Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

I can't edit posts that old. Sure, I guess it was pretty smooth sailing.

The entire flight path, including the wobbly corkscrew turn and, importantly, the fact that he did come in so dangerously close to the ground, all point to Hanjour being a pretty bad pilot. He had a very large, easy to hit target (that's what the Zembla experiment shows), and still almost crashed into the ground before getting there.

But the fact of the matter is: The plane did crash. It crashed where it crashed - that is a tautology. It is possible, and it was plausible and easily possible even from an a-priori point of view.

This is like if I throw darts at a dart board. I am a pretty bad dart player. I rarely hit close to the bull's eye. Now suppose I walk into a bar, and I throw exactly 1 dart - and I throw it recklessly hard -, and I almost miss, hitting a double 17, just barely clearing the back of a high chair that happens to stand in front of the board.
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darts#/media/File:Dartboard.svg

Would you say this is a difficult feat? Because I only almost missed? because few bad dart players like me throw so low and so hard?
Silly nonsense!
Me throwing too hard and almost missing is proof I am a bad dart player - but even a bad dart player rarely has trouble hitting the board at all.
I didn't aim at double-17. I just aimed at the board. I hit the board. It was easy. And yet I almost missed.
Hanjour didn't aim low at that spot. He aimed at the Pentagon. It was easy. And yet he almost missed.
 
You apparently linked the wrong video here - no Italian pilot speaking, instead that excellent 3D animation of the actual flight path. I thank you for that!
That video doesn't show the final approach in real time and from the pilot's point of view. It shows only the final second or so. You probably don't realize that terrain is sloping down from west towards the Pentagon (and the river) there.

This is the clip of the Italian pilot Capt. Giancarlo Tedeschi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1GCeuSr3Mk&feature=player_embedded#t=3840
 
You know, actually, on reddit.com/r/conspiracy and reddit.com/r/911truth I sometimes debunk no-757 Pentagon stuff as well as other assorted bits of disinfo when I see it. From now on, I'll advocate that there is no evidence for any other scenario other than the hijacker-controlled planes. LIHOP is enough.
 
Last edited:
It was explained to me by pilots who spend a good portion of their time arguing on the internet about conspiracy theories. A pilot on Italian television voiced the opinion that it would be much better to just come in at a high angle and crash onto the roof: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVDdjLQkUV8

When you're arguing conspiracy theories, you can find an army of experts on either side who can swear that their position is correct. Like with the single bullet theory: you'll find a bunch of people who swear that CE399 was the type of bullet that could withstand a lot of damage, but when it comes to experimental evidence, things get quieter. Of course, it is known that it is physically possible to fly a 757 in the manner flight 77 was flown, so it does have some Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy going on there since it can never be physically proven that it was remote-controlled.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZbUCoVEVsU&t=5m21s Their simulation definitely appears to be coming in at a higher angle and slower than 530 mph. Compare that to how low it was flying here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVDdjLQkUV8. The Jesse Ventura show tries to keep low to the ground and the two pilots can never get it right.


Could you hit the side of a large building with a motorcycle traveling 540 mph? I don't know, I wouldn't bet on it. I understand that something like "the planes on 9/11 were remote controlled" is an extraordinary claim which needs extraordinary evidence, but the only reason I retained the possibility is because the lies of 9/11 kept piling up (e.g. nobody could imagine flying hijacked planes into buildings), so I keep a particular cynicism.

I can see that every response I give, it pushes this thread back on the top of the "9/11 Conspiracy Theories" section, and also I never asked for my own split-thread so I think I'll stop replying now because this subject isn't that important to me.
Hold on just a minute. It was your claim in the first place.

You waded in asking your killer question, as you thought, only to find that the simulation had not only been done but that there were members here who were actual pilots and who had actually simulated that very scenario which you thought nobody had done. When confronted with the facts of the matter, you ran away for a while in the vain hope that everyone would forget your abject failure.

You still have not acknowledged that you were flat out wrong.

On top of that you continue to cite Jesse Ventura's TV buffoonery as some sort of authority and now that you have been soundly trounced you brush the whole thing off as "not important to you".

Sorry, but that won't wash.
 
Hold on just a minute. It was your claim in the first place.

You waded in asking your killer question, as you thought, only to find that the simulation had not only been done but that there were members here who were actual pilots and who had actually simulated that very scenario which you thought nobody had done. When confronted with the facts of the matter, you ran away for a while in the vain hope that everyone would forget your abject failure.

You still have not acknowledged that you were flat out wrong.

On top of that you continue to cite Jesse Ventura's TV buffoonery as some sort of authority and now that you have been soundly trounced you brush the whole thing off as "not important to you".

Sorry, but that won't wash.

Lol, dude. What are you even doing? Arguing on the internet is not as intense and serious as you're making it out to be. Read my last comment.
 
CJNewson has recreated the entire flight of AA77, with Air Traffic Controller voices dubbed in:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VrxqlroYvyw
You may want to fast-forward to 1:11:30 hours or so for the final 40 seconds.
Note that buildings on the ground are mostly not realistic (no Navy Anney, for example).


The NTSB also published an animated flight visualization, from Flight Data Recorder data, which records both control inputs (horn, throttle) and resulting measured flight parameters (speed, altitude, bank, ...):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vqDDlS9Hyw
I suggest you start at 1:19 hours, in the middle of the turn. Watch the horn, how Hanjour plays and fiddles with it constantly. Watch the speed top right instrument: Mostly under 300 knots. Watch how altitude wobble (middle right instrument). Not that throttles are set to only 25% (bottom left).
Hanjour concentrates on turning and descending, until the Pentagon is almost straight ahead in the window at ca. 1:21:15. At that time, he flies under 300 knots (345 mph), then increases throttle from 25% to 50%. At 1:21:35, he starts pushing throttle to 100% - speed now starts to increase fast.
1:21:49: Exceeds 360 knots (414 mph)
1:21:56: Exceeds 400 knots (460mph; just 7 seconds later!) at 1213 ft.
1:22:05: Exceeds 450 knots (517.5 mph) at 360 ft - that's -853 ft in 9 seconds, or -5687 ft/min.
Wild turns on the horn - Hanjour panics!
Notice how much he pushes the horn forward, and how the altidude clock races down! Hanjour IS diving!
1:22:08: Animation freezes - end of NTSB-decoded data: 462 knots (531 mph) at 180 ft.
So during the last 3 seconds, he lost another 180 feet of altitude - 60ft/s. The Pentagon is about 77 feet high; so 1.3 seconds before the crash, Hanjour was still above the roof!


What you see there is a bad pilot flying recklessly, and pushing on the horn too hard, fearing he might overfly his target.
 
Even now you have to cling on to a CT, just the LIHOP version?

Why are you determined to cling on to the CT?
I have to second this. You are not being skeptical, you are being a believer holding on to a belief. What evidence lead you to your skeptical belief the "official story" was significantly in error in the way you seem to believe.
 
If it wasn't LIHOP, why didn't the Pentagon activate the most advanced anti-aircraft defensive measures in the known universe? The ones that are always shooting down planes taking off and landing at Reagan. At least they should have unleashed the force fields.
 
This is the clip of the Italian pilot Capt. Giancarlo Tedeschi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1GCeuSr3Mk&feature=player_embedded#t=3840

Their simulation at 1:07 hours shows that it is difficult to dive into the Pentagon at such a steep angle as the Italian pilots suggest! That simulation is going much faster while still turning - that is not what Hanjour did!
Hanjour finished the turn at around 300 knots, which is easy, and only then increased speed and pushed seriously down.

The Italian pilots discuss this under the assumption that Hanjour flew close to the ground at 460 knots for an extended amount of time - this is simply not true! 12 seconds before impact, AA77 was still 1000 feet above the Pentagon! Hanjour was dangerously close to the ground for only perhaps 2 seconds!
 
The Dutch documentary's simulation shows the plane coming from a much higher angle, and it does not give any indications on how fast their simulated plane is going (doesn't look that fast). That is actually how I would reasonably expect a terrorist pilot to attack the Pentagon: To come in at a high angle and probably crash onto the roof. The simulation on Jesse Ventura's show is more accurate.

Your comment about the runways ignores another huge aspect - the speed of the aircraft. This is a POV video of a vehicle going 200 miles per hour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmNXCJt7K3Q&feature=youtu.be&?

Now triple that. Hanjour had to control a 757 at those speeds at sea level with severe turbulence while feet away from the ground. Any slightly wrong movement on the control stick and the plane crashes on the ground. What a stupid and illogical maneuver from someone who's life mission depended on hitting the Pentagon - he had to have at least known the dangers to going near or above the VMO. Suspiciously lucky, but like I said, the prevailing theory in my head is that Hani really did do it.

A higher angle is not normal. Our normal landing is around 3 degrees. Decents more than 4 or 5 degrees are rare, and only last seconds. An emergency decent might be at 10 degrees with all drag up, at Vmo; aka landing gear down, speed brakes full; thus high approach angles are unsual.

Hani/terrorist pilot picked an angle he was use to 3 to 4 degrees. Go fly, and learn what happens if you push the nose down... go do it, stop repeating BS you make up, go get some experience...

Jesse's show is the least real, the most BS, you continue to fail to the BS side filled with woo, and extra BS. Jesse's show was BS. Stop trying to hold on to ignorance found in 911 truth exclusively.

Going faster is not a problem, I exceeded Vmo and my jet was controllable, as good as slower, maybe better, more responsive, and easy to control. BINGO, I flew heavy jets, did you? The 911 truth nuts can only get about 0.05 percent of all pilots to agree with lies...
Please explain why higher speeds are harder, and I can show you why higher speeds are easier... And I flew jets as heavy as the jets on 911, an I had four engines... albeit the jet on 911 had more total thrust then I ever had...
Got some more BS?

911 was a perfect flying day, and an early morning approach going 483.5 knots would not be disturbed by turbulence, like a slow moving dirty plane on final. Big error on the turbulence BS, big error. There was no turbulence on 911, it was great weather; did you make up the turbulence, or plagiarize this BS from 911 truth?

The final Radar Altimeter readings from 77 over terrain which was getting lower as 77 approached the Pentagon.
233, 183, 89, 57, 4 - this is exact distance of 77 from the ground for the last five seconds... This is the distance from the bottom of the landing gear to the ground, thus the aircraft is not 4 feet above the ground, the landing gear would be... do you understand this simple concept even pilots understand...

Golly Gee, 77 was in a decent, and not next to the ground... We land at 2.5 to 3 degree glide slopes, and 77 was at a higher angle; oops... Study the FDR before you make up BS.

Hani was looking at a 900 foot wide target; the BS about him not able to fly was from flights he did from a 40 foot wide runway... There is so much 911 truth ignores it is hard to believe you make up more BS about why Hani was risking crashing before the Pentagon, when it really makes no difference; if he hit the ground he would have killed those on the roads... and those on the course, and the plane parts would be killing people for hundreds if not thousands of feet...

There are a lot of pilots who wash out; the cool part of Hani... He had to fly with instructors until a service was happy, and then rent a plane to him; we all suffer the same fate, we have to prove we can fly... Thus 911 truth quote mined the BS comments from instructors, and made it look like Hani was a poor pilot and could not crash... crash... the easy maneuver.

Thus now you are stuck with the more idiotic part of 911 truth, LIHOP. A level of abstraction which many 911 truth failed followers cling to.


This is the clip of the Italian pilot Capt. Giancarlo Tedeschi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1GCeuSr3Mk&feature=player_embedded#t=3840
Boy, that is BS...
"Normally, the plane would come down in a plunge."
Pure BS, why don't we pilot plunge at the Runway? Hello, he is spewing BS, and plunging is something Hani never did, we never were trained to do plunging. Dumber than dirt comment for an audience of 911 truth nuts.
OMG, you present 911 truth nuts video for what reason? lol, a dumbed down video to fool those who never flew...

And guess what... the last five seconds of pitch, are a plunge, over normal pitch angle,... -5.3, -5.6, -5.6, -3.2, -1.9... No wonder Hani accelerated from 300 knots to 483.5 knots... he was holding a steep angle...
But in the video you liked once, the idiot pilots take a toy plane and never think about the pitch angle... as they imply 10 to 20 degree approaches which they never did as pilots, not thinking at all as they spew Bar Room at best BS... So Hani did plunge a little...
 
Last edited:
For the record Java, ground effect is only significant at slow speeds. The faster you go, the less the effect of ground effect. At 500mph, there would be basically none.
 
For the record Java, ground effect is only significant at slow speeds. The faster you go, the less the effect of ground effect. At 500mph, there would be basically none.

A good explanation, prompted by 9/11 Truther claims, can be found here:
http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/conspiracy/q0274.shtml

Written almost 10 years ago by Jeffrey A. Scott, "an aerospace engineer specializing in aerodynamic analysis and conceptual design. His primary expertise is applying aerodynamic prediction software and trajectory simulations to flight test programs and flight clearance efforts. Among the projects Jeff has supported during his career are airframe design, flight testing, guidance and control software, modeling & simulation, system engineering, performance predictions, wind tunnel tests, high-speed propulsion research, and aviation safety. Jeff is the chief editor of Aerospaceweb.org". I found it easily on Google with the search string "ground effect at high speed".

Truthers have no excuse not to know this stuff when they make claims about "ground effect at Pentagon" - they are collectively in wilful ignorance and denial, and have been by their own choice for at least 10 years.

Karl Rader's piece on 911Myths is almost as old (earliest archived version on archive.org is from October 2006):
http://www.911myths.com/Ground_Effect.pdf
 
An aside

Does anyone know how they navigated to the Pentagon? Did they simply head East and hope for the Best?
 
Does anyone know how they navigated to the Pentagon? Did they simply head East and hope for the Best?

Very easily! They headed East and tuned in the Reagan VORTAC. Since they weren't blind once they got within 100 miles or so, all they then had to do was look for the Potomac and then the huge Pentagon. They also could see the Capital area and go from there. It was an incredibly easy task for them.
 
Does anyone know how they navigated to the Pentagon? Did they simply head East and hope for the Best?

All the aircraft that day had a fairly easy navigation challenge. AA 11 just had to turn around, head east and turn south when they found the Hudson - even then they could probably see NYC from a few hundred miles away on that CAVU day.

UA 175 just had to turn around, head east and they could have seen the smoke from AA 11's impact from a couple hundred miles away.

As Reheat pointed out, AA 77 just had to turn around, head east, and dial in Reagan National's beacon. These hijackers we not imbiciles. They did have more than a passing familiararity with an aircraft flight deck. Flying these aircraft was not difficult - design was to enhance comfort and ease for the pilots as much as it was for the passanger. Hydraulic-enhanced or fly-by-wire controls made it easy to move the flight controls and there qare only a few basic pieces of equipment that a hijacker bent on crashing the aircraft had to worry about - IFF, throttles, NAVAID selection, things like that - easily learned and located from the simulator sessions they had and/or from the manuals they had. This was not difficult.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom