Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

There are three types of posters... ones who bring woo, those who say it is woo, and those who are confused and upset after being told 911 truth is nonsensical woo because they were fooled by so called 911 truth experts.

911 truth is a movement of lies which fool people. A pathetic movement which misleads.
 
Last edited:
There are three types of posters... ones who bring woo, those who say it is woo, and those who are confused and upset after being told 911 truth is nonsensical woo because they were fooled by so called 911 truth experts.
clap.gif
clap.gif
Well said Sir!!!

911 truth is a movement of lies which fool people. A pathetic movement which misleads.
Yes. And if we take the posts of new member AClark as examples - the truth movement is still fooling people.

Why do CT supporters believe obviously false assertions from truth movement sources when they have top grade professional advice available - here in the fields of aviation reality and structural collapse dynamics. :o
 
I am not saying that those errors change a damn thing, I am stating as fact, because it is true, that they exist. ...

After saying this, why ask me

Specifically, which error or omission changes the conclusion that 19 terrorists hijacked 4 planes and crashed them?

What is the problem with establishing, as a baseline, that there were errors? It appears that it is you lot who are stuck in the Perfect Solution fallacy as previously mentioned.

The "problem" appears to be that when you lay down a premise as if it has some significance, then most people will expect you to follow up with some logical argument that follows from that premise, but you seem baffled by the request.
 
What is the problem with establishing, as a baseline, that there were errors?
That is not "the problem". There can be no doubt that any report into a complex event will have errors and omissions. So bleeding what?

YOU are the one ranting on as if it matters. Yet you refuse to say what are the errors that concern you and why they matter - and setting aside the proof that there are errors which is probably beyond your level of expertise.

So why not simply define a few of your alleged problems. And let some of us tell you what is wrong with them?
It appears that it is you lot who are stuck in the Perfect Solution fallacy as previously mentioned.
Gawd - pot v kettle - OR "mirror".
 
That is not "the problem". There can be no doubt that any report into a complex event will have errors and omissions. So bleeding what?

YOU are the one ranting on as if it matters. Yet you refuse to say what are the errors that concern you and why they matter - and setting aside the proof that there are errors which is probably beyond your level of expertise.

So why not simply define a few of your alleged problems. And let some of us tell you what is wrong with them?

Asserting premises like that without drawing conclusions seems to be similar to "just asking questions": They both appear to be inviting the reader to jump to his own conclusions while dodging any responsibility for invalid conclusions.
 
Last edited:
That would be your first problem - believing anything from that website would even be close to an objective, erudite and/or serious discussion of the topic.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove a breach of rule 0 and rule 12. Please review your membership agreement to which you agreed on joining the forum.


Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove forum management discussion. Please see the PM I have sent you.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That would be your first problem - believing anything from that website would even be close to an objective, erudite and/or serious discussion of the topic.
Stop telling the truth... it is banned in the world of 911 truth woo.

Pilots for truth offer BS, their only product. (and DVDs filled with BS)
 
Last edited:
Welcome to the forum AClark. I think from reading your posts that you are confused and misinformed about the facts of 9/11, as I was (well, I'm still a bit confused!) before I read the good posts on this forum for a few years.

In the main there are two types of regular posters on here: those who want to educate people who have heard about 9/11 Truth claims and don't understand the science thoroughly enough to evaluate the claims properly, and those for whom posting on here is a recreational activity where they vociferously marvel at how stupid twooferz are, call them names and pick fights with them.

Unless you actually want to join in with this childish behaviour, it is best to ignore this latter group as the last thing they want is for anyone who is confused to understand the issues better, they just want to fight.

It has been my experience that of the regular posters active in this thread, Ozeco41, pgimeno, Oystein, jaydeehess and Dave Rogers are the main ones who will really listen to what you say (if you take the time to outline a proper argument) and be willing to put in an equal effort to help you to understand anything you may be confused about.

Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you.
 
Asserting premises like that without drawing conclusions seems to be similar to "just asking questions": They both appear to be inviting the reader to jump to his own conclusions while dodging any responsibility for invalid conclusions.

There seems to be a very strong predisposition here to jumping very far to the most negative conclusion about the motives of the one asking the questions.

Lets try and simplify this for the more aggressive respondents on this forum:

Lets assume that I have a question to ask, and that before or during the asking of that question, I wish to set a baseline, and find out a little more about who I am dealing with. So, knowing that X is binary (TRUE or FALSE), regardless of it's significance, someone who cannot agree this simple premise on which all further discussions will be based, should be excluded from the discussion, especially if they are unwilling to have that view challenged.

Inventing motives, and assuming reasons way beyond the initial baseline is a fallacy and only slows down and muddies any further discussion.
 
... Out of interest, are we still going with the 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else? ... ...
and...
T... further discussion.
How many terrorist who did 911 were found alive? I am ready to discuss this one. Got some evidence yet? Can you source this claim?

Did you know they have the DNA profile for the terrorists on Flight 77 and 93? There are nine dead failed UBL followers... plus the 10 on 175 and 11. The DNA at the WTC was harder to find since the energy of collapse was equal in energy to more than 200 2000 pound bombs; and the energy of heat at the WTC fires was over the energy of 2700 tons of TNT, before collapse, not counting the heat energy of fires which burned for weeks...

When will you figure out the alive terrorists BS was a lie?
 
Last edited:
That is not "the problem". There can be no doubt that any report into a complex event will have errors and omissions. So bleeding what?

YOU are the one ranting on as if it matters. Yet you refuse to say what are the errors that concern you and why they matter - and setting aside the proof that there are errors which is probably beyond your level of expertise.

So why not simply define a few of your alleged problems. And let some of us tell you what is wrong with them?

From my perspective, that is the entirety of the problem, in a nutshell.

In many situations, the assumptions or declarations are laid out at the beginning. If the initial premise is false or challenged, then discussing anything further down the line is meaningless until those initial disagreements are resolved.

We agree that it is impossible for any of the reports into such a complex matter to be 100% accurate, therefore we can continue. Thank you for granting this tiny, and perhaps seeming irrelevant concession, (beleive me when I say it is extremely significant to me). It does not matter what those errors are, they are not even implied at this point. Inferring them is a fallacy, which is what many of the antagonists on this board have done. They have not only tried to anticipate my motives, they have assigned me beliefs that I do not hold, already challenged them in their own minds, and condemned both them and me. This is so much BS that I lack the words to fully express it.

At this point we have wasted so much time and effort trying to establish the basic foundations of asking a question, that I have already had to rule out a large portion of respondents as being relevant to this and any future discussions.
 
Welcome to the forum AClark. I think from reading your posts that you are confused and misinformed about the facts of 9/11, as I was (well, I'm still a bit confused!) before I read the good posts on this forum for a few years.

How many bad ones did you have to read? There seems to be a large noise to signal ratio here.


It has been my experience that of the regular posters active in this thread, Ozeco41, pgimeno, Oystein, jaydeehess and Dave Rogers are the main ones who will really listen to what you say (if you take the time to outline a proper argument) and be willing to put in an equal effort to help you to understand anything you may be confused about.

I have already determined that Oystein has a decent head on his shoulders, hopefully I can retain some semblance of sanity to deal with him and the others you mention. I will try not to get too distracted and angered by the foaming mouthed nut jobs that pad out the membership here.
 
... Which aircraft and who flew them is something else entirely..
The aircraft on 911 were exactly Flight 11, 175, 77 and 93. There is solid evidence for this, and no one has evidence otherwise. Even Radar proves this. anyone can get the Raw Radar data and check each flight's path, checking the NTSB work.

Who flew them, the terrorists; you can hear the pilots on Flight 93 being killed on a radio call... Also final words from flight crew helped the FBI identify who did 911.

Who flew the jets in your opinion; the pilots for truth failed to figure out much, what evidence do you have?
 
Last edited:
... I cannot identify the planes in question, nor who was aboard, I cannot categorically say what did or did not happen. ...

Each aircraft was identified. Did you see the NTSB reports, or check with United and American airlines. It is mandatory to have a flight manifest to fly, thus we know who was on board. The FBI have DNA for 9 or more terrorists. Thus we know who did it too. This took days to figure out; the FAA requires a manifest... don't fly if you do crime, you will be identified.

Anyone can identify the planes if you want, and the people who were on board; it is not logical to say otherwise since the evidence exists to prove who and what planes were used.

Opinions are not part of being a skeptic ...
 
Last edited:
What an odd question. The answer is they stay right where they were parked until the next scheduled flight*. It's usually not that long because these things are hugely expensive and it makes no money unless it's flying.

I wonder why you ask about this?

* unless there is a maintenance issue that needs specialized facilities.

Why is this an odd question? What motive or assumptions are you making on my behalf? I have stated that I am not an aeroplane person, so I am trying to ask aeroplane questions on an aeroplane thread in the hope of getting aeroplane answers. This is a lot harder than I thought it would be, as you lot cannot even agree on your interpretations of the questions I am asking, let alone the answers.

I am trying to establish the procedures and practices of air travel, it includes some assumptions on my part that may be incorrect.

I am assuming that planes are not in use 24/7. I am assuming that planes, after landing and offloading passengers and luggage are either scheduled to go again, or are moved elsewhere until their next flight, freeing up the gate for another flight. I am assuming that once a plane has finished its landing procedures (and is not scheduled to be turned around immediately) that it is powered down and towed to a parking area. I am assuming that when it is to be used again, it is towed to the correct gate. I am assuming that the plane changes its actual position in space and time, but that certain instruments onboard will not reflect this change if the plane is not powered on.

Your answer based on your assumptions is incomplete if landing is not the same as parking. You have missed at least one step in the events.

Now, as my pertinent questions were about INS, and its importance and relevance to the take off procedure, I wanted to make sure I wasn't missing anything relevant that happened before the plane arrived at the gate.

Contrary to popular belief, and as previously stated, I did not believe the article on p4t, and had previously challenged it. I could not fully challenge it because I am not competent to do so. Rather than asking in the forum where it was published, where the answers might have some bias, I came to an independent forum to see if I could further my understanding on the subject rather than taking their position as gospel, or jumping to too many conclusions myself. Unfortunately I was not prepared for the level of unsupervised mental patients I would run in to, and I crumbled under the onslaught of BS.

So, I am trying to frame questions with as little wriggle room in interpretation as I can, but it's bloody difficult given the standing level of hostility in the membership. It's a steep learning curve.
 
... as my pertinent questions were about INS, and its importance and relevance to the take off procedure, I. ...

The INS is aligned in parking (or as needed for the type of system used...). You insert the present position and align it. The errors in the system do not match the exact position, and the INS drifts 1/2 mile an hour. On 911 the offset slowly changes, as it did on prior flights for 77. Thus the INS Position showing 77 2,000 feet south of the runway is due to the INS errors. Look up INS and see how many system errors are in the INS.

The pilots for truth have no useful information for 911 issues. After 14 years of BS from 911 truth, it is amazing anyone says "own footprint" or free-fall to support the insane claim of CD, or thermite.

It does not matter where the plane has been, or parked before. But one option is to keep the planes as the Gate, and board it again. Fuel trucks come up and refuel the plane at the gate. the plane can be moved, but why? yes if needed. who cares, it is not factor. If moved the INS is still aligned when the crew aligns the INS based on the system used. There are quick alignment procedures, and longer alignments when use in the old days before GPS... with drift up to .5 NM per hour, the best alignment procedures would be used for over-water flights.
The position on 911 for 77 varied during the flight as DME/DME was used to update the position. Thus the initial offset seen in the data drifted during flight. Not sure why Balsamo made up idiotic claims about 911, or the INS.

Pilots for truth claim the INS should show an exact position, and they failed to see alignment can be off like it was due to INS errors... tiny angle errors during alignment can give over 600 m error in the position... and then the INS drifts

The pilots for truth are the ones with idiotic claims... they claim 77 was too high to hit the Pentagon, and say it would take 34gs to hit the Pentagon...

How is that evidence coming for the alive terrorists?
 
There seems to be a very strong predisposition here to jumping very far to the most negative conclusion about the motives of the one asking the questions.

Lets try and simplify this for the more aggressive respondents on this forum:

Lets assume that I have a question to ask, and that before or during the asking of that question, I wish to set a baseline, and find out a little more about who I am dealing with. So, knowing that X is binary (TRUE or FALSE), regardless of it's significance, someone who cannot agree this simple premise on which all further discussions will be based, should be excluded from the discussion, especially if they are unwilling to have that view challenged.

Inventing motives, and assuming reasons way beyond the initial baseline is a fallacy and only slows down and muddies any further discussion.

What, one wonders, prevents you from "setting" your "baseline", and asking your question?

Why not point out what "errors" exist; further, what difference those "errors" make; what "third side" those "errors" reveal?

You appear to be attempting to recruit agreement, without actually presenting an issue; among other things, this makes you look as if you are simply one more woo!-slinger with a "gotcha" you hope to unleash. If this is not so, why not simply ask your question?

You might also want to ponder the idea that it is not, after all, you who may or can exclude anyone from any discussion.

That being said, what questions have you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom