gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Gold's "safe haven" status returning?

massive divergence between risk assets and gold yesterday.

178524fc9e1818c9c7.png


comparative year to date performances, how quickly it turns once the free money splurge runs out (once again) and things get serious.

178524fc9e19f471d8.png
 
which is right, gold or stocks?

good article on ZH looking at the current disconnect between Gold & stocks

From early October of last year (Grand Plan and Global CB intervention) until the start of the LTRO program in Europe, Gold and Stocks (and Treasuries and the USD) all traded in sync with one another. Since the LTRO program, the equity market has generally been on its own in terms of belief.

20120606_goldstocks1_0.png


Simply put, equities have over-extended on hope that the relatively sterilized central banking juice in the last 7-9 months will create a self-fulfilling recovery (and so growth expectations have been repriced and multiples expanded).

However, gold remains muted for the same reason as the Fed has persuaded all that increasing its balance sheet duration is not devaluation. The re-emergence of European stress, China growth slowdowns, and the reality of a completely coupled US leaves market expectations for unsterilized QE which we think Gold has not priced in but stocks have.

those lines are going to hook up again, the only question is how
 
so which comes first, $1000 or $2000?

and do you want to bet me a 1 Oz silver coin? :)
 
so which comes first, $1000 or $2000?

and do you want to bet me a 1 Oz silver coin? :)

<tumbleweed> ..............................................</tumbleweed>

total lack of confidence in beliefs noted.

the beauty of this bet is it applies leverage to the winner, as if I win you have to pay (marginally) more for the coin in the future.

if you win, I will have not only lost the coin, but substantially more in the value of my metals holdings.

so I would have thought people would be queuing up to humiliate the silly goldbug in public?

so the question is, is this advance notice of public sentiment starting to shift?

deep down, or late at night when you cant sleep, do you secretly wonder if maybe, just maybe, the goldbugs are actually right? :eek:

my affiliate gold and silver sales site has gone ballistic with approximately another 100k (GBP) gold & silver bought through it in the last 3 months, and still accelerating at present.
 
Oh no, it's the "You don't believe it's a bubble unless you believe you can time it" -argument. That's so 1999.

lol. would you like to elaborate? I have supplied ample evidence as to why gold is not in a bubble throughout this thread.

not once, on not a single occasion, has anybody supplied even attempted to counter with any facts that they think "proves" bubble apart from:

"the price is too high" .. .."remember 1980"

..not once.

my position is that gold will be in a bubble one day, however before that can happen, we need first institutional money, and finally the stupid herd public to pile in, neither of those are happening yet, although institutions are just starting to turn.

the bubble will be fairly easy to recognise when it comes, just look for capitulation from all the previously smug bubble callers (here lol) and sell then.
 
lol. would you like to elaborate? I have supplied ample evidence as to why gold is not in a bubble throughout this thread.

not once, on not a single occasion, has anybody supplied even attempted to counter with any facts that they think "proves" bubble apart from:

"the price is too high" .. .."remember 1980"

..not once.

my position is that gold will be in a bubble one day, however before that can happen, we need first institutional money, and finally the stupid herd public to pile in, neither of those are happening yet, although institutions are just starting to turn.

the bubble will be fairly easy to recognise when it comes, just look for capitulation from all the previously smug bubble callers (here lol) and sell then.


Do you think the capitulation you refer to will be preceded by a sudden drop in the price of gold as the Euro falls apart and everybody rushes into the dollar?

Or will the POG take off without the foreplay?

Just wondering...
 
Do you think the capitulation you refer to will be preceded by a sudden drop in the price of gold as the Euro falls apart and everybody rushes into the dollar?

Or will the POG take off without the foreplay?

Just wondering...

well quite possibly a drop first, but today gold & bonds (not Spanish & Italian ones obviously) are grinding higher while stocks and risk drops, so it's debatable.

CNBC just had a piece about the proposed Gold-backed rescue plan for Europe.

wonder why theyre not using corn or lean hogs or other commodities to back the rescue of the world's economy lol
 
Last edited:
Money Morning Australia is predicting a big rise in the price of gold - not because of the European crisis but because of Chinese demand.

The US Federal Reserve – by keeping interest rates near zero, while simultaneously printing dollar bills – is making a concerted effort to inflate away its huge debt.

Who is the biggest holder of US debt?

China.

China holds $1.132 trillion in US Treasury securities.

This paper is depreciating in value by the day.

China's leaders know this and are preparing to defend against it by hoarding gold. They recently began encouraging Chinese citizens to do the same.

SOURCE.
 
Money Morning Australia is predicting a big rise in the price of gold - not because of the European crisis but because of Chinese demand.

That link is to a salesy squeeze page?

but China's gold acquisition is not a secret, they internalize all mine output from their own country and their buying is accelerating exponentially these last few months. I personally think they have massive buying orders in at 1525 and downwards, because the price bounces pretty hard whenever it gets down near there.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonc...the-chinese-buying-record-quantities-of-gold/

http://goldnews.bullionvault.com/gold-bullion-china-hong-kong-imports-060720121

the writing is very clearly on the wall, it's just amazing quite how many people cant read.
 
Do you think the capitulation you refer to will be preceded by a sudden drop in the price of gold as the Euro falls apart and everybody rushes into the dollar?

Or will the POG take off without the foreplay?

Just wondering...

The foreplay is required. There are numerous "safe havens" that people can still run to before turning to gold, which is the safe haven of absolute last resort. Even the UK, which is utterly incapable of paying off its sovereign debt, is currently enjoying low borrowing rates because even sterling looks attractive compared to what is going on in euroland. But that can all change very quickly once the eurobomb has actually gone off (which might be next week...) But even when the brown stuff really is hitting the fan then gold is going to be blown about in a random walk as various people who hold gold are forced to sell it to cover losses elsewhere. Only at the end of the endgame will the price of gold go truly parabolic - only when the masses finally realise that the US dollar can't be rescued either.
 
John Paulson on Gold: "We view gold as a currency, not a commodity," Paulson says. "Its importance as a currency will continue to increase as the major central banks around the world continue to print money."

He added that as the market keeps shuddering, demand for gold will stay high, and soon enough all of his depressed gold holdings should shoot up. He also thinks that "anyone in Greece, Italy, and France should pull all their money out of the banking system and purchase gold bars before the Continent collapses."

… John Paulson, the founder of Paulson & Co., one of the world’s largest hedge funds, in Business Week on June 28, 2012

gold-chart.png


image source, rehosted on my own site.

rally imminent? (and imminent on a weekly chart is obviously a matter of weeks)

178524ff4594ad15c0.png
 
Last edited:

What do those thick red and blue arrows mean? There are exactly 30 of them pointing up and 30 of them going down and yet the overall price has ascended in the interval you chose.

I also notice more than one reference to the €. Is your analysis contingent upon the stability of the € or its exchange rate with other currencies? Is the price of gold itself largely dependent upon the stability of major currencies?

My own analysis is that, if you bought all your gold in AUG 2006 at $539 and the price is now at $1,613 then you should sell it instead of buying more. You could even sell a mere 2/3rd of it, do something useful with the proceeds, and watch the charts risk-free.

Here's a free review of that genius John Paulson (who makes lots of money off gullible dupes):

JOHN PAULSON

“If you own one home, buy another one, and if you own two homes buy a third and lend your relatives the money to buy a home.”

In that article, written in SEP 2010, he claimed that the minimum price of gold would be $2,400/oz ($4,000/oz at the maximum) and that inflation would hit double digits. He has half a year for his predictions to come true.
 
The chart is voodoo as far as I am concerned. All I know is that the entire western monetary/banking/economic system is still completely ****** and that the problems are still getting worse, all over the world. We learned today that the entire British banking system has only been prevented from collapsing by systematic, fraudulent rigging of a key financial statistic by at least fifteen banks, with the knowledge of the UK authorities. There is no end in sight to the eurozone crisis. None of the powers that be are even trying to address the underlying fundamental problems. All they are doing is squabbling about how to stop the thing from collapsing next week, and increasingly having to spill the beans about others in order to protect their own backsides, or try to.

The chart is voodoo. Global macroeconomic and political reality says we are still heading towards some sort of massive financial hiatus - the process of financial collapse cannot now be reversed - it can only end in mass-default or crippling inflation. No other outcome is possible, and both will drive people towards buying land, gold and other non-perishable hard assets because their cash is rapidly evaporating.
 
What do those thick red and blue arrows mean? There are exactly 30 of them pointing up and 30 of them going down and yet the overall price has ascended in the interval you chose.

that chart is taken straight from my trading platform, MT4, only its normally on hourly or 15/5 min intervals for day trading purposes

the arrows are technical buy/sell signals, driven by the momentum on the bottom indicator. ie, all the time the momentum is rising in a particular direction, the previous arrow is in play.

when momentum in that direction peaks and rolls over (as visible by the red /green bars starting to reduce rather than further increase, the arrow appears.

the most important point of note on the chart is that the latest weekly bar has now gone blue (trend software), which on a weekly basis usually means a sustained move. it could of course go red again next week or the one after, but previous history shows the amount of times that happens, not so often.

I also notice more than one reference to the €. Is your analysis contingent upon the stability of the € or its exchange rate with other currencies?

no not really, although my most consistently profitable trade is arbing the USD / Eu gold price, so I am often short gold in $ terms and long in Eu or vice versa while the EURUSD does it's crazy gyrating.

Is the price of gold itself largely dependent upon the stability of major currencies?

lol, hardly. stability you say? which currencies are "stable" then?

http://buygoldsilver.org/gold-price-charts.html

so could you elaborate, ie "is the price [in what currency?] dependent on the "stability" of what other currencies?"

the Euro price of gold trades sort of inversely with the USD price, so if the Euro is rising, the Euro price of gold will obviously be falling, whilst the USD price tends to rise with the Euro (weakening Dollar)

but these are just daily oscillations, when we get gold movement (rather than currency weakness driving gold fluctuation) they spike (up or down) together.

My own analysis is that, if you bought all your gold in AUG 2006 at $539 and the price is now at $1,613 then you should sell it instead of buying more. You could even sell a mere 2/3rd of it, do something useful with the proceeds, and watch the charts risk-free.

I bought most of mine in 2009, at around the £600GBP per Oz mark and will not be swapping it for any devaluing paper, that would be dumb.

with regards to "doing something useful with the proceeds", you dont seem to get it at all stillicho, I am already.

everything I buy now, with money (gold) saved in 09/10 is at a 40-60% discount for me.

I expect this to continue, so that things I'm buying in 2014/5, with the money I recently saved (gold bought in the low 15's a few weeks back) will be discounted well into the future.

Here's a free review of that genius John Paulson (who makes lots of money off gullible dupes):

JOHN PAULSON

In that article, written in SEP 2010, he claimed that the minimum price of gold would be $2,400/oz ($4,000/oz at the maximum) and that inflation would hit double digits. He has half a year for his predictions to come true.

Im not so interested in his sky high predictions, everyone has one of those, this was the important part of that quote

"We view gold as a currency, not a commodity," Paulson says. "Its importance as a currency will continue to increase as the major central banks around the world continue to print money."

although even in that he is wrong, unlike any other currency, once again, gold is money, which can serve as a currency if required to, but unlike any other type of currency is not dependent on any particular regime, and will outlast all regimes.

so, definitely not just a commodity.
 
Last edited:
unlike any other currency, once again, gold is money, which can serve as a currency if required to
Anything can 'serve as a currency if required', but gold is not presently a currency. If someone tried to pay me in gold, I would refuse to accept it and ask for real money instead.

What could I do with it? No businesses around here accept payment in gold, the bank won't exchange it, I can't pay my bills or taxes with it. The only way I can get any currency out of it is to sell it to a gold merchant.

List of circulating currencies
 
Anything can 'serve as a currency if required', but gold is not presently a currency. If someone tried to pay me in gold, I would refuse to accept it and ask for real money instead.

What could I do with it? No businesses around here accept payment in gold, the bank won't exchange it, I can't pay my bills or taxes with it. The only way I can get any currency out of it is to sell it to a gold merchant.

List of circulating currencies

lol at argument by wiki. seriously? in this world of the wonderful interwebz I can exchange my money for government digital tokens and into goods in a matter of seconds.

I can also move it from Switz to HK to London in about the same amount of time. I can attach whatever government tax token denomination I like to it, at any point.

you might not be able to think or see outside of the official definitions given to you by your indoctrination training and wiki, but others can.

edit, and actually, at CB level, of course gold has always been, and continues to be money. if they do re-classify it to a Tier 1 CB asset, will this change your thoughts on your previous statement?
 
Last edited:
....

no not really, although my most consistently profitable trade is arbing the USD / Eu gold price, so I am often short gold in $ terms and long in Eu or vice versa while the EURUSD does it's crazy gyrating.

....

That's what I thought. You're not a gold bug. You're moving back and forth and gambling on currency:gold exchange values. It seems it's sometimes the €, sometimes the $, and sometimes the £. How many times do you lose on those gambles?

It's not the price of gold that's important to a currency trader but the exchange rates. In fact, you really shouldn't care what the per ounce price of gold is as long as there's volatility.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom