gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Gold price to fall 15% this year: strategists

http://www.emergingmarkets.org/Article/3184068/Financial-Markets/Gold-price-to-fall-15-this-year-strategists.html
Gold prices could average $1500 per ounce over the course of this year, gradually dropping to $1375/oz by the end of 2013, according to strategists at Societe Generale...

The rally in gold prices over the past five years was driven by fears that money-printing by major central banks would lead to very high inflation but so far price rises have been contained and now there are three factors that could put a stop to the rally... better economic conditions, fiscal stabilization, and a rise in the US dollar.
It's only April and gold has already dropped to US$1550, a staggering 7.3% down from the beginning of the year. If this trend continues then the strategists may be right!
 

Attachments

  • Gold 6 months April 3rd 2013.gif
    Gold 6 months April 3rd 2013.gif
    8.5 KB · Views: 4
I think the dollar is bound to collapse sometime within the next 30 years due to the ever increasing debt with ZERO indication that it will EVER be paid off.

I mean ◊◊◊◊, we couldn't even agree to finally REDUCE the spending INCREASE, let alone a decrease. They made a nice show of it though.

However I still wouldn't buy gold at the moment. The bubble has been carrying on for a long time now, but it is still a bubble. It is a bear and it is bound to pop given time.

Raising taxes is not the answer BTW. Historically, raising the taxes not far beyond where they are at now results in a decline in tax revenue, not an increase, in addition to an economic recession.
 
Last edited:
http://www.emergingmarkets.org/Article/3184068/Financial-Markets/Gold-price-to-fall-15-this-year-strategists.html
It's only April and gold has already dropped to US$1550, a staggering 7.3% down from the beginning of the year. If this trend continues then the strategists may be right!


"a staggering" - really. :rolleyes: seriously, re-visiting the low end of it's trading range is "staggering" is it?

do you have any idea how many times I have heard this same nonsense spouted by the propagandists and the know-nothings over the last 5 years? people were saying it as I was buying in 2009, I laughed at them then, just as I laugh at them (and you) now.

If you dont understand why it's run 600% in the last decade, why a secular bull market started in 2001, why it was making new highs before the GFC..then you wont understand why it's not even really got started yet.

"Forgive them, for they either have ulterior motives or not the foggiest idea what they are talking about.."



gold-gbp.png


gold-yen.png
 
Last edited:
What about the price of gold as measured in bitcoins!

Gold is really tanking bigtime!

:D and to be fair you are still kicking my ass on my theoretical long gold short S&P trade.

it wont last the year.
 

so we are running a bit late for the 19 month intervals, but after today I do think the bottom is probably in now.

NEW YORK (TheStreet) – Gold prices were popping on Friday after a poor jobs report forced investors to cover their short positions.

silly silly herd. they (managed money) are at record short positioning on margin, whilst the commercials who are permanently long by way of their business can hardly even be bothered to hedge (short) at these levels.

xaudaily.png


xauweekly.png


Gold for April delivery at the COMEX division of the CME was jumping $13.40 to $1,565.80 an ounce. The gold price traded as high as $1,576 and as low as $1,549 an ounce, while the spot price was gaining $13.80, according to Kitco’s gold index.

and closed at $1580 on the futures.

”There’s a lot of [ovine] shorts in the market here,” Tom Vitiello, partner at Aurum Options Strategies, said in an interview from the NYMEX. “We had people basically getting out of their shorts during the Cyprus crisis, … once … the perception of it subsided basically the shorts got back in again and they were in control as of yesterday. But today it was quite painful to be short with that number that came out.”

but.. but.. recovery.. improving economy.. fundamentals.. you cant eat it! :D

Payrolls Plunge To 88K, Biggest Miss Since December 2009, Participation Rate At New 30 Year Low

So much for "open-ended QE driven recovery". Moments ago the March Non-farm payroll hit and it was a doozy, printing at 88K, below the lowest forecast of 100K, well below the expected number of 190K, and a tragedy compared to the February revised print of 268K (was 236K).

This was the biggest miss to expectations since December 2009 and the worst print since June 2012. The unemployment rate declined to 7.6%, but this was due entirely to the collapse in the labor force participation rate, which declined by 20 bps to 63.3%, a new 30 year low.

Labor%20Force%20Rate.jpg


Real March Unemployment rate 11.6%

Today, we got the laughable news that the unemployment rate declined even as those not in the labor force grew by over 660,000, while the total civilian non-institutional population grew by just 167,000 to 244,995, meaning the actual labor force declined by 496,000.

Which is precisely the issue: fudging the labor force participation rate is how the Obama administration has managed to maintain the myth the economy has grown under his leadership for the past 4+ years.

It hasn't, and in fact if one renormalizes for the recent long-term average participation rate of 65.8%, one gets a very different number. How different?

A difference that is now at a record compared to what is reported. As the chart below shows, a "renormalization" process indicates a massive and record 4% difference between the reported unemployment rate of 7.6%, and what the real unemployment rate is assuming normal growth of the labor force, which in March was 11.6%, up from 11.3% in February, and the highest since August 2012 when it was 11.7%.

More importantly, as the real unemployment chart shows, the economy has not improved by one bit since 2009

the short squeeze alone could propel us to $1750 in a few days. throw in some Japanese watching it hit all time highs in Yen as their bonds start sliding and we have the potential makings of $2000+ this year easily.

kevsta said:
so anyway let's put on a "for fun" pair trade at this point. -I'll go long gold at $1571 and short S&P @ 1514.5.

do you want to "take the other side" of this? ie sell me your gold and buy my S&P shares?

4 days ago the S&P closed at 1571 and gold at $1575, (well done Bernanke btw, target achieved, briefly, intraday anyway) leaving me down $52.50 or 3.35%

I'll stick my neck out and say that I think that's as close as it gets now and both trends reverse from here.
 
Last edited:
oh and..

Roger Ramjets said:
Gold price to fall 15% this year: strategists
http://www.emergingmarkets.org/Artic...rategists.html
Quote:
Gold prices could average $1500 per ounce over the course of this year, gradually dropping to $1375/oz by the end of 2013, according to strategists at Societe Generale...


previous forecasts completely perfectly, 100% incorrect.

1785251601f4fcf70f.gif




motives, definitely "iffy" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Société_Générale#March_2008:_Missing_consignment_of_gold_by_Golda.C5.9F

March 2008: Missing consignment of gold by Goldaş
On March 21, 2008, Société Générale filed suit in Istanbul Commercial Court against Goldaş, a Turkish Jewelry firm, claiming the company had not paid for 15 tonnes(15,000 kg) of gold it had received through a consignment agreement.[17][18]

Goldaş stated that the consignment agreement was only for 3,250 kg of gold with a value of US$94 million.[19] In June 2008, the court found Goldaş not guilty.

[edit]March 2009: Potential loss of $11 billion averted due to US government bailout of AIG

On March 15, 2009, AIG disclosed that, among its counterparties, Société Générale was to date the largest recipient of both credit default swap (CDS) collateral postings ($4.1 bn) and CDS payments ($6.9 bn), payments made possible in part by the 2008 U.S. government bailout of AIG.[20]



conclusion, Socgen want you to sell them your gold, the cheaper, the better.

or people could listen to Sprott, who has been correct for the last 12 years. here he is with some more of that pesky evidence again.

Société Générale (“SocGen”) recently published a special report entitled “The end of the gold era” that garnered far more attention than we think it deserved. The majority of the report focused on SocGen’s “crash scenario” for gold wherein they suggest that gold could fall well below their 2013 target of US$1,375/oz. It also included a classic criticism that we’ve heard so many times before: that the gold price is in “bubble territory”. We have problems with both suggestions.

To begin, the report’s authors appear to view gold as a commodity, rather than as a currency. This is a common misconception that continues to plague most gold market analysis. Gold doesn’t really work as a commodity because it doesn’t get consumed like one.

The vast majority of gold mined throughout history remains in existence today, and the total global gold stockpile grows in small increments every year through additional mine supply. This is also precisely why gold works so well as a currency. Total gold supply can only grow marginally, while fiat money supply can grow exponentially through printing programs. This is why gold’s monetary value is so important – it’s the only “currency” in play that is immune to government devaluation.

Chart A illustrates the relationship between the growth of central bank balance sheets in the US, EU, UK and Japan and the price of gold. This relationship has an extremely high correlation with an R2 of about 95%.

As central banks increase the size of their balance sheets through ‘open market operations’ to buy bonds, mortgage-backed securities (“MBS”) and the like, they inject more fiat dollars into their respective banking systems. As gold has a relatively stable supply, if there are more dollars available, the price of gold should rise in dollar terms. It’s really a very simple and intuitive relationship – as it should be.

This relationship between central bank printing and gold has existed since the beginning of the gold bull market in 2000. In fact, this relationship shows that for every US$1 trillion increase in the collective central banks’ balance sheets, the price of gold has generally appreciated by an average of US$210/oz.

Somewhat surprisingly, it turns out that the collective central bank balance sheets have actually shrunk over the past three months – by approximately US$415 billion.

[kevsta was certainly gobsmacked I can tell you. wasnt expecting that :D ]

The biggest drop was seen in the ECB’s balance sheet, which shrunk by the equivalent of US$370 billion, while other central banks also experienced small declines. Based on our simple model above, a decrease of US$415 billion should produce a gold price decline of roughly US$87/oz. And as it turns out, gold fell by US$76/oz over the first quarter of 2013. Does this sound like a bubble to you?

It certainly doesn’t appear to be. Gold is performing almost exactly as it should – by acting as a currency barometer for the amount of money being injected into or withdrawn from the economy... which leads us to Japan...


any counter evidence welcomed, as always.. ;)
 
Last edited:
:) ..its probably fair to say that the IQs are on the whole somewhat higher here than the majority of internet forums.



those of us who believe gold is already money (and is gradually returning as the defacto global reserve currency day by day, despite what the Bernank and his hordes of clueless PHDs desperately want us to believe) think this is a silly argument, that profits must be measured in cents and $?

Why would I want to swap my superior money for your inferior and ever devaluing money? we are betting that we already possess the winning currency in the escalating currency wars, it's increasing in value every year for the last 10 years against the dying paper system, it's just a matter of waiting out the inevitable, and getting through the reset as best as possible.

once we get through the real crisis yet to come, there will be a time to swap the metals into real things, companies property etc but currently all those real things are (IMO) WAY overvalued due to debt that has yet to be purged, one way or another.

"priced in Gold" anything requiring leverage to own continues to deflate against Gold, housing, boats, stocks etc (Dow : Gold 6.90 on Friday) so I will continue to bet my 1655th of an Oz of gold against dollars and cents, well until the latter are no more.

when the time to sell did come, I'd only ever sell into a decent currency anyway, SF or something, whatever's still left at that point I suppose.

It's hard to read this and believe you've made any money in the last year and a half. Gold has been flat and silver has dropped from $44 an ounce (April 2011) to $27.50. If you're that bad a gold bug, I'm also betting you missed the 80+% growth in the market in the last 3.5 years.
 
It's hard to read this and believe you've made any money in the last year and a half. Gold has been flat and silver has dropped from $44 an ounce (April 2011) to $27.50. If you're that bad a gold bug, I'm also betting you missed the 80+% growth in the market in the last 3.5 years.

is it hard to do maths also? deduct 2009 prices from today's prices = substantial profit

ie cost price 600GBP per Oz. price now 1040GBP profit +440GBP or +73% if sold now

yes some of the frothiness has come off again since 2011, but fortunately I don't have to do year-end accounting in nominal fiat of any particular persuasion, and will still be positioned when the previous highs are next broken.

as per my quote you used above, exactly which devaluing government tax tokens would you have me swap my real money superior currency for, and why?
 
Last edited:
The Cycle Turns,

Goldman Lowers Gold Price Forecast Through 2014 as Cycle Turns
The turn in the gold price cycle is accelerating after a 12-year rally as the recovery in the U.S. economy gains momentum, according to Goldman Sachs Group Inc...

“While higher inflation may be the catalyst for the next gold cycle, this is likely several years away..."

“We believe a sharp rebound in gold prices is unlikely,” Goldman said. “The fall in prices could end up being faster and larger than our forecast"
Next gold cycle could be several years away? Oh no, say it isn't so!

is it hard to do maths also? deduct 2009 prices from today's prices = substantial profit
That's great for those who had spare funds during the depths of the economic down-turn and happened to catch gold at its lowest point. But this thread was started in August 2011, just before gold reached it's highest price ever. Since then it's been a bumpy downhill ride, and anybody who listened to the gold bugs then is probably feeling a bit foolish right now.

yes some of the frothiness has come off again since 2011,
I guess that's the closest we will get to an admission that "Megabull -The Sky's the Limit!" wasn't the most accurate prediction of where gold was going...
 
Goldman Lowers Gold Price Forecast Through 2014 as Cycle TurnsNext gold cycle could be several years away? Oh no, say it isn't so!

lol, GS want to buy your gold off you cheaply too? what a coincidence.. :D

That's great for those who had spare funds during the depths of the economic down-turn and happened to catch gold at its lowest point. But this thread was started in August 2011, just before gold reached it's highest price ever. Since then it's been a bumpy downhill ride, and anybody who listened to the gold bugs then is probably feeling a bit foolish right now.

anybody who bought because they "listened to the goldbugs" and didnt do their own research and agree with the conclusions, prior to buying, really deserves to lose their money, because they clearly would do that whatever the cause.

I personally wasn't in at the beginning, I was quite late in 2009 compared to those who really understood in advance, however having examined all the evidence I could see at the time, decided that "all-in" gold/silver with what was left of my UK housing profits from selling in 2005, was the way forwards.

so, trading timing skills not really so hot at the time, out of UK housing a good year or 2 before the top, into PMs several (7?!) years too late

but I am currently well ahead of where I would have been without these 2 not-even-very-well-timed moves.

UK house prices in gold

I guess that's the closest we will get to an admission that "Megabull -The Sky's the Limit!" wasn't the most accurate prediction of where gold was going...

your arbitrary time limits skew your view. did the OP say:

"should I buy gold right now, and only view it's performance from within the confines of year-end reporting figures?"

it is an admission that its taken/taking longer than I had thought, but this notion of "recovery" when every patient is now clinically dead on the operating table and only still twitching because of open ended adrenalin permanently pumping into the heart just seems patently absurd to me.

switch the global open ended money printing off everywhere, and raise interest rates 2 or 3% and lets see how "recovered" we are.

"Green shoots" in 2010 anybody? yea, well why has it reliably collapsed every time they switched the life support off ever since until we now have it on full blast max power around the whole world?

I don't know, maybe I am an insane paranoid doomer because I definitely feel like I'm looking at a different film entirely, to most here, at any rate. but as I have actually been right thus far with my insane paranoid delusions about these things, perhaps you can excuse me trusting my own views over the (un-involved) detractors?

and with the very notable lack of any kind of factual evidence pointing to a gold bubble of any sort throughout this whole thread, in fact nothing, but the daily propaganda of sell-side analysts who always have their own agendas, you are spectacularly failing to make me want to re-re-re-re-think my stance.

and once more, to you too..

as per my quote you used above, exactly which devaluing government tax tokens would you have me swap my real money superior currency for, and why?

I want to track your recommendation against your preferred currency over time.
 
Last edited:
That's great for those who had spare funds during the depths of the economic down-turn and happened to catch gold at its lowest point. But this thread was started in August 2011, just before gold reached it's highest price ever. Since then it's been a bumpy downhill ride, and anybody who listened to the gold bugs then is probably feeling a bit foolish right now.

Browse to gata.org and read. Learn about naked short selling, and how the largest bullion banks in the world are suppressing the gold and silver prices. Then you will understand why the gold price tends to languish for certain periods, but even seems to tank precisely at times where you would otherwise expect it to rise. There are roughly 100:1 paper/electronic gold ounces that have been sold per physical ounce. Even people like me, who are well aware of the situation, still have some gold derivatives (I am working to change that, as of the ABM AMRO gold default). So after the global bank run, there will in all likelihood be a paper gold run, and then you will see price discovery for physical gold.

I guess that's the closest we will get to an admission that "Megabull -The Sky's the Limit!" wasn't the most accurate prediction of where gold was going...

Wait a while. It's coming.
 
So is Jesus.

Predictions with open-ended time frames are useless.

Not at all. There is a big difference between knowing that something is going to happen, and knowing when. It will happen soon enough, but I'm not smart enough to offer a "time frame", neither are most.

Feel free to ignore me, and continue professing the idea that all investor success is accidental.
 
Feel free to ignore me, and continue professing the idea that all investor success is accidental.


I'm not ignoring you.

I hold physical gold and silver. It would please me if they appreciated in value, but that's not why I own them.

And as I've expressed, my take on markets is paradoxical:

Free markets tend to move randomly with assets always, by definition, being fairly priced.

Yet an informed investor can possibly intuit asset classes and individual assets that have a better chance than others at appreciating over time.

I would never bet against gold going much higher. I would also not bet against gold going much lower. Because I don't see investing as gambling.

But the strategy of moving in and out of contracts or stocks or whatever, chasing even 70¢ moves, does seem a lot like gambling, and I've never known anyone who was able to day-trade their way to wealth - though they may be out there, and more power to them if they can make a living at it. More often, an eventual "crash and burn" is in the offing, or so it seems.

To me! :p
 
I'm not ignoring you.

I hold physical gold and silver. It would please me if they appreciated in value, but that's not why I own them.

So, why do you own them?

And as I've expressed, my take on markets is paradoxical:

Free markets tend to move randomly with assets always, by definition, being fairly priced.

I just linked to evidence that shows that the gold and silver markets are anything but free, or fairly priced, and exist in a derivative fractional reserve gold system. The average "gold investor" calls their broker and asks to buy gold, the broker says "ok, you're in gold now!", and that's that.

You could look at this from one of two ways, that the gold and silver price will remain suppressed and manipulated in perpetuity, or that this scheme will end at some point, and it will have become apparent that gold was selling at a huge discount for a long time. I subscribe to the latter view. I've bet on the latter view. I've already made large unrealized gains which my posts going back on this forum will corroborate.

Yet an informed investor can possibly intuit asset classes and individual assets that have a better chance than others at appreciating over time.

I would never bet against gold going much higher. I would also not bet against gold going much lower. Because I don't see investing as gambling.

But the strategy of moving in and out of contracts or stocks or whatever, chasing even 70¢ moves, does seem a lot like gambling, and I've never known anyone who was able to day-trade their way to wealth - though they may be out there, and more power to them if they can make a living at it. More often, an eventual "crash and burn" is in the offing, or so it seems.

To me! :p

Yeah, I don't daytrade. I haven't sold a single ounce of gold or silver, and I don't plan to for some time. Daytraders have to overcome bid/ask spreads, commissions, and short term capital gains taxes, as well as short term manipulation in financial markets. While I agree with your criticisms of daytrading, I totally disagree with the more general point that you seem to be trying to make on these forums, which is that most of investing is just a random walk, and completely accidental. Clearly, at least to me, it's not. Investment gains are a function of knowledge and conviction.
 
So, why do you own them?

Insurance against the possibility of hyper- (or near hyper-) inflation.

If the dollar takes a huge hit and stocks plunge and gold goes to $20,000 an ounce, I see it as a way to retain wealth, not make real gains per sé.

You could look at this from one of two ways, that the gold and silver price will remain suppressed and manipulated in perpetuity, or that this scheme will end at some point, and it will have become apparent that gold was selling at a huge discount for a long time.

Sure.

I don't know how old you are, but I'm 63. I've been investing in gold starting in the mid to late 70's.

I remember then, gold running to $800 and silver to $50. I heard bubbly predictions then that "the sky was the limit" given the economic woes of the time. Everyone thought gold was headed to $1,000. Very few then could imagine sub-$300 gold, or $12 silver (IIRC) which we did in fact retreat to.

This just feels like déjà vu.


Investment gains are a function of knowledge and conviction.

It's like you focused on just one "horn" of my paradox.

I agree 100%, while still holding that day-to-day, or week-by-week or year-by-year predictions of stock or commodity moves are exceedingly difficult, if not impossible, to make with enough certainty to profit on those moves. Then again, buy stock in promising companies or intuit inefficiencies in other markets, and I think there's money to be made.

Works for me!
 
Last edited:
Well, in some circles, it's just "buy gold, it's cheap as long as you can buy it with money." In a few years, we'll be getting wonderful conspiracy theories on how Goldman Sachs or some other Jews cheated all goldbugs out of their well-deserved fortune.

Browse to gata.org and read. Learn about naked short selling, and how the largest bullion banks in the world are suppressing the gold and silver prices. Then you will understand why the gold price tends to languish for certain periods, but even seems to tank precisely at times where you would otherwise expect it to rise. There are roughly 100:1 paper/electronic gold ounces that have been sold per physical ounce. Even people like me, who are well aware of the situation, still have some gold derivatives (I am working to change that, as of the ABM AMRO gold default). So after the global bank run, there will in all likelihood be a paper gold run, and then you will see price discovery for physical gold.



Wait a while. It's coming.

Outstanding.
 
There seems to have been a rather large negative move in the price of gold recently.

http://www.bloomberg.com/markets/commodities/futures/metals/

Spot price fell below $1500, down 5%. Says $1482 now. Silver and other precious metals also had similar drops of c. 5%.

yes indeed, there was an absolute mauling yesterday for sure. so much for the bottom being in, in fact 5 days after I thought we were reversing, the bottom properly dropped out.

deeply suspect IMO, but I cant put my finger on it. there are various nonsense reasons being assigned by MSM as always, but none add up.

herd sentiment is at extreme bearish levels now though, you know that's the case when they even have me re-re-re-re-assessing my thesis. luckily I'm far enough in to be amongst the strongest hands now.

and in GBP (which mine is priced in) the drop isnt so scary yet compared tp previous pullbacks along the way.

goldgbp.png


If they got it all the way back down to £600 without a monster reversal prior, I'm not sure if I'd bail at zero or BTFD right now, but I still think GS and their ilk are just hoovering up the last of the weak hands before the next big run up..

178525169998512db5.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom