Thank you Oystein, for seeing beneath what I wrote to what I was trying to say
Your welcome, and thanks for the kudos elsewhere in this thread.
I didn't appreciate the hornets nest I would be stirring up, and wasn't prepared for the barrage from all directions.
I haven't read all the other posts since I last posted - don't have the time really today, but I see there is plenty of noise, and sometimes it is wise to be a bit slow in reacting, as not to fuel the "hottest" debaters into posting with even more heat.
Thank you for agreeing that there are errors in the official reports. That is what I was trying to establish as a fact. I did not suggest a motive or a reason for this, I was attempting to draw a line in the sand. I beleive that there is more to the truth than is contained in those documents, and was trying to say that there could be no debate with someone who insisted that "the official narrative" was the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. It's the Perfect Solution fallacy from the other side, if you will.
I agree that it would be silly to have complete faith in all the reports on all levels of detail - but I am not sure anyone seriously holds that position.
I will say though that I have often seen posters here quote or paraphrase something from NIST or the 9/11 Commission and include language to the effect that they consider this established fact
because it is "official".
As Georgio and ozeco have explained to you, there are indeed posters of various debate skills here, so it should not come as a surprise that you will encounter bad arguments.
I like to say that "debunkers" are all right, by and large, but some are right for the wrong reasons.
My use of the word compelling was perhaps mistaken, in that I did not mean to imply a strict dictionary definition. Perhaps captivating would have been more accurate. I agree, polls are unreliable.
3x
I disagree with you about NIST denying evidence. They did clearly state that there was no evidence of molten steel, and there was no evidence of explosions (not explosives). This is patently false, and I do not understand why they made such claims.
This is not something I wish to belabour, but it would be interesting to dig up the exact NIST quotes and look at the context they are made in. I am pretty sure they don't deny
reports mentioning "explosions" or "molten steel", nor do they deny things like that glowing flow of stuff from a corner of the South Tower in the minutes prior to collapse. Rather, they deny that these things are
proof of explosives, or of molten steel (the word "evidence" can be ambiguous). I could be mistaken, but that's how I remember my perception of NIST's statements on those issues.
I do have difficulty however when you use absolutes in your points, no one, never etc. These are the very things that get quickly jumped upon should a so-called troother use them.
These absolutes are an invitation to you to jump on, as an absolute negation is easily falsifiable - one counter-example, and my claim is debunked.
- I am convinced that there exists no professional or otherwise competent organization in the USA or Europe that supports any of the "US government made it happen on purpose" claims (with the obvious exception of the self-selected "XYZs for 9/11 Truth" outfits), but feel free to search for a counterexample.
- I am totally certain that there exists no "9/11 Truth" theory that a) explains the day's events comprehensively (including all four crash sites) and b) is not obviously contradicted by reality (such as the "holograms" or "Directed Energy" nonsenses).
Many Truthers object to these absolute "no"s, but then fail to provide the single counter-example; this is a very strong indication that the claims are true - you would think that if there existed a professional group, or if there existed a comprehensive theory, truthers all over would cite, copy, link and like them.
I am also not sure what your big picture is.
I told you:
- Arab terrorists hijacked four commercial airliners
- Piloted them to crash at the WTC, the Pentagon and a field in Shanksville
- Structural damage and fires caused by these plane crashed were the cause of the eventual collapses of the WTC twin towers and a section of the Pentagon
- Debris impact and/or fires caused by the collapsing towers were the cause of all the structural damage to buildings around the twin towers
- This includes the fact that fires caused the collapse of WTC7
- The attacks were sponsored and planned by know member of a known foreign terror group, citing certain political grievances against the USA, and being motivated by certain radical muslim beliefs
Fire fighters, relatives and professionals do disagree with some of the official narrative, and have asked for independent investigations for some time.
This is partially true, with "partial" applying on several levels:
A small part of the members of these groups call for more investigations
They call for investigations of parts of the whole story.
In particular:
- The vast majority of relatives accept the "big picture" I outlined above, but may question the extent to which the attacks, or the extent of the damages incurred, could have been prevented by better intelligence, police work, political guidance, engineering or workmanship, etc. They do NOT suspect explosive demolition or some such Truther lore. Only a tiny minority of relatives believes in "9/11Truth" claims.
- The vast majority of fire fighters, including, and quite in particular, almost everybody at the FDNY, accepts that OF COURSE fires and structural damage were the cause of all building collapses.You may have heard of an outfit "Firefighters for 9/11 Truth". This is, and always has been, essentially one person only - Eric Lawyer, a fire fighter from Seattle. More recently, one FDNY member has surfaced who parrots all the AE911Truth claims (and more): Rudy Dent. Three problems with Dent: First, he wasn't there at all when the twins collapsed, and was several blocks away when WTC7 collapsed - at a location where no explosions were heard. Secondly, it's rather strange that it took him so long to come out. Thirdly, I have never seen a more rabid Nazi, a more hateful anti-semite, a more open admirer of Adolf Hitler (I kid you not!) in all of the Truth Movement than Rudy Dent - there is something very seriously wrong with the way he sees reality.
- It's not clear which "professionals" you are refering to. Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth? Pilots for 9/11 Truth? You need to realize that these groups represent only a very tiny fraction of their professions (like 1 in 2000), and hardly anyone of them has any standing. Very few of the A&E in AE911Truth are actually active in any meaningful way; and most have no relevant professional expertise - electrical engineers, chemical engineers, landscape architects, or in general most architects, what do they bring to the table? Almost all articles and publications issued by AE911Truth are authored by folks who are neither architects nor engineers.
I don't care if the truth embarrases someone, I do care if it proves negligence, or culpability.
So do I - and as far as I can see, no such proof has come out of the "Truth" movement.
(I'll qualify that: No proof for any active involvement by US gov agencies, aka MIHOP - Made It Happen On Purpose. There seems to be evidence that some bureaus and officers screwed up - "Let It Happen Out Of Incompetence", or "LIHOOI" we call it sometimes. This might, potentially, border on a bit of LIHOP = Let It Happen On Purpose somewhere. There definitely is evidence of CYA = Cover Your Arse)
I do not understand the need for so much secrecy.
Yes, that is sometimes difficult to understand, but no necessity to attribute this to malice.
I do not understand why there are some clear contradictions in testimonies by high level players like Cheney.
a) CYA.
b) Genuine faulty recollection
(I am curious what contradictions in Cheney's testimonies you are refering to?)
I'm glad that you can see my bigger global, political picture, and whether or not we agree on the specifics, we can agree on some of the consequences, and their ramifications. I think that they are inextripacably linked,
Beware of the "
post hoc ergo propter hoc" fallacy

These are political issues that need to get addresses and, ideally, corrected. They are no strong evidence for criminal allegations of MIHOP or LIHOP.
and I see the massive amount of money being made off of the Middle East mess as ample motive to be involved in 9/11. I say motive, I do not say proof or evidence or even opportunity. I am not claiming some fact to be debunked.
Do you actually
see that money, or do you mostly
imagine that a lot of money
might have been made by some? Lots of money has been lost - huge amounts of money, that much is clear. On blance, values have been destroyed, productivity diminished, to the tune of hundreds of billions of of dollars. That doesn't mean it is likely that some individuals or some companies made net profits (for example: Haliburton may well have as a contractor of the US armed forces). But is it even plausible that such outcomes could have been foreseen and reliably planned for by hypothetical perpetrators within the US government?
I'm not sure what you are refering to as hyperbole. We see it in the UK as well. Heavy handed police tactics, random searches, an eradication of presumed innocence.
You made it sound as if freedoms of all citizens were massively invaded upon to the disruption of life as we knew it, when in fact to almost all citizens, almost nothing has substantially changed. This is not to defend excessive spying on communications metadata, the scandalous treatment of some groups of terror suspects, and what have you. Just pointing out that the actual life of 99% of us hasn't become a nightmare by any stretch of the imagination.
Am I advocating widespread violence and death? I'm not sure, to be honest. What would Abraham Lincoln have answered to that question? I will be happy to be wrong, but I don't rate the chances of a peaceful revolution, and an end to extreme capitalism. I forsee a continued widening of the rift between the haves and the have nots, leading to further privitisation of the police and military, until something breaks. When the rich get too greedy and complacent, empires fall. I don't know who Bernie Sanders is however, I tend not to look too closely at the pre-election promises of politicians, especially not in the US where I am not a native or resident.
I appreciate your open words on this - my question was provocative, no doubt; and it is sometimes legitimate to at least consider violence, that is, after all, very much a part of the policies of our governments.
My own take is that most violence will blow back and return to haunt you. As US foreign policy has come to experience over again. In former times (Abe Lincoln...), violence was much more a daily fact of life than it is today. We have grown much more risk-averse and and much less violent prone decade after decade. What seemed acceptable in 1860 is out of the question in 2016. I am rather glad this is so. Political change is still possible and still happens, even though it may sometimes appear like happening at the velocity of glaciers.
At any rate, I don't think that 9/11 Truth can point to a legitimate or viable course of action, whether peaceful or violent, because it ain't really the truth. It is a tiny minority loosely associated around a set of mutually exclusive delusions.
In summary and conclusion, I am not 9/11 Truth, I'm me truth. Truth Lite if you will. I'm a lot more reasonable than some of the wack jobs out there. I have questions and assumptions, I make mistakes, I look before I leap some of the time, I occasionally turn my brain on and put it to good use.
I'll take your word on this!
In a forum setting, my best advice is to try to focus on well defined questions about well-defined issues, and ask them one at a time. Then to resist the temptation to jump to other issues and questions before the one you asked has been settled.