God, Perfection, and the problem of Evil.

Isn't perfection a subjective judgement anyway?

No, but it's a relative one. While the "perfect" ice cream cone to you may be different to you on different days, there are definitely "perfect" ways to solve various problems...if you define "perfect" as "most efficiently by some criteria".

"Perfect" for a god apparently involves creating lowly mortals and heaving them into a world where they can torture and murder and terrorize each other. :rolleyes:
 
If you want to worship a God that allows children to starve, die of disease, die of natural disasters then knock yourself out. The human race has police to try to fight crime which is evil and if God existed he could have a similar cosmic police force at his disposal.
 
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

You are assuming a perfect universe.

If god is all-powerful, why couldn't he arrange things so that there is good without evil?

If he can't, then he's not all-powerful.
If he can but chooses not to, then he's not all-good.

All-powerful, all-good, all-knowing. Pick any two. You can't have it all.
 
Here's something you didn't address in your OP:

Let's say I concede that "God" is a perfect being/entity/whatever, where "perfect" is all-encompassing and thus includes imperfection - i.e. evil. The question remains...

Why would I want to worship such a malevolent entity?

Proposing that God is evil (as well as everything else that "perfection" encompasses) is not really the best way to "refute" atheism, nor is it in any way evidence for the existence of the big bad/good, invisible everything/nothing or whatever it is that you call "God".
 
Considering how highly Atheists praise intelligence, I wonder why they criticize God so much.

Strawman.

If God created the entire Universe, all of existence, then he is MUCH MUCH MUCH more intelligent than we are, and he created morality in the first place.

Groundless assumption. The complexity of the uniserve may merely be the inevtiable emergent property of simple impersonal forces, which god may or may not have been involved it. I can free an ice cube without having the slightest comprehension of how heat and temperature are related, how hydrogen bonds influence to shape of ice cystals, or any of the physical forces involved.

Why is their suffering? I don't know. I don't like it, and I wonder why God allows it. If you go off the thesis that God is the ultimate intelligence, as well as being the ultimate Good, then you have to trust that in the end what he does is Good no matter how we view it.

No. If you accept that god is infinitely intelligent it does not follow that suffering is good. That would be predicated on the argument that god is both infinitely intelligent and infinitely good, and that evil exists - but only nessecary evil, which is a peculiar restriction to make on an infinitely powerful deity.

We are like a sociopath that has no true understanding of what it is to be moral and good. If a sociopath murders someone they are punished for their crimes. In this way human beings are punished by God for their crimes.

Forever? An eternity of suffering, from an allegedly forgiving god?

Because we are inherently corrupted by sin, just as a sociopath is warped by their genetics, we don't fully understand our condition, we see it from our own perspective.

What sin? Where your evidence of sin, and if your special friend made humans and sin, then isn't he responsible? If we're broken, we require fixing, not torment.

God creates free will, and free will leads to disobeying God. Disobeying God = sin. Is God evil for allowing people to make their own decisions? I kind of view it as wrong to create people with free will knowing that you will send some of them to eternal punishment. I have no Idea why God would do such a thing, but then, I'm not God.

Special pleading, the very definition of special pleading, actually. An infinitely powerful and benevolent god should be able to make anything he does pleasant or acceptable - this does not invalidate free will any more than gravity does.

I hope one day to understand all of this, why it all happened this way, but I know I won't find out in this lifetime.

Consider the idea that our perspective are so limited by our short lifespans and lack of information that we cannot make a true moral assessment of God's works.

And yet Christianity asks us to do that very thing. It asks us to accept god entirely, submit to his will and his judgement, and accept his commandments.

If you ask me to do what you say because you claim to be the lord of the universe and the ultimate authority on good and evil, you're asking us to judge your moral character. Making a comparison between a tender hearted atheist with limited knowledge and power who helps those less fortunate, and a god who punishes humanity with sin and torment forever because two people who didn't know right from wrong did something they weren't supposed to is something any person with a brain will inevitably do.

Fortunately, your imaginary friend doesn't exist.
 
Last edited:
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!

Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.

In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.

Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.

Do not make the error of just repeating the standard atheist arguments which are already in the text, and which have already been countered. Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.
Philosophical bilge. Words mean only what we define - our definitions have no reality beyond that of our mimds. Nothing in that compels a philosophical answer that has any real world value. In other words, philosophy cannot prove or disprove the existence of any kind of god-thing.
 
...snippety...What sin? Where your evidence of sin, and if your special friend made humans and sin, then isn't he responsible? If we're broken, we require fixing, not torment. ...snip snip...

I think the Christian answer here would be that acceptance of Jesus as your saviour would be the "fix"; of course, there's still the question of why we'd be made "broken" to start with, and why punish us with eternal torment for something that part of God's design to begin with...
 
I think the Christian answer here would be that acceptance of Jesus as your saviour would be the "fix"; of course, there's still the question of why we'd be made "broken" to start with, and why punish us with eternal torment for something that part of God's design to begin with...

If I'm so broken and sinful that I need Jesus, how can failing to accept Jesus be my fault? If god made us sinful and messed up, and we don't recognize that and accept his blackmail offer we deserve to burn in hell forever?

If god is like a parental figure who knows best and whom we disobey at our peril, how is punishing us forever for not accepting his silly offer fair? I can't punish a toddler with a "time out" for longer than a minute.
 
...

EDIT: Oops, deleted this somehow. So heaven is not perfect and is constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence? Or is there evil in heaven?
...
.
Based on the number of people who have been evil in this life, and have said they're going to heaven, there certainly has to be evil in heaven! :)
 
Considering how highly Atheists praise intelligence, I wonder why they criticize God so much.
...
,
Atheists aren't criticizing god, there isn't/aren't any.
What they rail about is the believers who pound the idea of the "cosmic all" on the unbelievers.
 
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!

Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.

In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.

Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.

Do not make the error of just repeating the standard atheist arguments which are already in the text, and which have already been countered. Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.

I can understand the notion that for man to have freewill man needs to be capable of evil, but I think your argument only works if you define evil narrowly into the context suffering produced by man, and also only if you apply it so broadly that it has no useful context.

But man is not the sole creator of evil. Why, for example, does leprosy need to be? If it is logical that up needs to be to allow down to be, and people need to be able to run red lights and run over pedestrians in the crosswalk to appreciate the goodness of not being run over in the crosswalk (the example is already starting to break down when applied to a useful context) what type of goodness needs leprosy to rot away people’s flesh?

I do not think your argument is convincing if it is ever applied to a real situation in the material world.

Or am I missing something WaterBreather? Could you explain to me the “up” that counters the “down” of birth defects, diseases that slowly kill their hosts is nasty ways, or the fate of infants eaten by rats?

It seems to me that there is a lot of evil in this world that befalls mankind, but it is not directly attributable to the actions of man, but to the nature of the universe, and that puts a loving, all powerful, all knowing God back on the hot seat.
 
If I'm so broken and sinful that I need Jesus, how can failing to accept Jesus be my fault? If god made us sinful and messed up, and we don't recognize that and accept his blackmail offer we deserve to burn in hell forever?

If god is like a parental figure who knows best and whom we disobey at our peril, how is punishing us forever for not accepting his silly offer fair? I can't punish a toddler with a "time out" for longer than a minute.

Yep, agreed; all very good questions.
 
What about Paradise ? Isn't it supposed to be a place with no Evil and where everything is Perfect ?
No, that's Jose's Tequilla bar, a mile from my house.
Why not skipping the earthly part and send everyone to Paradise directly ?
More interesting the way it is.
And from there you got access to Earth, if you wish to experiment Evil and exercise free will, like some kind of theme park and after suffering for some time you go back to Paradise.
Hell, why not just drive a car without learning how first?
You still have the potential for evil without being a cruel sadist for letting billions of people struggle daily with poverty, hunger, debilating diseases, wars, atrocities...
The struggle is part of the human experience. Without it, what is there to overcome?

DR
 
The Paradox of God

One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.

In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.

Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.
Your chosen definition of perfection is interesting.
Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.
If I hold my piece, I'll get hair on the palm of my hands.

My opinion: trying to limit God within the bounds of human perfection may not be a suitable fit.

DR
 
In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.

Why don´t you go on to dawkins supreme stinker.
You could also pick two out of 3, or an evil god.

There are no gods, but as long as you keep your religion to yourself I will not care.
Downside is that religions can´t keep to themselfes and we have to actively keep the supersticius drivel away from decisionmaking
 
You still have the potential for evil without being a cruel sadist for letting billions of people struggle daily with poverty, hunger, debilating diseases, wars, atrocities...
The struggle is part of the human experience. Without it, what is there to overcome?
So your life isn't fullfilled until you or a loved one has experienced leukemia, a war, a large natural disaster or starvation?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom