gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
because Europe is all fixed now : / ..and the global economy is all fully recovered, back on positive real interest rates everywhere, so nobody needs to print any more money, so yes of course if that's all true, then gold has peaked.

I think when people like "roger ramjets" become capitulation buyers, then I will look to become a seller. As it is, I really don't know anyone who owns gold, or talks about it.
 
I think when people like "roger ramjets" become capitulation buyers, then I will look to become a seller.
People like me never invest in gold, so we will never be 'capitulation buyers'. I guess that means that you will never sell your gold. ;)

Why don't we invest in gold? Because we know that no matter how low it goes, it can always drop further!

Goldman cuts gold price forecasts as metal extends decline
Gold has been weak since the start of the year and hit a six-month low last week on fears that the U.S. may curtail its monetary easing policy as the economy picks up...

Goldman believes this trend will continue, with 2013 proving to be an inflection point for the gold price as U.S. real interest rates increase alongside an accelerating U.S. recovery in the second half of the year.

The broker trimmed its gold price forecasts for 2013 and 2014 by 5% and 4%, respectively, to US$1,787 and US$1,744 an ounce.

The broker’s longer term forecast was cut by 15% to US$1,200 an ounce.
 
People like me never invest in gold, so we will never be 'capitulation buyers'. I guess that means that you will never sell your gold. ;)

Why don't we invest in gold? Because we know that no matter how low it goes, it can always drop further!

Goldman cuts gold price forecasts as metal extends decline

Goldman was predicting gold prices in excess of $2000, if I recall correctly. Do you only quote Goldman forecasts when Goldman agrees with your premise?

I agree that interest rates are bound to rise eventually, the problem is that this will be concurrent with a bond market crash, not an economic recovery, and in that context there will be a lot of money available to bid up gold prices in lieu of anything else, assuming all the banks don't fail.
 
Goldman was predicting gold prices in excess of $2000, if I recall correctly. Do you only quote Goldman forecasts when Goldman agrees with your premise?
Goldman Sachs revised their predictions downward. IOW they admit to being wrong in the past. Can you?

I agree that interest rates are bound to rise eventually, the problem is that this will be concurrent with a bond market crash
The bond market won't 'crash' unless inflation takes off. Do you think this will happen, and if so - when?

and in that context there will be a lot of money available to bid up gold prices in lieu of anything else,
Are you saying that gold is the only alternative to bonds?

Perhaps you are right. But if everybody has their money in bonds, and the market crashes, where will they get the money to buy gold? Stupid speculators... :boggled:

assuming all the banks don't fail.
A pretty safe assumption IMO. Do you think there is a good chance that they will fail?
 
Goldman Sachs revised their predictions downward. IOW they admit to being wrong in the past. Can you?

you still don't understand that when Goldman Sachs are flipping bearish at the bottom and advising their customers to sell, their prop desk is buying? these people are not stupid, but they do rely on the unchanging stupidity of their muppets customers

last week's sell off smacks of classic herd capitulation. all the numbers now look powerfully bullish, this is one of those times to "buy fear"

but of course hardly anybody does, because the herd is now all facing the wrong way and still trying to "Sell (short) low", just like they were all piling in to buy the highs. you cant account for herd stupidity and the bull is, as always, determined to leave with as few onboard as possible.

here's some current analysis from a guy who called the start of the gold bull perfectly in 2002, and hence is worth listening to, rather than some GS sellside (salesman) propaganda nonsense

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article39154.html

Gold got crushed this week in what can only be described as a capitulation. Cascading selling took on a life of its own as the yellow metal knifed through multiple key support lines. Newsflow exacerbated gold’s free fall, as extreme fear tainted everything with a heavy pall of bearishness. Gold bears were euphoric, coming out in droves to pronounce doom on the metal. But capitulations are actually very bullish events...

...Also realize that bearishness peaks with fear during capitulations. So it is perfectly normal to see nothing but bearish predictions during and after a capitulation selloff. We humans have the natural tendency to extrapolate the present into the indefinite future. So when prices are falling, we assume they are going to keep falling. So we rationalize our outlook, selectively look for arguments to support our emotional bias.

Just after a capitulation, almost all commentary is bearish. It varies from the end-of-the-bull arguments to merely further downside. Even the less-bearish end of this spectrum is dominated by views looking for the falling price to keep trending a little lower before it bounces. Analysts and traders never like to call bottoms because it makes them stick out from the herd, leaving them with the risk of being proven wrong.

But contrarians don’t care, because we are always fighting the crowd. We strive to buy low, when a sector is already hated late in a major selloff. If prices fall lower still after we buy due to a relatively-rare unpredictable capitulation, so be it. If you liked gold for fundamental, technical, and sentimental reasons when it was trading near $1675 earlier this month, its outlook is far more bullish now near $1565!

Regardless of what the Fed says, it can’t stop monetizing debt anytime soon. Interest rates would soar which would devour the US government thanks to Obama’s debt bomb. And quantitative easing is just a sideshow to the Fed’s real monetary inflation, which continues perpetually. The Fed fears inflation expectations far more than inflation itself, so it is constantly trying to jawbone them back down.

And despite inflation garnering all the headlines as far as the bullish case for gold is concerned, it is but one facet of this metal’s bullish fundamentals. There are other major drivers of gold investment demand globally, inflation is just a tailwind. So no matter what the Fed does with QE3, or tries to convince the world it is going to do, the great majority of gold’s bullish case remains intact. The Fed’s role is minor.




A pretty safe assumption IMO. Do you think there is a good chance that they will fail?

lol yes, a very good chance, the only variable is time, your assumption is like betting against maths.
 
Last edited:
you still don't understand that when Goldman Sachs are flipping bearish at the bottom and advising their customers to sell, their prop desk is buying? these people are not stupid, but they do rely on the unchanging stupidity of their muppets customers

last week's sell off smacks of classic herd capitulation. all the numbers now look powerfully bullish, this is one of those times to "buy fear"

but of course hardly anybody does, because the herd is now all facing the wrong way and still trying to "Sell (short) low", just like they were all piling in to buy the highs. you cant account for herd stupidity and the bull is, as always, determined to leave with as few onboard as possible.

here's some current analysis from a guy who called the start of the gold bull perfectly in 2002, and hence is worth listening to, rather than some GS sellside (salesman) propaganda nonsense

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article39154.html








lol yes, a very good chance, the only variable is time, your assumption is like betting against maths.

I've been hearing this about gold and silver for years now. It's not PANNING out (rimshot). Since 2011, it's gone up, what, 10%? For the last 12 months, it's dropped. When is this amazing run-up going to happen? You would have done as well (or better) just keeping your money in an index fund.
 
I've been hearing this about gold and silver for years now. It's not PANNING out (rimshot). Since 2011, it's gone up, what, 10%? For the last 12 months, it's dropped. When is this amazing run-up going to happen?

you would have done as well (or better) just keeping your money in an index fund.

you don't think an average of 45% (gold) -60% (silver) per annum over a 10 year span is an amazing run up?

I would be interested to hear if you can find any index funds that can compare with that.

this is why the first part of a bull market is called the "stealth" phase, as most people still have no idea gold & silver have outperformed for so long.

nor why.
 
you don't think an average of 45% (gold) -60% (silver) per annum over a 10 year span is an amazing run up?

I would be interested to hear if you can find any index funds that can compare with that.

this is why the first part of a bull market is called the "stealth" phase, as most people still have no idea gold & silver have outperformed for so long.

nor why.

You can cherry-pick dates to eventually get any result you want. How about going back 20 or 30 or 40 years? I believe the market is the big winner in the long-term. Congrats if you timed the commodities bull market (bubble?) correctly, but you've been harping on gold and silver for awhile and they haven't done much of anything from their peak except drop. So when's the big run going to happen? How much have you lost over the last two years trading?
 
you don't think an average of 45% (gold) -60% (silver) per annum over a 10 year span is an amazing run up?

Not if, like you say, real inflation is raging out of control and the rise in gold prices is just a reflection of the doomed fiat dollar’s purchasing power. If inflation has really been that bad then all buying gold has done has allowed you to tread water. I mean, you have to redeem your gold in worthless fiat dollars, right?
 
You can cherry-pick dates to eventually get any result you want. How about going back 20 or 30 or 40 years?

how about further still? http://www.macro-investing-strategy.com/sp-500-in-gold/

Why Measure the S&P 500 in Gold?

The last 80 years has seen prolonged cycles of appreciation and depreciation of the S&P 500 in gold. Equities depreciate during times of economic difficulty, although this may not always be obvious when priced in dollars, and appreciate during times of growth. We have witnessed 3 shorter periods of equity depreciation in gold and 2 longer periods of equity outperformance.

Perhaps the most amazing fact is that the S&P 500 in gold stood at 1.1 ounces on October 1928, giving us a price higher than the ratio today. There has been a long stream of dividends since then, but the real price of the equity market is lower today than the level of 84 years ago



I believe the market is the big winner in the long-term. Congrats if you timed the commodities bull market (bubble?) correctly, but you've been harping on gold and silver for awhile and they haven't done much of anything from their peak except drop.

Im not claiming to have been in at the beginning, far from it, only since 2009. but this is still +75% in gold and about +90% in silver at today's prices. (I believe that's outpaced fiat devaluation SkepticPK ;) )

yes its been higher in between, and yes its down off the "peak" but by definition for there to be a peak, the price has to have been higher and pulled away? its not like this has never happened before or anything? :)

So when's the big run going to happen? How much have you lost over the last two years trading?

Im not sure what you mean by "the big run" really. I dont consider pushing through 2000, 2400 etc a big run, a mere +35-40% is nothing for gold, it has done this over and over again over the last 100 years.

and numbers are impossible to predict in any specific government digital fiat as it is all sinking at different rates.

there's a big run up going on in Gold-Yen right now if that counts?

SkepticPK said:
Not if, like you say, real inflation is raging out of control and the rise in gold prices is just a reflection of the doomed fiat dollar’s purchasing power. If inflation has really been that bad then all buying gold has done has allowed you to tread water.

not exactly no, it's cyclical. if you held over 100 years of ups and downs, you're closer to being correct, but obviously from the extremes of the ratios (DOW:GOLD , Gold:Housing etc) the movement is much more violent when it corrects.

ie there was an extreme high for the DOW / S&P before they started their cyclical bear markets in 2000, so selling equities and buying gold there produced +600% in a decade.

you've seen this before haven't you? the alternate inflation figure is simply inflation calculated the same way it was in our last big crisis (70's 80's)

17852505039d5b56f3.png


SkepticPK said:
I mean, you have to redeem your gold in worthless fiat dollars, right?

er, no. I get to choose whichever worthless fiat nonsense I prefer at the time, to quickly pass through into something of actual value.
 
Gold in Freefall?

Gold price suffers longest run of monthly falls in 16 years
The price of gold fell for the fifth month in a row in February, meaning that the precious metal has completed the longest run of monthly declines since 1996...

Gold lost 5pc of its value in February, as improving global economic outlooks lessened demand for the safe haven. Experts blamed a more buoyant stock market, and the growing confidence of both private and institutional investors

"What we are seeing just now is a lack of love from investors towards gold," Credit Suisse commodity analyst Karim Cherif said. "Why would you be in a market that doesn't pay any dividends and yield, and is most likely to underperform in an environment where economic indicators are seen improving?"
 
wanna take the $1000 or $2000 - (which is first) bet yet?

..earn yourself an easy 1 Oz silver coin? ;)

I believe that your earlier offer was $1200 or $2000.

You also suggested that a fall in the price of gold would happen if there was a stock market collapse. However, the recent negative trend in the gold price has happened while the stock market is doing pretty good.

Here's the relevant quote:
its possible in a collapse scenario, $1200 gold equals approx DOW 7-8k

do you want to place a bet that we see $2000 before $1200?
 
wanna take the $1000 or $2000 - (which is first) bet yet?

..earn yourself an easy 1 Oz silver coin? ;)

There's the rub - conflating defensive investing in precious metals with gambling.

And traders best keep in mind that gains in collectibles are taxed at higher rate than other investment vehicles - even those held more than a year are taxed at 28%. And traders/speculators don't often hold that long and may face tax rates of near 40%. That greatly inflates the price moves you need to come out ahead if you're attempting to capitalize on short term moves.

Admittedly, some of these gains can be "hidden" - unlike securities there's often no "paper trail" when you buy or sell silver or gold. But "not mentioning" those gains on your taxes is a felony.

Just sayin'.

But I do have a foolproof way of legally avoiding taxes on the metals you buy. Any guesses?
 
Last edited:
Any theories on why the price of platinum is about the same as gold right now (actually slightly less as I type this).

Historically platinum has usually been valued higher than gold, although sometimes for brief periods it has been less. If I were to be bullish on any precious metal right now I think it would be platinum for that reason. Also platinum is much rarer than gold.

Platinum has historically been an industrial, not a monetary metal. Its price tends to rise with greater demand for automobiles, as it and cheaper palladium are used in catalytic converters.

I don't really see explosive growth in auto sales, outside of possibly China.

On the other hand, the historical gold:silver ratio has been about 16:1, and it's currently 55:1, so that may imply some combination of lower gold prices and/or higher silver prices going forward. If I were hedging against the global debt/currency crisis, I would bet on silver, since it has a history of being both a monetary and industrial metal, although certainly industrial demand would be affected in any significant crisis. The drawback with silver is that it's expensive to store or ship in any significant volume, as I've found out the hard way. Not such a bad problem to have I guess.
 
Firstly lets address the pure propaganda the girlie without a clue regurgitated in the Telegraph, this is the crux of it, and just funny, my addition in red

Gold lost 5pc of its value in February, as [mainstream media dutifully parroted government and market-maker propaganda of] improving global economic outlooks [which supposedly] lessened demand for the safe haven

and definitely nothing to do with a fractional reserve paper gold trading system and unlimited fiat backing of naked shorts or anything.

http://www.gold.org/media/press_releases/archive/2013/02/gdt_q4_2012_pr/

Q4 2012 up 4% year-on-year as India, China and central banks drive demand. In value terms, gold demand in 2012 was US$236.4bn – an all-time high.

Gold demand in value terms for the final quarter of the year was 6% higher year-on-year at US$66.2bn, marking the highest ever Q4 total.

Global gold demand in Q4 2012 was 1,195.9 tonnes(t), up 4% on the same quarter in 2011. In Q4 2012, the average gold price reached a record level of US$1,721.8/oz, up 1% on the previous record average price in Q3 2011. The average price during 2012 was US$1,669.0/oz, up 6% from US$1,571.5/oz in 2011,

and lets put it into context. heres the chart over the approx period our blonde expert is discussing. you can clearly see that on the run from $317 at around the beginning of 2002 up to $1031 in 2007, every time price broke out through a new level, it always peaks, and pulls back to consolidate and test that same level from the topside, before breaking out north again when the time is next right.

but from $1226 all the way up to $1920 we didn't once re-test and consolidate above (on) the previous resistance, and have so far only re-tested the final 22% gains, and to do so now, has meant reaching oversold conditions on a par with the GFC.

analysis.png


I believe that your earlier offer was $1200 or $2000.

does it make a difference? ie you (or anyone) would take the bet at $1200 but not $1000?

open offer still stands. As I said once before (many pages ago) I'm not actually after taking your money, I'm interested in herd sentiment, but I have more than enough silver coins already (bought at around £12.00 GBP) to take this bet with anyone who wants it.

You also suggested that a fall in the price of gold would happen if there was a stock market collapse. However, the recent negative trend in the gold price has happened while the stock market is doing pretty good.

price most likely would fall on a risk off market swoon, and yes, it has hasn't it. gold has given back (re-tested) the final 22% of a 600+% run over this time and stocks are nearly back up to where they were at the beginning of the period.

plus I now believe we are at the extreme end of this range, the last time gold was this oversold (RSI) was at the depths of the panic in 2008. and the last time stock markets were this high (and overbought) were pre (and clueless about) GFC.

(btw, does this sound right to you in the current global environment?)

so anyway let's put on a "for fun" pair trade at this point. -I'll go long gold at $1571 and short S&P @ 1514.5.

do you want to "take the other side" of this? ie sell me your gold and buy my S&P shares? :)

FastEddieB said:
There's the rub - conflating defensive investing in precious metals with gambling.

not sure what you mean? but I know how keen you are to see what trading figures look like, so especially for you, not live, only on demo as time prevents me focusing properly until at least beg April yet, but been refining the system, and here's Feb's complete trading figures on a $100k demo account. (still looking good for go-live)

FastEddieB said:
And traders best keep in mind that gains in collectibles are taxed at higher rate than other investment vehicles - even those held more than a year are taxed at 28%. And traders/speculators don't often hold that long and may face tax rates of near 40%. That greatly inflates the price moves you need to come out ahead if you're attempting to capitalize on short term moves.

Admittedly, some of these gains can be "hidden" - unlike securities there's often no "paper trail" when you buy or sell silver or gold. But "not mentioning" those gains on your taxes is a felony.

Just sayin'.

But I do have a foolproof way of legally avoiding taxes on the metals you buy. Any guesses?

er, yes, not be American? thereby nothing you have written, nor any of their oppressive laws apply to me ;)
 
Last edited:
Any theories on why the price of platinum is about the same as gold right now (actually slightly less as I type this).

Historically platinum has usually been valued higher than gold, although sometimes for brief periods it has been less. If I were to be bullish on any precious metal right now I think it would be platinum for that reason. Also platinum is much rarer than gold.

I don't know much about platinum, except that I got stopped out of my first platinum trades by a single pip, before they ran about £60 profit :mad:

I only looked at it because Joe Terranova said on CNBC he was bullish as it broke through $1700 a couple weeks back, I had to short it then.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom