Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

...you're speculating that the aircraft would have eventually broken apart. I find it equally likely the aircraft didn't break apart because it was not the standard 767-200 allegedly used.

That is why you are a Truther: You assign equal likelihood to the entirely trivial, obviously true, and to the ridiculously contrived, unnecessarily complex, unevidenced fever dream.
 
Are you aware that Mach number refers to different speeds depending on air density? ...

This is essentially false. In an ideal gas, density has no influence on speed of sound / Mach number; in air (which is not an ideal gas), the influence is negligibly small. Humidity plays a somewhat greater, but still small role.

Much more important is temperature. Speed of sound is higher on the ground than at cruising altitude because it's colder up there.
At +20 °C near ground: 343 m/s
At -50 °C (cruising alt): 301 m/s
 
Based on CITs work, I think the passenger jet performed a flyover and was likely landed at Reagan. A pyrotechnic explosion along the perimeter would have concealed the flyover from the majority of potential witnesses west of the building. I think this event was the large plane that most people saw. The other plane, which was tracked by radar until impact was likely some kind of smaller drone and was delivered to the building to deposit pieces of itself in a deliberate collision to facilitate coverup of the initial flyover.


We were told that the majority of the 'windowed' plane vaporized in the collision, how physically possible is that? It seems much more likely to me that the 757 performed a flyover. YMMV

MMMV indeed. I'm not a crackpot.
 
This is essentially false. In an ideal gas, density has no influence on speed of sound / Mach number; in air (which is not an ideal gas), the influence is negligibly small. Humidity plays a somewhat greater, but still small role.

Much more important is temperature. Speed of sound is higher on the ground than at cruising altitude because it's colder up there.
At +20 °C near ground: 343 m/s
At -50 °C (cruising alt): 301 m/s

This is correct. I'm glad you corrected that mistake. I saw it yesterday, but didn't have time to post. Outside Air Temperature (OAT) is the only variable parameter that is calculated in determining Mach.

I'm being thoroughly entertained by this exchange. It's extremely difficult for me to believe that anyone buys all of this in this day and age. Heck, just a referral to a ton of material is all that's needed to defeated this crap. Why waste time typing post after post again. It's all been examined, recorded and repeated ad nauseum numerous times before.
 
This is essentially false. In an ideal gas, density has no influence on speed of sound / Mach number; in air (which is not an ideal gas), the influence is negligibly small. Humidity plays a somewhat greater, but still small role.
That's right. My bad. I was misled by a false recollection which was "confirmed" by this sentence from Wikipedia:

The local speed of sound, and thereby the Mach number, depends on the condition of the surrounding medium, in particular the temperature and pressure.
​
 
Probably easiest and most refreshing to just acknowledge the Cleveland landing.

YMMV

Why would anyone have to prove the plane didn't land in Cleveland? You have shown no evidence it actually did, do you have any?

Based on CITs work, I think the passenger jet performed a flyover and was likely landed at Reagan.

Do you have any actually evidence to support this belief? The number of people needed to cover-up this scheme is staggering.

Show that you are not just a troll that get's off on attention and back-up your assertions (any of them). I bet you won't. :rolleyes:
 
Most people require overwhelming evidence to go against an accepted theory that's backed by ample contrary evidence.

Your approach (and that of most Truthers) is to start with an extravagant counter-theory backed by nothing but speculation, then demand overwhelming contrary evidence. Then, often, reject that very evidence.

Doesn't it occur to you that the tail is wagging your dog? That the planes were controlled by hijackers is the default position, and all evidence supports it. Why do you actively look for reasons to disbelieve? Why were you ever closed to the planes being controlled by hijackers?


In other words, the prevailing theory in my head is that the planes were controlled by the Hijacker pilots.
 
In other words, the prevailing theory in my head is that the planes were controlled by the Hijacker pilots.

That is a dodge. In post #3 you posted the question had anyone cranked this scenario on a sim. What you least expected were a motley collection of actual pilots and anyone who actually had done so on the real deal. Your argument which you thought was a "killer argument" got floored the minute that the answer was "Why yes, we have and it is terribly easy to do with no training at all".

Having received the answer you really didn't want or expect, you bailed and posted copiously on other CT threads. Now, you return to this one hoping that everybody will have forgotten your failure.

Is not going to happen.
 
In other words, the prevailing theory in my head is that the planes were controlled by the Hijacker pilots.

No. The overwhelmingly likely theory - supported by copious evidence - is that the planes were controlled by hijacker pilots. I accept this theory because it's evidenced, not because it's just 'something in my head' that I want to believe.

Nitpicking details (nitpicking which often turning out to be totally wrong, as here) doesn't carry the weight to overturn the official explanation. You need something remarkably strong, and you're not presenting it. What you're demonstrating is a desire to believe in something different, despite evidence showing you to be wrong.

Address the evidence that opposes your beliefs. Plenty of it has been presented here.
 
That is a dodge. In post #3 you posted the question had anyone cranked this scenario on a sim. What you least expected were a motley collection of actual pilots and anyone who actually had done so on the real deal. Your argument which you thought was a "killer argument" got floored the minute that the answer was "Why yes, we have and it is terribly easy to do with no training at all".

Having received the answer you really didn't want or expect, you bailed and posted copiously on other CT threads. Now, you return to this one hoping that everybody will have forgotten your failure.

Is not going to happen.

I was never 100% convinced of either side. Skepticism often means rarely being 100% convinced of anything. I will not be bullied into zealously defending one side so that you can turn around and say that I am unskeptical.
 
Last edited:
I was never 100% convinced of either side. Skepticism often means rarely being 100% convinced of anything. I will not be bullied into zealously defending one side so that you can turn around and say that I am unskeptical.

That is an...odd...characterization of "skepticism".

You also appear to be unclear about the meaning of "bullying".
 
This is where you do err. You appear to have misspelled "backed by evidence"...

Is there a cockpit voice recording of any plane used on 9/11 except for the one that crashed and never hit it's target? No. And the rest of the flights had very little phone calls compared to Flight 93, so it's less clear what exactly was happening in flight 11,175 and 77. It can only be deduced that the hijacker pilots flew the planes. Like I said in the very beginning, me nor my significant other have any good reason to question if the hijackers were actually on the planes.
 
Is there a cockpit voice recording of any plane used on 9/11 except for the one that crashed and never hit it's target? No. And the rest of the flights had very little phone calls compared to Flight 93, so it's less clear what exactly was happening in flight 11,175 and 77. It can only be deduced that the hijacker pilots flew the planes. Like I said in the very beginning, me nor my significant other have any good reason to question if the hijackers were actually on the planes.

No, you simply dodge the matter at hand in this thread when caught out in favour of baloney in other threads. This is not a new tactic.

So let us put a fork in it.

Do you now accept that flying those planes into those targets was a trivial exercise even for a novice?

My bet is on equivocation as an answer.
 
Perhaps, if you think real hard, focus on the facts, you can figure out why flt 93 passengers made more phone calls than the three earlier flights.

As for CVR, yes and to that there is a resounding "so?".
 
That is an...odd...characterization of "skepticism".

You also appear to be unclear about the meaning of "bullying".

^^this^^
Skepticism is the examining of the evidence for a theory or argument and following where the evidence goes. It is not a perpetual state of "I just don't know", and saddle sores from straddling the fence.
 
MicahJava,

you originally asked if anyone had done a full flight simulation and managed to crash into the Pentagon.

I showed you one such demonstration, where a pilot whith only small plane experience did exactly that: Fly a 757 on a full simulator into the Pentagon in three out of three tries.

You acknowledged having seen this evidence.
However, you said that the simulation did not exactly replicate the actual flight 77, and did not hit in the same spot.

Now, I and others have pointed out that there is no good reason to assume that the pilot intended to hit the bulding in just that spot flying just that path; that instead it is more than plausible that the pilot merely intended to hit the Pentagon anywhere, and that the actual spot he hit is more or less coincidence.
You have been informed that your objection is a classic example of the so-called "Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy" (<- click me, I am a link to Wikipedia).
Have you read the article, and thought about why we would call your objection an example of the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy? Do you understand now that the exact flight path and impact spot are arbitrary as long as the pilot crashed anywhere into the Pentagon?


Also, I explained to you that flying a plane that is already airborne is - must be! - very easy: It essentially flies whereever you direct it to fly by pointing the joy stick up/down, left/right. Pilots routinely hit the cented of runways narrower than the WTC buildings, and at an altitude more tightly controlled than the height of the Pentagon.
In other words: Once you got the building roughly in front of you somewhere, hitting it is child's play (quite literally - a child could do it with almost no training whatsoever, it is really that easy. I could do it. You could do it!)
Could you please comment on this? Do you understand why flying a passenger plane must be really very easy?
 
Is there a cockpit voice recording of any plane used on 9/11 except for the one that crashed and never hit it's target? No. And the rest of the flights had very little phone calls compared to Flight 93, so it's less clear what exactly was happening in flight 11,175 and 77. It can only be deduced that the hijacker pilots flew the planes. Like I said in the very beginning, me nor my significant other have any good reason to question if the hijackers were actually on the planes.

Again, you do err. Here you appear to have left out the phrase, "...from the available evidence..."
 
MicahJava,

you originally asked if anyone had done a full flight simulation and managed to crash into the Pentagon.

I showed you one such demonstration, where a pilot whith only small plane experience did exactly that: Fly a 757 on a full simulator into the Pentagon in three out of three tries.

You acknowledged having seen this evidence.
However, you said that the simulation did not exactly replicate the actual flight 77, and did not hit in the same spot.

Now, I and others have pointed out that there is no good reason to assume that the pilot intended to hit the bulding in just that spot flying just that path; that instead it is more than plausible that the pilot merely intended to hit the Pentagon anywhere, and that the actual spot he hit is more or less coincidence.
You have been informed that your objection is a classic example of the so-called "Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy" (<- click me, I am a link to Wikipedia).
Have you read the article, and thought about why we would call your objection an example of the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy? Do you understand now that the exact flight path and impact spot are arbitrary as long as the pilot crashed anywhere into the Pentagon?


Also, I explained to you that flying a plane that is already airborne is - must be! - very easy: It essentially flies whereever you direct it to fly by pointing the joy stick up/down, left/right. Pilots routinely hit the cented of runways narrower than the WTC buildings, and at an altitude more tightly controlled than the height of the Pentagon.
In other words: Once you got the building roughly in front of you somewhere, hitting it is child's play (quite literally - a child could do it with almost no training whatsoever, it is really that easy. I could do it. You could do it!)
Could you please comment on this? Do you understand why flying a passenger plane must be really very easy?

The Dutch documentary's simulation shows the plane coming from a much higher angle, and it does not give any indications on how fast their simulated plane is going (doesn't look that fast). That is actually how I would reasonably expect a terrorist pilot to attack the Pentagon: To come in at a high angle and probably crash onto the roof. The simulation on Jesse Ventura's show is more accurate.

Your comment about the runways ignores another huge aspect - the speed of the aircraft. This is a POV video of a vehicle going 200 miles per hour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmNXCJt7K3Q&feature=youtu.be&?

Now triple that. Hanjour had to control a 757 at those speeds at sea level with severe turbulence while feet away from the ground. Any slightly wrong movement on the control stick and the plane crashes on the ground. What a stupid and illogical maneuver from someone who's life mission depended on hitting the Pentagon - he had to have at least known the dangers to going near or above the VMO. Suspiciously lucky, but like I said, the prevailing theory in my head is that Hani really did do it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom