Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

From my perspective, that is the entirety of the problem, in a nutshell.

In many situations, the assumptions or declarations are laid out at the beginning. If the initial premise is false or challenged, then discussing anything further down the line is meaningless until those initial disagreements are resolved.

We agree that it is impossible for any of the reports into such a complex matter to be 100% accurate, therefore we can continue. Thank you for granting this tiny, and perhaps seeming irrelevant concession, (beleive me when I say it is extremely significant to me). It does not matter what those errors are, they are not even implied at this point. Inferring them is a fallacy, which is what many of the antagonists on this board have done. They have not only tried to anticipate my motives, they have assigned me beliefs that I do not hold, already challenged them in their own minds, and condemned both them and me. This is so much BS that I lack the words to fully express it.

At this point we have wasted so much time and effort trying to establish the basic foundations of asking a question, that I have already had to rule out a large portion of respondents as being relevant to this and any future discussions.

Why not simply ask your questions?
 
Why is this an odd question? What motive or assumptions are you making on my behalf? I have stated that I am not an aeroplane person, so I am trying to ask aeroplane questions on an aeroplane thread in the hope of getting aeroplane answers.
So you claim, yet despite not being an "aeroplane person" you also claim to know pilots procedures and methods, aerodynamic limits etc when there are actual "aeroplane people" right here telling you that you are incorrect, wrong, and spouting flat out baloney.

This is a lot harder than I thought it would be, as you lot cannot even agree on your interpretations of the questions I am asking, let alone the answers.
You brought a knife to a gunfight. What did you expect?

I am trying to establish the procedures and practices of air travel, it includes some assumptions on my part that may be incorrect.
No kidding.

I am assuming that planes are not in use 24/7. I am assuming that planes, after landing and offloading passengers and luggage are either scheduled to go again, or are moved elsewhere until their next flight, freeing up the gate for another flight. I am assuming that once a plane has finished its landing procedures (and is not scheduled to be turned around immediately) that it is powered down and towed to a parking area. I am assuming that when it is to be used again, it is towed to the correct gate.
All reasonable assumptions.

I am assuming that the plane changes its actual position in space and time, but that certain instruments onboard will not reflect this change if the plane is not powered on.
And then you fall over. Which instruments? AP? GPS? FMC? NAV? What?

Your answer based on your assumptions is incomplete if landing is not the same as parking. You have missed at least one step in the events.
Landing is not the same as parking. Why you would make n issue of this is beyond guessing.

Now, as my pertinent questions were about INS, and its importance and relevance to the take off procedure, I wanted to make sure I wasn't missing anything relevant that happened before the plane arrived at the gate.
That makes no sense. How is take-off procedure relevant to arrival at the gate?

Contrary to popular belief, and as previously stated, I did not believe the article on p4t, and had previously challenged it.
Yet you were quite happy to present it here as some sort of evidence. Why?

I could not fully challenge it because I am not competent to do so.
No comment.

Rather than asking in the forum where it was published, where the answers might have some bias, I came to an independent forum to see if I could further my understanding on the subject rather than taking their position as gospel, or jumping to too many conclusions myself.
All of which answers you rejected out of hand.

Unfortunately I was not prepared for the level of unsupervised mental patients I would run in to, and I crumbled under the onslaught of BS.
Ad hom noted.

So, I am trying to frame questions with as little wriggle room in interpretation as I can, but it's bloody difficult given the standing level of hostility in the membership.
Any hostility you perceive is entirely deserved based on your attitude. Do not presume to say you are clueless about all things aviation while proceeding to tell actual pilots how to fly. You will inevitably engender hostility.

It's a steep learning curve.
And your fpm on that curve appears to remain negative.
 
<ever so polite snip for focus>
So, I am trying to frame questions with as little wriggle room in interpretation as I can, but it's bloody difficult given the standing level of hostility in the membership. It's a steep learning curve.

Just asking a question here: Does "foaming mouthed[sic] nut jobs" not count as a "level of hostility"?

Why not simply ask your questions? That way, you would not look so much as if you were trying to pre-load a "gotcha".
 
Never go full retard truther. All these questions are years old and have been debunked multiple times on this very forum. A simple search in this forum on the topics would give the answers and much better than spraying truther meme spam in one thread.
 
Just asking a question here: Does "foaming mouthed[sic] nut jobs" not count as a "level of hostility"?
Oh god yes.

Why not simply ask your questions? That way, you would not look so much as if you were trying to pre-load a "gotcha".

I've asked, I'm still waiting for quality answers that don't assume motives. I'm not trying to pre-load anything. Again, take a look at the most recent response from abaddon, where he/she tries to be clever by taking apart my previous post, but just succeeds in messing everything up.

you also claim to know pilots procedures and methods, aerodynamic limits etc when there are actual "aeroplane people" right here telling you that you are incorrect, wrong, and spouting flat out baloney.

Where do I do this?

And then you fall over. Which instruments? AP? GPS? FMC? NAV? What?

I don't fall over, I am asking questions. You tell me which instruments, I don't know.

How is take-off procedure relevant to arrival at the gate?

You cannot proceed to take off if you haven't arrived at the gate and loaded your passengers etc.

Landing is not the same as parking. Why you would make n issue of this is beyond guessing.

That's what I was trying to say in response to someone else. How could you get this so wrong?

Yet you were quite happy to present it here as some sort of evidence. Why?

Wrong again, I am not presenting it as evidence, I am presenting it as the reason that I have questions to ask.
 
I tried that, it didn't work too well. Look at the post below your own by abaddon. He's assuming all sorts of things based on what I have no idea.

With all due respect, what actual questions have you asked?

it seems to me that, despite your manly expostulations and your posing, several heavy hitters have responded, point-by-point to everything you have posted that could be considered a question, so far. Do you understand the answers you have gotten?

May I offer to help you with anything about which you are unclear?

What further questions have you?
 
... 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else ...
A perfect question, or what, for a "Flight paths and other questions" thread...

Is this relevant to flight paths? ...
It is relevant for "other questions", makes this a much broader than expected thread topic...

Thus where is your evidence for the alive terrorists, a topic you brought up. All without evidence, just more BS from the 911 truth box of BS.

Are terrorists alive?
 
Just asking a question here: Does "foaming mouthed[sic] nut jobs" not count as a "level of hostility"?
Oh god yes.
Don't do it then.

Why not simply ask your questions? That way, you would not look so much as if you were trying to pre-load a "gotcha".

I've asked, I'm still waiting for quality answers that don't assume motives. I'm not trying to pre-load anything. Again, take a look at the most recent response from abaddon, where he/she tries to be clever by taking apart my previous post, but just succeeds in messing everything up.
You are unable to respond to substantive replies. That is your failure and nobody elses.

you also claim to know pilots procedures and methods, aerodynamic limits etc when there are actual "aeroplane people" right here telling you that you are incorrect, wrong, and spouting flat out baloney.

Where do I do this?
ORLY? Do you really want to play that tired old truther game of hunt the post? Sorry, but I decline your game of Tactics of Mistake.

And then you fall over. Which instruments? AP? GPS? FMC? NAV? What?

I don't fall over, I am asking questions. You tell me which instruments, I don't know.
Which aircraft? Not all navaids are present on all aircraft. Each possible one operates independently or collectively as selected by the pilot. Frame a meaningful question and I will endeavour to answer it.

Off the top of my head, only GPS will have live data. Everything else will simply have the settings last entered by the last pilot.

Oh, and ACARS also.

How is take-off procedure relevant to arrival at the gate?

You cannot proceed to take off if you haven't arrived at the gate and loaded your passengers etc.
Bet you a dollar.

Landing is not the same as parking. Why you would make n issue of this is beyond guessing.

That's what I was trying to say in response to someone else. How could you get this so wrong?
You raised the issue.

Yet you were quite happy to present it here as some sort of evidence. Why?

Wrong again, I am not presenting it as evidence, I am presenting it as the reason that I have questions to ask.
And as stated, I will endeavour to answer.
 
Oh god yes.

Then why, one wonders, did you level that epithet at posters whose styles hurt your feels? Or are you exempt from your own strictures?

I've asked, I'm still waiting for quality answers that don't assume motives. I'm not trying to pre-load anything. Again, take a look at the most recent response from abaddon, where he/she tries to be clever by taking apart my previous post, but just succeeds in messing everything up.

Believe it or not, I did, in fact, read abaddon's point-by-point response to what you actually posted. Upon what do you presume to dismiss the Dread Angel's post as "trying to be clever"? In what substantive way do you feel what you actually posted was "messed up"?

You say that you are not trying to pre-load anything; please be aware that your apparent attempts to pull off the Verónica Grande support the impression that you have a 9/11Truth "gotcha" waiting in your bolsa mágica, to be unleashed when you feel a rhetorical point might be won.

You are not the first person to bring woo! to this fact fight...

Do consider simply asking your actual question. Re-ask it, if you need to.

(At this point in your post, you begin addressing a different poster; I will leave the response to them. Don't feel bad, as it is easy to get confused using the quote function.)
 
Last edited:
With all due respect, what actual questions have you asked?

it seems to me that, despite your manly expostulations and your posing, several heavy hitters have responded, point-by-point to everything you have posted that could be considered a question, so far. Do you understand the answers you have gotten?

May I offer to help you with anything about which you are unclear?

What further questions have you?

I can't find the initial article that I was reading, and I may have mixed up INS and IRS.

The thrust of their conversation was that inputting IRS was part of the pre-flight checklist and must be carried out or the plane would not be allowed to fly. One went as far as to say the plane COULD not fly, because some gadget would be stuck in NAV mode. This in particular is what I was trying to find to ask you guys about.

As I do not know, I wanted to find out more about these systems.
 
I can't find the initial article that I was reading, and I may have mixed up INS and IRS.

The thrust of their conversation was that inputting IRS was part of the pre-flight checklist and must be carried out or the plane would not be allowed to fly. One went as far as to say the plane COULD not fly, because some gadget would be stuck in NAV mode. This in particular is what I was trying to find to ask you guys about.

As I do not know, I wanted to find out more about these systems.
Any pilot has discretion to opt to go VFR and ignore all of the navaids subject to ATC. Nothing is ever "stuck in NAV mode" ever. The pilot has discretion. And the checklist baloney is actual baloney. I used to print the cockpit checklists for a large airline so I have more that a passing familiarity with what is really in there. "Stuck in NAV mode" is nonsense. It cannot happen. Whoever fed you that line is talking through their hat.
 
I can't find the initial article that I was reading, and I may have mixed up INS and IRS.

The thrust of their conversation was that inputting IRS was part of the pre-flight checklist and must be carried out or the plane would not be allowed to fly. One went as far as to say the plane COULD not fly, because some gadget would be stuck in NAV mode. This in particular is what I was trying to find to ask you guys about.

As I do not know, I wanted to find out more about these systems.

Beachnut is one of the actual pilots contributing to the thread; they will be more than glad to answer any actual questions that do not, for instance fall prey to the rhetorical victimization of (for instance) p4t (such as your "some of the terrorists are still alive" gaffe). Abaddon is another valuable resource.

What do you want to know about "these systems"? In reality, the planes did, in fact, take off; they did, in fact, crash against various targets (or crashed, failing to reach a target).

Suggestion: state your actual question clearly, then read the answers for content. If you still have needs, ask again. Sometimes it takes patience.
 
Last edited:
I tried that, it didn't work too well. Look at the post below your own by abaddon. He's assuming all sorts of things based on what I have no idea.

The problem is that a) you came here unprepared, as all truthers do and b) you apparently expected all here to bow to your superior knowledge, which you, as you've admitted, don't have.

I think you should be more patient here and read the answers to your claims and questions more carefully.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom