Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

I'm curious.

Is your so-early resort to equivocation a planned approach, or is it just in reaction to not being hailed as the sharpest ball in the toolshed, just for showing up? Did you not expect opposition?

The "official narrative" is the same kind of semantic construct as the "gay agenda". What happened, happened. Any explanation must be, in the words of James, "congruent, fruitful, and luminous".

I'm curious too, where is this going? I showed up to ask a question, I thanked people who responded, and I explained that I asked because I did not know the answer, things went downhill from there :)

If you object to my use of "the official narrative, TON", please provide an alternative label for convenient conversation. Please note that "The Truth" will not be accepted as an alternative for obvious reasons.

Why would I expect to be hailed as anything? Are you projecting? What should we hail you as?

I thought an open forum for international skeptics was something where people who have doubts could ask questions and engage in debate, is that assumption flawed?

What happened did indeed happen. Can someone please hail Slowvehicle for this nugget, as I am unsure of the correct etiquette to do so. Any and indeed every explanation should be open discussion. Attempts to silence these questions should be viewed with suspicion.
 
Is CD off the table? No. FEMA avoided the subject, the commission dropped the ball, and NIST had too many opposing answers to be credible, and they denied testimony that was in the public domain.

The problem is there is no evidence to put it on the table in the first place. If you have some please start a new thread that describes this evidence and how it could be implemented.

Do this and you will be the first in history to do so. You say the "official story" is incomplete and inaccurate but you seem to support one that doesn't even exists.
 
Are you just asking questions?
Now thst you say you have bern answered do you have any more questions that relate to the OP of the thread?
 
If you object to my use of "the official narrative, TON", please provide an alternative label for convenient conversation.

How about (1) saying that there are errors and omissions in certain official reports on the events of 9/11, (2) actually presenting examples, and (3) starting a discussion about what implications these have for understanding the events of the day?

Dave
 
I'm curious too, where is this going? I showed up to ask a question, I thanked people who responded, and I explained that I asked because I did not know the answer, things went downhill from there :)

If you object to my use of "the official narrative, TON", please provide an alternative label for convenient conversation. Please note that "The Truth" will not be accepted as an alternative for obvious reasons.<snip of much marshaling of straw persons>

I don't suppose you would care to delineate the "obvious reasons"?

Which bit of what actually happened do you find necessary to explain by Nano-hushaboom©, mirrors, or holograms?

Your construct "The Official Narrative" is equivocal for "obvious reasons". Can you name them?

And, oh, yes: be so courteous as to stack your persons of straw over there under yon windmill...

Welcome to the forum.
 
They are quite complete. The official narrative, as you people refer to it, is as follows:

19 Hijackers planned to take over 4 aircraft. This is confirmed by voice recorders, airport security footage, and the fact that they're all vaporized, along with a paper trail showing them preparing for the event.

Assertions not proven. Which airport security footage are you referring to? Sorry, are you saying the paper trail was vaporized, or something else?

The assertion that an alleged terrorist is vaporized, proves that they hijacked a plane. That's good science is it?

Out of interest, are we still going with the 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else? Are we still labelling hard drinking, drug taking, gambling men as Muslim extremists? That's pretty extreme Muslim behaviour, I concede that.

4 Aircraft were hijacked This is confirmed by the fact that 4 aircraft were hijacked.

Ahh good, you're not using any of that silly stuff that truthers do. The claim is the proof, and the proof is the claim. You're not taking this seriously, are you?

3 Aircraft crashed into each WTC Tower and the Pentagon. Confirmed using so much evidence it's almost comical, if it weren't for the death and destruction. Live television footage, eyewitness accounts, radar tracking, aircraft wreckage found during cleanup, etc..etc...etc...

I tend to agree with you here. Which aircraft and who flew them is something else entirely.

1 Aircraft crashed in Shanksville, PA This backs up the fact that 4 aircraft were hijacked. Eyewitness accounts and aircraft wreckage at the site confirms this.

Please remember, your ignorance - willful or not - doesn't change facts.

I still cannot get a handle on the Shanksville situation (NIST approved answer).

Seriously, a plane, in that hole? You are kidding me right?

Anyway,
The Twin Towers collapse Every canard "burning buildings don't collapse from fire" was proven wrong on that day. Many people, including laypeople such as myself were not surprised one bit that they collapsed. The fact that steel doesn't react well to prolonged heat is as basic as "water is wet". These fears were realized when the first tower fell, and confirmed when it happened for the second time in history less than an hour later. It should also come as no surprise that material that fell from 1,000 feet in the air can strike a building roughly 400 feet away.

Many people were also surprised that they did fall, and so quickly too. And that they pulverised themselves so effectively, and that FEMA couldn't explain it, and that Nist couldn't prove it.

So the Steel that was found 600 feet away, that has been identified as originating above the 600 foot high mark, and an explanation for its lateral force has been given, yes?


Unless and until you people can come up with a scenario that better explains the entire day's events, you need to go back under the rock you come from.

I like rocks, they don't fall over due to fire.
 
Are you just asking questions?
Now thst you say you have bern answered do you have any more questions that relate to the OP of the thread?

They haven't been answered, not the new ones. I still don't know who you knew, and what they did or did not have opinions on, because you do not appear to be one of the people answering the questions that I ask.

I did say that this was going off topic and was happy for the thread to be split.
 
Last edited:
I get it now, you are a 'No Planer' of some kind.
Do you doubt that the 4 aircraft existed?
Do you doubt that they no longer exist?
What happened to all the passengers and crew?
Whstabout the witnesses that saw them crash?
What evidence do you have that any of the hijackers were alive after the crashes?

I can think of a whole load more questions but they are easy to answer and will do for now.
 

How the hell do you explain them? You are the one showing them. What are they supposed to be evidence of? What context are you using?

Are you saying that an explosive force fired steel laterally from its origin, or that fire caused that steel to fall down?

What are you trying to say with these pictures?
 
How the hell do you explain them? You are the one showing them. What are they supposed to be evidence of? What context are you using?

Are you saying that an explosive force fired steel laterally from its origin, or that fire caused that steel to fall down?

What are you trying to say with these pictures?

That your claim was wrong, which it demonstrably is. Will you correct your original statement?

Or were you being ironic?
 
Last edited:
I get it now, you are a 'No Planer' of some kind.
Do you doubt that the 4 aircraft existed?
Do you doubt that they no longer exist?
What happened to all the passengers and crew?
Whstabout the witnesses that saw them crash?
What evidence do you have that any of the hijackers were alive after the crashes?

I can think of a whole load more questions but they are easy to answer and will do for now.

I can think of a load more questions too, but I'm still waiting for you to answer my earlier ones that were specifically addressed to you.

Is it easier for you to label me as a no planer? I don't consider myself to be one, I'm fairly certain that planes hit the three buildings in question.

Because I cannot identify the planes in question, nor who was aboard, I cannot categorically say what did or did not happen. I do not have a fact to present, nor a theory to speculate with. Please tell me that you can understand this very basic concept. I cannot confirm nor deny this story, therefore I will not present either as a fact.
 
Conspiracists simply do not understand how rational people think, and therefore they do not understand why the "truth movement" is the province of irrational people and why it will remain so until they can produce rational, evidence-based arguments. What they call the "official story" is simply the narrative that is best supported by the available evidence, which is why it's the common narrative of rational people, and why it will never be replaced by imaginative speculation, dubious facts, and unsubstantiated assertions. Evidence-based reasoning has some obvious limitations, and a truly rational person will recognize that it's conditional and contingent, subject to change with new evidence or better reasoning, but the point is that as a useful epistemology, it beats the holy crap out of whatever is in second place.

Calling conspiracists "irrational" is not ad hominem because "rational" simply means "based on or in accordance with reason or logic," and rationality vs. irrationality is really the crux of the conflict here. I have come to the conclusion that trying to explain that to conspiracists is a complete waste of time.
 
Sorry beach, but there are three sides, and many subsides (very bad pun intended). Only one of them is the truth, and no .
Sorry, there is one side, it is reality and now we will see your side is BS based on political BS and a Gish Gallop ranging from WMDs to you not knowing the Goals of NIST, FEMA and the 911 commission. Plus you seem to thing CD is an opition, and repeat BS tag-lines like, "own footprint", and free-fall. What does "own footprint" mean, because the two acres of WTC towers trashed 19 acres; is 19 acres the "own footprint". Even WTC 7 trashed the streets around it, and covered less area because it was smaller.

You can make up as many sides as you want, there is only the reality side that matters; thus one side, and you seem to like the side of woo manufactured by a fake movement based on BS from failed kids like Loose Change - a cut film which makes more sense when high. Loose Change a work of fiction to fool the gullible, those who can't think for themselves.

one as yet has placed it out there in its entirety..
I can... 19 terrosists did 911 with four planes. You want the steps?
1. Take plane.
2. Crash plane.
Darn, I did it. In its entirety, the 911 plot, and who did it... You were wrong.


Let me start off with a fact. The official narrative, as presented by FEMA, NIST and the 9/11 commission has omissions, and .
Which omissions? Like the flight path BS from 911 truth, the impossible flight paths; 911 truth claims of omissions turn out to be BS points based on ignorance and lack of knowledge.

contains falsehoods, theories and speculations. If we cannot agree on that, then there is no discussion. Facts do not .
And you can't support or present any of this BS with evidence. 14 years and you can't prove one falsehood. 19 terrorist did 911 - name a falsehood? can't

I'll follow that up with an opinion. Truthers are winning the PR war. Videos like Loose Change are slick and compelling. .
lol, 911 truth is BS. Winning the award of BS and mocking the murder of thousands with dumbed down claims, is winning? With 8 months being "quick", I guess this makes sense.

LOL, winning is earning a Pulitzer in less than a year - where is your Pulitzer? The same place 911 truth, and your evidence is, in fantasy-land.

Fact or Fantasy, they are entertaining, very much like a Hollywood "True Story". Titanic, Pearl Harbour etc may not have.
Titanic hit Ice, and its unique design caused it to sink, a fact known... Pearl Harbor, a surprise attack, yet we knew Japan was going to attack, but where... gee, like 911, a surprise attack... You left out Bigfoot and JFK, the moon, chemtrails...

The official narrative offers a relatively straight forward scenario, backed by some theories, however their story is .
It is not theory. 19 terrorists took four planes and did all the damage on 911 with no help from bombs, or thermite. 911 truth is a fantasy fest based on ignorance.
No theory, the fact is it is so simple CTers have to make up BS, lies and other nonsense, like your post; all BS, no substance; filled with political claptrap.

... story is a narrative version of building 7. If a truther comes along and removes column 79, the entire fabrication collapses into its own footprint at free-fall speeds..
LOL< you say science is a fabrication, and spew BS next about CD; all without any evidence. You might want to look up probable, and add that to your understanding of what NIST said; plus look up NIST's goals, they are not law enforcement. FBI did the criminal part... Not NIST.

18 seconds is not freefall, and there is not such thing as "own footprint", but you repeat the failed tag-lines like repeating Sunday school catechism.


Is CD off the table? No. FEMA avoided the subject, the commission dropped the ball, and NIST had too many opposing .
There was no CD, it is not off the table, it is safe in the paranoid minds of a fringe few 911 truth nuts. There were no explosives, no thermite, no CD. Why do you lie about FEMA and NIST, it is the FBI who investigated the crime, you don't seem to have a grasp on the Goal of NIST and FEMA; you need to check with the FBI who did the Biggest investigation in history, and guess what, no CD; they used planes and fires started did the damage.

The fact that all crime scenes were sterilised very quickly after the event, that evidence was destroyed, confiscated and denied independent scrutiny is indisputable..
LOL, quickly, 8 months is quickly? Thus I see why after 14 years some people have no clue 911 truth is BS, lies and fantasy.
and Osama Bin Laden wasn't there training 1000s of terrorists. What has happened .
UBL went and hid after he poked the hornet nest, now he is dead. He said he was going to kill Americans, and he did it.

... wandered into Afghanistan .

Yep, where the terrorists were training... The guy who killed americans. then you add political BS. Making up and believing lies about 911 will not help the fact you failed to stop your representatives from not attacking UBL where he was hiding... Why be silly with CD, and other BS about NIST, FEMA and others, when it is 911 truth which is the lie, which is the BS maker of woo.

hate the West and want us dead. .
That was UBL, he even said he hates the West, and wants to kill Americans

Where do you get the BS of thousands of terrorists? How many were there? Stop the BS and Gish Gallop of WMDs, andother nonsesne which in no way supports your fantasy version of 911.




Meanwhile, back at the ranch, civil liberties were being thrown out of the window. It is now almost a criminal offence to
be a passenger in an aircraft. You have to prove yourself innocent by the most invasive means possible. Rights of assembly and protest are quashed, with brutal crackdowns on civilians by a militarised police force. .
Where do you get this much BS? PrisonPlanet, or Alex Jones? Which civil liberties have you lost? What you listed are BS.

Sounds like PrisonPlanet and other web sites have you dropping your sketic side, and going full blown BS on 911.

CD is dumber than the claims about flight path and impossible maneuvers by terrorist pilots.

Where is your Pulitzer? What did you say, no newspaper will team with your because your claims of overwhelming evidence was a lie? Darn, you were so close with the WMD BS Gish Gallop stuff... darn

19 terrorists did 911, with a simple plot - zero cost terrorism. Steal the planes... 19 failed humans did 911, and now 911 truth can't figure it out after 14 years of making up BS... 911 truth is the liar on 911, not the government, not NIST, not FEMA; it is failed nuts who are the liars fooling the gullible with BS. you can't produce any evidence.

The fact is... Flight 93 Passengers figure out 911 in minutes, and took action... 911 truth has failed to produce any useful information for 14 years in the safety of their homes behind their keyboards flooding the Internet with the dumbest claims of CD, thermite, and other BS. 911 truth has no clue, no evidence after 14 years; big failure for fantasy. Mocking the murder of thousands by spreading lies, upset they did not take action to moderate US action after 911.
Being upset with what happened after 911 is not logical to make up BS about 911. Bringing up WMDs to support BS lies about 911 is not logical. Saying the government lies about stuff, so they lied about 911, is not logical.

Evidence to back up claims is logical; you have zero evidence, and never will. Your BS is all based on your feelings, and you will never have evidence for the claims you have presented, from CD to free-fall. How does Free-fall have anything to do with CD? Like the flight path BS, 911 truth has fooled you with tag lines... Please don't mention the law of least resistance, or the path of most resistance, it really dumbed down the BS of CD.

It appears the only research you have on 911 is from 911 truth sources. Do you know the energy from gravity for the falling WTC towers? Each tower collapse released the energy equal to 130 2,000 pound bombs. Learn some physics before falling for BS you found using google. learn to think for yourself and stop using "own footprint", then discuss ejections upto 600 feet, it makes you look silly...

You debunk yourself, saying "own foot" print, then 600 feet steel flying... which is it?

you never read NIST, never will

Were you fooled by the flight path BS too?
 
The problem is there is no evidence to put it on the table in the first place. If you have some please start a new thread that describes this evidence and how it could be implemented.

Do this and you will be the first in history to do so. You say the "official story" is incomplete and inaccurate but you seem to support one that doesn't even exists.

You are either mistaken, or you are misrepresenting the facts. Partly this will depend on what you classify as evidence.

I love the way that because I said I did not rule out CD, that I was somehow a proponent of it. There are other alternatives.

I dispute the Nordenson theory, and I agree that the case for CD has not been proven. I am also open to any other evidence that may be presented.

For example, an incomplete theory is that although the buildings were allegedly built to code, and certified as such by an allegedly impartial official, they were not fit for purpose. Criminal negligence on the part of some or all of those involved in the construction and certification of the building is grounds for a corporate manslaughter or even murder charge.
See Bailey and Nordenson for evidence that supports that theory.
 
You are either mistaken, or you are misrepresenting the facts. Partly this will depend on what you classify as evidence.

I love the way that because I said I did not rule out CD, that I was somehow a proponent of it. There are other alternatives.

I dispute the Nordenson theory, and I agree that the case for CD has not been proven. I am also open to any other evidence that may be presented.

For example, an incomplete theory is that although the buildings were allegedly built to code, and certified as such by an allegedly impartial official, they were not fit for purpose. Criminal negligence on the part of some or all of those involved in the construction and certification of the building is grounds for a corporate manslaughter or even murder charge.
See Bailey and Nordenson for evidence that supports that theory.

lol, what does this have to do with 19 terrorists? BTW, no CD, that was made up by idiots who heard Dan Rather say it "looks like" CD. Thus we have a movement based on simile. Really sad.

At least you are into the goals of FEMA and NIST with were they built to standards... FBI does crime, not NIST and FEMA...

BTW, there is no evidence for CD, but there is evidence for fire.

Were you fooled by the flight path BS 911 truth was flinging.


The still alive terrorists is proof you only have BS from 911 truth and failed to do any reality based research...
The alive BS is about people with the same names... lol, the BBC retracted the BS story after someone figured out people on earth have the same names, there are 7 billion of us, and many have the same name... need help on this one super skeptical guy? wow

I thought you might have a new take on the 911 truth BS, but you are regurgitating the dumbest claims, as if memorized, or your first time on a computer...
 
Last edited:
As always, unless otherwise stated, these are my opinions, and are open to review if challenged by new (to me) evidence.
...
I don't expect to alter anyone's opinions, this is not a persuasive argument. I simply wish to express where I am coming from.
All understood, and respected.
This is indeed all off-topic, so I don't intend to discuss every point you raise; I reply mainly to acknowledge you wrote it, as a welcoming gesture.

Sorry beach, but there are three sides, and many subsides (very bad pun intended). Only one of them is the truth, and no one as yet has placed it out there in its entirety.
We are all interested in the truth - conclusions differ on how to discern truth from untruth, and what the truth is.

As a "skeptics'" forum, devoted to rational skepticism, most folks here abide by some variant of scientific epistemology, which comes with ideas such as demanding evidence, placing burden of proof on claimants, the term "theory" as a set of proposition that explain some set of facts in the real world and that ought to be formulated such that it can be falsified if it were false. We try to keep an eye on logical consistency, and to stear clear of a host of formal and informal fallacies. At the same time, we try to remember that the standard of evidence remains "reasonable". This requires judgement calls and is one area where "opinion" may legitimately influence a rational conclusion.

Let me start off with a fact. The official narrative, as presented by FEMA, NIST and the 9/11 commission has omissions, and contains falsehoods, theories and speculations. If we cannot agree on that, then there is no discussion. Facts do not care about or require your agreement, they just are.
This is as true as it is trivial.
These works are printed on thousands of pages, and are the result of the work of hundreds of individuals who had hundreds of thousands of bits of information available to sift through and include or excluse, and to analyse to a smaller or greater degree. It is simply impossible to finish such reports in the time they were finish and have them both free of error and including all relevant details. As the researchers were operating in an imperfect world, where information is of necessity not completely available, there are many areas where they had to fill voids with informed speculation; no doubt they erred here and there.

It would be foolish to demand complete and error-free narratives ("Pefect Solution" fallacy). I hope you are not doing this.

I'll follow that up with an opinion. Truthers are winning the PR war. Videos like Loose Change are slick and compelling. Fact or Fantasy, they are entertaining, very much like a Hollywood "True Story". Titanic, Pearl Harbour etc may not have been historically accurate, but they reached wider audiences and made more money than any documentary on the same subjects. When it comes to hearts and minds, the approach of silence, secrecy, smugness and scorn does not get the public vote.
I agree that the media Truthers produce are more readily shared on social media by those who believe them than the media the rest of the world produces about 9/11. The reason is not that they are "compelling" in an objective sense; they mostly "compel" only those who are already compelled by 9/11 Truth, or are in general easily compelled by conspiracist claims.
They are shared quickly because the reduce complex arguments to simple memes.

They are, however, not compelling the vast majority of those who "count", who have standing, who are competent. By all measures, 9/11 Truth in 2016 is a small fringe within almost all segements of society. It has only a few tens of thousands of adherents world-wide. Truthers often claim to have "millions" who have awoken to the truth, but there is no robust data to support this. Years and years ago, polls showed some percentage of the US population supporting certain vague general 9/11 Truth ideas, that you could translate to "millions" in total numbers, but nothing comes of it - I found those polls to be unreliable; you get the darndest replies on polls.

There is not a single professional assocition, not a single university department, not a single government agency, not a single significant company in any of the relevant fields of expertise that supports any of the mainstream claims of 9/11 Truth. I challenge you to prove me wrong by naming one professional association or university department or government agency or significant company that supports 9/11 Truth.

So by what measure is 9/11 Truth "winning the PR war"?
Videos like Loose Change came out 10 years ago, were a phenomenon then, sparked a few short years of "research", but since 2010, there is nothing new under the sun, every truther claim has been debunked, and truther activity is declining.

The official narrative offers a relatively straight forward scenario, backed by some theories, however their story is constructed as such that when one challenges one aspect of it, it casts doubt upon many others.
How so?
I find the various parts of the "official narrative" actually quite robust. This is because they get the "Big Picture" right, and this rather obviously so. Literally hundreds of thousands of bits of information converge on this simple narrative:
Four teams of Arab hijackers with some radical convictions informed by their muslim faith, organized by a few named inddividuals and ultimately inspired and sponsored by Osama bin Laden, trained to hijack and fly planes, they did hijack, fly and crash planes, and the structural damage and building fires thus incurred led to all the destruction and death witnessed that day.​
It should be pointed out that part of this official narrative is the realization that there were some warnings before 9/11 that could potentially have been acted upon; and that there was some degree of CYA and lying by government officials after 9/11.

It's like the official story is a narrative version of building 7. If a truther comes along and removes column 79, the entire fabrication collapses into its own footprint at free-fall speeds.
It is ironic that you should say that - truthers do not believe this can be done.
I fail to see what "column 79" you think there is in the official story?

Is CD off the table? No. FEMA avoided the subject, the commission dropped the ball, and NIST had too many opposing answers to be credible, and they denied testimony that was in the public domain.
CD was never really on the table, as there never existed any prima facie evidence. If you want to put CD on the table, you need to provide such prima facie evidence.
Even if there every was some prima facie evidence, this has been looked into extensively by a small but dedicated and ideologically motivated minority of maverick researchers. They have, after 14 years, utterly failed to formulate even a rough starting proposal, a theory with at least a minimum of plausibility.

In short: There exists no theory of CD.

Perhaps FEMA "avoided" the subject, as they also avoided nukes, DEW and any number of implausible speculations.
The 9/11 Commission had absolutely no business at all thinking about the structural collapses - again, there was no prima facie evidence anywhere at all.
NIST did consider CD - and found no evidence.
You are poising the well on NIST: No, they did not have "too many opposing answers". No, none of the opposing answers affected their credibility to a meaningful degree. No, they did not deny and significant and relevant testimony that was in the public domain.

Your claim becomes a lot more truthful if you substitute "NIST" with "9/11 Truth": Essentially every claim ever made by 9/11 Truth has been found to be invalid, irrelevant or outright false. While one can nitpick NIST and find a few errors or ommission in a sea of highly qualified, good work, it is almost impossible to find anything of quality or merit in the collected works of the Truth Movement. In fact, many Truther claims have been rejected and debunked by other Truthers - there exist several schisms within 9/11 Truth, congregations with irreconcilable differences of belief.

This point - that it is difficult to find anything within 9/11 Truth writings that is correct - is often underscored by an experience I make over again:
A truthers pops up and presents a lengthy list of claims, all which allegedly oppose, refute, disprove the official story. The arguer usually tries a "Proof by verbosity" here (an informal fallacy): "Look, " he seems to exclaim, "I have all these arguments, and you need to debunk them all, and you can't" (that includes a "reversed burden of proof" fallacy). I often challenge the Truther to pick just one argument from his list and defend it. He gets to pick. I advise him to pick what is in his opinion the BEST argument, because he is most certain that the premises are true, the reasoning valid, and the conclusions both relevant and discerning; in other words: He is most convinced the argument actually speaks more strongly against the offical story and for an alternative theory than all the other.
Alway always always, with no exception ever so far, the Truther refuses to choos a best argument and defend it against me. They understand (because I explain) that IF they fail to show their BEST argument is true, valid, relevant and discerning, THEN NONE of their arguments are true, valid, relevant and discerning.

In short: Truthers generally do not possess even one argument that they are confident to stand up to scrutiny.

Both Bailey and ARUP rely too heavily on Nordenson, who appears to manipulate the data towards the required outcome, a very unscientific approach.
I am certain you cannot support that allegation with evidence. Perhaps in another thread you want to go into details?

Opposing them is history, gravity, testimony and physical evidence, as well as substantial circumstantial evidence.
Not according to any person whatsoever with standing and relevant experise that ever opined on the subject.
Again, every single professional body in the world, every university department, every specialized company disagrees.
There is not a single exception.

The fact that all crime scenes were sterilised very quickly after the event, that evidence was destroyed, confiscated and denied independent scrutiny is indisputable.
This is as indisputable as it is trivial.
EVERY crime scene gets sterilised, every evidence eventually destroyed or confiscated, and never ever is evidence in a criminal scene made available to anyone for scrutiny who makes vexatious claims.

But before the crime scenes were obliterated, before evidence was destroyed, a huge forensic and criminal investigation was carried out - the largest in US history. Practically everybody with standing - relatives of the victims, the companies that were hit, their insurers, all the first responders, etc etc etc - essentially agrees with the results of those investigations at least on a "big picture" level, as described above: hijacking and crashing 4 airliners because of Allah and certain grievances is what happened on 9/11, and it caused all the death and destruction.

The reason that 9/11 will not simply go away, is that it is a pivotal point in modern history. On that day the world changed. 9/11 has been the handle on a shovel that has moved a lot of **** since. I'm in the UK, we see things differently to those in the US, but we are also seeing some things the same. We did not want to go to war in Iraq, millions took to the streets in protest (a million in the UK is more significant than in the US). 9/11 and WMDs were the governments trump card. We didn't believe them, but it was enough for them to satisfy themselves to pass the required motions through the correct channels. We spent billions we could not afford so that wealthy businessmen could profit from oil contracts. No WMDs were ever found, and Osama Bin Laden wasn't there training 1000s of terrorists. What has happened is that we blew up a lot of innocent people, and created the next generation of would be terrorists. The world is less safe.
I agree with most of this political sentiment.
It doesn't inform us however on what really happened on 9/11, and who did it and why.

Then, we all wandered into Afghanistan and blew up some more innocent people, made some more money for the rich few, and inspired even more people to hate the West and want us dead. We didn't find any WMDs, OBL, or thousands of well trained and well equipped terrorists poised to wipe out the West in fiery death.
IMO, some of that is wrong.
1. "We" went into Afghanistan first, 1.5 years before Iraq
2. We found OBL eventually; he was in Afghanistan initially, and the Afghan regime at the time had supported him
3. No one claimed there were WMD in AFG.
4. There were large numbers of trained terrorists in Afgh., many of which in the OBL network.


Meanwhile, back at the ranch, civil liberties were being thrown out of the window. It is now almost a criminal offence to be a passenger in an aircraft. You have to prove yourself innocent by the most invasive means possible. Rights of assembly and protest are quashed, with brutal crackdowns on civilians by a militarised police force.
I lament some of those developments, even though you employ obvious hyperbole.

The US needs another civil war, for it seems that true to history, the men who came to replace the deposed oppressors are even worse.
Are you advocation widespread violence and the death of thousands upon thousands of Americans?

Unrestrained capitalism is not a goal to strive for, it is something to be feared.
US voters have a chance to make Bernie Sanders president, and to elect senators and representatives who oppose unrestrained capitalism.

You cannot shrink from Islamic extremists while subjugating yourself to capitalist extremists, the whole problem with extremes is that you either head back towards the middle, or you fall off the edge.

Perhaps one day I will sort through my thoughts and present them in a proper fashion, hell I might even write a book, that seems to be the way to go :) On average, the world is not in a great place right now, and 9/11 is being used to keep it that way.
Again, I sympathize with that political sentiment.
None of this makes 9/11 Truth true.
As you said: There is only one truth. 9/11 Truth doesn't have it, regardless of how unjust the political reaction to 9/11 may have been.
 
Assertions not proven. Which airport security footage are you referring to? Sorry, are you saying the paper trail was vaporized, or something else?

The assertion that an alleged terrorist is vaporized, proves that they hijacked a plane. That's good science is it?

Out of interest, are we still going with the 19 names, of which anywhere between 4 and 9 turned up alive somewhere else? Are we still labelling hard drinking, drug taking, gambling men as Muslim extremists? That's pretty extreme Muslim behaviour, I concede that.



Ahh good, you're not using any of that silly stuff that truthers do. The claim is the proof, and the proof is the claim. You're not taking this seriously, are you?



I tend to agree with you here. Which aircraft and who flew them is something else entirely.



I still cannot get a handle on the Shanksville situation (NIST approved answer).

Seriously, a plane, in that hole? You are kidding me right?



Many people were also surprised that they did fall, and so quickly too. And that they pulverised themselves so effectively, and that FEMA couldn't explain it, and that Nist couldn't prove it.

So the Steel that was found 600 feet away, that has been identified as originating above the 600 foot high mark, and an explanation for its lateral force has been given, yes?




I like rocks, they don't fall over due to fire.

:crazy:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom