Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

911 truth believers are skeptics.
... I would consider myself to be an International Skeptic in the literal sense of the word.

Skeptic to full blown zero evidence conspiracy theorist in less than 22 posts.

Free-fall, alive terrorists, "own footprint", denial of gravity contribution to E=mgh released on 911, denial of DNA, Radar, FDR, and physical evidence.

14 years and 911 truth continues to fool a fringe few.

The winning part was funny.
... Truthers are winning the PR war. ...

Winning the PR war? But failing to produce any evidence to support the claims...

What is bad, no one in 911 truth tries to produce evidence, or refute the evidence.
http://www.ntsb.gov/about/Documents/Rec_Radar_Data_Study_all_aircraft.pdf
Why can't 911 truth attack the Radar data? They fail to study the Radar data, and fail to understand the NTSB had to provide the raw data to anyone who asks... and we have seen both truthers and skeptics take the Raw Data and plot it. 911 truth take the data and makes up BS claims of swapped planes, but leaves out the fact no planes were swapped, and there is no Radar data to support swapped aircraft, just BS that blips were close...

This thread was split when a 911 truth claim of the "loopdeloop" was believed as being too complicated a flight maneuver to be done even by expert pilots... We learn the belief is based on faith that 911 truth was truthful.

A skeptic hears the planes on 911 made some fantastic maneuver. A skeptic gets the Radar data and finds claims of impossible flight moves are dumbed down lies from BS artists selling lies on DVDs; follow the money... A fake skeptic does the Gish Gallop and we end up in Iraq, WMDs, and the gobermint lies...
 
Last edited:
A mistake so many conspiracy theorists make. As I suggested, how about joining or starting a thread on a subject you feel is significant, rather than slinging mud at random in the hope that some of it sticks?

Dave
This.

AClark: You have no one to blame but yourself for the way people are replying to you. You are all over the place with your posts.

Pick a thread and your best argument and support it. Can you do this? Scatter gun post get you back the same in kind.
 
You'll have to forgive me if I can't get to all of you at once, I appear to be at the bottom of a very large puppy pile, and it's difficult to sort out which posts to reply to. I fear that I have erred in trying to respond with quantity rather than quality, and some of the sophistry is rather distracting.

Rubbish. We are all asking you the same fundamental question.

And your response is "ooo, I'm all on my lonesome against you meanies" which is rather odd given you claim that there is also an overwhelming groundswell of 911 support.

Surely even you can see that it cannot be both.
 
1. They actually do go kind of nuts that way. I had enough of them as students.

Me too, no less than a whole gang of Al-Rashid princelings back when I was teaching English. "Devout" Moslems doing booze, illegal drugs, prostitutes and gambling is nothing new.
 
It's as if none of you guys ever actually research anything. This has been debunked for ten years over.

Looking back at it, I suspect he might have used "fabrication" in the sense of "lie". But it isn't clear.

Actually, he hasn't made anything about his beliefs clear.
 
Thank you Oystein, for seeing beneath what I wrote to what I was trying to say :)

I didn't appreciate the hornets nest I would be stirring up, and wasn't prepared for the barrage from all directions.


Thank you for agreeing that there are errors in the official reports. That is what I was trying to establish as a fact. I did not suggest a motive or a reason for this, I was attempting to draw a line in the sand. I beleive that there is more to the truth than is contained in those documents, and was trying to say that there could be no debate with someone who insisted that "the official narrative" was the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. It's the Perfect Solution fallacy from the other side, if you will.


My use of the word compelling was perhaps mistaken, in that I did not mean to imply a strict dictionary definition. Perhaps captivating would have been more accurate. I agree, polls are unreliable.

I disagree with you about NIST denying evidence. They did clearly state that there was no evidence of molten steel, and there was no evidence of explosions (not explosives). This is patently false, and I do not understand why they made such claims.

I do have difficulty however when you use absolutes in your points, no one, never etc. These are the very things that get quickly jumped upon should a so-called troother use them. I am also not sure what your big picture is. Fire fighters, relatives and professionals do disagree with some of the official narrative, and have asked for independent investigations for some time. I don't care if the truth embarrases someone, I do care if it proves negligence, or culpability. I do not understand the need for so much secrecy. I do not understand why there are some clear contradictions in testimonies by high level players like Cheney.

I'm glad that you can see my bigger global, political picture, and whether or not we agree on the specifics, we can agree on some of the consequences, and their ramifications. I think that they are inextripacably linked, and I see the massive amount of money being made off of the Middle East mess as ample motive to be involved in 9/11. I say motive, I do not say proof or evidence or even opportunity. I am not claiming some fact to be debunked.

I'm not sure what you are refering to as hyperbole. We see it in the UK as well. Heavy handed police tactics, random searches, an eradication of presumed innocence.

Am I advocating widespread violence and death? I'm not sure, to be honest. What would Abraham Lincoln have answered to that question? I will be happy to be wrong, but I don't rate the chances of a peaceful revolution, and an end to extreme capitalism. I forsee a continued widening of the rift between the haves and the have nots, leading to further privitisation of the police and military, until something breaks. When the rich get too greedy and complacent, empires fall. I don't know who Bernie Sanders is however, I tend not to look too closely at the pre-election promises of politicians, especially not in the US where I am not a native or resident.

In summary and conclusion, I am not 9/11 Truth, I'm me truth. Truth Lite if you will. I'm a lot more reasonable than some of the wack jobs out there. I have questions and assumptions, I make mistakes, I look before I leap some of the time, I occasionally turn my brain on and put it to good use.
 
... Thank you for agreeing that there are errors in the official reports. ...
What errors would change 19 terrorists were responsible for all the damage on 911... none. Fire caused the collapses on 911, no errors would change this, and in fact the errors you and 911 truth have, are BS, based on nonsense.
They did clearly state that there was no evidence of molten steel, ...
there is no evidence of melted steel on 911. Thus 911 truth lies, and now you support the lie based on the lie?
and there was no evidence of explosions (not explosives). ...
No explosives used on 911, no blast damage to WTC steel, no blasts from explosives. Who said there were no loud noises, like a propane tank exploding, or a transformer, or stuff which blows up in office fires... The CD stuff is fantasy, the 19 terrorists caused all the damage due to their acts; a fact
Fire fighters, relatives and professionals do disagree with some of the official narrative, and have asked for independent investigations for some time. ...
LOL, less than 0.1 percent of all engineers fall for the BS - thus a fringe few are supporting ignoring the completed studies and investigation done on 911; a sure sign of ignorance is requesting a new study when the experts can't comprehend the old study. This is classic BS from 911 truth. you have the support of a fringe few, and many are clearly nuts.

I do not understand why there are some clear contradictions in testimonies by high level players like Cheney. ...
What does Cheney have to do with 911? 911 as an event lasted much shorter than having some top down BS flow through NORAD or the USAF. In the USAF we have instructions which let us operate as needed in emergencies, we don't have to wait for the Vice President to come up with some beautify the roads of American BS to act on an emergency; thus bringing up the guys at top BS is a Gish Gallop to avoid the fat you have no evidence for what are clearly, as you say, Opinions. You have Opinions based on BS and politics, and the 19 terrorists skipped doing the BS you made up. 911 was over before any at the top would have an impact. Did fire fighter wait for Cheney? This is BS, and only a chance for more political BS opinions.

I'm glad that you can see my bigger global, political picture, ......
Yes, the bigger global stuff is BS, since it can't help the CD opinion, or help melted steel be real. Where is the melted steel? (OMG, is it from Appendix C?)
a peaceful revolution, ...
Based on lies from 911 truth?

... I am not 9/11 Truth, I'm me truth. ...
"own footprint", 911 truth, free-fall speeds, 911 truth (it is acceleration not speed), ejected steel 600 feet to imply it had to be explosives, 911 truth.
You have opinion based on opinions, thus no evidence.

You are 911 truth, just asking questions - based on opinions.

... As always, unless otherwise stated, these are my opinions, ...
Bringing opinions to a fact/evidence fight - big error -
 
Last edited:
I disagree with you about NIST denying evidence. They did clearly state that there was no evidence of molten steel, and there was no evidence of explosions (not explosives). This is patently false, and I do not understand why they made such claims

You have evidence of explosives and molten steel?

Where is it? No one has been able to present any yet.

Fire fighters, relatives and professionals do disagree with some of the official narrative, and have asked for independent investigations*
Which ones disagree and which parts do they disagree with?
Do they think it was anything but 19 hijackers crashing aircraft?
 
Last edited:
Fer ***** sake beachnut, wind your neck in. Not everything is about CD or even 9/11. Can you not simply read and discuss things without trying to start a fight?

There are errors and omissions in the official 9/11 reports. That's a fact, undeniable, irrefutable, inescapable.

Why does it hurt you much to acknowledge this one simple thing? Why do you have to twist it and cry BS. I am not saying that those errors change a damn thing, I am stating as fact, because it is true, that they exist. You can use that to deny that the Earth is over 5000 years old, or you can sit back down and shut up. I am not using that fact as proof of anything else, you are trying to make that connection.

Mistakes were made, get over it, move on. If you cannot, or will not acknowledge that, then you are worse than a troother. Why does it undermine your personal belief system so badly? Why do you have to create connections that are not there?

There is a very high probability that there are alien life forms elsewhere in the multiverse. This is an opinion that has nothing to do with CD or 9/11 and it does not change the fact that there are and were errors and omissions in the 9/11 reports.

Now play nice or go away.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove a breach of rule 10. Do not mask expletives in the public sections of the forum. If you must swear, type the words out in full and correctly spelled so that the autocensor can catch them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You have evidence of explosives and molten steel?

I said explosions, stop your BS whining and Gish Gallop. Your entire argument is invalid.

I have no idea what Gish Gallop even is. Not nice though when you are pounced upon for a tiny detail.
 
... unless otherwise stated, these are my opinions, ...
Fer ***** sake beachnut, wind your neck in. Not everything is about CD or even 9/11. Can you not simply read and discuss things without trying to start a fight? ...
You spread BS, or was it opinions. False information, like melted steel, explosives, and an inability to decide on CD, or not. Not a fight, more like facts.

There are errors and omissions in the official 9/11 reports. That's a fact, undeniable, irrefutable, inescapable. ...
And you can't source this, or list one. Kind of like this is...

Why does it hurt you much to acknowledge this one simple thing? Why do you have to twist it and cry BS. I am not saying that those errors change a damn thing, I am stating as fact, because it is true, that they exist. ...
Again, your opinion, when you need evidence. So are you are in the BS mode, just asking questions which are based on opinions. Saying you have support of firefighter, engineers, etc, is BS since not one of them have valid points for 911 truth like claims, which seem to match your MeTruth movement of opinions based on BS.

Mistakes were made, get over it, move on. If you cannot, or will not acknowledge that, then you are worse than a troother. Why does it undermine your personal belief system so badly? Why do you have to create connections that are not there? ...
List one? Right, there is no source, this is again what did you say? Opinion.

There is a very high probability that there are alien life forms elsewhere in the multiverse. This is an opinion that has nothing to do with CD or 9/11 and it does not change the fact that there are and were errors and omissions in the 9/11 reports....
There is no alien life in the multiverse, relax, a theory inside a theory does match the opinion Gish Gallop effort so far. But there are unicorns in the multiverse, I have proof...
What errors, what omissions; go ahead, make my day source this opinion, remove the BS cloud of woo; source.

Now play nice or go away. ...
I can't argue, you have opinions based on nothing, nonsense, or BS; take your pick. I was looking for evidence, you bring opinion.
... unless otherwise stated, these are my opinions, ...
I was trained in aircraft accident investigation, the impact of Flight 93 is exactly what a high speed impact with the parameters 93 brought to the crash would look like. You bring opinion, the crash site is fact; you don't think it was plane, that is at best an opinion, and worse, a lie based on willful ignorance and political bias.

Do you have more questions on the Flight path issue? Got proof any terrorists are still alive? How can a BBC BS news mistake be your opinion? Please retract the big lie any terrorists are alive, and live up to playing nice instead of repeating lies based on 911 truth BS of quote mining failed reports. Be a skeptic, stop spreading opinions and back up claims with evidence. Don't go away, be a skeptic, not an repeater of "own footprint"... what the heck does that mean?

Gish Gallop is what you are doing; presenting opinion after opinions as if they support your opinion...

You said melted steel, source it...

You say things but never source them. Show me an alive terrorist...

better yet, do you have problems... oops you do, you have an opinion the planes might been swapped, thus you deny Radar data proves the planes which were used. That is anti-science; do you have evidence to support the opinion the planes might not be the only planes on earth to be missing on 911. Only four planes are missing, and Radar tracked them to their impacts, did the planes magically do ... what?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I said explosions, stop your BS whining and Gish Gallop. Your entire argument is invalid.

I have no idea what Gish Gallop even is. Not nice though when you are pounced upon for a tiny detail.

Explosions are to be expected in such a scenario. Any sealed container subjected to intense heat might explode.

But there was no molten steel. There was no heat source of sufficiently high temperature for that.
 
Me too, no less than a whole gang of Al-Rashid princelings back when I was teaching English. "Devout" Moslems doing booze, illegal drugs, prostitutes and gambling is nothing new.

Yeah, I really hate doing that characterisation, but my experience is that they go flat out bonkers when let off the religious leash. Is that representative? I honestly do not know.

The one time (back in the nineties, I am that old)I found myself discombulated was with a palestinian chappy who was resolutely inert in every class. Until we got to FM transmitters and timers. That was most disturbing.
 
They never think that one through because the corollary is that only one "John Smith" must exist in the world.
Yeah. Up until that point I was doing my best to concede AClark's claim of being skeptic about both sides, but that straw elephant broke the camel's back.
 
I like rocks, they don't fall over due to fire.
Funny. I have seen that happen hundreds of times. I have also seen rocks explode from fire. Damned dangerous, you gotta pick your fire pit rocks with care. Now I am left wondering if GWB had explosives embedded in those exploding, falling over rocks. That bastard!
 
There are errors and omissions in the official 9/11 reports. That's a fact, undeniable, irrefutable, inescapable.

Specifically, which error or omission changes the conclusion that 19 terrorists hijacked 4 planes and crashed them?
Or that steel, when exposed to extreme heat, will fail? (Not melt - FAIL)

BE SPECIFIC.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom