God, Perfection, and the problem of Evil.

The attitude that because there are multiple definitions of the term "atheist", either the one I use is invalid or else they all are. In addition, your behavior in an earlier thread made it fairly clear that you were more interested in painting atheists with a brush of your own devising rather than accepting that there is as much variety among self-proclaimed atheists as there is among theists.

Hence, my claim to be an ignostic.

The diversity among theists is extreme (Christian, Hindu, Muslim, Jewish, etc.). Can you find any atheist organizations that are anti-science, anti-materialist or anti-evolution?
 
The diversity among theists is extreme (Christian, Hindu, Muslim, Jewish, etc.). Can you find any atheist organizations that are anti-science, anti-materialist or anti-evolution?


Yep, been there, done that in the other thread.

You did not accept the evidence then, and I doubt you will accept it now, hence my comment regarding your attitude. Don't feel bad, many theists have the same blind spot you do.
 
Suppose you were God. If you have ever tried to write a novel, you would have taken this position.
No, if I wanted to make a universe, I'd take this position. I can make a novel in which a girl is repeatedly raped because she exists only as ink on the pages and a figure in the imaginations of the readers. I can make a movie script in which two little boys are made child soldiers in two opposing armies and end up having to fight each others to the death - because no matter how realistic I make the pretended suffering of the movie's actors appear, it won't get little boys hurt. But reality? A real universe with real lifeforms that feel real pain? I have friends who have been subjected to attempted homicide, physical abuse, sexual abuse, natural disasters, and warfare. An old friend of mine died this year of leukemia. The very idea that there is a God who had them go through these things because otherwise the world would be too boring for the rest of us... is sickening to me.

But let me get back to the notion of 'God the Novelist'. The perfect storyline, would be less interesting if all the characters did was to sing hymns all day.
More thinking in terms of polar opposites, I see. Doesn't matter, though, 'cause even a world where everything was perfect (ie. Garden of Eden or Paradise) would be vastly superior to one where people get raped, etc.


The attitude that because there are multiple definitions of the term "atheist", either the one I use is invalid or else they all are. In addition, your behavior in an earlier thread made it fairly clear that you were more interested in painting atheists with a brush of your own devising rather than accepting that there is as much variety among self-proclaimed atheists as there is among theists.
Yes, Malerin's made it pretty clear that he's a one-way street - you can listen to the cars that comes out, but you can't drive in yourself. Try this:
 

Attachments

  • Malerin.jpg
    Malerin.jpg
    4.6 KB · Views: 27
Last edited:
That's a shame. Dragon worship would be totally cool.
.
And as futile!
Consider many dragons are seen with 6 limbs. There's no 6-limbed antecedents which could have evolved into dragons.
Which of course equally applies to angels.
The furor over 4-limbed or 6-limbed, and the 2 front limbs as graspers or paws would be as loud as any of the pin-headed debates in religions today.
 
There are no organisations, who dominate the world, that believe in leprechauns and dragons.

Yet belief in dragons, leprechauns, fairies, sprites, evil spirits, giants, witches and many, many other magical creatures was once very common. Today, most people do not believe in such mythical beings. I wonder why that is. Could it be that they have simply substituted belief in other mythical beings? But the fact remains: There is no more empirical evidence for any of the gods currently worshiped than there is for leprechauns or dragons. I am just as justified in stating a lack of belief in gods as I am in stating a lack of belief in dragons.
 
Now you are deliberately missing my point.

You know full well, that many acclaimed scientists, like Isaac Newton, Franklin, Galileo, all believed in God. And then there is every single president of every vaguely successful country, along with leaders of massively powerful religions.

There are no such groups of people which believe in any such thing as Dragons, Leprechauns, or even Aliens either.

That you even TRY and equate the two concepts is irrational.

Also, consider that people believe in many invisible things like electromagnetic waves, atoms, electrons, quarks, emotions, etc...

And, all ideas are presented to us through the imagination of the mind, so saying its just in my mind, is the same as saying that the existence of electrons is just in someones mind. It is. But the mental image in the mind is a reflection of a real entity. That is why such ideas have effective power in the world. Have you not seen the effect that belief in God has had on the world? Are there any Atheist institutions that can vaguely even compare with the likes of all those splendid cathedrals, the works of the Renaisance, the all-conquering power of the Christian belief? Not even slightly.

Aaah, but you say, electrons, etc leave traces.

But this is exactly the same argument as the argument from design. The entire cosmos is evidence of an ordering factor, from the pure precision of pythagorus right down to the perfection of the gravitational formulae, and beyond. And its all a random coincidence?

And then there is the remarkably peculiar notion of the sun and moon being in precise opposition to one another. The mark of a Creator. Or would you have us believe in YET ANOTHER perfect coincidence?
 
Now you are deliberately missing my point.

You know full well, that many acclaimed scientists, like Isaac Newton, Franklin, Galileo, all believed in God. And then there is every single president of every vaguely successful country, along with leaders of massively powerful religions.
Appeal to popularity / authority. So what? The popularity of a belief is not evidence for that belief. You could argue that all of the great achievements of civilization prior to the 20th century were done by leaders and thinkers who had no knowledge of genetic theory. Does that mean we can credit ignorance of genetics for what they accomplished? Furthermore, is it evidence that genetic theory is false?

There are no such groups of people which believe in any such thing as Dragons, Leprechauns, or even Aliens either.
Scientology, Mormonism, and Raelism all believe in aliens and are all officially recognized as religions.

That you even TRY and equate the two concepts is irrational.

Also, consider that people believe in many invisible things like electromagnetic waves, atoms, electrons, quarks, emotions, etc...
They're not all invisible. We can measure their effects, run tests on them, use scientific procedures to get repeatable results, and in some cases directly observe them. If you don't think emotions have a measurable cause, I suggest you look into pharmaceutical psychology or neurobiology.

And, all ideas are presented to us through the imagination of the mind, so saying its just in my mind, is the same as saying that the existence of electrons is just in someones mind. It is. But the mental image in the mind is a reflection of a real entity.
This analogy is false. You're comparing tested theories with hypotheses that have no evidence to support them. Besides, belief in God is a matter of faith and personal choice, not a matter of evidence or proof.

That is why such ideas have effective power in the world. Have you not seen the effect that belief in God has had on the world? Are there any Atheist institutions that can vaguely even compare with the likes of all those splendid cathedrals, the works of the Renaisance, the all-conquering power of the Christian belief? Not even slightly.
Again, a person's beliefs (or lack thereof) have nothing to do with the validity of their ideas or the merits of their work. I could easily dig up lists of irreligious scientists and thinkers and rattle off their accomplishments, but it would not prove that atheism was responsible or that it could take credit for what they did.

Aaah, but you say, electrons, etc leave traces.

But this is exactly the same argument as the argument from design. The entire cosmos is evidence of an ordering factor, from the pure precision of pythagorus right down to the perfection of the gravitational formulae, and beyond. And its all a random coincidence?
You're assuming the conclusion, presupposing that there's design or purpose, in order to prove the existence of a designer. Humans certainly perceive design, but that's different from finding evidence for design. The whole argument from design is built on faulty analogies. There are zero observations of the design process in motion, no known or proposed mechanisms, no hypothesized forces, matter, or energy that would take part in the process, no testable predictions that come out of ID, and no practical applications for the science involved because there is none.

And then there is the remarkably peculiar notion of the sun and moon being in precise opposition to one another. The mark of a Creator. Or would you have us believe in YET ANOTHER perfect coincidence?
The sun is a star made of hydrogen and helium and the moon is a satellite made of rock and metals, miniscule in size by comparison. The moon reflects the light of the sun, affects the ocean tides, and it's possible to see the moon on some days. Aside from the fact that one is visible during the night and the other during the day, how exactly are they in "precise opposition"?
 
The sun is a star made of hydrogen and helium and the moon is a satellite made of rock and metals, miniscule in size by comparison. The moon reflects the light of the sun, affects the ocean tides, and it's possible to see the moon on some days. Aside from the fact that one is visible during the night and the other during the day, how exactly are they in "precise opposition"?


Not to mention the fact the moon is currently moving away from the earth. Apparently WaterBreather's creator isn't a decent enough engineer to create a stable system.
 
You know full well, that many acclaimed scientists, like Isaac Newton, Franklin, Galileo, all believed in God. And then there is every single president of every vaguely successful country, along with leaders of massively powerful religions.

There are no such groups of people which believe in any such thing as Dragons, Leprechauns, or even Aliens either.

That you even TRY and equate the two concepts is irrational.
Solely because people don't believe in them? Really? First of all, you'd be surprised, and probably scared, by how many people in the world take witchcraft, for example, seriously. You'd be nauseated by the sheer number of women and children are persecuted - driven out of their communities, bullied, subjected to violence or even outright killed, today, in 2008, for alleged witchcraft. Are you saying that the very fact that these sick people exist proves witchcraft is real?

And, all ideas are presented to us through the imagination of the mind, so saying its just in my mind, is the same as saying that the existence of electrons is just in someones mind. It is. But the mental image in the mind is a reflection of a real entity. That is why such ideas have effective power in the world. Have you not seen the effect that belief in God has had on the world? Are there any Atheist institutions that can vaguely even compare with the likes of all those splendid cathedrals, the works of the Renaisance, the all-conquering power of the Christian belief? Not even slightly.
No, atheists haven't built huge unnecessary monuments at crippling expense or launched huge campaigns to force their beliefs forcibly down other peoples' throats with threats of violence. This doesn't make atheism false. Though I agree that yes, organized religions do have lots of power in the world. This is a frightening concept - that certain people in the world are essentially respected and obeyed simply because they are believed to be the loudspeakers of some unproven deity.

Aaah, but you say, electrons, etc leave traces.

But this is exactly the same argument as the argument from design. The entire cosmos is evidence of an ordering factor, from the pure precision of pythagorus right down to the perfection of the gravitational formulae, and beyond. And its all a random coincidence?
No, we're stating that they came about through natural processes 'guided' by laws of nature. We have evidence of the Big Bang, how the Earth, like so many other worlds, were formed, and how early lifeforms evolved through natural selection. There simply is no need to invoke a god.

Not that a god would explain anything anyhow. Evolution, for example, had a finite number of paths it can 'choose' for its early lifeforms, just like how water running down a rocky decline has a finite number of ways it can erode the rock into a river. The earliest lifeforms could evolve in an enormous number of ways, of course, but in the end, it is a finite number.

With an omnipotent Yahweh, the possibilities are literally endless. If there's something He can't create on the Earth, He's by definition not omnipotent, so the odds of humans being one of the species to be created isn't some incredibly unlikely event, but an infinitely unlikely event. You don't solve anything by introducing Yahweh, you merely make the odds even bigger.
 
Last edited:
Now you are deliberately missing my point.

You know full well, that many acclaimed scientists, like Isaac Newton, Franklin, Galileo, all believed in God. And then there is every single president of every vaguely successful country, along with leaders of massively powerful religions.

Argument from popularity and argument from authority. Please cite evidence that god exists.

There are no such groups of people which believe in any such thing as Dragons, Leprechauns, or even Aliens either.

Incorrect times three. Dragons are a fundamental part of the synchronistic set of beliefs often called "Chinese Folk Religion" which has at least many hundreds of millions of adherents. Leprechauns are members of the faire folk, or Tuatha Dé Danann if you prefer, which are believed in by many neo-pagans. Aliens are not only widely believe in by people all over the Earth, belief in aliens is one of the central dogmas of the Raelian faith.

That you even TRY and equate the two concepts is irrational.

Those people don't believe in your god for precisely the same reason you don't believe in their favorite invisible friends.

Also, consider that people believe in many invisible things like electromagnetic waves, atoms, electrons, quarks, emotions, etc...

Evidence for all those invisible things is trivially easy to produce.

And, all ideas are presented to us through the imagination of the mind, so saying its just in my mind, is the same as saying that the existence of electrons is just in someones mind. It is. But the mental image in the mind is a reflection of a real entity. That is why such ideas have effective power in the world. Have you not seen the effect that belief in God has had on the world? Are there any Atheist institutions that can vaguely even compare with the likes of all those splendid cathedrals, the works of the Renaisance, the all-conquering power of the Christian belief? Not even slightly.

Wrong, again. I dare you to find a religious institution which competes with the healing power of medicine, the warming power of radiant heating, or the illumination of an electric light. These things make specific predictions which can be put to the test. They provide us tangible results which make our lives better.

Religion's major product is excuses.

Aaah, but you say, electrons, etc leave traces.

But this is exactly the same argument as the argument from design. The entire cosmos is evidence of an ordering factor, from the pure precision of pythagorus right down to the perfection of the gravitational formulae, and beyond. And its all a random coincidence?

Merely because the universe is explicable, it does not follow that it was designed. That requires proof, which is lacking.

And then there is the remarkably peculiar notion of the sun and moon being in precise opposition to one another. The mark of a Creator. Or would you have us believe in YET ANOTHER perfect coincidence?

What perfect coincidence? The sun is an incandescent wild nuclear fireball jetting crap everywhere, most of it we can't perceive, and most of blocked from us by the atmosphere. The moon is an irregular jagged ball. Google Bailey's Beads. What's perfect about a lumpy, bumpy ball? The moon has an elliptical orbit, like all orbiting bodies. The distance between us and the moon changes from 360 million and 410 million kilometers. Mighty big range for perfection. So, about two thirds of the few solar eclipses we ever see mean the moon's much smaller than the sun (from our vantage points so we get a weird light show, not an eclipse, because it isn't a perfect fit.) It's not a perfect anything. The difference between the angle at which the moon orbits the Earth, relative to the angle at which the Earth orbits the sun is roughly 5.1 degrees. What's perfect about 5.1 askew?
 
Last edited:
However,
let me explain what I am saying in a thought experiment.

Suppose you were God. If you have ever tried to write a novel, you would have taken this position. Try and write a novel where everyone and everything in it is perfect. You will be forced to offset the perfections of some with their own imperfections or with the imperfections of others. If you did not, the novel would be less than authentic; less than perfect. We need shadow to show what light is. We need a pitch black night, so that the stars can really shine.

I want to propose a thought experiment to you too. Try and write a novel where everyone and everything in it is evil. Now compare it to the one you got by trying to write the perfect one. Spot the differences, if any.

Oh, yeah, Jesus and Mo had something about this:
http://www.jesusandmo.net/2008/10/08/world/
 
Now you are deliberately missing my point.
No, your argument just isn't as sound as you believe.

You know full well, that many acclaimed scientists, like Isaac Newton, Franklin, Galileo, all believed in God. And then there is every single president of every vaguely successful country, along with leaders of massively powerful religions.
Logical fallacy. Look up "appeal to authority" and "argumentum ad populum".

There are no such groups of people which believe in any such thing as Dragons, Leprechauns, or even Aliens either.
Scientology has become quite widespread and involves belief in aliens. Raelianism is a modern religion that also involves belief in aliens. In fact, a recent CNN/Time poll indicated that 64% of U.S. citizens believe that aliens have visited humans, 50% believe that humans have been abducted by aliens, and 37% believe that aliens have contacted the U.S. government.

That you even TRY and equate the two concepts is irrational.
What two concepts, mythical beings and gods? Very well, provide evidence that substantiates the existence of gods.

Also, consider that people believe in many invisible things like electromagnetic waves, atoms, electrons, quarks, emotions, etc...
Would you recommend that someone stick a metal fork into a wall socket? There is empirical, non-visual evidence for all of those things.

And, all ideas are presented to us through the imagination of the mind, so saying its just in my mind, is the same as saying that the existence of electrons is just in someones mind. It is. But the mental image in the mind is a reflection of a real entity. That is why such ideas have effective power in the world.
No, ideas about electrons are evidenced by our senses. This evidence can be measured independently by multiple people with the same result. J. J. Thomson's experiments can be performed by anyone and the result will be the same. This consistency cannot be found in experiences of gods.

Have you not seen the effect that belief in God has had on the world? Are there any Atheist institutions that can vaguely even compare with the likes of all those splendid cathedrals, the works of the Renaisance, the all-conquering power of the Christian belief? Not even slightly.
Atheism is not a belief system like religions are. There is no atheist doctrine, no unifying laws or central authority. Many theists look at atheism and expect that it is supposed to be some sort of replacement for religion, when in reality it is simply a lack of belief in gods. There are no more cathedrals of atheism than there are cathedrals of not collecting stamps. The only thing that cathedrals or religious art demonstrates is the existence of belief in gods(nice as the art was, the most important achievements of the Renaissance were scientific, and often in contradiction of religious dogma). It does not demonstrate the existence of the actual gods, unless you, who speaks of the all conquering power of the Christian belief are willing to acknowledge the veracity of Islam, Hinduism or Buddhism based on the great monuments that have been built under their influence.

Aaah, but you say, electrons, etc leave traces.

But this is exactly the same argument as the argument from design. The entire cosmos is evidence of an ordering factor, from the pure precision of pythagorus right down to the perfection of the gravitational formulae, and beyond. And its all a random coincidence?
The traces of the electron led to predictions based on theories that eventually led to the monitor on which you are now reading my words. What predictions can be made based on ID? Douglas Adams once made an elegant analogy about a rain puddle that marvels that the depression in which it sits fits it so perfectly that it must have been made for it.

And what does Pythagoras have to do with ID?

And then there is the remarkably peculiar notion of the sun and moon being in precise opposition to one another. The mark of a Creator. Or would you have us believe in YET ANOTHER perfect coincidence?
"Precise opposition"? What are you talking about?
 
The moon reflects the light of the sun, affects the ocean tides, and it's possible to see the moon on some days. Aside from the fact that one is visible during the night and the other during the day, how exactly are they in "precise opposition"?

The moon is often visible during the day too.
 
Now you are deliberately missing my point.

Not me.

Instead of shotgunning the same old tired religious arguments at everyone, why don't you try responding to individuals here, so you can get a discussion going? Perhaps you would find that more productive.

For instance, you might respond to my post concerning the fact that no solutions to the problem of evil account for the possibility of one human eliminating the potential of another.

You know full well, that many acclaimed scientists, like Isaac Newton, Franklin, Galileo, all believed in God.

I don't want to respond to the rest of your post, because I don't care to argue such things, but you should know that this statement is extremely misleading.

Saying "person X believes in God" can mean a great many things, because "God" is a very sweeping term. In this case, all the scientists you mentioned happened to be heretics because their idea of "God" was somewhat different from the accepted notion of "God" I.E. the notion propagated and enforced by the church.

I wouldn't go as far as claiming that they would be atheists if they were living today, but they were heretics then and they most likely would be today. So, the question is, what is a modern day heretic most likely to believe?
 
The moon reflects the light of the sun, affects the ocean tides, and it's possible to see the moon on some days. Aside from the fact that one is visible during the night and the other during the day, how exactly are they in "precise opposition"?

The moon is often visible during the day too.
I know, I said that in the part of my post you quoted. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom