WaterBreather
Thinker
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2008
- Messages
- 130
The Paradox of God
The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?
Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.
If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.
Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!
Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.
We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.
In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.
Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.
Do not make the error of just repeating the standard atheist arguments which are already in the text, and which have already been countered. Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.
The standard argument for atheism, is that if God is perfect, then why does evil exist?
Well, we cannot have up without down, forward without backward, or day without night, so we cannot have good without the possibility of evil. Not to suggest that being evil is justified from a persons point of view, but that logically the potential for evil must exist from the Creator's point of view.
If the potential for evil did not exist, we would have no free will, as we would be constrained to a determinist metaphysical existence. Which would not be a perfect universe.
Aaah, says the Atheist, but then God is not perfect!
Not so.
One of the qualities of perfection will be that it is complete. It comprises every possibility. If the potential for evil did not exist, the Universe (God) would not be all that it could be. It would be limited.
We are, of course, using the term 'Perfection' in two contexts, which is why it appears as a contradiction, although it is not such, but a paradox.
In the first context : Perfection is that which excludes imperfection.
In the second context : Perfection is all encompassing, and thus it includes imperfection.
Do not be bedevilled by the notion that we have an imperfect (limited) language, by which we are describing a perfect (unlimited ) universe.
Do not make the error of just repeating the standard atheist arguments which are already in the text, and which have already been countered. Express your unique opinion, or hold your peace.