my few hundred ounces of physical gold for a bit longer to ride the next wave.

Up-Down-Up-Down, see-saw, see-saw. This way - that way. I really wish it would get to a point now already.
 
I'm by no means near as knowledgable on this as most here, but have seen so many technical analysis of gold that made such a good and convincing case that just did not materialise. Using these to make decisions seems like russian roulette. This gold market's behaving strangely indeed.

This makes me to seriously consider the position than Jim Sinclair expressed in his Thunder Report of 28 March 2012, but his position is on the other extreme and borders on CT. If he's even partially correct however, it won't be containable forever and will shoot off again so I should hold my gold.

The dip below various DMAs and the recent return into the wedge, after the seemingly false break out, with no indication of more QE points to a possible break to the lower side of this last few months' neutral movement, makes me want to sell off.

Gary North then makes a good case against deflationists here > http://www.garynorth.com/public/9871.cfm and if inflation is inevitable, then this means I must sit on my few hundred ounces of physical gold for a bit longer to ride the next wave.

Up-Down-Up-Down, see-saw, see-saw. This way - that way. I really wish it would get to a point now already.

its of course up to you, but I have set 2 conditions before I'm selling.

1. all the problems I can see coming, have to be in the rearview mirror.

2. positive real interest rates in all the important economies

relationship between gold and real interest rates

My considered opinion is also that there has been massive and sustained price manipulation in Gold and especially silver for years. this does not make me a conspiracy theorist, my opinion is based on documented facts and my own market observations.

I suspect that long before conditions 1 & 2 can ever become reality, true price discovery will occur in these two metals, but even if that is incorrect, gold is in a powerful long term bull market.

as Jesse Livermore once said, the hardest thing in the world, is to be right and sit tight

- the wall of worry is called that for a reason, and the corrections are violent and scary. (I said this, not Jesse)

“And right here let me say one thing: After spending many years in Wall Street and after making and losing millions of dollars I want to tell you this:

It never was my thinking that made the big money for me. It always was my sitting. Got that? My sitting tight! It is no trick at all to be right on the market.

You always find lots of early bulls in bull markets and early bears in bear markets. I’ve known many men who were right at exactly the right time, and began buying and selling stocks when prices were at the very level which should show the greatest profit. And their experience invariably matched mine – that is, they made no real money out of it.

Men who can both be right and sit tight are uncommon. I found it one of the hardest things to learn. But it is only after a stock operator has firmly grasped this that he can make big money. It is literally true that millions come easier to a trader after he knows how to trade than hundreds did in the days of his ignorance.”

I had to take up leveraged Forex trading to stop myself gambling on price rises and falls on my main stack :)

edit, I just noticed properly your comment on the false breakout and return to within the wedge.

not in my analysis, it's just perfectly normal market movement to retest the downtrend line we broke through last week from the top, and it has, and bounced again, following the Euro, image below. dont pay too much attention to the small movements, they're primarily currency driven, when Gold moves, you'll know it.

Image
 
Last edited:
I'm by no means near as knowledgable on this as most here, but have seen so many technical analysis of gold that made such a good and convincing case that just did not materialise. Using these to make decisions seems like russian roulette. This gold market's behaving strangely indeed.

It's behaving like it is rigged. Funny, that. And as for the silver market...
 
It's behaving like it is rigged. Funny, that. And as for the silver market...

this all got a bit wierd this weekend. firstly the FT came out with a report on Sunday night saying the CTFC were dropping the 4 year old silver probe, due to "lack of evidence" (lol)

then yesterday Bart Chilton (CTFC) refuted this to several different analysts.

and, added further fuel to the fire..

In his remarks to me on Monday morning, Chilton took the fascinating step of broadening the scope of his remarks to include gold this time around, and he also seemed to connect the more recent episodes of highly questionable market dynamics -- which market observers like the Gold Antitrust Action Committee and myself have publicly decried -- to the specific events considered within the four-year silver investigation:

"I continue to believe, consistent with my previous statements and information from the public, that there have been devious efforts related to moving the price of silver. There have also been silver and gold market anomalies outside of the silver investigation window that have raised, and continue to raise, market concerns."

With those powerful remarks, Chilton suggests that he believes the particular events upon which the silver investigation has focused form part of a broader pattern concerning "market anomalies" that continue right through to the present day.

Ultimately, I think the investing public will discover the hand of the Federal Reserve in these ongoing efforts to manipulate gold and silver prices as a form of damage control to mitigate the consequences of sustained easy monetary policy. I am certainly not alone in that assessment, as none other than Paul Craig Roberts -- former Assistant Secretary of the Treasury under President Reagan -- recently had this to say on the matter:

"I suspect that the Federal Reserve is manipulating the gold and silver markets in order to prevent its low interest rate policy from undermining the value of the US dollar. It is easy to offset rising prices of bullion due to physical demand by selling shorts in the paper market.
"

lets see them open up the traders emails on this one like LIBOR, that would be most amusing :)
 
So that's why gold is doing doing so poorly of late - it's being 'manipulated' by the FED! :rolleyes:

they wouldnt do that would they? :rolleyes:

I'm sure they are wholly content with just manipulating the entire market with interest rates and mutterings, why would they want to influence the herd's opinion about the only real whistleblower on their global ponzi scheme?

silly CTers.
 
Last edited:
Oddly enough, it was Soros who proclaimed the bubble. Soros needs to do a better job keeping up with his own lies.

widely misquoted, he actually said gold is (will be) the ultimate bubble. ie the last.

gold since Soros said that - he's still the wrong side of a profitable trade

"When interest rates are low we have conditions for asset bubbles to develop, and they are developing at the moment. The ultimate asset bubble is gold."

and he is correct, it will be. ie after all the imaginary numbers do the Hindenberg thing.
 
"Disappointment over a lack of more stimulus by the U.S. Federal Reserve and other central banks has weighed heavily on gold"

So that's how the FED is manipulating the gold market, by doing nothing! This blatant inaction is appalling. Have they no shame?

lol, its one of their manipulation techniques, yes, MOPE.

"management of performance expectations" that works on all markets, not just gold. ie the S&P from newyorkfed.org
 
and with regards to attracting your attention, at what price will you be considering buying? .. once the herd and momentum chasers are all fully in again?

be quick, as gold's just broken out though the downtrend line (red sloping) dating back to the start of the correction a year ago, the algos are/will all flick to "buy" now.

hot momentum money inbound as we speak.

178525035dc0f6217c.png


any more takers on whether we see $1200 or $2000 first ? :)
 
any more takers on whether we see $1200 or $2000 first ? :)
Neither is likely anytime soon.

be quick, as gold's just broken out though the downtrend line (red sloping) dating back to the start of the correction a year ago, the algos are/will all flick to "buy" now.
Or perhaps it's just another minor uptick, as has happened many times in the last year.

Anyway whatever happens, for me it's already too late. Almost exactly one year ago, when I first read this thread, gold was shooting up like a rocket. I admit that I was tempted, but then rationality kicked in and I went for the safe bet of a term deposit instead.

What happened next? The bottom dropped out of gold, and it is now trading 13.3% lower than a year ago. Factor in the 4.5% per annum interest that I am receiving on my investment, and gold will have to break through $2000 in the next 12 months just to break even with what I am getting now!
 
Neither is likely anytime soon.

probability-wise, one is very much more likely than the other ;)

Or perhaps it's just another minor uptick, as has happened many times in the last year.

its not, it's based and reversed. this is not to say it cannot and will not be smashed down continually to try and slow the rise, because it will be, however the bottom is in at 1525 on this now IMO.

Anyway whatever happens, for me it's already too late. Almost exactly one year ago, when I first read this thread, gold was shooting up like a rocket. I admit that I was tempted, but then rationality kicked in and I went for the safe bet of a term deposit instead.

What happened next? The bottom dropped out of gold, and it is now trading 13.3% lower than a year ago. Factor in the 4.5% per annum interest that I am receiving on my investment, and gold will have to break through $2000 in the next 12 months just to break even with what I am getting now!

from the OPs original clarification of his timescales for the thread

OK, I can see the reasons for possible confusion. I'm not interested in short-term trading positions. I'm only interested in big pictures and longer timescales, where "long" means the next 18 months to two years. After that, my crystal ball doesn't seem to be functioning very well.

I'm pretty sure that taken over a 2 year period from the start of this thread, gold will make your 4.5% look pretty stupid.

the point is, your instincts were correct to be not buying near all-time highs, but incorrect at the bottom, where we should all be buying when were scared to.

15xx now looks like a pretty solid bottom and from those (historically) come powerful 20 or 30% moves.

If PIMCO** are layering in on dips towards $1500, and China are buying as much as they can get without forcing the price higher at levels between $1500-1600, after a year of being smashed down without going through the $1500 floor, what direction do you think the next big move is most likely to be in?

clue: its already started. (in my opinion, not investment advice DYODD blah blah blah)

**PIMCO being the bond kings, and knowing that inflation is the enemy of their portfolio, and hence increasing their gold ownership, is *somewhat* bullish.

as is the fact that the only people left selling the market are the stupid retail traders who are in direct opposition to the commercials and swap dealers who are at historic levels of net longyness vs shortyness
 
Last edited:
Neither is likely anytime soon.

Almost exactly one year ago, when I first read this thread, gold was shooting up like a rocket. I admit that I was tempted, but then rationality kicked in and I went for the safe bet of a term deposit instead.

What happened next? The bottom dropped out of gold, and it is now trading 13.3% lower than a year ago. Factor in the 4.5% per annum interest that I am receiving on my investment, and gold will have to break through $2000 in the next 12 months just to break even with what I am getting now!

and so I just took the time to check this. not very accurate is it? :D

this thread was started on 4th Aug, 2011, on which day gold traded between $1640 and $1680, closing at $1647



so the 13.3% down is incorrect isn't it?

taking a round $1650 on Aug 4th we've been up to approx +15% ($1900 - about when you appeared on 3rd Sept ) down to -8% and are currently back over even.

in the last year we made new all time highs in $, € and many other currencies, and then consolidated and held ABOVE the last new all-time highs ($1500)

or if you are going to use "a year ago", the year end you need to wait for is 3rd Sept?


explain to me how you need $2000 to break even again? although if all your investment is based on interpreting the facts like this and funny August cutoff points Im not saying its impossible ;)
 
Last edited:
so the 13.3% down is incorrect isn't it?
No, it is absolutely correct that (according to goldprice.org) gold was down 13.3% in exactly 1 year, at the time I made that post.

taking a round $1650 on Aug 4th we've been up to approx +15% ($1900 - about when you appeared on 3rd Sept ) down to -8% and are currently back over even.
Did I ever deny that gold was going up at the time? No. Did I vote that gold was in a bubble, and would soon fall? Yes. Is that what happened? Yes.

As of right now gold is sitting at $1655.80, so it has made virtually no gain since the start of this thread. Technically you may be correct to say that it is "currently back over even" since Aug 3rd, but some of us didn't even see this thread until some time later. So on Sept 3rd, after doing a bit of research into gold and watching the price for a few days, I made the following statement...
Roger Ramjets said:
Obviously the price of gold can't continue to rise at its current exponential rate.
... which was scoffed at by gold bugs.

And then you predicted...
kevsta said:
I think next week is quite likely going to be one for the history books, we have a virtual perfect storm blowing for the metals
Did it turn out how you expected?

in the last year we made new all time highs
That was a joke, right? The chart below shows the last year in gold, which reached its final and unbeaten All Time High of $1889.70 on Aug 20th 2011. Please show us all the 'new' all time highs which have occurred since then!

or if you are going to use "a year ago", the year end you need to wait for is 3rd Sept?
Obviously I was taking "a year ago" to mean the same date last year. But that post was on Aug 23rd, so let's wait until Sept 3rd and see if things are different. Who knows, maybe a miracle will happen and gold shoots back up to "over even" relative to Sept 3rd 2011! (I'm not holding my breath on that one...)
 

Attachments

  • all time high.gif
    all time high.gif
    12 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:

quibbling with you about your particular posting/viewing dates and wierd investing deadlines is tedious.

since this thread began, Gold HAS made new highs in many (and all the important) currencies. since the very top when most of the herd (baaaah! ;) ) got interested, of course it has corrected, thats what markets do.

11 years worth of bull market gold corrections.

http://www.caseyresearch.com/articles/your-window-buy-gold-below-1700-closing

this one is:

a) not particularly impressive historically
b) just about over

so you just watch from the outside again, that way I get to taunt you more moving forwards ;)
 
Last edited:
The results are in, and...

It's not looking good for gold. On Sept 3rd 2011 I predicted that gold couldn't maintain its meteoric rise, and was headed for a fall. Sure enough, just a few days later gold got knocked off its perch, and has yet to claw its way back. Several times gold attempted to regain its former glory, only to crash down again in despair. And now, exactly 1 year later, gold is still down 10.08%. :(

If you take the peak in August/September 2011 as your base price you can show that the price of gold has fallen.

Yet take the base price from even a month earlier
I never tried to hide the earlier price rise. Why would I, when to be in a bubble it must rise before falling. My point is not the fact that gold has fallen dramatically since Sept 2011, but that it fell when gold bugs were insisting that it would keep rising. And then when it did fall the denial kicked in... First they insisted it was just a short-term fluctuation, then every bump on the way down became a 'new all time high'! :boggled:

Sooner or later gold will bottom out. Perhaps it has already - or perhaps not. But what cannot be denied is the fact that anybody who was fooled into buying gold 12 months ago (because "it's not a bubble!" and "the sky is the limit, fiat money is doomed!") has now lost 10% of their 'investment'. :mad:

and the charts show that apart from a couple of bubbles,
Oh no! Cover your eyes, it's the 'b' word! :covereyes
 

Attachments

  • gold_1_year_o_usd 3rd sept.png
    gold_1_year_o_usd 3rd sept.png
    11.3 KB · Views: 4
I'm not knocking you. You correctly picked that gold had peaked on September 4 last year and gold has been on a roller coaster since.

I'm only pointing out that in true Yes Minister style, you (by coincidence I think) picked the date that presents gold in the worst possible light. Only someone who bought at that peak would have lost that much money. (If you fear a currency or banking crash, you might think yourself lucky if 10% is the most you lose).

I still think that the two year chart is more interesting than the one year chart.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom