God, Perfection, and the problem of Evil.

If we are to gauge perfection we need to examine just what function was given to the celestial bodies and how they are performing that function. For example, one of the functions mentioned in Genesis is to provide mankind with a way to keep time. Has the moon served its purpose in that respect? Lunar calendars were made and time was kept satisfactorily. Then we shifted to the solar year of course.

Another function which the moon serves is to stabilize Earth's tilt. Without a moon our earth's tilt would wander as Mar's does and weather would be chaotic making human life
extremely difficult. The moon also provides tides which can be harnessed for energy. As for giving light, it provides what it was intended to provide-a lesser light.
 
If we are to gauge perfection we need to examine just what function was given to the celestial bodies and how they are performing that function. For example, one of the functions mentioned in Genesis is to provide mankind with a way to keep time. Has the moon served its purpose in that respect? Lunar calendars were made and time was kept satisfactorily. Then we shifted to the solar year of course.

Another function which the moon serves is to stabilize Earth's tilt. Without a moon our earth's tilt would wander as Mar's does and weather would be chaotic making human life
extremely difficult. The moon also provides tides which can be harnessed for energy. As for giving light, it provides what it was intended to provide-a lesser light.

Of all the stars in the universe, what are the odds that at least one would have a planetary system with such a planet?

This depression in the ground sure is comfy. It must have been made specifically for a puddle like me.
 
Your particular brand of theodicy fails to address the fact that granting one entity free-will can result in the loss of free-will for others. Such is the case when one human kills other humans.

But don't feel bad -- all theodicies fail in that respect.
At the risk of a derail, I find that a narrow approach to the topic. You seem to assume a zero sum game. Part of the whole process of exercising free will is in discovering the value of sacrifice, which is putting another on par with, or even ahead of, one's self. (See Matthew, greatest commandment. See also Romans, all will sin and fall short of the glory of God, etc. ) This sets up the option, a decision point, from which variable outcomes take place. As I've suggested previously, an all loving God loves even Satan, so how would God want Satan to be lonely? (Presuming Hell, of course.) Send him some company. ;)

Your short snippet there IMO overlooks, by use of a stovepipe, that exercise of free will is a process. It isn't an end in itself, nor a one time transaction.

Darth Rotor gets my point, I think.
When I can harvest it from the chaffe, I think I understand where you are coming from. That does not equal agreement, merely grasp. I am uncomfortable with a non atheist having the gall to tell an atheist what he or she thinks. Seems a bit presumptious, to me.

DR
 
Last edited:
At the risk of a derail, I find that a narrow approach to the topic. You seem to assume a zero sum game. Part of the whole process of exercising free will is in discovering the value of sacrifice, which is putting another on par with, or even ahead of, one's self. (See Matthew, greatest commandment. See also Romans, all will sin and fall short of the glory of God, etc. ) This sets up the option, a decision point, from which variable outcomes take place. As I've suggested previously, an all loving God loves even Satan, so how would God want Satan to be lonely? (Presuming Hell, of course.) Send him some company. ;)

Your short snippet there IMO overlooks, by use of a stovepipe, that exercise of free will is a process. It isn't an end in itself, nor a one time transaction.

What does this have to do with my argument?

Perhaps you didn't understand.

Suppose person X kills person Y.

Person X still has free will. Person Y does not. How does any theodicy account for that?

They don't. None of them. There are solutions, but none are acceptable to theists.

And one can't simply say "person Y is in the afterlife, where they continue to have free will" because it contradicts the whole idea of the necessity of free will in the worldly life. If the existence of free will necessiates the possibility of evil, then either evil is possible in the afterlife or there is not complete free will in the afterlife.

So... what is a theist to do? Stick their fingers in their ears, I suppose.
 
If we are to gauge perfection we need to examine just what function was given to the celestial bodies and how they are performing that function. For example, one of the functions mentioned in Genesis is to provide mankind with a way to keep time. Has the moon served its purpose in that respect? Lunar calendars were made and time was kept satisfactorily. Then we shifted to the solar year of course.

Another function which the moon serves is to stabilize Earth's tilt. Without a moon our earth's tilt would wander as Mar's does and weather would be chaotic making human life
extremely difficult. The moon also provides tides which can be harnessed for energy. As for giving light, it provides what it was intended to provide-a lesser light.

What if I told you one of the functions of religion, mentioned in sociology texts, is to provide mankind with a way to placate the masses and enforce dominance hierarchies?

Since it does serve that function so well, those texts must be right.
 
In fact, astronomers who search for earth-like planets have concluded that finding one necessitates finding one with the same moon to planet ratio as the Earth moon system among other things. Which of course drastically cuts down the number of planets that would qualify as earthlike. In our solar system such moon/planet density ratio isn't typical. Neither have the exoplanets discovered presented that ratio. Based on this some might conclude that it's an extremely rare anomaly. To atheists it all depends on chance interactions. To those believing in an ID it indicates an ID. To each his own I guess.
 
Last edited:
If we are to gauge perfection we need to examine just what function was given to the celestial bodies and how they are performing that function. For example, one of the functions mentioned in Genesis is to provide mankind with a way to keep time. Has the moon served its purpose in that respect? Lunar calendars were made and time was kept satisfactorily. Then we shifted to the solar year of course.


Um, if god made the celestial bodies to keep time, why did we have to abandon first the lunar and then the solar calendar due to their imperfections? Did god design timekeeping on a government contract or something? You would think he would have gotten right the first time.

Another function which the moon serves is to stabilize Earth's tilt. Without a moon our earth's tilt would wander as Mar's does and weather would be chaotic making human life extremely difficult. The moon also provides tides which can be harnessed for energy. As for giving light, it provides what it was intended to provide-a lesser light.


You do realize the tidal influences of the moon are also causing the length of the day to change and the orbit of the moon to get larger every year, yes? Not exactly stable over the long term, is it?
 
Did god design timekeeping on a government contract or something?
No, that was delegated to Satan, since the Devil is in the detail. ;) Satan is the patron anti-Saint of all bureaucracies. If I'm lyin' I'm dyin'
You would think he would have gotten right the first time.
He did, but since God is outside of time, he has no first time . . . which means God is a Virgin, no wait, he isn't, he did Mary, no that was the Holy Spirit . . . or is Jesus really the son of the Mailman, archangel Gabriel, and thus it's the Father, the Grandnephew, and the Holy Spirit? (Dizzzy, I am.)
You do realize the tidal influences of the moon are also causing the length of the day to change and the orbit of the moon to get larger every year, yes? Not exactly stable over the long term, is it?
Not to mention what it does to women and lycanthropes . . .

:duck:

DR
 
In fact, astronomers who search for earth-like planets have concluded that finding one necessitates finding one with the same moon to planet ratio as the Earth moon system among other things. Which of course drastically cuts down the number of planets that would qualify as earthlike. In our solar system such moon/planet density ratio isn't typical. Neither have the exoplanets discovered presented that ratio. Based on this some might conclude that it's an extremely rare anomaly. To atheists it all depends on chance interactions. To those believing in an ID it indicates an ID. To each his own I guess.

Nice try. It would be foolish to make assumptions based on the extremely limited data collected so far.

And most astronomers have already concluded that the ratio of "Earth like" planets is probably very small. What you are ignoring is the fact that the total number of planets is vast beyond comprehension. So the fact that at least one planet has the conditions we find on Earth is to be expected. There is nothing so remarkable that we have to conclude supernatural intervention. The odds of winning a state lottery are very small. But if I have billions of billions of tickets it would be remarkable if I didn't win.
 
clarification:

Instability in the long run is based on the atheistic assumption that things will continue as they are indefinitely with no Godly readjustments or interventions. From a believer's viewpoint such instability base on present conditions will be remedied during the restoration of all things. Furthermore, the long-run involves millions of years and according to prophecy we are living during end times. So the restoration takes place long before the godless atheistic predictions based on our present situation have a chance to kick in. So I guess that's another area where atheists and Christians differ.
 
And then there is the remarkably peculiar notion of the sun and moon being in precise opposition to one another. The mark of a Creator. Or would you have us believe in YET ANOTHER perfect coincidence?

What he's trying to get at here, in his hunky-dunky use-the-big-words sort of way is that during some solar eclipses the moon more-or-less exactly covers the sun. This is simply a coincidence, you have to get over it. The proof is in the fact that in a lot of cases the moon is farther away than it sometimes is, and sometimes closer. When its farther away, you get an annular eclipse where the moon doesn't cover the whole face of the sun but leaves a ring visible. In the other case, the fact is that if they exactly covered one another the time of totality would be vanishingly small, and the path very thin, but it usually is not, so most eclipses have the aspect that the moon is larger than the sun.

Furthermore, the moon was once much closer to the earth than it is now; in that case, total eclipses would have lasted appropriately longer, and there is no coincidence of which you speak. As Hokulele pointed out, the moon is receeding in its orbit, so eventually all eclipses will be annular at best. Again, the coincidence is that they are so nearly the same apparently size right now. I cannot appreciate how might indicate that there must have been a designer, unless you are trying to point out that such a designer has a trivial, easily amused frame of mind. I couldn't find my way to respect such a god. Read Sagan's Contact for what it means to have respect for a god.
 
Last edited:
Th Genesis account doesn't say that the moon's purpose was to provide us with eclipses. It says it was provided for ancient mankind to use it to keep time as well a lesser source of light during the night. Furthermore, total eclipses aren't visible from every geographical location.

BTW
I read Carl Sagan's Contact and don't recall what you just mentioned. Is that something that you concluded from the content of the story? If so, what part?
 
Th Genesis account doesn't say that the moon's purpose was to provide us with eclipses. It says it was provided for ancient mankind to use it to keep time as well a lesser source of light during the night.


Then why is it such a poor timekeeping device that it has been largely abandoned?



(Yeah, yeah, yeah. I know. I'm on ignore.)
 
clarification:

Instability in the long run is based on the atheistic assumption that things will continue as they are indefinitely with no Godly readjustments or interventions. From a believer's viewpoint such instability base on present conditions will be remedied during the restoration of all things.

So you're saying that God got it wrong the first time, but it's ok, because He'll be back to fix up the botch job that he made?
 
So you're saying that God got it wrong the first time, but it's ok, because He'll be back to fix up the botch job that he made?

He's still trying to decide if it's "creation 2.0" or just " service pack 3"
 
In fact, astronomers who search for earth-like planets have concluded that finding one necessitates finding one with the same moon to planet ratio as the Earth moon system among other things. Which of course drastically cuts down the number of planets that would qualify as earthlike. In our solar system such moon/planet density ratio isn't typical. Neither have the exoplanets discovered presented that ratio. Based on this some might conclude that it's an extremely rare anomaly. To atheists it all depends on chance interactions. To those believing in an ID it indicates an ID. To each his own I guess.

The range of exoplanets discovered to date aren't exactly a representative sample of the exoplanets that exist (or at least we have no reason to believe they are). A big planet close to the star it orbits (ie a non-Earthlike exoplanet) is a lot easier to detect than a small planet at a larger distance (ie an Earthlike exoplanet).
 
If we are to gauge perfection we need to examine just what function was given to the celestial bodies and how they are performing that function. For example, one of the functions mentioned in Genesis is to provide mankind with a way to keep time. Has the moon served its purpose in that respect? Lunar calendars were made and time was kept satisfactorily. Then we shifted to the solar year of course.


This is retro-fitting human use of lunar cycles into God's plan. It's like Kirk Cameron's banana - divinely bent to aid in eating. :boggled:

As pattern-seeking animals, humans recognised the pattern in the moon, sun and seasons and then used them to keep track of time, not the other way around. And Kirk Cameron, as a pattern-seeking animal, turns the banana around for easier eating, not the other way around.

If I'm falling over and grab onto a tree to support myself, it doesn't mean the tree was created for this purpose. It means I'm clever enough to avoid breaking my nose on the ground.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom