Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

MicahJava

Illuminator
Joined
Jan 26, 2016
Messages
3,041
911 truth questions were answered on 911.

To remain anonymous and murder, don't use a plane, FAA requires a passenger manifest, and your DNA becomes part of the crime scene. Even the FBI figured out 911 in a day, and Flight 93 Passengers figured out 911 in minutes; to take over 14 years is sad.

But as for relationships, it would help if both were 911 truth followers, thus a match made where both believe in BS and false claims based on ignorance.

I don't think either of us doubt that the hijackers were on the planes. I would even have no problem with them controlling the planes except for the way the Pentagon was hit and how wedge one was renovated for blast/missile impacts. We've all seen the episode of Jesse Ventura's show where they try to replicate the flight path in the simulator, they just couldn't do it.


Split from here as a separate topic.
Posted By: zooterkin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think either of us doubt that the hijackers were on the planes. I would even have no problem with them controlling the planes except for the way the Pentagon was hit and how wedge one was renovated for blast/missile impacts. We've all seen the episode of Jesse Ventura's show where they try to replicate the flight path in the simulator, they just couldn't do it.

If you have any real questions about the Pentagon feel free to ask. I was there before, during and after.
 
If you have any real questions about the Pentagon feel free to ask. I was there before, during and after.

Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?

With The Pentagon basically being a giant bullseye from a terrorist's point of view, why would Hani Hanjour choose to attack the side?

Otherwise, I could just doubt that Hani would feel the need to loopdeloop around to hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts. He could've just hit the roof without risking precious minutes.
 
Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?

With The Pentagon basically being a giant bullseye from a terrorist's point of view, why would Hani Hanjour choose to attack the side?

Otherwise, I could just doubt that Hani would feel the need to loopdeloop around to hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts. He could've just hit the roof without risking precious minutes.

Others more knowledgeable than me might step in here, but I doubt that an airliner can be controlled in such a dive with any accuracy. There might also be issues with the plane being able to handle the forces created by the speed such a dive would produce without breaking up.

And hitting the reinforced side is a red herring. That was the one that presented itself when the plane was at a suitable height? There are only five of them, after all.
 
Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?

That's potentially a misleading question. Suppose I take a dice and roll it ten times, getting 6, 2, 5, 5, 1, 3, 2, 4, 1, 3, in that order. Will you be able to replicate that result? If not, does that mean that it's impossible, or even implausible, that I got those numbers?

The track followed by flight 77 was, according to the flight recorder data, the result of a poorly-controlled turn by a barely competent pilot, so it has quite a considerable amount of randomness to it. The fact that it's not possible to reproduce that random element to unlimited precision doesn't mean it couldn't have happened. But I'm sure that, if somebody tried, truthers would highlight every difference between the reproduction and the original and claim it meant that the original is impossible. This is, in effect, the Texas Sharpshooter fallacy, and the commonest invocation of it is along the lines of "How did Hanjour hit the Pentagon almost exactly at ground level without hitting the ground?" The answer is, that's just where he happened to hit it.

With The Pentagon basically being a giant bullseye from a terrorist's point of view, why would Hani Hanjour choose to attack the side?

Otherwise, I could just doubt that Hani would feel the need to loopdeloop around to hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts. He could've just hit the roof without risking precious minutes.

Because controlling a plane in a steep dive is actually very difficult. And also, he didn't "hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts," because there was no such thing. The Pentagon was renovated in wedges, and Hanjour hit the junction between the renovated wedge and one of the un-renovated ones. And he didn't "loopdeloop", he made a turn.

Incidentally, the odds of choosing a side that was half renovated were therefore 40%. Not exactly implausible.

Dave
 
That's potentially a misleading question. Suppose I take a dice and roll it ten times, getting 6, 2, 5, 5, 1, 3, 2, 4, 1, 3, in that order. Will you be able to replicate that result? If not, does that mean that it's impossible, or even implausible, that I got those numbers?

The track followed by flight 77 was, according to the flight recorder data, the result of a poorly-controlled turn by a barely competent pilot, so it has quite a considerable amount of randomness to it. The fact that it's not possible to reproduce that random element to unlimited precision doesn't mean it couldn't have happened. But I'm sure that, if somebody tried, truthers would highlight every difference between the reproduction and the original and claim it meant that the original is impossible. This is, in effect, the Texas Sharpshooter fallacy, and the commonest invocation of it is along the lines of "How did Hanjour hit the Pentagon almost exactly at ground level without hitting the ground?" The answer is, that's just where he happened to hit it.



Because controlling a plane in a steep dive is actually very difficult. And also, he didn't "hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts," because there was no such thing. The Pentagon was renovated in wedges, and Hanjour hit the junction between the renovated wedge and one of the un-renovated ones. And he didn't "loopdeloop", he made a turn.

Incidentally, the odds of choosing a side that was half renovated were therefore 40%. Not exactly implausible.

Dave

I don't know, if the justification for Hanjour's feats mostly rely on luck, then I think the remote-controlled hypothesis has more weight. The "Hani Hanjour" portion of September 11: The New Pearl Harbor responds to every one of your explanations quite well.

I don't know the logistics of that theory, though (unassuming jihadist hijackers themselves being hijacked by remote-control). Like I said, I'm open to the idea that the planes were manually controlled by jihadists, but flight 77 is the real kicker for me.
 
Last edited:
I don't know, if the justification for Hanjour's feats mostly rely on luck, then I think the remote-controlled hypothesis has more weight.

Try reading again and comprehending, because that wasn't what I said. Hanjour aimed at the building and hit it, and was just about a good enough pilot to do that. All the flight recorder data is consistent with a very poor pilot making a badly controlled turn, and I'm sure Beachnut will be along in a while to flesh out the details.

Dave
 
Others more knowledgeable than me might step in here, but I doubt that an airliner can be controlled in such a dive with any accuracy. There might also be issues with the plane being able to handle the forces created by the speed such a dive would produce without breaking up.

And hitting the reinforced side is a red herring. That was the one that presented itself when the plane was at a suitable height? There are only five of them, after all.

The "Programmed Flight Control" page on 911research.wtc7 does have sources that say that a Boeing 757 and 767 can be remote controlled with their "flight management computer system".

Unless the hijacker pilots couldn't see that well, they could have descended down to hit The Pentagon on the roof without having to pass it and make that turn.
 
Last edited:
Try reading again and comprehending, because that wasn't what I said. Hanjour aimed at the building and hit it, and was just about a good enough pilot to do that. All the flight recorder data is consistent with a very poor pilot making a badly controlled turn, and I'm sure Beachnut will be along in a while to flesh out the details.

Dave

You said that aiming right for the roof in a "steep dive" would be more difficult than hitting the side. The clips from Italian television in September 11: The New Pearl Harbor has experienced pilots giving the opposite opinion. Then, there's the part in Jesse Ventura's show where they couldn't get close to replicating the path of Flight 77 in a full motion flight simulator no matter how many times they tried. Since experiment is the arbitrator of competing hypotheses, more examples of full motion simulator experiments would be a better way of settling the question than carefully selected individuals giving their opinion (professional or not). In that sense, I probably shouldn't have even bothered commenting because nobody here would want to set up an experiment like that.
 
The "Programmed Flight Control" page on 911research.wtc7 does have sources that say that a Boeing 757 and 767 can be remote controlled with their "flight management computer system".

Not the planes of that era, iirc. The concept of remotely-controlling those planes has been debated and debunked here endlessly.

Unless the hijacker pilots couldn't see that well, they could have descended down to hit The Pentagon on the roof without having to pass it and make that turn.

Only in a steep dive, surely? In a steep-but-standard descent the tiniest error would have you miss the target. Coming in low is a much better plan.
 
You said that aiming right for the roof in a "steep dive" would be more difficult than hitting the side. The clips from Italian television in September 11: The New Pearl Harbor has experienced pilots giving the opposite opinion. Then, there's the part in Jesse Ventura's show where they couldn't get close to replicating the path of Flight 77 in a full motion flight simulator no matter how many times they tried. Since experiment is the arbitrator of competing hypotheses, more examples of full motion simulator experiments would be a better way of settling the question than carefully selected individuals giving their opinion (professional or not). In that sense, I probably shouldn't have even bothered commenting because nobody here would want to set up an experiment like that.

Who programmed the simulator, garbage in garbage out.
A simulator is just a computer you can program it to allow you to hit the building, or to make you miss.
A simulator is not an experiment unless the person programming it, replicates 100% the conditions of both the day, and the plane, that might not be possible.
 
Last edited:
You said that aiming right for the roof in a "steep dive" would be more difficult than hitting the side. The clips from Italian television in September 11: The New Pearl Harbor has experienced pilots giving the opposite opinion. Then, there's the part in Jesse Ventura's show where they couldn't get close to replicating the path of Flight 77 in a full motion flight simulator no matter how many times they tried. Since experiment is the arbitrator of competing hypotheses, more examples of full motion simulator experiments would be a better way of settling the question than carefully selected individuals giving their opinion (professional or not). In that sense, I probably shouldn't have even bothered commenting because nobody here would want to set up an experiment like that.
You're still missing Dave's central point, I think. Let's try it like this- if a major league baseball player hits a home run by knocking the ball entirely out of the park, and the ball glances off a light pole on its way, then lands in a particular spot in the parking lot, breaking a car's windshield, would you insist that, because that exact trajectory couldn't be replicated, down to the light pole and windshield, the original feat was impossible?

Do you see? You're appealing to a perfection in replication of a trajectory that wasn't, in detail, ever intended as that perfection. Hanjour had one aim- hit the building- and he did that; and that's all that really needs to be replicated.
 
Others more knowledgeable than me might step in here, but I doubt that an airliner can be controlled in such a dive with any accuracy. There might also be issues with the plane being able to handle the forces created by the speed such a dive would produce without breaking up.

And hitting the reinforced side is a red herring. That was the one that presented itself when the plane was at a suitable height? There are only five of them, after all.

I can't speak to the maneuverability of the plane, but I do know quite a bit about what the area around the Pentagon looks like, and quite frankly on 9/11, the side that Hanjour hit was probably the only side that had a reasonably open flight path he could follow.

When you look at the Pentagon on Google Maps, to the northwest it is obscured by trees growing in Arlington National Cemetery, which would present a significant obstacle to a relatively inexperienced pilot like Hanjour. To the northeast, while the Pentagon is situated next to the Potomac, directly across the Potomac are some fairly tall buildings that would force him to come in at far too steep an angle to be sure of hitting the Pentagon; he might have crashed in the river instead. Plus, Reagan National Airport is just southeast of the Pentagon, and not all flights had been grounded at that point in the day, so he ran the risk of crossing the flight path of another plane there, because the majority of takeoffs and landings at that airport follow the line of the Potomac. To the southeast as well is Crystal City, which is full of skyscrapers, hotels, and shopping; can't go in that way. But to the south/southwest, which is approximately the direction Hanjour came in from, all he'd have to do is follow I-395 in a general way and he'd be nearly certain of a direct hit. There weren't a lot of buildings back in 2001 that were much taller than four stories or so within a half mile, I'd guesstimate, of the Pentagon to the south, and while nowadays the Air Force Memorial blocks the route Hanjour took, that memorial didn't exist on 9/11. It was, quite frankly, the clearest, easiest route in existence at the time, which is likely why Hanjour took such a big circuit around the area before arrowing in on that course; he may have been evaluating possible approaches and realized that was the best and quickest approach for him to carry out his mission. I doubt he knew or cared that that particular facade had been reinforced in previous years.
 
Last edited:
You said that aiming right for the roof in a "steep dive" would be more difficult than hitting the side. The clips from Italian television in September 11: The New Pearl Harbor has experienced pilots giving the opposite opinion. Then, there's the part in Jesse Ventura's show where they couldn't get close to replicating the path of Flight 77 in a full motion flight simulator no matter how many times they tried. Since experiment is the arbitrator of competing hypotheses, more examples of full motion simulator experiments would be a better way of settling the question than carefully selected individuals giving their opinion (professional or not). In that sense, I probably shouldn't have even bothered commenting because nobody here would want to set up an experiment like that.

Found your problem.
Jesse Ventura is a crackpot. A common misconception is that wrestling is fake, therefore injuries sustained doing it are fake, too.

Wrestling is pre-determined. However, the injuries can be all too real. There can be no doubt as to the affect of Traumatic Brain Injury today. We see it everywhere. When Jesse was wrestling, it was just "getting dinged up". Well, now the years have passed and we see what TBI can really do. It can make you think that 9/11 was a government plot.

As to setting up the experiments - there's no need. Literally. Would you need to set up an experiment that shows getting stabbed by a knife can cause bleeding? No, you wouldn't. Something like that is just understood.

The events of 9/11 are equally easily explained. 19 homicidal/suicidal morons flew planes into buildings with only a 75% success rate. We know any and all maneuvers performed by the pilots were possible, because they happened. Not one of you people has, in 14 YEARS come up with an alternative narrative that better explains the entire day's events. Not one. You pick and choose what minutiae to cling to, and that's that. Pathetic.
 
Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?
Exact replication? No, that would be unrealistic. You would not be able to do that with a car on a track either.
Able to fly a 270 degree descending turn in a couple of minutes,, I would think that to be no problem for even a novice. Its harder to maintain a level altitude in a turn than to allow it to descend.

With The Pentagon basically being a giant bullseye from a terrorist's point of view, why would Hani Hanjour choose to attack the side? Otherwise, I could just doubt that Hani would feel the need to loopdeloop around to hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts. He could've just hit the roof without risking precious minutes.
Hanjour apparently did not catch sight of the Pentagon until he was almost on top of it. A negative g pitch down into a dive is a very difficult manouver whereas one of the first things taught to a pilot is a three minute turn. Hitting the roof in a dive would be tres tres difficult.
Perhaps though he was aiming for the inside of the far wing of the Pentagon and was too low, perhaps he was aiming for the top floors of the side he did hit and was too low. Are you assuming he hit exactly where he wanted to hit at a location that was exactly planned to be hit? If so why would you assume such?



[/QUOTE]
 
I don't think either of us doubt that the hijackers were on the planes. I would even have no problem with them controlling the planes except for the way the Pentagon was hit and how wedge one was renovated for blast/missile impacts. We've all seen the episode of Jesse Ventura's show where they try to replicate the flight path in the simulator, they just couldn't do it.


Split from here as a separate topic.
Posted By: zooterkin

Please research "Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy" before embarrassing yourself any further.
 
Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?
Yes. I did it and it was a trivial exercise. A330-200. I did it by hand, AP and FMC. None was challenging.

With The Pentagon basically being a giant bullseye from a terrorist's point of view, why would Hani Hanjour choose to attack the side?
If he hit the top you would be asking why he targeted the top. If he hit the middle, you would be asking why he targeted the middle. If he missed entirely, you would be asking why he missed.

Otherwise, I could just doubt that Hani would feel the need to loopdeloop around to hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts. He could've just hit the roof without risking precious minutes.
He had to lose altitude. It really is that simple.
 
Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?

Yes, there are:
http://911blogger.com/node/20232

Conclusion: Is it probable that the 767-200 can make 560mph at sea level?
It is highly probable that AA11 and UA175 could easily make the airspeeds quoted in the official reports and as seen in the video footage. Here is a summation of the facts;
1. The aircraft were seen to make those airspeeds on September 11, 2001. This has never been questioned by any peer reviewed paper or team of experts, so it stands as fact.
2. The aircraft were well within their structural limit of .86 Mach by a margin of .12 Mach or approximately 14%; flying at maximum of reported speed of .74 Mach.
3. The simulator test carried out on an actual certified Full Flight Simulator (the best available), in a fully accredited pilot certification facility, showed that the 767 aircraft can reach an airspeed of .86 Mach in a flat trajectory at approximate sea level. It was also shown that .89 Mach could be achieved in a similar shallow dive as seen made by AA11 and UA175 on 9/11. These results show far greater speeds possible than the required official airspeed of 560mph or .74 Mach by some 16% at the minimum and 20% if the actual flight conditions were simulated in a shallow dive.
4. Considering the large margins demonstrated here, we can now conclude that the “Impossible Airspeed” stated by John Lear et al. is false.
 
I don't think either of us doubt that the hijackers were on the planes. I would even have no problem with them controlling the planes except for the way the Pentagon was hit and how wedge one was renovated for blast/missile impacts. We've all seen the episode of Jesse Ventura's show where they try to replicate the flight path in the simulator, they just couldn't do it.
Don't fly with the idiots who can't hit a 900 foot wide target! What a load of BS. I can't stop laughing at how dumb Jesse is exposing the worlds worse pilots who can't fly as poorly and hit 900 foot wide target; kind of self debunking, don't you think? Did you think about it? no, you fell for BS

That is total BS. Hani, or his fellow murderer flew the worse turn in history. Poor bank angle, poor airspeed control, and poor decent rate. Hani was aiming to hit the Pentagon, not a special section. He had a target that was 900 feet wide, not 40 feet wide like the runway where he had his last Cessna flight. 900 feet wide and you say pilots on Jesse the Body's show could not hit a 900 foot wide runway? Are you saying pilots are bragging about not being able to do what a bad pilot did do? So sad to see pilots who can't hit a 900 foot target, yet they claim to be pilots who land on 40 to 200 feet wide runways. How do they land?

LOL, the biggest error is trying to hit where Hani hit, he hit at random, it was not a game of "horse", it was random. Thus to replicate Hani's poor flying, hitting the Pentagon Anywhere is the same as hitting it where Hani hit it; He was not aiming at the specific section, he was trying to hit the Pentagon.

The Pentagon was being renovated, which has nothing to do with an idiot pilot who is murdering people. You can't make up BS about where he hit, it does no make sense; it is a Gish Gallop kind of nonsense. What does it mean if he hit a section renovated? When was it renovate, why does it matter?
Then the budget analysis BS, I had an office of 7, and we had a "budget analyst", SO? Gee, 911 truth puts out so much BS how can you ignore the simple plot of UBL to murder Americans with 4 planes.

It defies logic to make up BS about what was hit when the target was the Pentagon, WTC towers, and possibly the place where congress meets...
 
Last edited:
Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?
...
Yes. The Dutch documentary program Zembla aired this in September 2006:
http://zembla.vara.nl/seizoenen/2006/afleveringen/10-09-2006

A low-quality copy with English subtitles is on YouTube. The bit where a guy with only small plane experience hit the Pentagon three times in three tries starts at 27:40 seconds:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Li89cUQNHZ4&t=27m41s


This is the same program, by the way, that so many Truthers quote from when they take Dutch explosive demolitions expert Danny Jowenko as their witness that WTC7 was a controlled demolition (starting 46:44), so it can't be said that Truthers never heard of this program. They just never tell you this important truth about the flight 77 simulation. Just like they never ever tell you that the same Danny Jowenko, in the same interview, starting at 32:19, explains why WTC1+2 collapses were definitely caused by fire, and why explosives were not possible. This example should teach you to never ever trust Truther films and Truther websites - they are willfully ignorant.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom