Erm.The Dutch documentary's simulation shows the plane coming from a much higher angle, and it does not give any indications on how fast their simulated plane is going (doesn't look that fast). That is actually how I would reasonably expect a terrorist pilot to attack the Pentagon: To come in at a low angle and crash onto the roof. The simulation on Jesse Ventura's show is more accurate.
Your comment about the runways ignores another huge aspect - the speed of the aircraft. This is a POV video of a vehicle going 200 miles per hour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmNXCJt7K3Q&feature=youtu.be&?
Now triple that. Hanjour had to control a 757 at those speeds at sea level with severe turbulence while feet away from the ground. Any slightly wrong movement on the control stick and the plane crashes on the ground. What a stupid and illogical maneuver from someone who's life mission depended on hitting the Pentagon - he had to have at least known the dangers to going near or above the VMO. Suspiciously lucky, but like I said, the prevailing theory in my head is that Hani really did do it.
what severe turbulence?
Have you heard of Ground Effect?
Erm.
No.
And he did crash, which was his intention. Actually hitting the Pentagon was a bonus.
OK so who else would be flying it andy why and how?
How did you determine it was coming in from a higher angle?The Dutch documentary's simulation shows the plane coming from a much higher angle,
Looks can be deceiving.and it does not give any indications on how fast their simulated plane is going (doesn't look that fast).
You cannot pretend that pilots have explained to you already why you are wrong - why the reasonable approach is actually coming in at a low angle.That is actually how I would reasonably expect a terrorist pilot to attack the Pentagon: To come in at a high angle and probably crash onto the roof.
Accurate to what?The simulation on Jesse Ventura's show is more accurate.
Thank you. This video illustrates nicely that vehicles can be operated to within a few inches (or a fraction of their width) of accuracy even very close to their physical limits.Your comment about the runways ignores another huge aspect - the speed of the aircraft. This is a POV video of a vehicle going 200 miles per hour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmNXCJt7K3Q&feature=youtu.be&?
Why is "sea level" an issue here? It isn't! You made that up!Now triple that. Hanjour had to control a 757 at those speeds at sea level with severe turbulence while feet away from the ground.
Again - for the umpteenth time you commit the Texas Sharpshooter FallacyAny slightly wrong movement on the control stick and the plane crashes on the ground. What a stupid and illogical maneuver from someone who's life mission depended on hitting the Pentagon - he had to have at least known the dangers to going near or above the VMO. Suspiciously lucky, but like I said, the prevailing theory in my head is that Hani really did do it.
So, Flight 77 would not have experienced turbulence like that?
If Flight 77 would not have experienced severe turbulence while approaching The Pentagon at sea level, I'm open to learning ...
If Flight 77 would not have experienced severe turbulence while approaching The Pentagon at sea level, I'm open to learning. The Wikipedia page on ground effect seems to assume it's not talking about a 757 over VMO at sea level.
How did you determine it was coming in from a higher angle?
Looks can be deceiving.
You cannot pretend that pilots have explained to you already why you are wrong - why the reasonable approach is actually coming in at a low angle.
Because pilots have explained to you why the reasonable approach is actually coming in at a low angle. Have you forgotten? Or do you think you know better than pilots what is a reasonable way to fly a plane?
The word "reasoable" means, literally, that you can provide reasons. Pilots provided you with the following reasons why not to approach from a high angle:
What is wrong with these reasons? Please provide reasons that hold up to scrutiny by a real heavy jet pilot like beachnut!
- You cannot control velocity sufficiently if your descent angle is > 4°
- If you see you are about to miss, you cannot pull up and turn for a second approach
Or admit that your amateur guess is not, in fact, "reasonable", as you cannot, in fact, provide good reasons.
Accurate to what?
You have not addressed the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy - which you might also call the "fallacy from accuracy". No accuracy is required to hit the Pentagon, as the Pentagon is HUGE. Many many many paths into the Pentagon are possible coming from the 270° loop, all of which are equally good if you want to crash into the Pentagon.
Please address now the argument that you present an example of the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy!
Please do not dodge any longer the explanation that you are committing the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy!
Thank you. This video illustrates nicely that vehicles can be operated to within a few inches (or a fraction of their width) of accuracy even very close to their physical limits.
I am sure you will agree that if that race bike driver intended to crash into a building along the route, he would have abslutely no problem whatsover hitting it, right? Right? <- Do not dodge this yes/no question! Answer it straight and honestly with yes, no, or the "don't know" weasle option!
Why is "sea level" an issue here? It isn't! You made that up!
What "severe turbulences"? There were absolutely none whatsoever! You made that up!!
Feet away? How many feet away? Until a second before impact, he was many man many many feet way from the ground. You made that "control ... while feet away from the ground" up!
Why do you make up stuff? Why do you invent claims of fact that are not true?
Again - for the umpteenth time you commit the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy
Stop committing the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy!
Read up on the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy!
Here is a link to the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_sharpshooter_fallacy
Please discuss the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy in your next reply!
Do not forget to address the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy and how you commit the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy and how you plan to avoid in the future to commit the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy
I hope it is clear to you now that I see, we all see you committing the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy, and that therefore the smart thing for you is to try to understand what the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy is, and to think hard about the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy.
I can see that every response I give, it pushes this thread back on the top of the "9/11 Conspiracy Theories" section, and also I never asked for my own split-thread so I think I'll stop replying now because this subject isn't that important to me.
...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZbUCoVEVsU&t=5m21s Their simulation definitely appears to be coming in at a higher angle and slower than 530 mph. Compare that to how low it was flying here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVDdjLQkUV8. The Jesse Ventura show tries to keep low to the ground and the two pilots can never get it right.
...
...
Could you hit the side of a large building with a motorcycle traveling 540 mph? I don't know, I wouldn't bet on it. ...
I think I'll stop replying now because this subject isn't that important to me.
...A pilot on Italian television voiced the opinion that it would be much better to just come in at a high angle and crash onto the roof: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVDdjLQkUV8 ...
It was explained to me by pilots who spend a good portion of their time arguing on the internet about conspiracy theories. A pilot on Italian television voiced the opinion that it would be much better to just come in at a high angle and crash onto the roof: