Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

Assertions not proven. Which airport security footage are you referring to? Sorry, are you saying the paper trail was vaporized, or something else?

The assertion that an alleged terrorist is vaporized, proves that they hijacked a plane. That's good science is it?

Out of interest, are we still going with the 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else? Are we still labelling hard drinking, drug taking, gambling men as Muslim extremists? That's pretty extreme Muslim behaviour, I concede that.



Ahh good, you're not using any of that silly stuff that truthers do. The claim is the proof, and the proof is the claim. You're not taking this seriously, are you?



I tend to agree with you here. Which aircraft and who flew them is something else entirely.



I still cannot get a handle on the Shanksville situation (NIST approved answer).

Seriously, a plane, in that hole? You are kidding me right?



Many people were also surprised that they did fall, and so quickly too. And that they pulverised themselves so effectively, and that FEMA couldn't explain it, and that Nist couldn't prove it.

So the Steel that was found 600 feet away, that has been identified as originating above the 600 foot high mark, and an explanation for its lateral force has been given, yes?




I like rocks, they don't fall over due to fire.

Just out of interest, what do you consider acceptable evidence that anything at all happened on 9/11? Assuming you weren't a witness to the events, it seems to me that the best you could do here is note that you saw the Twin Towers prior to September 2001 and subsequently saw them not there in a place that the maps and/or public transport enterprises that took you there told you was the same place. The rest is all documented in the same sources whose validity you're questioning, and is a lot better documented than the fairy stories you've quoted above. If you reject the sources you don't agree with, why do you accept the equivalent ones that make the highly unusual assertion that four airliners crashed into three buildings and a field and that two 110 storey buildings collapsed?

Dave
 
You are either mistaken, or you are misrepresenting the facts. Partly this will depend on what you classify as evidence.

What am I misrepresenting? There has never been a coherent narrative presented by a "truther" that can pass even casual scrutiny.

I love the way that because I said I did not rule out CD, that I was somehow a proponent of it. There are other alternatives.

Why have you even ruled it in? There's no evidence of it.

I dispute the Nordenson theory, and I agree that the case for CD has not been proven. I am also open to any other evidence that may be presented.

What part do you dispute? Certainly not that building can be overwhelmed and collapse due to fire given enough time. That was his theory.

For example, an incomplete theory is that although the buildings were allegedly built to code, and certified as such by an allegedly impartial official, they were not fit for purpose. Criminal negligence on the part of some or all of those involved in the construction and certification of the building is grounds for a corporate manslaughter or even murder charge.
See Bailey and Nordenson for evidence that supports that theory.

I don't know how you got this from the Nordenson or Bailey testimonies because it was certainly not in the papers I read.
 
What lower reach? TV viewing figures are made up, we know that. Are you claiming that these are all distinct individuals, or is your maximum a fabricated 5 million?

Take it up with Barb.
I'm sure ITVs advertisers would be glad to know they're paying advertising rates based on a complete fabrication.

Are you only using Loose Change as the opposing viewpoint, or are you expecting me to try and calculate all the views of all the possible contrary view points?

You brought up Loose Change as an example of slickly produced material (which implies the above examples by me are not, or something)...so I presume it is your best example. And I take it, then, that you have no figures.

I'll help a bit. Online viewings are in the millions, with no idea of duplicate viewings, worldwide. It has not (as far as I am aware) had a screening in the UK. Since the total number of DVD prints was in the 100,000s, mostly given away, I doubt many made it to the UK.

What are you trying to do here other than dig yourself a deeper hole? Or are you actually arguing with Dave and Swoop who claim that no-one cares or has an opinion? According to you between 5 and 10.7 million people might have an opinion. Are we also assuming that because these unknown number of people that don't have an opinion, watched these shows that no-one cares about, in popular media that isn't covering it, all agree with the official narrative that doesn't exist?

Nurse, medication all round please.

I am simply pointing out that the "slick and compelling" videos (eg Loose Change) are a drop inthe ocean in the UK compared to the productions screened on mainstream UK TV.
 
I am simply pointing out that the "slick and compelling" videos (eg Loose Change) are a drop inthe ocean in the UK compared to the productions screened on mainstream UK TV.

Also, claiming that truthers are winning the PR war because their videos are so slick and compelling is like claiming that the Germans won the Second World War because the Me262 and King Tiger were really cool.

Dave
 
They never think that one through because the corollary is that only one "John Smith" must exist in the world.

picture.php
 
Assertions not proven. Which airport security footage are you referring to? Sorry, are you saying the paper trail was vaporized, or something else?

Security footage from the DC and Boston airports. Would you rather see the security footage from Helena, Montana? I'm saying the hijackers were vaporized. I'm sure some paper was too, but that's hardly important to the big picture.

Out of interest, are we still going with the 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else? Are we still labelling hard drinking, drug taking, gambling men as Muslim extremists? That's pretty extreme Muslim behaviour, I concede that.

762 John Smith's in Quincy, MA. I'll even do you one better:
picture.php



Ahh good, you're not using any of that silly stuff that truthers do. The claim is the proof, and the proof is the claim. You're not taking this seriously, are you?

No need for proof anymore. This is common knowledge. 19 hijackers took over 4 planes. This is a fact. Again, just because you don't agree, doesn't change it. What was it Neil DeGrass Tyson says? Science doesn't care what you believe.

I tend to agree with you here. Which aircraft and who flew them is something else entirely.

Actually it isn't something else. It is what it is - the 4 aircraft were proven to be at the crash sites using the wreckage. This is fact.

I still cannot get a handle on the Shanksville situation (NIST approved answer).

Seriously, a plane, in that hole? You are kidding me right?

Yep. A plane. A very large, very fast plane. Care to provide an alternative? I know you can't but I could use the laugh.

picture.php

Man, that almost looks like it was caused by something that was fat in the middle, and had these, I dunno. Wing-like things on either side.

Many people were also surprised that they did fall, and so quickly too. And that they pulverised themselves so effectively, and that FEMA couldn't explain it, and that Nist couldn't prove it.

Word salad.

So the Steel that was found 600 feet away, that has been identified as originating above the 600 foot high mark, and an explanation for its lateral force has been given, yes?
Momentum.

School's out kiddo. Get a new hobby. Preferably one that doesn't mock the murder of thousands of people.
 
They are quite complete. The official narrative, as you people refer to it, is as follows:

19 Hijackers planned to take over 4 aircraft. This is confirmed by voice recorders, airport security footage, and the fact that they're all vaporized, along with a paper trail showing them preparing for the event.

Assertions not proven. Which airport security footage are you referring to? Sorry, are you saying the paper trail was vaporized, or something else?
You claim you have not seen the security tapes? Sorry. Not buying that. They are everywhere on the internet.

Have one at random.

The assertion that an alleged terrorist is vaporized, proves that they hijacked a plane. That's good science is it?
Strawman. Nobody claimed that but you.

Out of interest, are we still going with the 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else?
That never happened. Take, for example, Muhammed Atta. Guess what his fathers name is.

You guessed it. Muhammed Atta. It turns out that Muhammed Attas are a dime a dozen throughout the ME.

Are we still labelling hard drinking, drug taking, gambling men as Muslim extremists? That's pretty extreme Muslim behaviour, I concede that.
1. They actually do go kind of nuts that way. I had enough of them as students.

2. The Koran mandates a dispensation for martyrs to be.

4 Aircraft were hijacked This is confirmed by the fact that 4 aircraft were hijacked.

Ahh good, you're not using any of that silly stuff that truthers do. The claim is the proof, and the proof is the claim. You're not taking this seriously, are you?
Erm...no. Strawman again. Nobody made any such claim, you simply invented it out of whole cloth in order to push your agenda.

3 Aircraft crashed into each WTC Tower and the Pentagon. Confirmed using so much evidence it's almost comical, if it weren't for the death and destruction. Live television footage, eyewitness accounts, radar tracking, aircraft wreckage found during cleanup, etc..etc...etc...

I tend to agree with you here. Which aircraft and who flew them is something else entirely.
Who flew them and which aircraft were they, then? You won't say because you haven't a clue.

1 Aircraft crashed in Shanksville, PA This backs up the fact that 4 aircraft were hijacked. Eyewitness accounts and aircraft wreckage at the site confirms this.

Please remember, your ignorance - willful or not - doesn't change facts.

I still cannot get a handle on the Shanksville situation (NIST approved answer).

Seriously, a plane, in that hole? You are kidding me right?
Nope. Done to death right here on these forums. That plane in that hole in the ground actually happened. Turns out to be typical for involuntary conversion of a jetliner with a high AOA.

Anyway,
The Twin Towers collapse Every canard "burning buildings don't collapse from fire" was proven wrong on that day. Many people, including laypeople such as myself were not surprised one bit that they collapsed. The fact that steel doesn't react well to prolonged heat is as basic as "water is wet". These fears were realized when the first tower fell, and confirmed when it happened for the second time in history less than an hour later. It should also come as no surprise that material that fell from 1,000 feet in the air can strike a building roughly 400 feet away.

Many people were also surprised that they did fall, and so quickly too. And that they pulverised themselves so effectively, and that FEMA couldn't explain it, and that Nist couldn't prove it.
As an engineer I was more surprised that they stood as long as they did after impact. Impressed even.

FEMA didn't explain it nor did NIST prove it because they are not in the business of investigating events which never happened.

So the Steel that was found 600 feet away, that has been identified as originating above the 600 foot high mark, and an explanation for its lateral force has been given, yes?
Yes.

Unless and until you people can come up with a scenario that better explains the entire day's events, you need to go back under the rock you come from.

I like rocks, they don't fall over due to fire.
They collapse due to fire. Analogy fail.
 
Mohamed Atta is still alive and one is over 55... I found 6 in the USA...

Playing the alive terrorist card, instant self-debunking.

... zero deviation from the typical BS from 911 truth. Zero rational research, and playing the alive terrorist card. Or the no plane in the hole made by a plane...


... I would consider myself to be an International Skeptic in the literal sense of the word.
Playing the terrorists are still alive card does not support this claim, and is the opposite of a skeptic.
Saying Flight 93 did not make the crater in PA, ignoring the FDR buried in the hole, is not a good sign for claiming to be an International Skeptic.
You never studied the evidence related to 911.
 
Last edited:
Same old. Nothing new at all, it's like the forum is stuck in a time warp.
Maybe a dedicated forum isn't needed anymore.
 
I don't know how you got this from the Nordenson or Bailey testimonies because it was certainly not in the papers I read.

Re-read the sections on unfilled flutes, and bracing that failed to meet the 2% lateral requirements. As I understand it, these should have been done but were not.
 

The damage to the Fiterman Hall building, opposite of the direction WTC 7 leaned, appears to have been caused by the perimeter structure peeling outwards.
sqFDnMS.jpg


It's pointless playing semantics with whether or not WTC 7 fell "into it's own footprint". The Verizon building was damaged because it like was right up against it. Considering that it may have been the world's tallest building to be imploded, it's quite the work of art. :thumbsup:

People would pay good money to have a building as big as 7 come down into a pile that small.
 
Last edited:
You'll have to forgive me if I can't get to all of you at once, I appear to be at the bottom of a very large puppy pile, and it's difficult to sort out which posts to reply to. I fear that I have erred in trying to respond with quantity rather than quality, and some of the sophistry is rather distracting.
 
Choose something and start a new thread.
These posts are getting in the way of this thread.
 
Last edited:
You'll have to forgive me if I can't get to all of you at once, I appear to be at the bottom of a very large puppy pile, and it's difficult to sort out which posts to reply to. I fear that I have erred in trying to respond with quantity rather than quality, and some of the sophistry is rather distracting.
You have no quality, you have lies and BS. You are the one with massive amounts of sophistry, and it appears it is "unknowing sophistry".

Someone is blindly repeating lies from 911 truth, all based on no evidence...

Flight 93 aircraft parts...
[IMGw=500]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/flt93debris18sm.jpg[/IMGw]
The crash of 93 is exactly what it should look like for a 757 hitting that fast, upside down, and 40 degrees nose low.
Proof it is 93, a stock 757.
DNA from crew, passengers and terrorists found at the crash site.
FDR found inside the crater, and it is from 93, shows 24 to 25 hours of flight time for the aircraft.
Radar tracked 93 from take off to impact.

Thus spreading a lie it does not look like a plane did it, is based on complete lack of knowledge, and zero research; and total rejection of reality based evidence.
You are not at the bottom a pile of puppy stuff, you are dropping a pile of BS and Gish Gallop all based on BS you googled from 911 truth.

Are the aircraft parts fake? Was the DNA fake? FDR fake? Got some evidence to refute DNA, FDR, Radar, aircraft parts? No

[IMGw=500]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/flt93debris21sm.jpg[/IMGw]
[IMGw=500]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/flt93debris11d.jpg[/IMGw]
How did they fake the engine in the crater? DNA? How can you make up BS claims and ignore the evidence?

The other crash at the bottom is Payne Stewart's plane, in a crash much slower...

Have you retracted the dead terrorists rose from the dead yet?
 
Last edited:
Re-read the sections on unfilled flutes, and bracing that failed to meet the 2% lateral requirements. As I understand it, these should have been done but were not.
No need to re-read it. It was reasonably determined that the building performed to code (actually better) even though it did eventually collapse. It was ruled that the designers could not have foreseen the extraordinary circumstance the building was subjected to that day.

Bottom line. Had the building not had it's fire protection systems compromised by the collapse of the towers it would have had no problems surviving a normal office fire.
 
Last edited:
You'll have to forgive me if I can't get to all of you at once, I appear to be at the bottom of a very large puppy pile, and it's difficult to sort out which posts to reply to. I fear that I have erred in trying to respond with quantity rather than quality, and some of the sophistry is rather distracting.

In what appears to be an attempt to belittle, or be demeaning, you have used the wrong word. A "puppy pile" is not the same thing as a "dogpile".

Nor is a group of individuals noticing, and pointing out to you, that you are wrong, in multiple different ways, a "dogpile"

Details...
 
I fear that I have erred in trying to respond with quantity rather than quality,

A mistake so many conspiracy theorists make. As I suggested, how about joining or starting a thread on a subject you feel is significant, rather than slinging mud at random in the hope that some of it sticks?

Dave
 
I see we are thinking along the same lines.

Assertions not proven. Which airport security footage are you referring to? Sorry, are you saying the paper trail was vaporized, or something else?

Security footage from the DC and Boston airports. Would you rather see the security footage from Helena, Montana? I'm saying the hijackers were vaporized. I'm sure some paper was too, but that's hardly important to the big picture.
Well, it seems an oddity, but flimsy items very often survive aircraft crashes. Truthers simply cannot get their heads around this.


Out of interest, are we still going with the 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else? Are we still labelling hard drinking, drug taking, gambling men as Muslim extremists? That's pretty extreme Muslim behaviour, I concede that.

762 John Smith's in Quincy, MA. I'll even do you one better:
picture.php
There was a guy in Morocco who had to go into hiding simply because he had the very same moniker as one of the hijackers. Harassment by the cops? CIA? FBI? MOSSAD? Nope. Harassment by truthers.


Ahh good, you're not using any of that silly stuff that truthers do. The claim is the proof, and the proof is the claim. You're not taking this seriously, are you?

No need for proof anymore. This is common knowledge. 19 hijackers took over 4 planes. This is a fact. Again, just because you don't agree, doesn't change it. What was it Neil DeGrass Tyson says? Science doesn't care what you believe.
Precisely.


I tend to agree with you here. Which aircraft and who flew them is something else entirely.

Actually it isn't something else. It is what it is - the 4 aircraft were proven to be at the crash sites using the wreckage. This is fact.

I still cannot get a handle on the Shanksville situation (NIST approved answer).

Seriously, a plane, in that hole? You are kidding me right?

Yep. A plane. A very large, very fast plane. Care to provide an alternative? I know you can't but I could use the laugh.

picture.php

Man, that almost looks like it was caused by something that was fat in the middle, and had these, I dunno. Wing-like things on either side.
Obvious to you. Obvious to me. Not obvious to a tiny minority who can't see it. However, not content with selective blindness, ever more complex fantasy stories are conjured out of fat air. Thus you have Yankee451 claiming that it is the result of three precisely aimed and timed cruise missiles to intentionally simulate what an actual crash would look like.


Many people were also surprised that they did fall, and so quickly too. And that they pulverised themselves so effectively, and that FEMA couldn't explain it, and that Nist couldn't prove it.

Word salad.
No, I think that is simply a restatement of the dustification baloney. At this point I would not be terribly surprised if DEW gets wheeled out. Or nukes. Or something else.

Something else might be fun but I reckon remote control will be next.


So the Steel that was found 600 feet away, that has been identified as originating above the 600 foot high mark, and an explanation for its lateral force has been given, yes?
Momentum.
And here you run slap bang into the eternal contradiction of trutherism.

Collapsed into own footprint? Proof of CD.
Debris 600 feet away? Proof of CD.

WTF?


School's out kiddo. Get a new hobby. Preferably one that doesn't mock the murder of thousands of people.
And there it is. Truthers are on an ego trip fuelled by nothing more than abusing those orphaned children, those widowed mothers and fathers, those bereaved parents and... well you get the picture.

I must perforce be very, very careful in 911 threads, because if I gave vent to my actual thoughts and feelings on the matter, I would quickly buy a ban.

Let me close it thusly. As you walk through life you will inevitably step in the occasional turd. Yes, I have had that unhappy occasion of picking the poo out of the treads of my shoes, my ex-wifes shoes, my kids shoes with a blunt stick and I can tell you it is not a happy experience.

It is, however, heaven compared to dealing with truthers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom