WaterBreather
Thinker
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2008
- Messages
- 130
ok
The standard argument I have shown is for atheists who use logic.
The argument for atheists who do not use logic is this :
There is no God, and I don't need a reason to think this.
The argument for atheists who try to use logic, but fail is this:
I see no evidence, therefor God does not exist.
(This would actually make you agnostic, as you would believe in God if you saw evidence)
....
However,
let me explain what I am saying in a thought experiment.
Suppose you were God. If you have ever tried to write a novel, you would have taken this position. Try and write a novel where everyone and everything in it is perfect. You will be forced to offset the perfections of some with their own imperfections or with the imperfections of others. If you did not, the novel would be less than authentic; less than perfect. We need shadow to show what light is. We need a pitch black night, so that the stars can really shine.
Darth Rotor gets my point, I think.
Now lets look at the notions of Heaven, purgatory, Earth, and Hell.
We use absolute terms to describe things that are more like gradients. Do you think Hitler and Mugabe are going to go to the same level of Hell? Surely Hitler will be destined to shovel the crap of the likes of Mugabe?
Now consider Heaven : Will Saint Paul, and John the Baptist be on the same cloud? Saint Paul started life as a sinner, so he would likely inhabit a less fluffy cloud than Cousin John.
Now consider Heaven for ordinary people : Will John Lennon be on cloud 9, whilst Paul McCartney is, perhaps on cloud 7? Or is it the other way?
So, yes their may be elements of evil in heaven. The likes of Saint Paul would still be prone to the occasional sin, but to call it 'sin' as in like SIN, is to miss the point of our imperfect language limiting what is being said.
But let me get back to the notion of 'God the Novelist'. The perfect storyline, would be less interesting if all the characters did was to sing hymns all day. And in the sense of God the infinite, all possible storylines exist. So there are worlds where you are exactly who you are, except you are left-handed instead of right-handed.
There are worlds of utter horror, that make our little soap opera seem like a bad dream - it all exists - everything - every possible thing. There are even illogical impossible contradictory worlds that just do not make the slightest bit of sense : these we often call dreams.
The real question which we all must face in the moral decisions that we make is :
What type of world do you WANT to live in?
In this particular world, all aspects of the material are governed by unmoveable laws of nature. This is God the Father. He will not forgive you if you fire a bullet at your friend's face. That bullet goes where-ever you aim it. You cannot undo the shot that has been fired in this world. We do, however have freedom of thought : the mind, which can alter psychological fate by forgiveness: God the Son. And there is always the unkown: The mystical unknown of the Holy ghost.
God, in one instance of the word, (it has infinite instances) - is the Universal consciousness. So each time you make a decision to hurt some person or creature, you make a decision to hurt yourself.
Now lets consider the notion of time. It would be good literary architecture if all these lives followed the timeline of mind in temporal progress. So that Mind follows each and every existence from flee to prophet. As Mind progresses, so evil recedes, and as our world improves we catch a glimpse of it all - each life, a mere paragraph in the Infinite Cosmic Novel. Until eventually we reach a state where evil in its worst forms, exists only in some half-forgotten past. Or, if you wish: a theme park.
Just like a bird need not fall, to actually fly, it must still have the possibility of falling, to remind it what flying actually is : Something more profound than merely floating in the sea with the common old fish.
The standard argument I have shown is for atheists who use logic.
The argument for atheists who do not use logic is this :
There is no God, and I don't need a reason to think this.
The argument for atheists who try to use logic, but fail is this:
I see no evidence, therefor God does not exist.
(This would actually make you agnostic, as you would believe in God if you saw evidence)
....
However,
let me explain what I am saying in a thought experiment.
Suppose you were God. If you have ever tried to write a novel, you would have taken this position. Try and write a novel where everyone and everything in it is perfect. You will be forced to offset the perfections of some with their own imperfections or with the imperfections of others. If you did not, the novel would be less than authentic; less than perfect. We need shadow to show what light is. We need a pitch black night, so that the stars can really shine.
Darth Rotor gets my point, I think.
Now lets look at the notions of Heaven, purgatory, Earth, and Hell.
We use absolute terms to describe things that are more like gradients. Do you think Hitler and Mugabe are going to go to the same level of Hell? Surely Hitler will be destined to shovel the crap of the likes of Mugabe?
Now consider Heaven : Will Saint Paul, and John the Baptist be on the same cloud? Saint Paul started life as a sinner, so he would likely inhabit a less fluffy cloud than Cousin John.
Now consider Heaven for ordinary people : Will John Lennon be on cloud 9, whilst Paul McCartney is, perhaps on cloud 7? Or is it the other way?
So, yes their may be elements of evil in heaven. The likes of Saint Paul would still be prone to the occasional sin, but to call it 'sin' as in like SIN, is to miss the point of our imperfect language limiting what is being said.
But let me get back to the notion of 'God the Novelist'. The perfect storyline, would be less interesting if all the characters did was to sing hymns all day. And in the sense of God the infinite, all possible storylines exist. So there are worlds where you are exactly who you are, except you are left-handed instead of right-handed.
There are worlds of utter horror, that make our little soap opera seem like a bad dream - it all exists - everything - every possible thing. There are even illogical impossible contradictory worlds that just do not make the slightest bit of sense : these we often call dreams.
The real question which we all must face in the moral decisions that we make is :
What type of world do you WANT to live in?
In this particular world, all aspects of the material are governed by unmoveable laws of nature. This is God the Father. He will not forgive you if you fire a bullet at your friend's face. That bullet goes where-ever you aim it. You cannot undo the shot that has been fired in this world. We do, however have freedom of thought : the mind, which can alter psychological fate by forgiveness: God the Son. And there is always the unkown: The mystical unknown of the Holy ghost.
God, in one instance of the word, (it has infinite instances) - is the Universal consciousness. So each time you make a decision to hurt some person or creature, you make a decision to hurt yourself.
Now lets consider the notion of time. It would be good literary architecture if all these lives followed the timeline of mind in temporal progress. So that Mind follows each and every existence from flee to prophet. As Mind progresses, so evil recedes, and as our world improves we catch a glimpse of it all - each life, a mere paragraph in the Infinite Cosmic Novel. Until eventually we reach a state where evil in its worst forms, exists only in some half-forgotten past. Or, if you wish: a theme park.
Just like a bird need not fall, to actually fly, it must still have the possibility of falling, to remind it what flying actually is : Something more profound than merely floating in the sea with the common old fish.