The problem with that argument I have is the fact that stupid people would keep doing stupid things and smart people would keep doing smart thing. If they billed him hand and foot (say 1250$ for intervention, or ten times the cost of it) smart people would decide to pay 75$ a year, while stupid will still decide to take chances, only consequences of such gambling would be a little less drastic for everybody.
From economic perspective: charge 1250$ and get that money right now and maybe lose some of that 75$ a year because of influx of stupid, or don't charge anything and gain a bit more of 75$ because of influx of scared. Tough choice?