Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

Apart from you, Dave and I, and the couple of loons, and the ones who agree with the official narrative.

I think you're a bit confused. The people you describe as "the ones who agree with the official narrative," one might assume, don't think it was anything but terrorists crashing jets, and in general don't bother expressing that opinion because it's trivial. We're therefore left with the posters on this forum and 'a couple of loons,' and those sets are almost certainly not orthogonal whichever way you look at it.

Dave
 
Last edited:
Vastly more people in the UK will have seen the anniversary programs on the Beeb, ITV and C4 that dissected the CD "theories" as presented in Loose Change than would have watched Loose Change.
 
No, not at all. By describing the collection of reports as "the official story" you are trying to set it in the light of a full and authoritative account of events which must be accepted in full or rejected in full. In reality it is no such thing; it's simply the best efforts, after the event, to determine as much as can be known of what happened. As such, it's bound to have errors and be incomplete. Conspiracy theorists use the term "the official story" to bolster an invalid falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus standard of proof, while evading any similar level of scrutiny of their own claims.

So, your argument that my fact stating that the official narrative is incomplete is that the official narrative is incomplete, but this is not semantics? Are you one of those anti-semantics I hear about?

But the question has been answered, again to the best of the abilities of those answering it. The counter-claims of other mechanisms do not survive even casual scrutiny.

The question was answered because it was raised because the official narrative was incomplete. Can you please stop arguing by saying I am right.

So on the one hand you claim that the truth movement is winning the PR war, and on the other that it is excluded from the public eye. If your opinion had any weight, it would be impossible to exclude such a crucial issue from the popular media in the middle of an election campaign. The reason that it's not being covered is that practically nobody cares about it, certainly not enough to campaign on it.

Assertion without evidence, are you a truther? It's not in the media because no-one cares and it would be impossible to exclude, therefore it doesn't exist.

So you say, yet I have never seen any plausible exceptions, because all the ones that have been offered fail to stand up to scrutiny. If you think you have any, please start or join threads as appropriate to discuss them, but be aware that an enormous amount of ground has been covered already in fifteen years.

Dave

You have just said that the official narrative is incomplete. Please don't argue with me by arguing with yourself.
 
Apart from you, Dave and I, and the couple of loons, and the ones who agree with the official narrative.

Such a small post to be so full of contradictions.

I don't know you or Dave.

Whst is the 'official narrative'? where can I read it? Who are the people that agree with it that I know?
 
I think you're a bit confused. The people you describe as "the ones who agree with the official narrative," one might assume, don't think it was anything but terrorists crashing jets, and in general don't bother expressing that opinion because it's trivial. We're therefore left with the posters on this forum and 'a couple of loons,' and those sets are almost certainly not orthogonal whichever way you look at it.

Dave

Is an opinion not expressed still an opinion? If it is not expressed, is it assumed? Are you saying that the absence of expressing a conflicting opinion is bone fide support for the official narrative?

How did we get from no opinions exist, to assumed opinions?

And you call me crazy ;)
 
Vastly more people in the UK will have seen the anniversary programs on the Beeb, ITV and C4 that dissected the CD "theories" as presented in Loose Change than would have watched Loose Change.

Evidence or assertion?

I think 80% of your statistic was made up on the spot.
 
Is this all you have?

Why not tell us what you think happened and show the support you have?
What is your narrative?
 
I don't know you or Dave.

Whst is the 'official narrative'? where can I read it? Who are the people that agree with it that I know?

I can't speak for Dave, but you certainly don't know me, and definitely not in any biblical sense.

The official narrative is the set of NIST reports, either in conjunction with, or as a replacement to the 9/11 commission and FEMA reports, henceforth, and previously referred to as "the official narrative".

I have never met ... who thinks it was anything but terrorists crashing jets.

I am assuming that you know some of these people that you previously referred to. I believe "thinks it was" could be described as opines, or has an opinion on.
 
Is this all you have?

Why not tell us what you think happened and show the support you have?
What is your narrative?

Do I have to have an equal and opposite narrative? Am I not allowed to simply say "I do not agree with what you say."?

When a teacher marks school work, is a red X enough, or must they explain everything and supply the correct answer?
 
Do I have to have an equal and opposite narrative? Am I not allowed to simply say "I do not agree with what you say."?

When a teacher marks school work, is a red X enough, or must they explain everything and supply the correct answer?

So you hsve nothing? novreason to doubt? no contrary evidence?

You must have some opinions otherwise why go to the trouble of signing up for the Forum and posting?
 
That is semantics. By definition these are the official narrative. The fact remains that they are not complete, as a consequence of which questions have arisen. Some ludicrous, others very pertinent. Free fall would not have been added into the report were it not raised as a question.

They are quite complete. The official narrative, as you people refer to it, is as follows:

19 Hijackers planned to take over 4 aircraft. This is confirmed by voice recorders, airport security footage, and the fact that they're all vaporized, along with a paper trail showing them preparing for the event.

4 Aircraft were hijacked This is confirmed by the fact that 4 aircraft were hijacked.

3 Aircraft crashed into each WTC Tower and the Pentagon. Confirmed using so much evidence it's almost comical, if it weren't for the death and destruction. Live television footage, eyewitness accounts, radar tracking, aircraft wreckage found during cleanup, etc..etc...etc...

1 Aircraft crashed in Shanksville, PA This backs up the fact that 4 aircraft were hijacked. Eyewitness accounts and aircraft wreckage at the site confirms this.

Please remember, your ignorance - willful or not - doesn't change facts.

Anyway,
The Twin Towers collapse Every canard "burning buildings don't collapse from fire" was proven wrong on that day. Many people, including laypeople such as myself were not surprised one bit that they collapsed. The fact that steel doesn't react well to prolonged heat is as basic as "water is wet". These fears were realized when the first tower fell, and confirmed when it happened for the second time in history less than an hour later. It should also come as no surprise that material that fell from 1,000 feet in the air can strike a building roughly 400 feet away.

Unless and until you people can come up with a scenario that better explains the entire day's events, you need to go back under the rock you come from.
 
Last edited:
Do I have to have an equal and opposite narrative? Am I not allowed to simply say "I do not agree with what you say."?

When a teacher marks school work, is a red X enough, or must they explain everything and supply the correct answer?

They must be able to justify the red X, which usually means knowing or being able to find out the correct answer.
 
.... the entire fabrication collapses into its own footprint at free-fall speeds.

How do you explain the following photos then? :



WTC7 debris after impacting the neighbouring Verizon building:

 
Last edited:
Evidence or assertion?

I think 80% of your statistic was made up on the spot.

Over 5 million watched ITVs The Day That Changed the World.
Over 2 million watched Beeb2's 9/11 Ten Year's On
Over 2 milion watched C4s 9/11 The Firemen's Stories

These are the 7 day Barb figures for the week to 4th September 2011.
You can look them up yourself.

BBC2's Conspiracy Files also did one on WTC 7, but I don't know when that was transmitted.
Edit: October 26th 2008, with 1.7 million.

Are you seriously going to imply that Loose Change achieved even the lower end of that reach?
 
Last edited:
Do I have to have an equal and opposite narrative? Am I not allowed to simply say "I do not agree with what you say."?

When a teacher marks school work, is a red X enough, or must they explain everything and supply the correct answer?

A GOOD teacher will always explain why an answer got a "red X".

Just telling a student that an answer is "wrong" is not effective pedagogy at all.
 
So you hsve nothing? novreason to doubt? no contrary evidence?

You must have some opinions otherwise why go to the trouble of signing up for the Forum and posting?

Actually, I signed up to ask a question, amongst other things.

Have you sorted out who you know yet, and what classes as an opinion?
 
Actually, I signed up to ask a question, amongst other things.

Have you sorted out who you know yet, and what classes as an opinion?

I'm curious.

Is your so-early resort to equivocation a planned approach, or is it just in reaction to not being hailed as the sharpest ball in the toolshed, just for showing up? Did you not expect opposition?

The "official narrative" is the same kind of semantic construct as the "gay agenda". What happened, happened. Any explanation must be, in the words of James, "congruent, fruitful, and luminous".
 
Over 5 million watched ITVs The Day That Changed the World.
Over 2 million watched Beeb2's 9/11 Ten Year's On
Over 2 milion watched C4s 9/11 The Firemen's Stories

These are the 7 day Barb figures for the week to 4th September 2011.
You can look them up yourself.

BBC2's Conspiracy Files also did one on WTC 7, but I don't know when that was transmitted.
Edit: October 26th, with 1.7 million.

Are you seriously going to imply that Loose Change achieved even the lower end of that reach?

What lower reach? TV viewing figures are made up, we know that. Are you claiming that these are all distinct individuals, or is your maximum a fabricated 5 million?

Are you only using Loose Change as the opposing viewpoint, or are you expecting me to try and calculate all the views of all the possible contrary view points?

What are you trying to do here other than dig yourself a deeper hole? Or are you actually arguing with Dave and Swoop who claim that no-one cares or has an opinion? According to you between 5 and 10.7 million people might have an opinion. Are we also assuming that because these unknown number of people that don't have an opinion, watched these shows that no-one cares about, in popular media that isn't covering it, all agree with the official narrative that doesn't exist?

Nurse, medication all round please.
 
Actually, I signed up to ask a question, amongst other things.

Have you sorted out who you know yet, and what classes as an opinion?

I'm curious.

Is your so-early resort to equivocation a planned approach, or is it just in reaction to not being hailed as the sharpest ball in the toolshed, just for showing up? Did you not expect opposition?

ETA: that's the "red X" (although I use green, in class)

The "official narrative" is the same kind of semantic construct as the "gay agenda". What happened, happened. Any explanation must be, in the words of James, "congruent, fruitful, and luminous".

ETA: that's a constructivist approach to helping you understand why...
 
So, your argument that my fact stating that the official narrative is incomplete is that the official narrative is incomplete, but this is not semantics?

Have you heard of the "Rule of so"? It states that any post starting with the word "So" is likely to contain a gross misrepresentation of a previous post. If that's how you want to conduct yourself here, don't let me stop you, but if you're determined to fling strawmen about like this then any benefit of the doubt you're afforded will be withdrawn pretty quickly. I said that "the official story" is a construct of conspiracy theorists; we are discussing actual events here.

Assertion without evidence, are you a truther? It's not in the media because no-one cares and it would be impossible to exclude, therefore it doesn't exist.

Again, deliberate misrepresentation. Alternative theories of 9/11 are not being covered by the media and are not perceived as significant political issues, therefore your opinion that the truth movement is winning the PR war is untenable, because the initial aim in the PR war is to get publicity.

Now, there are those here who think that all 9/11 truthers are barefaced liars, those who think they're all insane, and those with more nuanced views who think they include liars, lunatics and those who simply don't understand how to assess evidence properly; I'm definitely in the third camp. But that gives me three camps I can put you into, and by telling me I've said things I haven't, you're giving me a strong hint which one to choose.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom