Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

... stop your BS ... and Gish Gallop. ...

Should I point out this is indicative of your knowledge of 911.

I have no idea what Gish Gallop ... is. ...

Any more questions about the flight paths?
Why does 911 truth lies about the flight paths or hitting buildings being hard, or impossible for expert pilots?
 
Last edited:
Specifically, which error or omission changes the conclusion that 19 terrorists hijacked 4 planes and crashed them?
Or that steel, when exposed to extreme heat, will fail? (Not melt - FAIL)

BE SPECIFIC.

What is wrong with you?
 
What is wrong with you?

Please be so kind as to identify one actual "error" in the 9/11 reports that actually casts doubt on whether 4 planes did, in fact, crash on that day, hijacked, in fact, by the 19 terrorists.

And, oh, yes...do try to do so without the manly expostulations, hey?

Looking forward to your detailed reply.
 
Why does 911 truth lies about the flight paths or hitting buildings being hard, or impossible for expert pilots?

I am not qualified to interpret whatever you are trying to say here.

That being said, I do have a question about flight paths etc. I will try and frame it so that you can grasp the fundamentals of what I am asking, and reduce the amount of BS replies I will have to wade through.

I saw an article on Pilots for 9/11 truth that I think may be spurious, but as I am not an aeroplane person, I am asking a question about it. This article referred to INS data contained within the FDR file. The thrust of the article was that the latitude and longitude coordinates contained within the file did not plot exactly to the runways at Dulles. There was an attempt to realign the data with the runways, however this then indicated that the alleged plane in question would not have departed from Gate D26, as Flight 77 was supposed to. The speculation then ranged from either the data was faked, the plane was faked, or something else entirely.

Let me be clear, this is not what I believe, I am not presenting anything as fact, other than that I read something written by someone else. In fact I challenged the adjusted data, as it appeared that the plane in question taxied down a service road, something I do not think would have happened, but I digress.

The discussion split into whether the plane would, could or should take off without setting the INS coordinates at the gate. Would and Should are obviously speculatory, and opinions are welcomed on such a matter. However some claimed that the plane could not take off without INS numbers being entered, as something I can't recall would be in NAV mode.

So (he said breaking the rule of so, apparently), my questions are as follows:

Is it possible to move a plane without the INS numbers changing?
Is it possible to take off without setting the INS numbers?
Is it likely, common or unusual (speculate away) for a pilot not to set these numbers before take off?

Where do planes go to sleep? If it has finished for the day, do they shove it somewhere else out of the way? If so, does it go there under it's own power, or does it get towed?

No claims, no facts, just questions.
 
What's the problem? He's just asking questions.

I don't know if he's taking the piss or what.

I am not saying that those errors change a damn thing, I am stating as fact, because it is true, that they exist. ...

After saying this, why ask me

Specifically, which error or omission changes the conclusion that 19 terrorists hijacked 4 planes and crashed them?

What is the problem with establishing, as a baseline, that there were errors? It appears that it is you lot who are stuck in the Perfect Solution fallacy as previously mentioned.

Lets try a starter for 10, and see if you can keep up this time.

The NIST report did not acknowledge that building 7 underwent a period of near free-fall during its collapse.

It was brought to their attention that for a period of time, building 7 did in fact do so.

NIST amended their claims to include this information. Is any of this in dispute, or can we move on?
 
Please be so kind as to identify one actual "error" in the 9/11 reports that actually casts doubt on whether 4 planes did, in fact, crash on that day, hijacked, in fact, by the 19 terrorists.

And, oh, yes...do try to do so without the manly expostulations, hey?

Looking forward to your detailed reply.

What is wrong with you? Is this contagious, it appears to be spreading.
 
I saw an article on Pilots for 9/11 truth... .

That would be your first problem - believing anything from that website would even be close to an objective, erudite and/or serious discussion of the topic.
 
Where do planes go to sleep? If it has finished for the day, do they shove it somewhere else out of the way? If so, does it go there under it's own power, or does it get towed?
What an odd question. The answer is they stay right where they were parked until the next scheduled flight*. It's usually not that long because these things are hugely expensive and it makes no money unless it's flying.

I wonder why you ask about this?

* unless there is a maintenance issue that needs specialized facilities.
 
Last edited:
...
The NIST report did not acknowledge that building 7 underwent a period of near free-fall during its collapse. ...
The free fall period, after the interior was collapsing for 10 or 12 seconds, is in the NIST data. Gee, the NIST raw data is a video... open to all. This is BS...

LOL, did you read NIST yet? Even if NIST left out the free fall period, the collapse for that section was 40 percent slower than free-fall...
NIST%20WTC%207%20free%20fall.jpg

oops, NIST report... did they add it, or was the free-fall always in the raw data? what does it mean?
How does this make an omission, since it was in the data?
Fall time of the 18 floors remains at 40 percent slower than freefall, and why did free fall not happen right off the bat?

Looks like the interior collapsing made the facade experience a period of free-fall acceleration, since the interior, the support for the facade was gone many seconds before. What do you think?

What is the point of the BS>? What does it mean; you will never say.

Who can explain how NIST made an error by including more information about the timing of the collapse? How does this help 911 truth claims? And which claims are supported by this BS? What is the point? This is not an omission, it is an inclusion; big fail, no clue what claim this supports... no one has said what this means; can you? no


Since NIST got the timing from a video, and proof is they had the basic data in the draft, the 40 percent slower than free-fall time remains a fact. Thus there is no error, no omission, gee, NIST added more detail to the fall time, which supports the fact the interior failed many seconds before the exterior, the roof-line fell. Thus this is not an error, not an omission.

it is illogical to claim an error or omission for something in the final report.... wow
 
Last edited:
I saw an article on Pilots for 9/11 truth that I think may be spurious,...
lol, pilots for truth have no valid claims, only BS, lies and idiotic nonsense.

Yes, pilots for truth think an INS would be perfect position when present position is used to initialize the INS. But how can a model of the earth in the INS be perfect as it "spins" up; what are the errors? The INS alone can drift over 1/2 mile an hour, and you are worried it is 2000 feet off at takeoff?
The p4t make up BS to sell DVDs, follow the money. And they offer no theory... When you put in the initial position what are the possible errors? Is 500 feet too far off? Do you know how an INS works?

I remember my Navigator babying the INS to get it down to 1/4 mile at takeoff, he made me sit for 15 minutes... I doubt commercial pilots car about accuracy of INS over the USA, we had VORs all over the place, this is a no brain area to fly, you can use the old VOR and be accurate enough in 2001... no need for super INS, or GPS in 2001. Accuracy in flight can kill, and now with GPS there are procedures to fly off course... lol

This article referred to INS data contained within the FDR file. The thrust of the article was that the latitude and longitude coordinates contained within the file did not plot exactly to the runways at Dulles. ...
How many feet off was it? An INS is started by entering a present position. The earth model in the INS needs this position to be close to the real position of the plane, or the INS will have problems running algorithms based on an earth model. When it wakes up, it is only as accurate as the system allows, which might be as good as a 1/4 mile. Gee, will the data line up with the taxiway? No.
As a pilot do I need the position the INS thinks we are at to be exact, or is 1/4 to 1/2 mile okay? I use my eyes to taxi out, NOT the INS. During flight the INS drifts... DME/DME are used to slowly correct INS errors and drive the position to best possible position based on algorithms, Kalman filters, etc... Look up INS errors, look up wiki, INS stuff.
Pilots for truth are not a credible source for anything but maybe the date of 911.
There was an attempt to realign the data with the runways, however this then indicated that the alleged plane in question would not have departed from Gate D26, as Flight 77 was supposed to. ...
Yes, the data shows Flight 77 2,000 feet off the runway, this is why we don't use the INS for takeoff direction, we use the MARK1 Eyeball... gee,

The speculation then ranged from either the data was faked, the plane was faked, or something else entirely....
How can the data be faked? Are you saying the p4t nuts say the NTSB is in on some plot? How do you fake a FDR? All the data from over 24 hours of flight on the FDR are consistent with standard INS errors. How did they fake reality so well? Remember, p4t offer no theory, only BS sold on DVD...

In fact I challenged the adjusted data, as it appeared that the plane in question taxied down a service road, something I do not think would have happened, but I digress....
We don't taxi with the INS, who would?

The discussion split into whether the plane would, could or should take off without setting the INS coordinates at the gate. ...
Which means what? The INS is easy to set up for someone who is current in the system; I don't need the INS, I could use the VOR in the USA; when I flew overseas, the INS is nice, but I had a Navigator who could use the stars, moon and sun to navigate with +-25NM accuracy... no need for BS INS.

However some claimed that the plane could not take off without INS numbers being entered, as something I can't recall would be in NAV mode....
So? What would this mean?

Is it possible to move a plane without the INS numbers changing?...
Without power? Why would the INS numbers change?

Is it possible to take off without setting the INS numbers?...
gee, I hope you can take off, what if it was an emergency?

Is it likely, common or unusual (speculate away) for a pilot not to set these numbers before take off?...
Why would pilots on 911 not set up the INS, it was working normal, and was correcting over time using DME/DME... The offset from the beginning of the flight to the end changed over time, as the system applied correction.

Where do planes go to sleep? ...
On a sleep Number bed set to 77.
If it has finished for the day, do they shove it somewhere else out of the way? ...
lol, and this would be with respect to what 911 truth claim?
If so, does it go there under it's own power, or does it get towed?...
It depends, you want to pay for jet fuel and engine wear, or a tug fuel... hello...
If you are loading furniture in the PI, you go out and taxi it close to the road, load up, and taxi back, in your t-shirt...

No claims, no facts, just questions. ...
lol, JAQ, the 911 truth method to woo.

Let me try again?
Why does 911 truth lies about the flight paths?
911 truth claims the flying was too hard for novice pilots, and too hard for expert pilots... Why does 911 truth lie?
You can't comprehend why people lie about 911.
Pilots for truth sell DVDs to people; the DVDs are filled with lies, aimed at the gullible conspiracy theory fringe few.

Why does 911 truth lie and say it is hard to hit 200 foot wide buildings? Or 900 foot wide Pentagon?

Why do you say Flight 93 did not make the crater in PA? Did you see the thousands of aircraft parts due to the Kinetic Energy impact equal to 1200 pounds of TNT? That is a lot of TNT...
 
Last edited:
The NIST report did not acknowledge that building 7 underwent a period of near free-fall during its collapse.
False statement - lying by half truth plus implication.

The period of free fall was both expected as a possibility and of Zero significance.

The NIST report was NOT directed at people who not comprehend basic physics OR David Chandler who MUST know better. Chandler misrepresents physics - which MUST be deliberate dishonesty on his part given that he is supposed to be a retired high school teacher of physics.

I and quite a few others posting here can attempt to overcome the shortcomings in your understanding - but not whilst you keep engaging in the partial truths/dishonesties and snide comments.

It was brought to their attention that for a period of time, building 7 did in fact do so.
Near enough to true. The draft report was "out for comment" and Chandler queried the non-event of "near free fall" - thereby revealing two things:
1) His own limited competence at applied physics; AND
2) His personal and dishonest commitment to the "truther meme" that free fall somehow only occurs with CD. FALSE - free-fall is a characteristic of the collapse mechanism. NOT what started the collapse.

So why not start to learn some basic points of the physics of collapse dynamics. Here is a first entry for your list of "points learned":

#1 Free fall does not distinguish collapses which initiated with assistance from CD from so called "natural" or fire induced collapses.

NIST amended their claims to include this information. Is any of this in dispute, or can we move on?
Who is disputing it? You are the one who needs to move on. Yes it is true. So what?

Suggestion - why don't you drop your unfounded snide comments and repeated "lies by innuendo"...

....as several members have challenged - be specific.

#2 There was no CD at WTC on 9/11.

Do you accept that simple fact? If you don't are you aware that no one has EVER demonstrated a prima-facie ("case to answer") supporting CD.

So if you want to assert that there was CD you are out on your lonesome.

You would be well advised to get at least some basic understanding of the physics involved BEFORE you blindly parrot "truther memes".
 
Is it possible to move a plane without the INS numbers changing?
Yup. Those numbers will be whatever the last PIC jammed in. TUG drivers mostly do not care.
Is it possible to take off without setting the INS numbers?
Yup. Are you suggesting that birds and bees do not exist? Personally speaking I find landing far more stressful.
Is it likely, common or unusual (speculate away) for a pilot not to set these numbers before take off?
Do you even know what you are asking? I could sit in the cockpit and dial up the numbers for Baku, Azerbaijan just for fun. Tomorrow, when the next pilot lands in the left hand seat those very same numbers will be sitting there.

Bet you don't even know the significance of "the left hand seat".

Where do planes go to sleep?
Designated parking areas When I come home, I park my car. It does not somehow vanish until I climb back into it for the ensuing eight or so hours.
If it has finished for the day, do they shove it somewhere else out of the way?
Yes. Those are called parking areas.
If so, does it go there under it's own power, or does it get towed?
Both. Usually it is cheaper to use a tug.

No claims, no facts, just questions.
Sure you are.
 
Over the USA, on a clear day, I don't know why a flight crew would be particularily concerned about accurate INS setting. As mentioned above there are abundant VOR/DME sites all over the USA and Canada plus ILS for landing.
2000 ft out at take off.....so what? The easiest part in daylight on a clear day, would be finding your take off runway. After take off , being half a mile out makes little difference with VOR to follow and ATC providing routing info. Not to mention being able to orient oneself by landmarks.

I have been in many a small plane with no INS, no GPS, flying to remote northern villages with no VOR, no NDB, no radar coverage. Yet the pilot gets me there everytime unerringly. After all he/she has a map, and its called Visual Flight Rules for a reason.
 
What is wrong with you? Is this contagious, it appears to be spreading.

Sweetie: there is nothing "wrong with" me. It is, in fact, you who seem to be saying that 911Truth is real(!) because there are errors(!) in the "official narrative"(!).

Why not point out what "errors" exist; further, what difference those "errors" make; what "third side" those "errors" reveal?

Remember that "a difference that makes no difference is no difference".

You might also consider doing so without the hybris; without the manly expostulations; without the aggrieved posturing.

"Come on Neville, show us what you got."

ETA: Nothing to say about your egregious "puppy pile" error, caused by your hasty search for a put-down? Tsk, tsk...

AETA: What do you, personally, find to be the significance of "free fall", in a gravity well?
 
Last edited:
By the way:
I'll follow that up with an opinion. Truthers are winning the PR war. Videos like Loose Change are slick and compelling.
The PR war is the only one they can fight. The court war has been lost at every attempt, and they don't have weapons to fight the technical war or the evidence-based war with.

And this is how the PR war is going:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=220104
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8267554#post8267554
 
Welcome to the forum AClark. I think from reading your posts that you are confused and misinformed about the facts of 9/11, as I was (well, I'm still a bit confused!) before I read the good posts on this forum for a few years.

In the main there are two types of regular posters on here: those who want to educate people who have heard about 9/11 Truth claims and don't understand the science thoroughly enough to evaluate the claims properly, and those for whom posting on here is a recreational activity where they vociferously marvel at how stupid twooferz are, call them names and pick fights with them.

Unless you actually want to join in with this childish behaviour, it is best to ignore this latter group as the last thing they want is for anyone who is confused to understand the issues better, they just want to fight.

It has been my experience that of the regular posters active in this thread, Ozeco41, pgimeno, Oystein, jaydeehess and Dave Rogers are the main ones who will really listen to what you say (if you take the time to outline a proper argument) and be willing to put in an equal effort to help you to understand anything you may be confused about.
 
Last edited:
Welcome to the forum AClark. I think from reading your posts that you are confused and misinformed about the facts of 9/11,
Agreed :thumbsup:
....as I was (well, I'm still a bit confused!) before I read the good posts on this forum for a few years.
..sure ... but personally it has been a pleasure trying to assist you, Georgio, with some explanations.

In the main there are two types of regular posters on here: those who want to educate people who have heard about 9/11 Truth claims and don't understand the science thoroughly enough to evaluate the claims properly, and those for whom posting on here is a recreational activity where they vociferously marvel at how stupid twooferz are, call them names and pick fights with them.
:thumbsup::thumbsup:
Great summary Georgio.
Those are the distinctions which matter. There are some "middle ground" people but the split into "explainers" and "disagree-ers" is good enough for government work.
Unless you actually want to join in with this childish behaviour, it is best to ignore this latter group as the last thing they want is for anyone who is confused to understand the issues better, they just want to fight.
And fighting "like with like" will put you on the losing side AClark - "they" have you outnumbered and "Who started the name calling?" wont win any points. Whether it was you or "them".
It has been my experience that of the regular posters active in this thread, Ozeco41, pgimeno, Oystein, jaydeehess and Dave Rogers are the main ones who will really listen to what you say (if you take the time to outline a proper argument) and be willing to put in an equal effort to help you to understand anything you may be confused about.
Thanks Georgio. My primary goal is explaining - not winning arguments. And those other four are "explainers" - plus they are all brave enough to tell me when I'm wrong. (...err...ummm..."When they think I am wrong." :o ;))
 
Last edited:
Sweetie: there is nothing "wrong with" me. It is, in fact, you who seem to be saying that 911Truth is real(!) because there are errors(!) in the "official narrative"(!).

Why not point out what "errors" exist; further, what difference those "errors" make; what "third side" those "errors" reveal?
Remember that "a difference that makes no difference is no difference".

You might also consider doing so without the hybris; without the manly expostulations; without the aggrieved posturing.

"Come on Neville, show us what you got."

ETA: Nothing to say about your egregious "puppy pile" error, caused by your hasty search for a put-down? Tsk, tsk...

AETA: What do you, personally, find to be the significance of "free fall", in a gravity well?
clap.gif
clap.gif


Exactly. Those are the three key questions of process.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom