Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

Does anyone know how they navigated to the Pentagon? Did they simply head East and hope for the Best?
After the terrorists took over, they turned east, with a heading of 90 degrees for 60 miles.

At 13:01 one VOR was set to 111.0 DCA, the VOR right next to the Pentagon, the VOR was 1.5 miles from the Pentagon. Turn the aircraft to follow the arrow... A pilot skill taught from the beginning; we have to do cross-country flying, and learn VOR.

They never had an exact course for DCA, they homed to DCA, pointing directly at the arrow and failing to add wind drift; winds out of 290 degrees drifted them 5 miles south after 15 minutes, then it appears they started to look for the Pentagon 30 miles out by turning slowly to the left.

They arrived too high for normal decent, and did a "360" to let down.

At 13:31:57 both VORs were set to 111.0. One was changed from 113.5 which is a VOR at Dulles.

I flew with a handheld GPS at the time to keep track of how far off course I was from the VOR airways I was flying.

Lol, dude. What are you even doing? Arguing on the internet is not as intense and serious as you're making it out to be. Read my last comment.
So spreading lies on the Internet is not serious; misleading others with lies is not serious? Did the lies about 911 the Boston bombers got from the Internet help them feel better about their acts, or is that not serious. Some people are dumb enough to act on the lies and BS 911 truth spews on the Internet. Why do you and 911 truth spread lies about 911?

But spreading lies about the murder of thousands is okay... Are you serious? 911 truth follower spreading lies you found on the Internet, and now you say it is not serious to lie. Your last comment is another lie, LIHOP, all supported with the same thing you used before, lies and BS.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, beachnut! I had not realized so far that VOR settings were recorded in the FDR data (Flight Data Recording).

Assuming that AClark, as well as any lurkers, may be novices to aviation terminology, allow me to try a translation to amateur speak:

"After the terrorists took over, they turned east, with a heading of 90 degrees for 60 miles."
That was a few minutes before 9 a.m. local time. AA77 was originally flying almost exactly west (heading around 270°). The hijackers started turning at 8:54, and were on the opposite course due east (90°) after 5 minutes.

"At 13:01 ..."
That time stamp is Universal Time (UT) - Greenwich Mean Time without daylight savings time shift in summer. That's 4 hours ahead of of Eastern Daylight Time (EDT) in september, so that's 9:01 local time.

"... one VOR was set to 111.0 DCA, the VOR right next to the Pentagon, the VOR was 1.5 miles from the Pentagon. Turn the aircraft to follow the arrow... A pilot skill taught from the beginning; we have to do cross-country flying, and learn VOR. "
A VOR is a radio beacon, DCA is the acronym for Reagan National Airport, just a stone throw from the Pentagon, and 111.0 is the radio frequency of Reagan's VOR. The pilot has a prominent instrument that show the direction to the VOR he dialed to. Actually, there are two such instruments, and the pilot can tune into two different beacons.

"They never had an exact course for DCA, they homed to DCA, pointing directly at the arrow and failing to add wind drift; winds out of 290 degrees drifted them 5 miles south after 15 minutes, then it appears they started to look for the Pentagon 30 miles out by turning slowly to the left."
I think you are speaking from memory here? By my eyeballing the FDR data, the adjusted the course from approximately 88° (almost exactly east) to nearly 75° (somewhat north of east) after about 8 minutes, and another ca. 5 minutes later to around 80°. None of that was particularly steady.
"winds out of 290 degrees" is wind blowing from west-northwest towards east-southeast.

"They arrived too high for normal decent, and did a "360" to let down. "
Yep - not fully 360 degrees loop, but nearly.

"At 13:31:57 both VORs were set to 111.0. One was changed from 113.5 which is a VOR at Dulles."
That (9:31:57 local time, about 6 minutes prior to crash) was quite exactly at the time Hanjour began the loop. Why would he select Dulles? The Pentagon should already have been visible?

ETA: The right VOR frequency 111.0 (Reagan) was selected at 08:57:15, in the middle of turning the plane around.
The left VOR frequency 113.5 (Dulles) was set at 9:08, from 117.4, and 117.1 and 117.7 prior to that. He played around with the VORleft a bit.
 
Last edited:
Thank you all for your answers.

That is such a weird question. It's easy.

It's not that weird. I had heard that the first plane in NYC followed the river, and guessed that the second just aimed for a plume of smoke :)

I don't know anything about navigating aeroplanes though, so I wondered how they could aim for the Pentagon which is relatively squat. I don't know how it looks from 20,000 feet, or how far you can see from a cockpit, so I thought I'd ask and find out.

I hope you aren't looking for some sort of secret hidden agenda, it was a simple straight forward question asked in ignorance.

Again, thanks all for the answers, I didn't know you could just dial things in like putting dinner in the microwave (simplified of course).

A
 
...

ETA: The right VOR frequency 111.0 (Reagan) was selected at 08:57:15, in the middle of turning the plane around.
The left VOR frequency 113.5 (Dulles) was set at 9:08, from 117.4, and 117.1 and 117.7 prior to that. He played around with the VORleft a bit.

The Nav system uses DME to get an accurate position... I suspect it is possible the NAV system cycles the VOR for the DME fixes.

The 111.0 DME did not "lock" on till 13:16, at 130 miles... And although 111.0 was set earlier, both set varied during the inbound flight.

VOR/DME can go up to 200 miles, or "more", but light of sight helps, and altitude helps for getting more range. But 111.0 for DME did not "lock" on until 130 miles.

I would use GPS, a handheld.

The pilots on each plane had time before 911 to figure out how to find their targets. They could use many methods. When I had less than 45 hours total time, I used VORs to find place which would be hard to see from a mile away. With the use of maps/charts, you could plan to find almost anything, anywhere in the USA.

Good job translating Beachy BS... thanks


Thank you all for your answers.

It's not that weird. I had heard that the first plane in NYC followed the river, and guessed that the second just aimed for a plume of smoke :)

I don't know anything about navigating aeroplanes though, so I wondered how they could aim for the Pentagon which is relatively squat. I don't know how it looks from 20,000 feet, or how far you can see from a cockpit, so I thought I'd ask and find out.

I hope you aren't looking for some sort of secret hidden agenda, it was a simple straight forward question asked in ignorance.

Again, thanks all for the answers, I didn't know you could just dial things in like putting dinner in the microwave (simplified of course).
A
VOR%20767%20757.jpg
Turn the knobs, set the freq. There are "2" VOR control panels, one on each side. This shows the Freq set to 116.8

You could use anything you want. Not a trained pilot, use a handheld GPS, already set with waypoint/fix/target - point the plane to your target; no flight training required.

IFR is for instrument flight rules, but sometimes as a joke, "IFR", is I Follow Roads... sometimes we did follow Roads as means to aid VFR flight... some instructors would turn off all Navigation Aids for the student and require a out of the cockpit navigation, all on way-points you could see and had to identify. Many times we would see planes following the Interstate when we returned from our training areas in USAF pilot training; we had to look out and avoid the planes we knew might be following the Interstate.

You can see as far as something on the horizon is recognizable. At night we can see ramp lights over 200 miles away if you are high enough. At 45,000 feet (be sure not to put in a "," if using a calculator for stuff in some countries, thus 45,000 is 45.0 - added BS for the day) you can see stuff up to 260 miles.

At 20,000 feet you can see stuff 173 miles away. The mall in DC which is two miles long, might stand out from a distance. Baltimore was only 60 miles away when 77 had a heading toward Baltimore for 14 miles; maybe the suicide pilots thought the big city was DC instead, until they checked VOR, DME, or got a visual of the Pentagon only 25 miles away.
 
Last edited:
The Nav system uses DME to get an accurate position... I suspect it is possible the NAV system cycles the VOR for the DME fixes.

The 111.0 DME did not "lock" on till 13:16, at 130 miles... And although 111.0 was set earlier, both set varied during the inbound flight.

VOR/DME can go up to 200 miles, or "more", but light of sight helps, and altitude helps for getting more range. But 111.0 for DME did not "lock" on until 130 miles.

I would use GPS, a handheld.

The pilots on each plane had time before 911 to figure out how to find their targets. They could use many methods. When I had less than 45 hours total time, I used VORs to find place which would be hard to see from a mile away. With the use of maps/charts, you could plan to find almost anything, anywhere in the USA.

Good job translating Beachy BS... thanks



[qimg]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/VOR%20767%20757.jpg[/qimg] Turn the knobs, set the freq. There are "2" VOR control panels, one on each side. This shows the Freq set to 116.8

You could use anything you want. Not a trained pilot, use a handheld GPS, already set with waypoint/fix/target - point the plane to your target; no flight training required.

IFR is for instrument flight rules, but sometimes as a joke, "IFR", is I Follow Roads... sometimes we did follow Roads as means to aid VFR flight... some instructors would turn off all Navigation Aids for the student and require a out of the cockpit navigation, all on way-points you could see and had to identify. Many times we would see planes following the Interstate when we returned from our training areas in USAF pilot training; we had to look out and avoid the planes we knew might be following the Interstate.

You can see as far as something on the horizon is recognizable. At night we can see ramp lights over 200 miles away if you are high enough. At 45,000 feet (be sure not to put in a "," if using a calculator for stuff in some countries, thus 45,000 is 45.0 - added BS for the day) you can see stuff up to 260 miles.

At 20,000 feet you can see stuff 173 miles away. The mall in DC which is two miles long, might stand out from a distance. Baltimore was only 60 miles away when 77 had a heading toward Baltimore for 14 miles; maybe the suicide pilots thought the big city was DC instead, until they checked VOR, DME, or got a visual of the Pentagon only 25 miles away.
If I may lend a machete to the intellectual thicket. Truthers are confused by TLAs. It is all very well that you or I know full well the meaning of VOR, DME, NAV1, NAV2 and so forth. There are those who have not the foggiest what those actually mean.

The genuine will simply ask. "I am not sure what that term means" and I applaud that. It takes a certain courage to do so.

The cranks, however, well that is a whole other ball of baloney. Unforgivable IMHO because it is intentional deception.
 
If I may lend a machete to the intellectual thicket. Truthers are confused by TLAs. It is all very well that you or I know full well the meaning of VOR, DME, NAV1, NAV2 and so forth. There are those who have not the foggiest what those actually mean.

The genuine will simply ask. "I am not sure what that term means" and I applaud that. It takes a certain courage to do so.

The cranks, however, well that is a whole other ball of baloney. Unforgivable IMHO because it is intentional deception.

For the record, I consider myself to be a troofer, whether that be God, the big bang, dinosaurs, 9/11, WMD in Iraq or what really happened to Bruce Lee and Brandon Lee. I will caveat that, however, in that I do not automatically follow conspiracies, and I do not rate things on how far they deviate from the official narrative. I have found myself arguing against both sides (sometimes at the same time) :blush:

Usually, I will ask if there is something I do not know, or I will present something as "This is what I have found, please review it and reply" and actually mean it (even if I forget to say it). I know that you will have had to deal with many crazies over the years, and some of you may have little patience for noobs. I would consider myself to be an International Skeptic in the literal sense of the word.
 
For the record, I consider myself to be a troofer, whether that be God, the big bang, dinosaurs, 9/11, WMD in Iraq or what really happened to Bruce Lee and Brandon Lee. I will caveat that, however, in that I do not automatically follow conspiracies..................

Nothing wrong with questioning the status quo, It's to what degree you require evidence for as to evidence against. "Truthers" expect evidence to be rock solid in support of things they don't believe with no possible voids while not expecting any continuity for their own.

As a 9/11 "truther", where do you stand as far as issues that actually have clear evidence?

Surely, "controlled demolition" is off the table.
 
Last edited:
... I have found myself arguing against both sides (sometimes at the same time) :blush:
... I would consider myself to be an International Skeptic in the literal sense of the word.

There are not two sides to 911. There is one side, called reality. The reality based version of 911 is the only side backed with evidence, facts, and what happened.

911 truth is a fantasy based movement, mainly based on the ignorance of the followers. Not a single claim from 911 truth is based on evidence.

We are skeptical of something when there is no evidence. 911 truth has no evidence.

What happened on this topic? 911 truth lies, saying terrorist pilots did some super-duper maneuver experienced pilots can't do; or can't do the first time. Calling the approach to DC a loopdeloop is pure BS. 911 truth has pilots who claim they can't do it, they can't fly the very type of jet to hit the target, a jet they claim they flew... I have never met a pilot who should be a pilot who can't beat any flying feat done by a another pilot... we may not be type A people, but we are type A people when we strap-on the jet. I find the pilots who support the BS about 911 flying to be idiots on the topic,spewing BS, and are the Type A/BS people. Must be some ego problem, maybe they are bigots, or just plain idiots on the topic. Or, they made up their minds without checking Radar data, FDR (flight data recorder), and ignore the DNA, witnesses, etc. Then the worse 911 truth flight liars, are the ones who take witnesses and quote mine them.

Anyway, if you find a valid 911 truth claim, RUN, don't walk to the nearest favorite Newspaper and take all that overwhelming evidence to support the for-sure claim of 911 truth, team with them to earn the biggest Pulitzer since Watergate.

With old men like Richard Clarke claiming they could have stopped 911 "IF", or blaming Bush for the fact Clarke did not do his job to stop 911. The hindsight BS is another path and source of fuel for 911 truth BS. The same is true of 911 truth pilots, usually old guys with BS.
 
With old men like Richard Clarke claiming they could have stopped 911 "IF", or blaming Bush for the fact Clarke did not do his job to stop 911.

Sorry beach, but for the first time I must disagree with you. Clarke was doing everything in his power to get action against al Qaeda. For years. The bush admin were not willing to listen. Even up to the September 4th principles meeting, CIA and Clarke were trying desperately to get Bush to take action against al Qaeda. The Bush admin did nothing. Clarke is not to blame, the Bush admin is, through lack of action.
 
If I may lend a machete to the intellectual thicket. Truthers are confused by TLAs. It is all very well that you or I know full well the meaning of VOR, DME, NAV1, NAV2 and so forth. There are those who have not the foggiest what those actually mean.

I think the Cliff Notes version goes something like, "Hani Hanjour was a trained pilot with a commercial pilot's license for multi-engined aircraft, and had the full range of navigational aids available to him." The Pentagon is almost directly under the approach path to Ronald Reagan Airport, so it's somewhere that people with the same qualifications and equipment as Hanjour navigate successfully to many times a day. As such, it's entirely unremarkable that he was able to do so, whatever the fine details of how he did it. And, OK, he was a piss-poor pilot, but as the old joke goes: What do you call someone who graduated bottom of the class in med school? Doctor.

Dave
 
Bugger, I was halfway through a long reply and then the board lost it. Copying this from Notepad now :(

As we are wandering off topic, please feel free to split this thread.

As always, unless otherwise stated, these are my opinions, and are open to review if challenged by new (to me) evidence.


Sorry beach, but there are three sides, and many subsides (very bad pun intended). Only one of them is the truth, and no

one as yet has placed it out there in its entirety.


Let me start off with a fact. The official narrative, as presented by FEMA, NIST and the 9/11 commission has omissions, and

contains falsehoods, theories and speculations. If we cannot agree on that, then there is no discussion. Facts do not

care about or require your agreement, they just are.


I'll follow that up with an opinion. Truthers are winning the PR war. Videos like Loose Change are slick and compelling.

Fact or Fantasy, they are entertaining, very much like a Hollywood "True Story". Titanic, Pearl Harbour etc may not have

been historically accurate, but they reached wider audiences and made more money than any documentary on the same subjects.

When it comes to hearts and minds, the approach of silence, secrecy, smugness and scorn does not get the public vote.

The official narrative offers a relatively straight forward scenario, backed by some theories, however their story is

constructed as such that when one challenges one aspect of it, it casts doubt upon many others. It's like the official

story is a narrative version of building 7. If a truther comes along and removes column 79, the entire fabrication

collapses into its own footprint at free-fall speeds.


Is CD off the table? No. FEMA avoided the subject, the commission dropped the ball, and NIST had too many opposing

answers to be credible, and they denied testimony that was in the public domain. Both Bailey and ARUP rely too heavily on

Nordenson, who appears to manipulate the data towards the required outcome, a very unscientific approach.
Opposing them is history, gravity, testimony and physical evidence, as well as substantial circumstantial evidence.

The fact that all crime scenes were sterilised very quickly after the event, that evidence was destroyed, confiscated and

denied independent scrutiny is indisputable.


The reason that 9/11 will not simply go away, is that it is a pivotal point in modern history. On that day the world

changed. 9/11 has been the handle on a shovel that has moved a lot of **** since. I'm in the UK, we see things

differently to those in the US, but we are also seeing some things the same. We did not want to go to war in Iraq,

millions took to the streets in protest (a million in the UK is more significant than in the US). 9/11 and WMDs were the

governments trump card. We didn't believe them, but it was enough for them to satisfy themselves to pass the required

motions through the correct channels. We spent billions we could not afford so that wealthy businessmen could profit from

oil contracts. No WMDs were ever found, and Osama Bin Laden wasn't there training 1000s of terrorists. What has happened

is that we blew up a lot of innocent people, and created the next generation of would be terrorists. The world is less

safe.


Then, we all wandered into Afghanistan and blew up some more innocent people, made some more money for the rich few, and

inspired even more people to hate the West and want us dead. We didn't find any WMDs, OBL, or thousands of well trained

and well equipped terrorists poised to wipe out the West in fiery death.


Meanwhile, back at the ranch, civil liberties were being thrown out of the window. It is now almost a criminal offence to

be a passenger in an aircraft. You have to prove yourself innocent by the most invasive means possible. Rights of

assembly and protest are quashed, with brutal crackdowns on civilians by a militarised police force.


The US needs another civil war, for it seems that true to history, the men who came to replace the deposed oppressors are

even worse. Unrestrained capitalism is not a goal to strive for, it is something to be feared. You cannot shrink from

Islamic extremists while subjugating yourself to capitalist extremists, the whole problem with extremes is that you

either head back towards the middle, or you fall off the edge.


I don't expect to alter anyone's opinions, this is not a persuasive argument. I simply wish to express where I am coming

from. Perhaps one day I will sort through my thoughts and present them in a proper fashion, hell I might even write a

book, that seems to be the way to go :) On average, the world is not in a great place right now, and 9/11 is being used to

keep it that way.
 
Last edited:
Please edit your post to make it readable.

Click the "edit button" and the rest is easy.
 
Let me start off with a fact. The official narrative, as presented by FEMA, NIST and the 9/11 commission has omissions, and contains falsehoods, theories and speculations. If we cannot agree on that, then there is no discussion.

Then there is no discussion, because the thing you're quoting facts about does not, in the sense you claim it to, exist. The "official narrative" is no such thing; a series of reports has been compiled by experts to do their best to describe specific aspects of what happened and recommend changes to mitigate further similar happenstances. None of these reports is perfect, and by definition they must contain theories and speculations because our knowledge of events is not perfect.

I'll follow that up with an opinion. Truthers are winning the PR war.

And that opinion is utterly unsustainable. There is currently a US Presidential election campaign in its early stages, and the issue of what the truth movement claims to be the greatest act of treason in US history, perpetrated by its own government, is nowhere to be seen. Truthers are not just losing the PR war; nobody else is even aware they're fighting it. Discussions of 9/11 truth are confined to echo chambers where opinions are strictly regulated, and this forum. Nobody else cares.

The official narrative offers a relatively straight forward scenario, backed by some theories, however their story is constructed as such that when one challenges one aspect of it, it casts doubt upon many others. It's like the official story is a narrative version of building 7. If a truther comes along and removes column 79, the entire fabrication collapses into its own footprint at free-fall speeds.

And this is the standard conspiracy theorist's fallacy: if one aspect of "the official story" is called into question then the whole story must be rejected and replaced by a far less satisfactory explanation. Come up with a theory that better explains the events of 9/11 and you've got something to offer; at the moment, "the official story" explains all the actual events (as opposed to the made-up ones that are most commonly used to try to discredit it).

I'm in the UK,

So am I. Practically nobody cares here either.

Dave
 
Then there is no discussion, because the thing you're quoting facts about does not, in the sense you claim it to, exist. The "official narrative" is no such thing; a series of reports has been compiled by experts to do their best to describe specific aspects of what happened and recommend changes to mitigate further similar happenstances. None of these reports is perfect, and by definition they must contain theories and speculations because our knowledge of events is not perfect.

That is semantics. By definition these are the official narrative. The fact remains that they are not complete, as a consequence of which questions have arisen. Some ludicrous, others very pertinent. Free fall would not have been added into the report were it not raised as a question.


And that opinion is utterly unsustainable. There is currently a US Presidential election campaign in its early stages, and the issue of what the truth movement claims to be the greatest act of treason in US history, perpetrated by its own government, is nowhere to be seen. Truthers are not just losing the PR war; nobody else is even aware they're fighting it. Discussions of 9/11 truth are confined to echo chambers where opinions are strictly regulated, and this forum. Nobody else cares.

Not entirely true, you are welcome to your opinion, however I disagree with it. Life is not only what the popular media discusses moment to moment.


And this is the standard conspiracy theorist's fallacy: if one aspect of "the official story" is called into question then the whole story must be rejected and replaced by a far less satisfactory explanation. Come up with a theory that better explains the events of 9/11 and you've got something to offer; at the moment, "the official story" explains all the actual events (as opposed to the made-up ones that are most commonly used to try to discredit it).

This is a typical distraction technique that is often used to debunk opposing theories.
Disputing a sequence of events, especially interdependent ones can not be so easily dismissed. If C follows B follows A, and B is called into question, then so must all of the relationships and the sequence. That is not the same as "I dispute B therefore your whole alphabet is invalid".

Your stance of ""the official story" explains all the actual events" is opinion, and does not stand up to scrutiny. Does that not sound like "if one aspect is true, then all aspects must be true?"

So am I. Practically nobody cares here either.

Dave

It is not discussed in popular media, that is not the same thing.
 
Bugger, I was halfway through a long reply and then the board lost it. Copying this from Notepad now :(

Re-formated for ease of reading.

As we are wandering off topic, please feel free to split this thread.

As always, unless otherwise stated, these are my opinions, and are open to review if challenged by new (to me) evidence.


Sorry beach, but there are three sides, and many subsides (very bad pun intended). Only one of them is the truth, and no one as yet has placed it out there in its entirety.


Let me start off with a fact. The official narrative, as presented by FEMA, NIST and the 9/11 commission has omissions, and contains falsehoods, theories and speculations. If we cannot agree on that, then there is no discussion. Facts do not care about or require your agreement, they just are.


I'll follow that up with an opinion. Truthers are winning the PR war. Videos like Loose Change are slick and compelling. Fact or Fantasy, they are entertaining, very much like a Hollywood "True Story". Titanic, Pearl Harbour etc may not have been historically accurate, but they reached wider audiences and made more money than any documentary on the same subjects. When it comes to hearts and minds, the approach of silence, secrecy, smugness and scorn does not get the public vote.

The official narrative offers a relatively straight forward scenario, backed by some theories, however their story is constructed as such that when one challenges one aspect of it, it casts doubt upon many others. It's like the official story is a narrative version of building 7. If a truther comes along and removes column 79, the entire fabrication collapses into its own footprint at free-fall speeds.


Is CD off the table? No. FEMA avoided the subject, the commission dropped the ball, and NIST had too many opposing answers to be credible, and they denied testimony that was in the public domain. Both Bailey and ARUP rely too heavily on Nordenson, who appears to manipulate the data towards the required outcome, a very unscientific approach.
Opposing them is history, gravity, testimony and physical evidence, as well as substantial circumstantial evidence.

The fact that all crime scenes were sterilised very quickly after the event, that evidence was destroyed, confiscated and denied independent scrutiny is indisputable.


The reason that 9/11 will not simply go away, is that it is a pivotal point in modern history. On that day the world changed. 9/11 has been the handle on a shovel that has moved a lot of **** since. I'm in the UK, we see things differently to those in the US, but we are also seeing some things the same. We did not want to go to war in Iraq, millions took to the streets in protest (a million in the UK is more significant than in the US). 9/11 and WMDs were the governments trump card. We didn't believe them, but it was enough for them to satisfy themselves to pass the required motions through the correct channels. We spent billions we could not afford so that wealthy businessmen could profit from oil contracts. No WMDs were ever found, and Osama Bin Laden wasn't there training 1000s of terrorists. What has happened is that we blew up a lot of innocent people, and created the next generation of would be terrorists. The world is less safe.


Then, we all wandered into Afghanistan and blew up some more innocent people, made some more money for the rich few, and inspired even more people to hate the West and want us dead. We didn't find any WMDs, OBL, or thousands of well trained and well equipped terrorists poised to wipe out the West in fiery death.


Meanwhile, back at the ranch, civil liberties were being thrown out of the window. It is now almost a criminal offence to be a passenger in an aircraft. You have to prove yourself innocent by the most invasive means possible. Rights of assembly and protest are quashed, with brutal crackdowns on civilians by a militarised police force.


The US needs another civil war, for it seems that true to history, the men who came to replace the deposed oppressors are even worse. Unrestrained capitalism is not a goal to strive for, it is something to be feared. You cannot shrink from Islamic extremists while subjugating yourself to capitalist extremists, the whole problem with extremes is that you either head back towards the middle, or you fall off the edge.


I don't expect to alter anyone's opinions, this is not a persuasive argument. I simply wish to express where I am coming from. Perhaps one day I will sort through my thoughts and present them in a proper fashion, hell I might even write a book, that seems to be the way to go :) On average, the world is not in a great place right now, and 9/11 is being used to keep it that way.
 
Nice story.

I am in the UK.
I don't know anyone that has sny opinion on 9/11
I have never met anyone apart from a couple of loons that believe every conspiracy or any USA story on the go who thinks it was anything but terrorists crashing jets.
 
Nice story.

I am in the UK.
I don't know anyone that has sny opinion on 9/11
I have never met anyone apart from a couple of loons that believe every conspiracy or any USA story on the go who thinks it was anything but terrorists crashing jets.

Apart from you, Dave and I, and the couple of loons, and the ones who agree with the official narrative.

Such a small post to be so full of contradictions.
 
That is semantics.

No, not at all. By describing the collection of reports as "the official story" you are trying to set it in the light of a full and authoritative account of events which must be accepted in full or rejected in full. In reality it is no such thing; it's simply the best efforts, after the event, to determine as much as can be known of what happened. As such, it's bound to have errors and be incomplete. Conspiracy theorists use the term "the official story" to bolster an invalid falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus standard of proof, while evading any similar level of scrutiny of their own claims.

Free fall would not have been added into the report were it not raised as a question.

But the question has been answered, again to the best of the abilities of those answering it. The counter-claims of other mechanisms do not survive even casual scrutiny.

Not entirely true, you are welcome to your opinion, however I disagree with it. Life is not only what the popular media discusses moment to moment.

So on the one hand you claim that the truth movement is winning the PR war, and on the other that it is excluded from the public eye. If your opinion had any weight, it would be impossible to exclude such a crucial issue from the popular media in the middle of an election campaign. The reason that it's not being covered is that practically nobody cares about it, certainly not enough to campaign on it.

Your stance of ""the official story" explains all the actual events" is opinion, and does not stand up to scrutiny.

So you say, yet I have never seen any plausible exceptions, because all the ones that have been offered fail to stand up to scrutiny. If you think you have any, please start or join threads as appropriate to discuss them, but be aware that an enormous amount of ground has been covered already in fifteen years.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom