Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Three dogs and a cat were killed in the fire.
According to the story the fire took 2 hours to reach the house once it started. He couldn't have saved his pets in that 2 hour window? This makes me hate the guy even more.
 
Make it work like insurance.

You can pay the annual premium ($75) or you can pay the full cost of calling out a fire crew ($thousands). If you haven't paid the premium, the fire department can sue you to recover costs. If you didn't want them to save your house and they did, well, they get the house; everyone's happy.

What you don't do is stand around while the house burns down. That's idiocy at every level.
Suppose there's 1,000 properties outside the city limits that can be covered by the city for the $75 fee. In any given year, maybe one of those houses needs fire dept. response.

Now suppose it works as you describe, and the fire dept. charges a fee for their costs of fighting the fire. Why would anyone pay the $75? Now the fire dept. gets $75,000 less in revenue every year, and no way can they charge a homeowner $75,000 to fight their fire. The fire dept. will not be able to use that money to pay its firemen, maintain the equipment, or maintain the fire house. Your remedy results in cuts to the fire department.

The $75 doesn't just cover the cost of putting out a fire, it covers the cxosts of keeping a well-equipped firemen on the job 24/7/365. You can't recover those costs after the fact by charging only for fire response.

eta: and when you place a lien on a property you can't collect until the property is sold, which can take decades. And even then you have to get in line with all the other creditors, and you'll be lucky to collect pennies on the dollar.
 
Last edited:
What I want to know, is why this thought never crossed anyones freaking minds:

Put the fire out, and BILL the guy for the services.

Gee, neat concept. You bill the person for services rendered.

People have to pay when the amublance comes to pick them up at their home, and is covered under insurance, and NO one pays in advance for ambulance services.


Really, what's so hard in saying "Screw the list, let me put this fire out, and its between the COUNTY and the man to have him pay for it"
So how much money do you envision in the fire department's budget when their only revenue comes from billing people after the fact?

IMHO you've just cut their budget by 95%, good luck maintaining a functional fire dept. with that.
 
If you put it into legal agreement to pay 75$ a year or 1500$ for intervention otherwise in BIG BOLD LETTERS, it would be all nice and legal. I guess they will do it for the next guy...

He knew the terms when he decided not to pay: either pay $75 per year, or do not get fire brigade services. He chose not to get fire brigade services.

It's probably emotional thing. It looks too much like OT punishment to me: one guy made a decision not to pay measly 75$, his whole family, that probably had nothing with that decision, lost their home and things.

That is his fault, not the fire brigade´s fault. He is the one who decided he did not want the fire brigade to serve him.

He's a selfish, stupid, irresponsible prick, but if he were to sue firemen for liability, and I were in jury, I would have decided for him.

Another reason why juries are perhaps not such a good idea. He decided he wants nothing to do with the fire brigade. He decided that his money should not go towards funding the fire brigade. The fire brigade existed in spite of his refusal to pay for them. Why should he reap the benefits of something he refuses to pay for?
 
It also has something to do with the new chief enforcing policy strictly, as well.


ETA: They may not have been covered (insurance) as well. Although that can be proven/disproven.
Apparently this has been policy since 1990, I wouldn't consider that "new".

Probably became policy because people weren't paying the $75 and the budget was suffering.
 
The problem with that argument I have is the fact that stupid people would keep doing stupid things and smart people would keep doing smart thing. If they billed him hand and foot (say 1250$ for intervention, or ten times the cost of it) smart people would decide to pay 75$ a year, while stupid will still decide to take chances, only consequences of such gambling would be a little less drastic for everybody.

From economic perspective: charge 1250$ and get that money right now and maybe lose some of that 75$ a year because of influx of stupid, or don't charge anything and gain a bit more of 75$ because of influx of scared. Tough choice?:confused:
Congratulations, now the fire dept. revenue has been cut by $73,750 (assuming 1,000 homes and an average of one house fire a year, and also assuming the 1 person actually pays his bill).

Now you have 2 less firemen to respond to fires.
 
Last edited:
So there's no Obion County fire department, at all? There must be a county police department. So why no fire dept?

This stupid county needs to get its act together.

Well most counties don't have them, fire protection distrcits are smaller units.

Now county sheriffs can be sparse on the ground as well.
 
Last edited:
The $75 doesn't just cover the cost of putting out a fire, it covers the cxosts of keeping a well-equipped firemen on the job 24/7/365. You can't recover those costs after the fact by charging only for fire response.

Unless you have a cynical fire department which realizes that to get funded they have to start a certain number of fires every year.
 
Congratulations, now the fire dept. revenue has been cut by $73,750 (assuming 1,000 homes and an average of one house fire a year, and also assuming the 1 person actually pays his bill).

Now you have 2 less firemen to respond to fires.

Congratulations, you just presumed 100% of the population is stupid and unable to recognise a good deal when they see one. Good job!

All I presumed was that % of people already paying the fee will not drop considerably if you add penalty for not paying fee. That penalty will be tax for stupid, but I guess I'm considered stupidly optimistic myself :p.

Maybe we should let evolution cull the herd a bit? Stupid people that don't pay that fee should burn!:covereyes We could even organise Ankh-Morpork Fire Fighter's Guild!
 
Last edited:
He knew the terms when he decided not to pay: either pay $75 per year, or do not get fire brigade services. He chose not to get fire brigade services.



That is his fault, not the fire brigade´s fault. He is the one who decided he did not want the fire brigade to serve him.



Another reason why juries are perhaps not such a good idea. He decided he wants nothing to do with the fire brigade. He decided that his money should not go towards funding the fire brigade. The fire brigade existed in spite of his refusal to pay for them. Why should he reap the benefits of something he refuses to pay for?

So, are you saying that when he had seen fire moving towards his house, he should have sent his son to the bank immediately instead of calling fire brigade? All I'm saying is, that he should have been able to pay for it when push came to shove... Also, just the fact that he called them at all could be proven to mean that he didn't know the terms... maybe.
 
Last edited:
But not at the level mentioned. Do you have a national firefighters service or are they local municipalities?

The problem here is that he did not live in a municipality, and was in a county that had now county fire department. So he chose to live in an area with out fire fighter coverage paid for in taxes. Then he chose to forgo purchasing the coverage himself.


You know what? I have No Freaking Idea.

All I know is that there are fire stations at convenient points, some (in the big cities) manned constantly by full-time crew, while others are served by locals who have other jobs, who are paid a retainer to train and be competent and to turn out PDQ whenever there is an incident.

I pay my taxes, but I never asked anyone which particular set of taxes funds that particular service. It's neither here nor there, because coverage is universal, country-wide.

(Though there was a big scandal last year when it turned out that every single retained firefighter in a particular town had gone off to the same football match many miles away - the town's team had got through to the final of a very prestigious tournament that should have been out of its league. As it happened, nothing happened. There was a lot of shuffling by fire service bosses saying that the team in the next town would have covered if necessary, honest mate.... Probably.)

Rolfe.
 
So, are you saying that when he had seen fire moving towards his house, he should have sent his son to the bank immediately instead of calling fire brigade?

No, I´m saying that, once he has this nice, flammable house, surrounded by nice, flammable fields, he should have taken the offer of paying $75 a year to protect them.

All I'm saying is, that he should have been able to pay for it when push came to shove... Also, just the fact that he called them at all could be proven to mean that he didn't know the terms... maybe.

The fact that he called the fire brigade at all only proves that he thinks that the institution he refused to fund owes him for refusing to fund them. He has done his utmost to destroy their ability to fight fires, and now he´s paying for it.
 
No, I´m saying that, once he has this nice, flammable house, surrounded by nice, flammable fields, he should have taken the offer of paying $75 a year to protect them.



The fact that he called the fire brigade at all only proves that he thinks that the institution he refused to fund owes him for refusing to fund them. He has done his utmost to destroy their ability to fight fires, and now he´s paying for it.

I actually agree with you that he was stupid for not accepting it. I also think that he should have been able to correct his mistake when it all got wahooney shaped...
 
I actually agree with you that he was stupid for not accepting it. I also think that he should have been able to correct his mistake when it all got wahooney shaped...

Why?

By the way do we know if insurance would cover the firefighters if they had put out the fire and one of them got injured?
 
The problem with that argument I have is the fact that stupid people would keep doing stupid things and smart people would keep doing smart thing. If they billed him hand and foot (say 1250$ for intervention, or ten times the cost of it) smart people would decide to pay 75$ a year, while stupid will still decide to take chances, only consequences of such gambling would be a little less drastic for everybody.

From economic perspective: charge 1250$ and get that money right now and maybe lose some of that 75$ a year because of influx of stupid, or don't charge anything and gain a bit more of 75$ because of influx of scared. Tough choice?:confused:

Doesn't work for me for several reasons.

For instance, what if he agrees to pay on the spot, and then says he can't pay, or denies that he agreed to pay, or says their offer was $500, not $1250?

It's fraught with potential error and litigation.

Also, I don't want to live in a society where we apply social Darwinism to "smart" and "stupid" people.
 
It seems to have worked perfectly well in this case.

I don't know if you're being sarcastic or not, but this does seem to be correct. This wasn't a failure. It appears the system actually worked as designed. Only problem is that the idiotic homeowner decided to change his mind when it was too late.
 
I actually agree with you that he was stupid for not accepting it.

I wonder if he bought insurance with the understanding that there was fire protection nearby and that when the insurance company finds out he didn't pay the fee, they turn down his claim.

I know fire protection makes a huge difference in rates in remote areas and if this guy was too cheap/stupid to pay the $75 what are the chances he would tell a little fib to save more money?
 
Doesn't work for me for several reasons.

For instance, what if he agrees to pay on the spot, and then says he can't pay, or denies that he agreed to pay, or says their offer was $500, not $1250?

It's fraught with potential error and litigation.

Also, I don't want to live in a society where we apply social Darwinism to "smart" and "stupid" people.

I agree and many people in htis thread want to ignore the fact that there is a system in place that works perfectly well. Pay the fee or the fire department will not fight fires on your property. How simple is that?
 
I wonder if he bought insurance with the understanding that there was fire protection nearby and that when the insurance company finds out he didn't pay the fee, they turn down his claim.

I know fire protection makes a huge difference in rates in remote areas and if this guy was too cheap/stupid to pay the $75 what are the chances he would tell a little fib to save more money?

I used to work for insurance, including the claims department for household/building insurance for a while.

I´m pretty sure that, if the insurance knew about the arrangement of fire protection in the area, they´d make his paying the $75 fee a condition for providing cover.

And I am absolutely certain that the information about this arrangement is a fact relevant to the fire risk inherent in his property, meaning he has to provide it when he takes out the insurance - if he does not, the insurance can withhold coverage because he fraudulently withheld relevant information.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom