Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

http://pilotsfor911truth.org/aa77-gate-position.html is the original article, from 4 years ago, and basically I thought it was junk. I don't know enough about the subject to prove adequately to myself that my gut instinct was correct.

So, I followed some links, dug around in their forums, and read some stuff, and then tried to look for alternative viewpoints, which led me here.

The problem is, rather than answer me directly, people have been trying to leap ahead of the conversation and argue things that I am not discussing.

I know that the hijackers had nothing to do with the gate/take off etc. I know that from a big picture that asking these questions could be deemed irrelevant. I don't care. I'm not asking for the motives that are assumed on my behalf.

There is an area (among very many) of aircraft procedures that I don't know anything about, therefore I am asking questions. I do not care if they are relevant to 9/11, because I am not asking for any 9/11 related reason. I am asking about INS and take off procedures because I do not know the answers, and I assumed, wrongly as it turns out, that I could get help from people here.

The questions arose around my personal journey through the 9/11 maze, but I'm not trying to spring some trap like a bad Sherlock villain, and I resent the implication that I am. It goes back to the guilty until proven innocent scenario I was despairing of, that seems to be relished by the majority of people on this thread.

Before embarrassing yourself here any further I suggest you use the search function, all this nonsense has been debunked years ago. :rolleyes:
 
http://pilotsfor911truth.org/aa77-gate-position.html is the original article, from 4 years ago, and basically I thought it was junk. ...
It is not only junk, it is a lie. With pilots for truth having the "offer no theory" BS rule, it turns out they "offer BS lies".

Here is the summary take, the offer no theory but lots of dumbed down lies...
Once again the data being offered by government agencies do not support their theories. - from pilots for truth aka, dolts who lie

The big argument Balsamo makes out of ignorance, is if you align the INS, called an IRS in the 767/757, it wakes up with the exact lat and long of the present position just inserted... This is not true.

When we first got INS, it was a big celebration by the Navigator if the initial alignment was within a 1/4 mile of our location... that is 1500 feet. The best you can get the INS to take the present position I have found is 600 feet.
Plus what we see in the FDR, which is what the article is plotting, what is the data; Raw IRS data, or FMS data. The navigation system is more than three IRSs... The IRS accumulate errors on the order of .5 NM per hour, then why is the FDR NAV data see to be updated as soon as it takes off. The Point is, Pilots for truth have no useful information on what happened on 911.
You were right, pilots for truth are spreading idiotic claims, lies and assorted BS - as they try to sell DVDs filled with the same BS.

The INS/IRS are instruments with errors...for more information, for tons of technical stuff, google INS navigation for flight, etc... you can get the equations for Kalman filters used to take out errors, and find people who can refine the INS to be more accurate with lots of math...

Today, the Navigation systems have GPS, and they are accurate to feet, and integrated with INS systems.

Balsamo thinks the IRS is 100 percent accurate, but it is not. Pilots for truth offer lies, and assorted BS. Wonder how much money they made selling DVDs filled with BS.


Now where is your evidence for your claim of alive terrorists?
... 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else ...
Got some evidence for this yet?
 
Last edited:
It is not only junk, it is a lie.

That's what I thought. If you are interested, I found the page where it was discussed at length, and they show a page from a manual: http://pilotsfor911truth.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=21149&st=80

Let me be clear, I am showing what they are saying. I do not believe it, and I am not presenting it as evidence or proof of anything, and I am not setting a trap for anyone. I could not prove to myself that it was junk, therefore I was/am seeking clarification. I appreciate that whether what they say is true or not, it would have had no impact on any of the events on 9/11, this is purely for my information in an area I know little about.
 
Let me be clear, I am showing what they are saying. I do not believe it*, and I am not presenting it as evidence or proof of anything*, and I am not setting a trap for anyone*. I could not prove to myself that it was junk,*
Good move AClark - making your position clear on those four * points.

....therefore I was/am seeking clarification*. I appreciate that whether what they say is true or not, it would have had no impact on any of the events on 9/11*, this is purely for my information in an area I know little about*.

Same comment.

If you make your point and purpose in posting explicit it should save a lot of angst. :thumbsup:
 
That's what I thought. If you are interested, I found the page where it was discussed at length, and they show a page from a manual: http://pilotsfor911truth.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=21149&st=80

Let me be clear, I am showing what they are saying. I do not believe it, and I am not presenting it as evidence or proof of anything, and I am not setting a trap for anyone. I could not prove to myself that it was junk, therefore I was/am seeking clarification. I appreciate that whether what they say is true or not, it would have had no impact on any of the events on 9/11, this is purely for my information in an area I know little about.
And what did you get from the Manual? What is the point? It seems the only point at pilots for truth is how much the posts are based on BS.

What is the best accuracy after alignment? Did the manual say so, you read the Manual, what is the accuracy?
The rest is BS, Flight 77 taxied out and the Nav system was working as proved by the FDR; which is evidence, hard facts, not silly BS opinions of Balsamo's peanut gallery of gullible paranoid want-to-be-pilots.

Okay, what does the page show as beginning accuracy after a 10 minute alignment, or a quick alignment of the IRS? got some numbers, got a source.

I have used INS, which is what an IRS is, and the best accuracy the navigators got excited with was 1/4 mile. Super nav, my nav is able to get .1 NM, 600 feet accuracy at alignment...
I don't see any problems with the offset on 911 from a normal 10 minute alignement, or a quick alignment.

What does the manual say? What is the meaning of pilot for truth BS? It is you with the question, what the heck is the question now...

"""Let me be clear, """
Pilots for truth, David Ray Griffin, Kevin Ryan, and all of 911 truth have zero evidence. 911 truth nuts like Balsamo and Kevin Ryan claim to have evidence, but never produce it.

Papers, aka fake research papers and delusional youtube videos by the nuts and dolts like David Chandler, Jonathan Cole, Nils Harrit, Steven Jones, Kevin Ryan, have fooled people who can't do math, physics, chemistry, logical thought, or think for themselves. People who entertain these dolts' work as valid, never had, or lost the ability to think critcally, and are not skeptics.

It is refreshing you see pilots for truth work as BS at face value. As a pilot I find it easy to see Balsamo is BS, not sure it would be that way if I was 25 with no higher education and no flight training, but by the age of 28 I was flying the left seat in a heavy jet for the USAF, the same as a Captain in an airline. But being a trained pilot may help understand pilots for truth only have BS claims, but simple research has the same result.

Ironically failed pilot for truth nuts have to call a skeptic forum the cesspool. This is called projection, as they wallow in ignorance, BS and lies born in overwhelming ignorance.

Most of 911 truth believers have no clue steel fails in fire, or why. 911 truth has no room for science, it is all woo based on opinions. And 911 truth movement membership is based solely on the ignorance of its members, the followers. The best part about 911 for the real world, most 911 truth believers are rational people, unlike the Boston bombers (911 truth believer peers), and will recover from the temporary spell of BS and ignorance, and realize they were fooled... better to be fooled for a few weeks by 911 truth, than to fall for insurance scams, and finding out 6000 dollars too late.... thus 911 truth is perfect practice for recovering from being gullible, for falling for scams...

Even Jones has stopped wasting time misleading gullible people with his thermite fraud. He moved on to over unity circuits... from woo to woo, faster than free-fall, into his own footprint.

Some 911 truth idiots claim flight 11 and 175 were modified KC-767 planes used to replace the real planes. And then go insane saying the real crews on 11 ans 175 were incapacitated... it can't can dumber when it comes to 911 truth; then 911 truth falls deeper into the pit of ignorance and out spews dumber claims.

Some fantasy minded 911 truth followers say the terrorist never existed, which is proved wrong with the DNA profiled of the terrorists on Flight 93 and 77. Can't believe how stupid one has to be to ignore the DNA evidence, not even taking time to explain how it fits in the delusional and insane no terrorist fantasy.

Then we have super experts who are idiots, and they do papers to have a lasting legacy of woo their grand-kids will cringe at due to overwhelming ignorance and extra credit paranoia. Like this BS...
http://www.journalof911studies.com/volume/2010/Monaghan_Analysis.pdf Wow, lies and BS; we could power the country with this much BS, and BS has more than 3 times the energy of the famous super-thermite fantasy... lol -
Wow, this kind of woo is what 911 truth nuts push as truth. Dumbed down claims of BS, mixed with fake science.

Glad you agree pilots for truth have failed claims, and BS.
... I do not believe it, ...
It is great to see you are skeptical of dumbed down BS made up by failed pilots who spread BS based on failed opinions. Good job.

What was their claim, and why are they evidence free? They don't understand the offset is due to IRS accuracy.

good you see Balsamo is full of BS, but what about your alive terrorists... ?
 
Last edited:
God... alive hijackers.. I did a write up on PF about it not long ago, I'll link it here:

http://www.politicalforum.com/showthread.php?t=341112&p=1065779734#post1065779734

cjnewson88 said:
It should be noted that the FBI did not release its full photo list of hijackers until September 27th. Their list released on September 14th was names only. You can see it here. All your stories you have linked were posted well before that date. The ones who keep coming up most frequently:

Waleed M al-Shehri - Note that next to his name lists no less than 7 possible birth dates, 3 possible residences, and believing he may be a pilot. So someone in the middle east thought it was him and spoke out, too bad he didn't look at the name properly. The hijackers name was Waleed Mohammed al-Shehri. The man who came forward saying he was alive is Waleed Ahmed al-Shehri. Not the same person.

Abdulaziz Al Omari - Again, two possible birth days, one for a 28 year old and one for a 22 year old. The 22 year old was the terrorist. The 28 year old is the pilot being interviewed. Again, the photo list released by the FBI on September 27th shows the correct Abdulaziz Al Omari. It's pretty obvious to see the difference between the two:

BBC_al-Omari_zpsssgfqokf.jpg

Abdul_Aziz_Alomari_1_zps7ikzl7xq.jpg


Saeed al-Ghamdi - The claim is that a man named Saeed al-Ghamdi living in Saudi Arabia was outraged when his "name, place, date of birth and occupation" were released to the world as a hijacker. Except again if you look at the list the FBI released on September 14th, they list no date of birth, no place of birth, no occupation, no nationality, just a name and a possible residence in Delray Beach, Florida. Again, this is before the FBI released the photo list on September the 27th. Not the same guy.

Again, it can't be emphasised enough that all these 'hijackers alive' stories seem to be a reprint of the same story which were published days before the FBI released it's full photo list of the 9/11 hijackers.

So I put it back on you, the same question I've been asking truthers for years, find me a video with one of these alive hijackers in it. You wont be able to.
 
That's what I thought. If you are interested, I found the page where it was discussed at length, and they show a page from a manual: http://pilotsfor911truth.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=21149&st=80

Let me be clear, I am showing what they are saying. I do not believe it, and I am not presenting it as evidence or proof of anything, and I am not setting a trap for anyone. I could not prove to myself that it was junk, therefore I was/am seeking clarification. I appreciate that whether what they say is true or not, it would have had no impact on any of the events on 9/11, this is purely for my information in an area I know little about.
My first thought is "what does the manual say after that?" Its much like the PfT interpretation of Vd. They assume that immediately at passing Vd that the a/c will suffer massive structural disintegration. In this case they assume that not aligning the IRS will result in the plane not being able to fly.
So ask yourself what would happen if the IRS broke down mid-flight? does the a/c fall from the sky?

Let me be clear. Every single issue you have brought up has been discussed at length, several times each, in the pages of this subforum. Thus the frustration exhibited by many here at, yet again, seeing them brought forth.

Perhaps you have only just begun looking at the details of 9/11, perhaps you were very young in 2001.
 
Last edited:
My first thought is "what does the manual say after that?" Its much like the PfT interpretation of Vd. They assume that immediately at passing Vd that the a/c will suffer massive structural disintegration.

I know, I ran into this brick wall too, even the concept of exceeding VMO is a challenge to some of them.

Perhaps you have only just begun looking at the details of 9/11, perhaps you were very young in 2001.

Not even close
 
I know, I ran into this brick wall too, even the concept of exceeding VMO is a challenge to some of them

Not even close
good one, comparing pilots for truth to a brick wall, a dumbed down one at that.

Exceeding Vmo... for a change of command we flew the Wings aircraft as a "pass in review" flyby. We had a U-2, 4 T-38s, the SR-71, and "my" KC-135... we finished our AR (air refueling) and dropped down to the CA central valley... we could hear the T-38s asking where we were as we silently joined the loose formation of 38s, and the 71. We would go last.
When we executed the flyby, the only thing a tanker can do is make black smoke and lots of noise... so as we followed the SR-71, at field boundry I pushed the throttle up to "max thrust" (a max EPR, not firewall), we had the noise and smoke... the boom was down... but I looked at the airspeed, we had exceed Vmo by a lot, and I ripped the throttle back to idle, catching the copilots hand, who was guarding the throttles... the plane few great, and the extra speed made it easy to turn right and pull up from 500 feet, to 3000 feet back to Radar (approach control)... we almost caught the SR-71 during my over Vmo smooth flight ride.
The other time I know of a KC-135 exceeding Vmo was our number two in the Indian Ocean... we were beating feet back to base to turn our aircraft, number two wanted to fly close to us, but I was flying Vmo back to the base and had a few miles on 2; no way he can catch me... But he did as we pitched out to land at Diego... on the ground he had gone to fast and ripped of some skin under the leading edge of the wing... a KC-135 lost skin exceeding Vmo... We had been flying .9 MACH until lower when we picked up 355 KCAS, which is kind of reflected on the airspeed indicator with a pointer... it is actually below Vmo, and we fly over the Vmo marker some times when we calculate Vmo explicitly, and fly that indicated airspeed during refueling the SR... next
... pilotsfor911truth ... I do not believe it, and I am not presenting it as evidence ...
It is easy to see how stupid claims are at pilot for truth...

Pilots for truth claim an engine ejected when Flight 175 hit the WTC tower, is not from Flight 175. That is border line insanity... delusional BS. Radar proves it was 175, and pilots for truth amazing have no clue; so they make up lies. And they go from idiotic claims, like not 175 engine, to the insanity of nano-thermite in the dust.

With implications of planes being swapped, or dumber claims, etc, 911 truth pilots for truth nuts ignore the fact Insurance companies would all be on the pilots for truth BS claims train, if it was reality based... but pilots for truth are nuts who appear to be trying to make up the dumbest and most insane claims possible. Insurance companies out for all the damage could refuse to pay if pilots for truth claims were not BS...

Another reason to avoid pilot for truth claims and interaction...
“Mark Roberts deserves to die a traitors [sic] death for trying to suppress 9/11 families from seeking the Truth.”–"Pilots for

Truth" founder, and ex-commercial pilot, Robert Balsamo
"Mark Roberts does deserve to die a traitors death....
I will not apologize for it this time. I will be there for his death should America fall into Civil War. That is not a threat. .that is a promise.
If he gets in my way of defending our Constitution.. it will be my pleasure to put a bullet in his head to defend our Constitution from enemies foreign or domestic." –"Pilots for Truth" founder Robert Balsamo

He sounds like McVeigh, but only sells BS on DVDs.

Some times the failed pilots and peanut gallery at pilots for truth bring up BS like nukes and thermite, and ignore the energy to destory the WTC was stored in the towers; the inablity to do physics, is proved post after post by people who can't figure out 911 given the answers... they ignore E=mgh and fail to realize the energy released. NO physics, just fantasy.

With pilots for truth spread lies about flight and buying into insane claims of thermite from Jones and Harrit... no surprize they failed to fool you with their extra credit delusional lies... falling for the lie Jones found thermite in the dust an ignoring the dust energy did not match the energy in thermite... and the paper did not offer proof of thermite, making the people at pilot for truth reading comprehension challenged gullible followers. And adding more BS, pilot for truth posters claim nano-thermite has orders of magnitude increases in power, yet when burned offer less and more energy of termite on an order of 1, not magnitude. Guess the heat energy of office fires equal to more than 2700 Tons of Thermite does not impress those who can't comprehend steel fails in fire...

An order of magnitude is 10... orders of magnitude are more than 100 times more... pilots for truth, no clue for 14 years.

If we had a drinking game for the lies and BS of pilots for truth, we would not be able to find enough makers mark to keep the game going...

And you can forget about the BS of living terrorists, it is explained above, and was one of the dumbest 911 truth BS dead-end no meaning BS claim. You never did source the alive terrorist lie...
Most likely you got the lie from 911 truth nuts... But the original story was a mistake...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/1559151.stm
And then 911 truth failed followers jumped on the BS and started rumor based on ignorance and paranoia.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theeditors/2006/10/911_conspiracy_theory_1.html
BBC printed a retraction...
Guess 911 truth followers repeating this BS failed to do research.
 
Last edited:
Most likely you got the lie from 911 truth nuts... But the original story was a mistake...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/1559151.stm
And then 911 truth failed followers jumped on the BS and started rumor based on ignorance and paranoia.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theeditors/2006/10/911_conspiracy_theory_1.html
BBC printed a retraction...
Guess 911 truth followers repeating this BS failed to do research.

Thank you for the links.

Actually, I got the lie from a source much less trustworthy than 911 truth. I got it from the BBC on 23 September 2001. Seeing that again brought it right back to me. Back then the BBC was my news media of choice, before I fully appreciated what a foul pit of scum and villainy they are.

I remember the discussions in the office, mocking the FBI for cocking it up. I think they linked it in to an old Monty Python sketch of failed kamikaze pilots on some of the satirical shows.

I suspect that a lot more people saw the article at the time than saw the update two weeks later, (which is actually posted as separate articles, not a retraction. Auntie would never admit to printing a lie). More than the BBC though, chances are it was front page news on every tabloid as well. Those things are poison, even if you don't read them, just walking past a news stand, the headlines get subliminally inserted into your brain. Terrorists Alive! FBI Cockup! over and over again. That's probably where it stuck, reinforced as the talk of the day, repeated on every news bulletin for weeks, and a little retraction hidden away in an editorial somewhere. How many people read the editorials, let alone one 5 years later? Corrections are always much, much smaller than the main story.

I don't remember seeing any headlines at the time "BBC cocks up, fuels conspiracy theories!", or "BBC apologises for massive mistake", or even "Dead Terrorists found alive are actually still dead", or maybe "Hijack 'suspects' alive and well, Hijack suspects dead".

"The High Court in London today ruled that the BBC can print what the 'hell' it likes, as long as it puts 'inverted' 'commas' around some of it, to prevent the implication that it is 'reporting' facts. Lord Justice Fatwallet concluded "a fact's not a fact if it's in quotes" before dismissing the case, and awarding the BBC £3.50 in damages, and 'half' a tuna sandwich he had been 'sitting' on. No-one was available at the BBC for comment.

Even though I'm technically at the BBC, so I suppose I could comment. Tell me, how do I feel after today's ruling? No comment.
What's my answer to allegations that we don't check our facts properly? No comment.

We now go back to the studio, I'm Dumb Down, BBC, London. "
 
Assuming your reply applies to both of the above inquires, the fact that you are bringing up long debunked memes yet again is doubly odd.

Or perhaps I have a life, and thought everything would blow over and sort itself out. That the land of the brave and home of the free World Police would settle down.

Maybe I paid attention at the time, and then just left it sitting bubbling away in the back of my mind until recently. Maybe I didn't keep up to date, and spend years arguing on forums with complete strangers. Perhaps now that I look into see what's being said there are a million more sources of conflicting information. I'm definately older, possibly wiser, and a damn sight less trusting of official sources and mainstream media, which makes finding out the truth a lot harder. Ignorance is bliss, in many ways life is a lot easier if you sit back, don't give a ****, and let the corporations pour instructions into your head. You don't have to think, just be. Let the news tell you how the world is and ought to be. No need to find out who the bad guys are and who to trust, television will tell you who has been naughty or nice. Don't worry if what we tell you now is not the same as what we told you yesterday, the world has moved on, let go of the past. We will tell you what the past was when we want you to know it. Now, here's a picture of a Kardashian, and you can almost see a nipple!
 
Can you support the BBC as the source for the still living terroridts?
I don't remember it at all.
 
Can you support the BBC as the source for the still living terroridts?
I don't remember it at all.

Actually I believe it was first reported in Arab media outlets and then the BBC and Daily Telegraph got hold of it a couple of days later and basically re-reported it.

Where the confusion stemmed from was US media outlets taking the list of names from the FBI and digging up photographs of people (presumably from the internet) without actually making sure it was the same person. Once the FBI released photographs a little bit later it became clear they were talking about different people.
 
Or perhaps I have a life,...!
Being fooled by the BBS for over 14 years is not proof. Gee, why would anyone fail follow up; if the claim was true, one could team with a USA newspaper and earn a pulitzer for alive terrorists... But it seem to have had life for 14 years, because you have a life...

Learn to type faster, and while typing online stuff, take care of TV, or old movie watching, thus combining two or more tasks so one can "have a life". lol what a weak veiled put down BS statement.

Is love of the USA a motive to find a 911 truth BS claim to nail on the USA.

Do you think pilots for truth are covert anti-Semitic liars on 911, or in the spreading lies to sell DVDs filled with dumbed down tripe.
The IRS claim, was silly, since pilots for truth can't source the accuracy of an initialized IRS... you put in the present position, wait 10 minutes, and when it is ready, the pilot set it to NAV... the pilot has indication if the alignment worked, because the unit works; I doubt if any pilots take the NAV output and check it to see where the IRS thinks it is at, because it does not matter as long as it is within standards... Big Clue, the IRS drifts up to .5 NM an hour, thus after one hour the IRS is 6000 feet more off, etc

Thus Balsamo is unable to source what is allowable alignment accuracy... I can tell you if you put in a present position off by a lot at alignment, INSs will not align properly. The INS can find latitude, but not good at longitude; thus you must be close... how close, it is a degree, or what; should we ask Balsamo
 
Last edited:
Can you support the BBC as the source for the still living terroridts?
I don't remember it at all.

I don't understand your question.

Do I support the BBC? Hell no.
Did I believe them at the time? Most certainly. The BBC had, to many, a much stronger reputation for reliability than pretty much everyone else on the planet. Then we found out it was all smoke and mirrors and PR.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom