God, Perfection, and the problem of Evil.

ok
The standard argument I have shown is for atheists who use logic.

The argument for atheists who do not use logic is this :
There is no God, and I don't need a reason to think this.

The argument for atheists who try to use logic, but fail is this:
I see no evidence, therefor God does not exist.
(This would actually make you agnostic, as you would believe in God if you saw evidence)

....
However,
let me explain what I am saying in a thought experiment.

Suppose you were God. If you have ever tried to write a novel, you would have taken this position. Try and write a novel where everyone and everything in it is perfect. You will be forced to offset the perfections of some with their own imperfections or with the imperfections of others. If you did not, the novel would be less than authentic; less than perfect. We need shadow to show what light is. We need a pitch black night, so that the stars can really shine.

Darth Rotor gets my point, I think.

Now lets look at the notions of Heaven, purgatory, Earth, and Hell.
We use absolute terms to describe things that are more like gradients. Do you think Hitler and Mugabe are going to go to the same level of Hell? Surely Hitler will be destined to shovel the crap of the likes of Mugabe?

Now consider Heaven : Will Saint Paul, and John the Baptist be on the same cloud? Saint Paul started life as a sinner, so he would likely inhabit a less fluffy cloud than Cousin John.

Now consider Heaven for ordinary people : Will John Lennon be on cloud 9, whilst Paul McCartney is, perhaps on cloud 7? Or is it the other way?

So, yes their may be elements of evil in heaven. The likes of Saint Paul would still be prone to the occasional sin, but to call it 'sin' as in like SIN, is to miss the point of our imperfect language limiting what is being said.

But let me get back to the notion of 'God the Novelist'. The perfect storyline, would be less interesting if all the characters did was to sing hymns all day. And in the sense of God the infinite, all possible storylines exist. So there are worlds where you are exactly who you are, except you are left-handed instead of right-handed.

There are worlds of utter horror, that make our little soap opera seem like a bad dream - it all exists - everything - every possible thing. There are even illogical impossible contradictory worlds that just do not make the slightest bit of sense : these we often call dreams.

The real question which we all must face in the moral decisions that we make is :
What type of world do you WANT to live in?
In this particular world, all aspects of the material are governed by unmoveable laws of nature. This is God the Father. He will not forgive you if you fire a bullet at your friend's face. That bullet goes where-ever you aim it. You cannot undo the shot that has been fired in this world. We do, however have freedom of thought : the mind, which can alter psychological fate by forgiveness: God the Son. And there is always the unkown: The mystical unknown of the Holy ghost.

God, in one instance of the word, (it has infinite instances) - is the Universal consciousness. So each time you make a decision to hurt some person or creature, you make a decision to hurt yourself.

Now lets consider the notion of time. It would be good literary architecture if all these lives followed the timeline of mind in temporal progress. So that Mind follows each and every existence from flee to prophet. As Mind progresses, so evil recedes, and as our world improves we catch a glimpse of it all - each life, a mere paragraph in the Infinite Cosmic Novel. Until eventually we reach a state where evil in its worst forms, exists only in some half-forgotten past. Or, if you wish: a theme park.

Just like a bird need not fall, to actually fly, it must still have the possibility of falling, to remind it what flying actually is : Something more profound than merely floating in the sea with the common old fish.
 
If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

Your particular brand of theodicy fails to address the fact that granting one entity free-will can result in the loss of free-will for others. Such is the case when one human kills other humans.

But don't feel bad -- all theodicies fail in that respect.

Then again, why would you expect a theodicy to not fail in some way?
 
ok
The standard argument I have shown is for atheists who use logic.

...snip...

Just like a bird need not fall, to actually fly, it must still have the possibility of falling, to remind it what flying actually is : Something more profound than merely floating in the sea with the common old fish.

...still fails to account for one entity destroying the potential of another.

Keep trying!

(although it is futile)
 
So, yes their may be elements of evil in heaven. The likes of Saint Paul would still be prone to the occasional sin, but to call it 'sin' as in like SIN, is to miss the point of our imperfect language limiting what is being said.

Why don't you try a different word?

But let me get back to the notion of 'God the Novelist'. The perfect storyline, would be less interesting if all the characters did was to sing hymns all day. And in the sense of God the infinite, all possible storylines exist. So there are worlds where you are exactly who you are, except you are left-handed instead of right-handed.

Are there worlds where God doesn't exist, also? And if there are (as you suggest) is this one of them?

We do, however have freedom of thought : the mind, which can alter psychological fate by forgiveness: God the Son. And there is always the unkown: The mystical unknown of the Holy ghost.

What about schizophrenic people? People with OCD? Do they have freedom of thought?

Now lets consider the notion of time. It would be good literary architecture if all these lives followed the timeline of mind in temporal progress. So that Mind follows each and every existence from flee to prophet. As Mind progresses, so evil recedes, and as our world improves we catch a glimpse of it all - each life, a mere paragraph in the Infinite Cosmic Novel. Until eventually we reach a state where evil in its worst forms, exists only in some half-forgotten past. Or, if you wish: a theme park.

Are we still talking about the Biblical God? It's starting to sound New Age and Quantum Mechanical all at once.
 
Why is the meaning of "atheist" and "main argument" so difficult for so many to understand? I read this forum and am constantly surprised that so many theists find those two simple things beyond the scope of their understanding. I am not the brightest person around here but even I have no trouble understanding those two things.

Hokulele summed it up beautifully.

Maybe because actual atheist organizations define atheism completely different than everyone here?
 
Are we still talking about the Biblical God? It's starting to sound New Age and Quantum Mechanical all at once.
I'd certainly like to see Bible citations for, eh, any of the claims in that post.
 
Maybe because actual atheist organizations define atheism completely different than everyone here?

Thanks, that could well be the case, then. I'll check into that. I never think of atheism as "organized" so that did not enter into my thinking.

Still, even here on this forum some can explain until they are exhausted that atheism is a "lack of belief in gods" and many don't seem to grasp that.
 
ok
The standard argument I have shown is for atheists who use logic.

The argument for atheists who do not use logic is this :
There is no God, and I don't need a reason to think this.
Goodness, you sure like to present straw men arguments. That is typical of people who hold an indefensible belief such as god beliefs. Any chance you might look at the actual arguments rather than the straw ones you set up so as to look fierce tearing down?

The standard arguments for atheists' conclusions there are no gods are several:
  • Despite an extensive search for evidence of the the existence of gods, no evidence can be found.
  • The vast multitude of claims god believers make about their gods can be shown to be invalid, for example, prayer has no effect other than a placebo effect when you actually test it.
  • The evidence overwhelmingly supports the conclusion god beliefs are the result of human imagination, not the result of actual human encounters or interactions with real gods.
God believers disbelieve all god beliefs except their own then can't understand why atheists disbelieve all god beliefs including the believer's own.
 
Your arguments are inane and childish.
Your understanding of the topic of atheism is embarrassing.
Whatever bible study pamphlet or TBN show you got them from does a fine job of insulting those few Christian thinkers who really try to use intelligent discussion.
Atheists don’t believe in your silly myths.
 
Thanks, that could well be the case, then. I'll check into that. I never think of atheism as "organized" so that did not enter into my thinking.

Still, even here on this forum some can explain until they are exhausted that atheism is a "lack of belief in gods" and many don't seem to grasp that.
Granted we go round and round on this one but I do believe you are describing agnostics or as some have referred to themselves, atheist agnostics or something like that.

People with my view believe the evidence strongly supports the conclusion god beliefs are based on human imagination. As such, agnosticism or as you put it, simply lacking a belief in gods, ignores this elephant in the room to varying extents.

In other words, one can say there is no evidence for gods and leave it at that. Or one can say the evidence supports all god beliefs as belief in myths. I go with the latter.
 
Last edited:
Your arguments are inane and childish.
Your understanding of the topic of atheism is embarrassing.
Whatever bible study pamphlet or TBN show you got them from does a fine job of insulting those few Christian thinkers who really try to use intelligent discussion.
Atheists don’t believe in your silly myths.
It would help if you identified who you were addressing here.
 
Considering how highly Atheists praise intelligence, I wonder why they criticize God so much.
Because it's blindingly obvious that atheists secretly hate God, despite professing not to believe in him. That's one of the basic tenets of atheism.

If God created the entire Universe, all of existence, then he is MUCH MUCH MUCH more intelligent than we are, and he created morality in the first place.
You're just assunotming all this. Never assunotme because it makes an ASS out of U, NOT ME. :rolleyes:

Why is their suffering?
Who else's suffering would it be?

I don't know. I don't like it, and I wonder why God allows it. If you go off the thesis that God is the ultimate intelligence, as well as being the ultimate Good, then you have to trust that in the end what he does is Good no matter how we view it.
But in Isaiah 29:14 God is said to destroy intelligence and the wisdom of the wise. Since stupidity is the antithesis to intelligence, then God must be stupidity. There you have it, solid proof, and I say this with a complete and utter disregard for context.

We are like a sociopath that has no true understanding of what it is to be moral and good. If a sociopath murders someone they are punished for their crimes. In this way human beings are punished by God for their crimes.
So we can't understand what it means to be moral and good, yet we're supposed to know what it means that God is the ultimate good. Right, gotcha.

Because we are inherently corrupted by sin, just as a sociopath is warped by their genetics, we don't fully understand our condition, we see it from our own perspective.
Not me, I'm lucky enough to be corrupted by csc.

God creates free will, and free will leads to disobeying God. Disobeying God = sin. Is God evil for allowing people to make their own decisions? I kind of view it as wrong to create people with free will knowing that you will send some of them to eternal punishment. I have no Idea why God would do such a thing, but then, I'm not God.
Well, mum's the word, but Hell is where the real party is going to be. All the skeptics, freethinkers, and cool people are going to end up there. I even have a lakeside apartment that comes complete with air conditioning, because that's what I believe.

I hope one day to understand all of this, why it all happened this way, but I know I won't find out in this lifetime.

Consider the idea that our perspective are so limited by our short lifespans and lack of information that we cannot make a true moral assessment of God's works.
Glad your beliefs give you so much to look forward to.
 
ok
The standard argument I have shown is for atheists who use logic.

The argument for atheists who do not use logic is this :
There is no God, and I don't need a reason to think this.

The argument for atheists who try to use logic, but fail is this:
I see no evidence, therefor God does not exist.
(This would actually make you agnostic, as you would believe in God if you

Please stop trying to make up your own definitions for words.

Atheism means 'without theism' as in 'not a theist'

Agnostic means 'without knowledge' as in 'I don't know enough to say either way.'

I know enough to make my choice. My choice is that there is no god. That makes me atheist.

Just because I am not ABSOLUTELY certain does not mean I am uncertain in the way an agnostic is.

Please stop projecting your need for absolute certainty onto me, I don't need to be absolutely certain to be certain.

I don't believe in dragons. I am adragonist. If there ever was some evidence for dragons I would change my mind. But from the evidence I have seen, I am certain that there is no dragons. This does not make me agnostic about dragons.

In order to be agnostic about dragons, I would have to have no knowledge (or not enough) about dragons, and thus be unable to make a decision about their existence. It would be a non-committal, can't say yes or no.

So again, absolute belief with no possibility of change may be required for your beliefs, but it isn't for mine. Please realize that most peoples 'beliefs' aren't impossible to change and set in stone as yours are.
 
Last edited:
Maybe because actual atheist organizations define atheism completely different than everyone here?


And actual Christian organizations define Christianity differently from each other.

And actual Muslim organizations define Islam differently from each other.

And actual Buddhist organizations define Buddhism differently from each other.

And so on.

And so on.

And so on.

Blah, it is attitudes such as Malerin's that is why when pressed for details, I will call myself an ignostic. Show me a god concept that is coherent, logical, and testable, and I will be interested. Until then, meh.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignosticism
 
And actual Christian organizations define Christianity differently from each other.

And actual Muslim organizations define Islam differently from each other.

And actual Buddhist organizations define Buddhism differently from each other.

And so on.

And so on.

And so on.

Blah, it is attitudes such as Malerin's that is why when pressed for details, I will call myself an ignostic. Show me a god concept that is coherent, logical, and testable, and I will be interested. Until then, meh.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignosticism

What "attitude" did I display? I merely pointed out that confusion about the term "atheist" can partly be attributed to an atheist organization that defines "atheism":

"Atheism is a doctrine that states that nothing exists but natural phenomena (matter), that thought is a property or function of matter, and that death irreversibly and totally terminates individual organic units. This definition means that there are no forces, phenomena, or entities which exist outside of or apart from physical nature, or which transcend nature, or are “super” natural, nor can there be. Humankind is on its own."

http://www.atheists.org/Atheism/

There are two organizations on the first Google page on "Atheism". One defines atheism in the standard sense (lack of belief in God(s)). The other doesn't.
 
I hope one day to understand all of this, why it all happened this way, but I know I won't find out in this lifetime.

God refuses to give evidence of his existence (again usually on the alter of free will, except for those people who he's given evidence to I guess it doesn't impact their free will). God goes on and on for 66 books about stuff like who you can sleep with and how many cubits the temple should be, but doesn't give any stunning moral revelations that hadn't already been worked out by other cultures. Doesn't answer the REALLY hard questions that he knew would come up.

So basically it all boils down to God saying "Trust me, I'm right"? That's not very compelling, and certainly doesn't say why I should choose God over another deity.

ok
The standard argument I have shown is for atheists who use logic.

Yet you don't respond to the posts that question your logic.

The argument for atheists who try to use logic, but fail is this:
I see no evidence, therefor God does not exist.
(This would actually make you agnostic, as you would believe in God if you saw evidence)

See Third Eye Blind's post, you've got your definitions messed up.

Suppose you were God. If you have ever tried to write a novel, you would have taken this position. Try and write a novel where everyone and everything in it is perfect. You will be forced to offset the perfections of some with their own imperfections or with the imperfections of others. If you did not, the novel would be less than authentic; less than perfect. We need shadow to show what light is. We need a pitch black night, so that the stars can really shine.

As I asked once before, who created this system of dichotomies that God must adhere to? If God is constrained then something must exist to constrain Him. Who created those constraints?

And you don't need shadow to show what light is. If you were a 2 dimensional being living on the inside of a 3 dimensional sphere with a light at the center, there's no such thing as shadow, just light. If I can easily make up a situation where there's no dichotomy necessary, a vastly more intelligent being should be able to do the same with morality and free will.

As has been pointed out, being bound by gravity doesn't remove my free will, I cannot fly. Being incapable of sinning would not remove my free will, I'd just be unable to sin. Even God intervening directly in the lives of people so to them there is no question He exists doesn't remove their free will!

But let me get back to the notion of 'God the Novelist'. The perfect storyline, would be less interesting if all the characters did was to sing hymns all day.

Who created "interesting"? Couldn't have been the novelist because the novelist is writing to some value of interesting, if he created interesting he could set maximum interesting to be singing hymns all day.

And in the sense of God the infinite, all possible storylines exist. So there are worlds where you are exactly who you are, except you are left-handed instead of right-handed.

Which scripture is that? Or if you're allowed to make stuff up, everyone else is too don't you think?

The real question which we all must face in the moral decisions that we make is :
What type of world do you WANT to live in?
In this particular world, all aspects of the material are governed by unmoveable laws of nature. This is God the Father. He will not forgive you if you fire a bullet at your friend's face. That bullet goes where-ever you aim it. You cannot undo the shot that has been fired in this world.

Yes he will forgive you, or so the Bible says. You can lead a moral life, do good, love your kids, love your homosexual husband and die but you are living in sin and if you didn't repent and accept Jesus then you go to hell, whereas you fire a bullet into a little girl's face, chop her up into tiny pieces and bury her in a plastic bag, if you repent on your way to the chair you go to heaven.

Not a world I want to live in. I don't think we can pick and choose which worlds we get to live in though.
 
There are two organizations on the first Google page on "Atheism". One defines atheism in the standard sense (lack of belief in God(s)). The other doesn't.

That would certainly be confusing, that definition you posted doesn't mention God at all, that sounds more like philosophical materialism, not atheism.
 
Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

So, prior to God's creation of anything, when it was just God and the Void, there was evil as well as good in God's nature. God is both good and evil.
 
The argument for atheists who try to use logic, but fail is this:
I see no evidence, therefor God does not exist.
(This would actually make you agnostic, as you would believe in God if you saw evidence)
If I saw evidence for the existence of leprechauns or dragons I would believe in them too.

I am agnostic regarding extraterrestrial life: I have not seen evidence of extraterrestrial life, but I know that life exists on Earth. I consider the possibility of life on another world to be reasonable enough to call myself agnostic in the face of the lack of evidence for it.

On the other hand, gods are like leprechauns and dragons: I have never seen any evidence that they exist at all. I consider the possibility that they do exist to be so remote that I have no trouble calling myself an atheist.
 
What "attitude" did I display?


The attitude that because there are multiple definitions of the term "atheist", either the one I use is invalid or else they all are. In addition, your behavior in an earlier thread made it fairly clear that you were more interested in painting atheists with a brush of your own devising rather than accepting that there is as much variety among self-proclaimed atheists as there is among theists.

Hence, my claim to be an ignostic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom