God, Perfection, and the problem of Evil.

WaterBreather

Thinker
Joined
Nov 15, 2008
Messages
130
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!

Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.

In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.

Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.

Do not make the error of just repeating the standard atheist arguments which are already in the text, and which have already been countered. Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.
 
The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

No. The standard argument from atheists is that gods do not exist. Period

Aaah, says the atheist, but then God is not perfect!

No. Atheist say gods don't exist

Do not make the error of just repeating the standard atheist arguments which are already in the text, and which have already been countered. Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.

Since you don't seem to understand what an atheist is I can't see how you could have counted any arguement.
 
Why is the meaning of "atheist" and "main argument" so difficult for so many to understand? I read this forum and am constantly surprised that so many theists find those two simple things beyond the scope of their understanding. I am not the brightest person around here but even I have no trouble understanding those two things.

Hokulele summed it up beautifully.
 
Last edited:
Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

Then the creator is constrained by properties that exist outside the creator's control. Who created those constraints? Who created the good / evil dichotomy.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

EDIT: Oops, deleted this somehow. So heaven is not perfect and is constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence? Or is there evil in heaven?

One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

The potential for a third opposite of good and evil exists, it does not, the Universe is not all it could be, therefore I can say God doesn't exist? (I wouldn't say that, just following the same lines of logic here).
 
Last edited:
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

I would say a better argument is, why is there injustice. Eternity in hell can rarely be justified.

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

I guess we can't have God's existence without his inexistence either.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

How do you know whether we have free will or not?

Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!

Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

How do you know the the universe is not limited?

So is God complete or incomplete? And is God the Universe or not?

We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.

So God is perfect because God is complete, but God is imperfect because perfection requires imperfection?

So aren't you admitting that God is imperfect, because perfection requires imperfection?

In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.

Right, so you have just stated that God is both perfect and imperfect.

Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.

Aren't you saying that God could be Evil and still be perfect, as long as there is good in the world?
 
Why does god have to be perfect? Does it say this in the bible somewhere? I don't get it.

I think it's just the result of thousands of years of one-uping? 'My god is strong' 'my god is stronger' 'my god is infinitely strong!' And 'my god is smart' 'my god is smarter' 'my god is infinitely smart!' And the same for size, how much he loves you, and all other qualities.

Maybe Christians (i don't know much about other gods so I name that one) should realize that their god doesn't make any sense, and change him so that he does.
 
Considering how highly Atheists praise intelligence, I wonder why they criticize God so much. If God created the entire Universe, all of existence, then he is MUCH MUCH MUCH more intelligent than we are, and he created morality in the first place.

Why is their suffering? I don't know. I don't like it, and I wonder why God allows it. If you go off the thesis that God is the ultimate intelligence, as well as being the ultimate Good, then you have to trust that in the end what he does is Good no matter how we view it.

We are like a sociopath that has no true understanding of what it is to be moral and good. If a sociopath murders someone they are punished for their crimes. In this way human beings are punished by God for their crimes.

Because we are inherently corrupted by sin, just as a sociopath is warped by their genetics, we don't fully understand our condition, we see it from our own perspective.

God creates free will, and free will leads to disobeying God. Disobeying God = sin. Is God evil for allowing people to make their own decisions? I kind of view it as wrong to create people with free will knowing that you will send some of them to eternal punishment. I have no Idea why God would do such a thing, but then, I'm not God.

I hope one day to understand all of this, why it all happened this way, but I know I won't find out in this lifetime.

Consider the idea that our perspective are so limited by our short lifespans and lack of information that we cannot make a true moral assessment of God's works.
 
I think Christians are far more interested in 'The Problem of Evil' than atheists are. Every time I've heard about the concept, Christians have brought it up.
 
Considering how highly Atheists praise intelligence, I wonder why they criticize God so much. If God created the entire Universe, all of existence, then he is MUCH MUCH MUCH more intelligent than we are, and he created morality in the first place.

No, if god created the entire universe and all of existence then he is a moron. What kind of idiot creates an entire universe just so that he can place one planet with one important species on it? Not to mention the fact that even this one planet is thoroughly unsuited to us (come on god, can't you cut back on the diseases and natural disasters just a little bit?).

Also, you seem to be leading up to the popular "god invented morality, so if god seems to commit an evil act, we just don't understand why it was actually a good act". This is a semantic game. Almost nobody defines good and evil in terms of an omnipotent being who we cannot understand, so what you've done is you've redefined good and evil, and then tried to apply the old outdated definitions to god. If god can commit an act that we perceive as evil, when objectively (if there is such a thing as objective morality), he has actually committed an act of good, god is still not good, we just don't know what good and evil actually are.

Why is their suffering? I don't know. I don't like it, and I wonder why God allows it. If you go off the thesis that God is the ultimate intelligence, as well as being the ultimate Good, then you have to trust that in the end what he does is Good no matter how we view it.

We are like a sociopath that has no true understanding of what it is to be moral and good. If a sociopath murders someone they are punished for their crimes. In this way human beings are punished by God for their crimes.

Because we are inherently corrupted by sin, just as a sociopath is warped by their genetics, we don't fully understand our condition, we see it from our own perspective.

And here it is. Again, if you're going to say that we do not or cannot understand what is good and what is evil, then all you can say about god is that you have no idea about the morality of anything he does, or anything we do for that matter. You cannot turn around and proclaim to know that his acts are good.

God creates free will, and free will leads to disobeying God. Disobeying God = sin. Is God evil for allowing people to make their own decisions? I kind of view it as wrong to create people with free will knowing that you will send some of them to eternal punishment. I have no Idea why God would do such a thing, but then, I'm not God.

I hope one day to understand all of this, why it all happened this way, but I know I won't find out in this lifetime.

Consider the idea that our perspective are so limited by our short lifespans and lack of information that we cannot make a true moral assessment of God's works.

Here are a few of my questions regarding god and morality:

If god is the ultimate intelligence why do his creations fail so much, and why, when his creations fail, does god blame the creations themselves? Certainly the creator is always ultimately responsible for a failed creation.

Why, if god's laws are right and just, does god himself work so hard to subvert them all the time? Does god not like his own laws? What does this say about how moral god is? I've heard god compared to a judge many times, but what kind of judge works on the side to help known criminals avoid their punishment? If god's punishments are just, than by working against them is god unjust?
 
Considering how highly Atheists praise intelligence, I wonder why they criticize God so much. If God created the entire Universe, all of existence, then he is MUCH MUCH MUCH more intelligent than we are, and he created morality in the first place.
Since atheists know that God does not exist, what they are criticising is others' ideas, descriptions and apparent proofs of God.
Why is their suffering? I don't know. I don't like it, and I wonder why God allows it. If you go off the thesis that God is the ultimate intelligence, as well as being the ultimate Good, then you have to trust that in the end what he does is Good no matter how we view it.
A world where humans had evolved without suffering would be just about impossible, as humans developing strategies to defend themselves against attack and illness, and all other causes of suffering, survived; those who expected perfection did not.
We are like a sociopath that has no true understanding of what it is to be moral and good. If a sociopath murders someone they are punished for their crimes. In this way human beings are punished by God for their crimes.
No. Law, created by humans, is used to punish law-breakers. An outside supernatural, imagined deity has nothing to do with it. It is only the idea of said deity that influences people's actions.
Because we are inherently corrupted by sin, just as a sociopath is warped by their genetics, we don't fully understand our condition, we see it from our own perspective.
Once you do see it from an entirely human point of view, the world and our actions make a lot more sense. There is a whole range of behaviour, but the word sin is one that should be eliminated by eventual lack of use.
God creates free will, and free will leads to disobeying God. Disobeying God = sin. Is God evil for allowing people to make their own decisions? I kind of view it as wrong to create people with free will knowing that you will send some of them to eternal punishment. I have no Idea why God would do such a thing, but then, I'm not God.
My response to this can be inferred from what I have already said here.
I hope one day to understand all of this, why it all happened this way, but I know I won't find out in this lifetime.
At one time, I would have said the same (although probably not as emphatically), but just look at things from the atheist point of view and you most certanly can achieve a great deal more understanding in this life; and as a result feel like a complete jigsaw puzzle, with not even the tiniest bit missing, whole and complete. Of course, with faults and ups and downs, but understanding them as natural, not supernatural.
Consider the idea that our perspective are so limited by our short lifespans and lack of information that we cannot make a true moral assessment of God's works.
Realising that there are no works of God to make an assessment of is the way to go.
Thanks. I have enjoyed responding to this.
 
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!

Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

<snip>

What about Paradise ? Isn't it supposed to be a place with no Evil and where everything is Perfect ?

Why not skipping the earthly part and send everyone to Paradise directly ?

And from there you got access to Earth, if you wish to experiment Evil and exercise free will, like some kind of theme park and after suffering for some time you go back to Paradise.

You still have the potential for evil without being a cruel sadist for letting billions of people struggle daily with poverty, hunger, debilating diseases, wars, atrocities...
 
Last edited:
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.

If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.

Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!

Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.

We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.

In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.

Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.

Do not make the error of just repeating the standard atheist arguments which are already in the text, and which have already been countered. Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.

That is simply breath-taking in it's strawman arguments and bald assertions. "The standard argument is...", "We can't have
[list of antonyms]", "We can't have good without evil", "...we have no free will". Who needs "determinist metaphysical existence", when we have a solid quantum theory? Perhaps there is no free will; it's all predetermined, as Bohr would have it, or at every decision point we actually make all the possible choices?

You know, I really hate to have my arguments predetermined for me. Especially by you, bedevilled as you seem to be.
 
Consider the idea that our perspective are so limited by our short lifespans and lack of information that we cannot make a true moral assessment of God's works.


Consider the idea that it's impossible to make a true moral assessment of someone who doesn't exist.
 
The Paradox of God

The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?

Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.


No, it's not logical. The analogy is flawed. While "up" implies "down", "good" does not imply "evil".

If things are becoming "gooder", then they're more pleasant. But they need not get "less gooder", downward and downward, until 8 day old babies are being raped to death.


I highly doubt that, in order to have orgasms, puppies, or fresh cherries in reality, one must logically allow 9 year olds to be kidnapped, raped, then wrapped in plastic and given a teddy bear to comfort them as they're being buried alive in dirt.

And for that matter, it doesn't require people be able to stub their toe, get bitten by a snake, or get a paper cut.




You know, we are supposedly told all this by a "god" who will never suffer pain, terror, torture, and death. Who will never have to worry about being killed, end of story. Who will never have to worry about being resurrected and tortured, for ever and ever. Who never need be scared of anything, even if they voluntarily submit to such, as "God-as-Jesus" did.

Ya, such a god laying that crap on humanity really takes the cake.
 


That one little word demolishes both your arguments. Atheists don't criticise gods for their actions. What would be the point, given that the sole meaning of atheism is a lack of belief in gods? Poking holes in the various claims made by said believers may be an amusing pastime for some, but has nothing to do with atheism itself, which was summed up perfectly by Hokulele.

You can try to build all the arguments in favour of your preferred religion that you like. As long as you start off with "If god is/did this...", you are doomed to fail because the entire premise of atheism is that god isn't and didn't.
 
If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will
Really? None at all? So since I'm unable to deliberately make my heart stop beating, this means I have no control of my body at all? If I'm unable to fly, I must logically also be unable to run? What about my inability to process advanced logarithms in my head - does that mean I can't figure out 2+2 without using a calculator?
 
I guess we can't have God's existence without his inexistence either.


23174926e9e513c3a.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom