God, Perfection, and the problem of Evil.

Seems like a bizarre waste, to create a whole moon so a few intelligent people can finally figure out how to keep time.

If this is some kind of "nice, neat world" in said god's eyes, sheesh. :rolleyes:
 
Seems like a bizarre waste, to create a whole moon so a few intelligent people can finally figure out how to keep time.

If this is some kind of "nice, neat world" in said god's eyes, sheesh. :rolleyes:

Mankind would have figured out a way to tell time even if there were no moon. Why do you attempt to draw that conclusion?

BTW

Your argument is strawman since I never said that is the moon's sole purpose. Also, what might appear as wasteful to us might be insignificant from God's standpoint.
 
Last edited:
This is retro-fitting human use of lunar cycles into God's plan. It's like Kirk Cameron's banana - divinely bent to aid in eating. :boggled:

As pattern-seeking animals, humans recognised the pattern in the moon, sun and seasons and then used them to keep track of time, not the other way around. And Kirk Cameron, as a pattern-seeking animal, turns the banana around for easier eating, not the other way around.

If I'm falling over and grab onto a tree to support myself, it doesn't mean the tree was created for this purpose. It means I'm clever enough to avoid breaking my nose on the ground.

I'm saying that's one of the purposes specifically mentioned in the Bible. I didn't say it is the sole purpose. Neither did I say that mankind would have been unable to devise other ways to tell time.

BTW
My response was in reference to the accusation that God made the moon for eclipse purposes.
 
Radrook, you’re just making the old “puddle of water” argument (the water in a pothole says “wow look how well I fit in this hole it must have been created just for me”)
The supernatural point of view does nothing to explain the natural world, it never did.
 
Th Genesis account doesn't say that the moon's purpose was to provide us with eclipses. It says it was provided for ancient mankind to use it to keep time as well a lesser source of light during the night. Furthermore, total eclipses aren't visible from every geographical location.

And that's how you interpret "And then there is the remarkably peculiar notion of the sun and moon being in precise opposition to one another. The mark of a Creator."? I see no way in which the meaning of a time piece or a part time nightlight can be fitted into that statement.

BTW
I read Carl Sagan's Contact and don't recall what you just mentioned. Is that something that you concluded from the content of the story? If so, what part?
In the last pages of the book a computer is working out the digits of PI, looking for a pattern in the transcendentalism of the result. It finds that when expanded in base 11, after some millions of digits, the sequence settled into a series of 0's and 1's, and that these, when arranged into a square array displayed a perfect rastered circle of 1's in a fields of 0's.

"The circle was made on purpose, the circle said. In whatever galaxy you find yourself, you take the circumference of a circle and divide it by the diameter, measure closely enough, and you uncover a miracle -- another circle, drawn kilometers downstream of the decimal point. ... It doesn't matter what you look like, what you are made of or where you are from. As long as you live in the universe, and have a modest talent in mathematics, you'll find it. It's already there. It's inside everything. You don't have to leave your planet to find it. In the fabric of space and the nature of matter, as in a great work of art, there is, written small, the artist's signature. Standing over humans, gods and demons, subsuming Caretakers and Tunnel Builders [the aliens in the novel], there is an intelligence that antedates the universe.

"The circle has been closed.

"She [Ellie] found what she had been searching for."

Ellie ran the SETI program that starts the novel. She was searching for extraterrestrial intelligence. She found it in her adventures in the novel, but as it turned out in the final pages there is a deeper meaning, a difference of kind as well as magnitude, of intelligence she found. Sagan purposely doesn't call it God, in fact, he places gods under it as human creations. Regardless of how exactly you define the word god, a god who manipluates the universe like that - as opposed to one that floods the world to kill his creations run amok - that is a god that I could respect.

Of course, it's only a novel.
 
Last edited:
Voltaire's Dr. Pangloss reasoned we have noses to have a good place to rest our spectacles on.
 
Darn, you beat me to it! Oh well, nothing says I can't still post it. :D

http://www.literature.org/authors/voltaire/candide/chapter-01.html

Master Pangloss taught the metaphysico-theologo-cosmolonigology. He could prove to admiration that there is no effect without a cause; and, that in this best of all possible worlds, the Baron's castle was the most magnificent of all castles, and My Lady the best of all possible baronesses.

"It is demonstrable," said he, "that things cannot be otherwise than as they are; for as all things have been created for some end, they must necessarily be created for the best end. Observe, for instance, the nose is formed for spectacles, therefore we wear spectacles. The legs are visibly designed for stockings, accordingly we wear stockings. Stones were made to be hewn and to construct castles, therefore My Lord has a magnificent castle; for the greatest baron in the province ought to be the best lodged. Swine were intended to be eaten, therefore we eat pork all the year round: and they, who assert that everything is right, do not express themselves correctly; they should say that everything is best."
 
And that's how you interpret "And then there is the remarkably peculiar notion of the sun and moon being in precise opposition to one another. The mark of a Creator."? I see no way in which the meaning of a time piece or a part time nightlight can be fitted into that statement.

You misunderstood. Genesis chaper one itself tells us that is one reason for providing a moon.




In the last pages of the book a computer is working out the digits of PI, looking for a pattern in the transcendentalism of the result. It finds that when expanded in base 11, after some millions of digits, the sequence settled into a series of 0's and 1's, and that these, when arranged into a square array displayed a perfect rastered circle of 1's in a fields of 0's.

"The circle was made on purpose, the circle said. In whatever galaxy you find yourself, you take the circumference of a circle and divide it by the diameter, measure closely enough, and you uncover a miracle -- another circle, drawn kilometers downstream of the decimal point. ... It doesn't matter what you look like, what you are made of or where you are from. As long as you live in the universe, and have a modest talent in mathematics, you'll find it. It's already there. It's inside everything. You don't have to leave your planet to find it. In the fabric of space and the nature of matter, as in a great work of art, there is, written small, the artist's signature. Standing over humans, gods and demons, subsuming Caretakers and Tunnel Builders [the aliens in the novel], there is an intelligence that antedates the universe.

"The circle has been closed.

"She [Ellie] found what she had been searching for."

Ellie ran the SETI program that starts the novel. She was searching for extraterrestrial intelligence. She found it in her adventures in the novel, but as it turned out in the final pages there is a deeper meaning, a difference of kind as well as magnitude, of intelligence she found. Sagan purposely doesn't call it God, in fact, he places gods under it as human creations. Regardless of how exactly you define the word god, a god who manipluates the universe like that - as opposed to one that floods the world to kill his creations run amok - that is a god that I could respect.

Of course, it's only a novel.[/spoiler]

True, but novels bear important concepts and messages. My understanding of the novel is different. There is a strong religious sub theme to that novel. Religionists Vs atheists. Ellie is rejected as a representative of mankind because she is an atheist while most of mankind are religionists. Her atheism is based on he doubt in statements concerning the supernatural which amount to mere unsubstantiated faith. When she returns from her adventure she is doubted and asked to prove that her experiences were real. All she can come up with is that she knows they are real. Which of course places her in the same league with those she formerly doubted and criticized. The minister which she disagreed with is there when she realizes that her atheism might be in error based on her doubts.

Now, about the respecting God if he behaved as the aliens behaved, I'm not sure that I see them as measuring up. All they revealed was that they were there. No promises of assistance were made. No hope for a new beginning was given. For all mankind knew in the novel another million years could have gone by without any further contact. So that's just too cryptic for my taste. But of course I respect your opinion. Just giving my own. : )
Thanx for the feedback.

BTW

When Ellie asked, the aliens who contacted earth didn't even know who originally constructed the transportation system they were using. In contrast God is described as all-knowing.
 
Last edited:
There is no "purpose" to the universe nor anything in it.
It's all accidental.
Man, in his arrogant presumption that it was all "designed" for him finds "purpose" in the existence of the Moon, or how to use the force of gravity when making waterwheels, but the universe on the whole, has nothing to do with any of it, and all the time needed to not do it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom