Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

The problem I have is that there should be an option to hire someone to put out a fire. So he forgot to pay the $75. That shouldn't mean that all means of fire protection are inaccessible. So charge the guy $1000, $2000, $5000. Whatever. Make a profit if that's what they want. But at least make some kind of option to put out a fire in such scenarios rather than let someone suffer such a huge loss over such a minor fee. If the fire dept is volunteer, then make such a scenario a paid one so they get more incentive at the home owners expense. Then their regret is that they had to pay so much money they could have saved by simply paying the $75 fee. Not losing an entire house.
 
If I lived in Gene Cranick's neighborhood, my concern wouldn't be whether or not he deserved to lose his property, but how fast the fire was able to spread before the fire department finally responded. If the fire department wouldn't turn on the water until the fire jumped the property line onto my land, threatening my home, I'd be livid. I've seen how fast a fire in a rural area can spread, how easily it can get out of control, and I'd be extremely angry if the lack of response to my non-fee paying neighbor caused the entire neighborhood to go up in flames because the fire got out of hand. Only putting out fires in specific parts of a rural area is a policy that's asking for trouble.
 
What I want to know, is why this thought never crossed anyones freaking minds:

Put the fire out, and BILL the guy for the services.

Gee, neat concept. You bill the person for services rendered.

People have to pay when the amublance comes to pick them up at their home, and is covered under insurance, and NO one pays in advance for ambulance services.


Really, what's so hard in saying "Screw the list, let me put this fire out, and its between the COUNTY and the man to have him pay for it"
 
What I want to know, is why this thought never crossed anyones freaking minds:

Put the fire out, and BILL the guy for the services.

Gee, neat concept. You bill the person for services rendered.

People have to pay when the amublance comes to pick them up at their home, and is covered under insurance, and NO one pays in advance for ambulance services.


Really, what's so hard in saying "Screw the list, let me put this fire out, and its between the COUNTY and the man to have him pay for it"

I said that, page two I think.

No, it wasn't. As far as it goes, it was brilliant economically as well. The guy was a tightwad. He wasn't willing to put out $75 dollars to protect a huge investment.

Now he has to rebuild and rebuy everything he had. That means more money into the economy than if his house hadn't burned to the ground.

Economically speaking, it was bad for the individual, great for the region.

Hate to break it to you, but economy doesn't work that way! Here's why: opportunity costs. One sentence explanation: He could have used all that money he'll now squander rebuilding for economic expansion.
His personal economic power got smaller, weaker. Albeit contractors and other guys might THINK it's good for them, it is not good for "market" as a whole. Why? Short answer: part of overall value was lost. Long answer:
Observe this very simplified example:
Value of unburnt house: 10.000$
Value of county economy as a whole: 1.010.000
Value of county economy as a whole after firemen let it burn: 1.000.000

For further explanation, think about all the alternative uses he could have spent that 10.000$ for. New fancy car, for example. College for kids etc. And if insurance paid for it, you got it a bit worse. Because burden of the disaster shifted from one man to financial institution, which means less "free", usable money for loans, which means slightly bigger costs of loans than otherwise, which means less money left for investments.

That's why shop owner hates punks that break his front window; he wanted to buy new shelves instead!

Also, some five year old logic: When you destroy one of your toys, you'll have a toy less. Destruction doesn't produce value, it makes it disappear!
 
Last edited:
What I want to know, is why this thought never crossed anyones freaking minds:

Put the fire out, and BILL the guy for the services.

Gee, neat concept. You bill the person for services rendered.

People have to pay when the amublance comes to pick them up at their home, and is covered under insurance, and NO one pays in advance for ambulance services.


Really, what's so hard in saying "Screw the list, let me put this fire out, and its between the COUNTY and the man to have him pay for it"

This was suggested before, and rebutted quite thoroughly.

If there is no incentive to pay the $75 before the house burns, why would anyone pay the $75 up front. This leads to a decreased budget for the firehouse. Ad infinitum.

It's the same reason that States require auto insurance. Because if people were allowed to only pay for it when it was needed (during/after an accident), the insurance system would fall apart quite rapidly.
 
I said that, page two I think.



Hate to break it to you, but economy doesn't work that way! Here's why: opportunity costs. One sentence explanation: He could have used all that money he'll now squander rebuilding for economic expansion.
His personal economic power got smaller, weaker. Albeit contractors and other guys might THINK it's good for them, it is not good for "market" as a whole. Why? Short answer: part of overall value was lost. Long answer:
Observe this very simplified example:
Value of unburnt house: 10.000$
Value of county economy as a whole: 1.010.000
Value of county economy as a whole after firemen let it burn: 1.000.000

For further explanation, think about all the alternative uses he could have spent that 10.000$ for. New fancy car, for example. College for kids etc. And if insurance paid for it, you got it a bit worse. Because burden of the disaster shifted from one man to financial institution, which means less "free", usable money for loans, which means slightly bigger costs of loans than otherwise, which means less money left for investments.

That's why shop owner hates punks that break his front window; he wanted to buy new shelves instead!

Also, some five year old logic: When you destroy one of your toys, you'll have a toy less. Destruction doesn't produce value, it makes it disappear!

Congratulations, you've ignored the ensuing increase in economic activity in the County from the building of a new house on the property (whether this owner or a new one in the future).
 
Congratulations, you've ignored the ensuing increase in economic activity in the County from the building of a new house on the property (whether this owner or a new one in the future).

Increase in economic activity that could have been different kind of economic activity. Instead of building a house more, selling one more car, having one more college educated student etc, you are building a house whose benefits of using you have lost.
 
Last edited:
This was suggested before, and rebutted quite thoroughly.

If there is no incentive to pay the $75 before the house burns, why would anyone pay the $75 up front. This leads to a decreased budget for the firehouse. Ad infinitum.

It's the same reason that States require auto insurance. Because if people were allowed to only pay for it when it was needed (during/after an accident), the insurance system would fall apart quite rapidly.

I have a problem with that argument. If firemen did just that (saved house, fined/billed him afterwards) they wouldn't have made the news. No one would have known!
 
I have a problem with that argument. If firemen did just that (saved house, fined/billed him afterwards) they wouldn't have made the news. No one would have known!

I would bet that his neighbors would have. It would very likely have made the local paper/news broadcast. The City Firefighters couldn't care less if the people in Alaska hear about it - it's the local population that counts when it comes to the fee and keeping the Dept funded...


ETA: And I wouldn't be surprised if it had still made the news based on fallacious appeals to emotion because it's "just wrong for the Fire Dept to bill for doing it's job"(etc etc).
 
Last edited:
Ok, let's recapitulate points made in this thread.

One family lost their house because:

1) county, town and fire station made a deal and do not give a **** about little guy. (as befits government, public authorities).

2) Deal was made in such a way that left a "window" open for reckless and stupid behaviour, behaviour against home-owners' best interests.

3) Town doesn't give a **** about county's interests, and town firemen especially.

4) Home owner was stupid enough to "throw himself out of a window" left by point number 2).

5) Thanks to 1) and 3), firemen did absolutely nothing to prevent him from "getting spilled all over concrete", metaphorically speaking.

Did I get that right? :p

Now, all jokes aside, there are few sides of this issue here:

One side says firemen did the right thing. It wasn't their problem. Guy didn't pay the price (fee), so he doesn't get the service (benefit). This side says that fire department had absolutely no obligations to him.
He perfectly knew what he was doing, he knowingly gambled and lost, he was acting stupid and he SHOULD and HAS paid the price for his stupidity.
They say it was a rational choice the firemen made, and if you turn it to legalese (lawyer and law language, which is bare minimum of society's morality), they are probably right. It was county's problem for leaving a hole for stupid to fall in, and it was stupid's fault for falling in.

Other side says the first side is wrong on some points. They say the firemen hadn't made rational and/or moral choice. Now, there are different arguments on that side:

One argument says that as compassionate human beings they should have helped anyway and that it was very cruel to just stand and watch. That, as firemen, it's their job to extinguish fires and that they should do that job as a public service (serving public interest, and all that...). That argument was considered very immature, good for "perfect world/planet X" but not good for this harsh, unforgiving reality.

Second argument says that burned house was too high a punishment and that he should have been fined instead, given big bill after firemen saved his house. The first sides main problem with this argument is that no one would have paid the fee if they did so. I disagree: if firemen just did their job, they wouldn't have made it into the news and no one would have known about it.

Third argument goes at the issue from purely economic perspective. They say that albeit he didn't pay the fee, there are opportunity costs of not saving a house from fire.
The biggest one is missed property taxes, although there are costs of building new one, buying new things to replace those that were inside the house, higher insurance rates for the whole area and finally, costs of extinguishing fire on other (payer's) property. (That last one is simple logic: if they prevented fire from spreading, they wouldn't have to extinguish it on the place it had spread to).
But, as it was pointed out by the first side, it has nothing to do with fire department. It's not their problem, it's county's problem! It's their problem they have one more homeless family on the (metaphorical) shoulder and less taxes from future period. It's their problem Mr I-won't-pay-firemen will use his money on rebuilding instead on economic expansion. And they are right, as far as that counter-argument goes.

My two cents on that last, economic argument is this: Firemen were extremely unpatriotic. They have refused to protect their fellow American, American property, their county's future and present property, their state's wealth.... nah, let's try that again.
It SHOULD have been their problem. If you look at the really big picture, it WAS their problem. But, if you look at the small one, it wasn't. Why? Because the county doesn't finance them. They do not get any part of that aforementioned personal economic expansion of Mr I-won't-pay-firemen. They don't get any part of (potential) trade tax or property tax or any tax whatsoever. No, what they got was 75$ fee a year. And Mr I-won't-pay-firemen didn't pay that fee.

At the end, I can conclude that human selfishness triumphed once again in this case. Firemen didn't want to work their very dangerous job for free, for a man that haven't paid them. And he hadn't paid them because he was selfish (probably).
Blame it on the lack of human empathy and close the case. He didn't care about them and their needs so, in turn, they didn't care about HIM and his needs.

That's all there is to it.

Edited, breach of Rule 10. Do not curse in you posts, or mask such words in an attempt to by-pass the auto-censor.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ok, let's recapitulate points made in this thread.

One family lost their house because:

1) county, town and fire station made a deal and do not give a **** about little guy. (as befits government, public authorities).

2) Deal was made in such a way that left a "window" open for reckless and stupid behaviour, behaviour against home-owners' best interests.

3) Town doesn't give a **** about county's interests, and town firemen especially.

4) Home owner was stupid enough to "throw himself out of a window" left by point number 2).

5) Thanks to 1) and 3), firemen did absolutely nothing to prevent him from "getting spilled all over concrete", metaphorically speaking.

Did I get that right? :p

Now, all jokes aside, there are few sides of this issue here:

One side says firemen did the right thing. It wasn't their problem. Guy didn't pay the price (fee), so he doesn't get the service (benefit). This side says that fire department had absolutely no obligations to him.
He perfectly knew what he was doing, he knowingly gambled and lost, he was acting stupid and he SHOULD and have paid the price for his stupidity.
They say it was a rational choice the firemen made, and if you turn it to legalese (lawyer and law language, which is bare minimum of society's morality), they are probably right. It was county's problem for leaving a hole for stupid to fall in, and it was stupid's fault for falling in.

Other side says the first side is wrong on some points. They say the firemen hadn't made rational and/or moral choice. Now, there are different arguments on that side:

One argument says that as a compassionate human beings they should have helped anyway and that it was very cruel to just stand and watch. That, as a firemen, it's their job to extinguish fires and that they should do that job as a public service (serving public interest, and all that...). That argument was considered very immature, good for "perfect world/planet X" but not good for this harsh, unforgiving reality.

Second argument says that burned house was too high a punishment and that he should have been fined instead, given big bill after firemen saved his house. The first sides main problem with this argument is that no one would have paid the fee if they did so. I disagree: if firemen just did their job, they wouldn't have made it into the news and no one would have known about it.

Third argument goes at the issue from purely economic perspective. They say that albeit he didn't pay the fee, there are opportunity costs of not saving a house from fire.
The biggest one is missed property taxes, although there are costs of building new one, buying new things to replace those that were inside the house, higher insurance rates for the whole area and finally, costs of extinguishing fire on other (payer's) property. (That last one is simple logic: if they prevented fire from spreading, they wouldn't have to extinguish it on the place it had spread to).
But, as it was pointed out by the first side, it has nothing to do with fire department. It's not their problem, it's county's problem! It's their problem they have one more homeless family on the (metaphorical) shoulder and less taxes from future period. It's their problem Mr I-won't-pay-firemen will use his money on rebuilding instead on economic expansion. And they are right, as far as that counter-argument goes.

My two cents on that last, economic argument is this: Firemen were extremely unpatriotic. They have refused to protect their fellow American, American property, their county's future and present property, their state's wealth.... nah, let's try that again.
It SHOULD have been their problem. If you look at the really big picture, it WAS their problem. But, if you look at the small one, it wasn't. Why? Because the county doesn't finance them. They do not get any part of that aforementioned personal economic expansion of Mr I-won't-pay-firemen. They don't get any part of (potential) trade tax or property tax or any tax whatsoever. No, what they got was 75$ fee a year. And Mr I-won't-pay-firemen didn't pay that fee.

At the end, I can conclude that human selfishness triumphed once again in this case. Firemen didn't want to work their very dangerous job for free, for a man that haven't paid them. And he hadn't paid them because he was selfish (probably).
Blame it on the lack of human empathy and close the case. He didn't care about them and their needs so, in turn, they didn't care about HIM and his needs.

Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content removed.

Wow. Pulling out the UnPatriotic bit, eh?

That's definitely an appeal to emotion. This is not about being patriotic or not. If you want to go that way, the homeowner was being unpatriotic by refusing to support his local firefighters as a dutiful citizen should. But, that's just as fallacious an argument as yours was.

Anytime you have any valid reason to claim the firefighters should have acted rather than appeals to emotion, that'd be great... ;)


It's really pretty open and closed when one realizes the simple bottom line that the Firefighters were outside of the coverage area they were responsible for. They had no moral nor legal obligation to assist the homeowner beyond ensuring the safety of the inhabitant (sorry, pets lives are not worth the Firefighters' lives). The homeowner received exactly what he paid for (or didn't, as the case may be).

The argument that the Firefighters should have saved the house simply because they're Firefighters is based on the emotion that we would all hope this is something Firefighters would do out of shear nobility. That is, however, not how the system in that particular County/Town/City was setup.

As others have posted, it is not uncommon for Counties to "purchase" firefighting services from local communities. That this County decided to not do so is not the City Firefighters' concern. The City graciously offered to assist homeowners outside the City's limits at a truly ludicrously low annual fee. The homeowner in question neglected to accept the City's offer. How is that, in any way, the fault of the Firefighters and/or the City?


ETA: Your conclusion is correct, however. Human greed surely played a part. The homeowner was too greedy to sacrifice $75/yr to purchase offered firefighting services.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wow. Pulling out the UnPatriotic bit, eh?

That's definitely an appeal to emotion. This is not about being patriotic or not. If you want to go that way, the homeowner was being unpatriotic by refusing to support his local firefighters as a dutiful citizen should. But, that's just as fallacious an argument as yours was.

Anytime you have any valid reason to claim the firefighters should have acted rather than appeals to emotion, that'd be great... ;)

I feel like it's not appeal to emotion, it's appeal to rationality to the n-th (last) degree. If you look closer, you'll see I pushed that line of reasoning away and went with economy. And yes, the homeowner was unpatriotic. Doesn't mean they should have been too. But that's planet X line of reasoning, right?;)

It's really pretty open and closed when one realizes the simple bottom line that the Firefighters were outside of the coverage area they were responsible for. They had no moral nor legal obligation to assist the homeowner beyond ensuring the safety of the inhabitant (sorry, pets lives are not worth the Firefighters' lives). The homeowner received exactly what he paid for (or didn't, as the case may be).

The argument that the Firefighters should have saved the house simply because they're Firefighters is based on the emotion that we would all hope this is something Firefighters would do out of shear nobility. That is, however, not how the system in that particular County/Town/City was setup.

As others have posted, it is not uncommon for Counties to "purchase" firefighting services from local communities. That this County decided to not do so is not the City Firefighters' concern. The City graciously offered to assist homeowners outside the City's limits at a truly ludicrously low annual fee. The homeowner in question neglected to accept the City's offer. How is that, in any way, the fault of the Firefighters and/or the City?

That was the point: the system was flawed. It County just set out the fee as a part of taxes, the stupid b*stard wouldn't have had any hole to fall into. Because they gave him choice, he was able to choose stupid.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'd like to clarify my position:


The County should have simply accepted the City's offer and passed the fee on as a tax on affected County property owners. That the County did not does not indemnify the Fire Dept in question. As the County did not accept the City's offer, it became the individual homeowner's responsibility to ensure his/her property's protection. Again, that the homeowner did not does not indemnify the Fire Dept in question.

As for the new Chief strictly enforcing policy...sometimes this happens because the new Chief is a prick. Sometimes it happens because the new Chief realizes just how stupid the current policy is.
 
I feel like it's not appeal to emotion, it's appeal to rationality to the n-th (last) degree. If you look closer, you'll see I pushed that line of reasoning away and went with economy. And yes, the homeowner was unpatriotic. Doesn't mean they should have been too. But that's planet X line of reasoning, right?;)
Sorry, patriotic is an appeal to emotion. You might feel it is perfectly rational...but...it's not. What I find amazing, though, is that you felt the appeal to patriotic emotion is somehow a response to the economic argument. "Well, you say it's good for the economy. But it's unpatriotic" is definitely not an appropriate response ;)

That was the point: the system was flawed. It County just set out the fee as a part of taxes, the stupid b*stard wouldn't have had any hole to drop into. Because they gave him choice, he was able to choose stupid.

Then how is it the Fire Dept's fault that the homeowner "[chose] stupid"?
 
Sorry, patriotic is an appeal to emotion. You might feel it is perfectly rational...but...it's not. What I find amazing, though, is that you felt the appeal to patriotic emotion is somehow a response to the economic argument. "Well, you say it's good for the economy. But it's unpatriotic" is definitely not an appropriate response ;)



Then how is it the Fire Dept's fault that the homeowner "[chose] stupid"?

That's why I didn't use those arguments. I didn't use "unpatriotic". I used an appeal to economy as a whole (although, in this case it was american economy, so you can call behaviour that is not good for american economy as a whole to be "unpatriotic" if you wish). Simplified, it goes like this: It does no one good to let the house burn, therefore, it's a bad thing. And you shouldn't do bad things.

Yet again, I said that on a small scale, it wasn't their problem and it definitely wasn't their fault for him choosing stupid. On big scale... very probably there should be some guilt involved for not doing your job. (and then someone will tell that it wasn't their job, and this whole thread will start all over again :eye-poppi ).
 
Last edited:
I saw a good comment on this story by a fire fighter on a FFs' blog. Don't have the exact wording, but it was something like this: "Fire fighters watch as house burns down" makes a much better headline than "County Commission continues to ponder what to do about providing fire fighting services to their citizens as house burns down".

I'm sure no fire fighter wants to stand by and watch a house burn. It's probably painful for them.

But if they provide services that aren't paid for, or if they accept payment on the spot, then others will decide they don't need to pay either.

When that happens, they then start providing more services and receive less revenue, and we know what happens to fire stations when that happens -- they have their manpower or hours cut, or the station is closed.

Then the next time there's a fire, there's no one to respond in time, even if you had paid your taxes.

There was a tragic story earlier this year. A boy was choking, the parents took him to the nearby fire station, but it had been closed. The kid died.

It ain't always so easy as doing what seems right at the moment.

The problem with that argument I have is the fact that stupid people would keep doing stupid things and smart people would keep doing smart thing. If they billed him hand and foot (say 1250$ for intervention, or ten times the cost of it) smart people would decide to pay 75$ a year, while stupid will still decide to take chances, only consequences of such gambling would be a little less drastic for everybody.

From economic perspective: charge 1250$ and get that money right now and maybe lose some of that 75$ a year because of influx of stupid, or don't charge anything and gain a bit more of 75$ because of influx of scared. Tough choice?:confused:
 
The problem with that argument I have is the fact that stupid people would keep doing stupid things and smart people would keep doing smart thing. If they billed him hand and foot (say 1250$ for intervention, or ten times the cost of it) smart people would decide to pay 75$ a year, while stupid will still decide to take chances, only consequences of such gambling would be a little less drastic for everybody.

From economic perspective: charge 1250$ and get that money right now and maybe lose some of that 75$ a year because of influx of stupid, or don't charge anything and gain a bit more of 75$ because of influx of scared. Tough choice?:confused:

If they billed him "hand and foot", that would be overturned in no time because he could argue he only agreed to it under duress.

I don´t know why you´re so upset. He made his bed, now he can lie in it.
 
If they billed him "hand and foot", that would be overturned in no time because he could argue he only agreed to it under duress.

If you put it into legal agreement to pay 75$ a year or 1500$ for intervention otherwise in BIG BOLD LETTERS, it would be all nice and legal. I guess they will do it for the next guy...

I don´t know why you´re so upset. He made his bed, now he can lie in it.

It's probably emotional thing. It looks too much like OT punishment to me: one guy made a decision not to pay measly 75$, his whole family, that probably had nothing with that decision, lost their home and things.

He's a selfish, stupid, irresponsible prickly person, but if he were to sue firemen for liability, and I were in jury, I would have decided for him. If they saved his home and billed him for it, then he sued THEM, I would have decided for firemen.
 
Last edited:
How juvenile, mean-spirited and dangerous a "lesson" is this sort of nonsense? They should have put the fire out and then billed him for it at twice the original rate. He may have been stubborn and stupid but that doesn't mean the fire department (whose job it, assumedly, is to put out fires) shouldn't have done their job or at least taken him up on his offer to pay right then. Why did he have to lose his house? They'd already spent the money on gas and personnel to get to the fire and back to the station so why couldn't they have just put out the fire? I know libertarians love having their wet dreams acted out real-time but for Christ's sake, why can't it be done to actual libertarian's?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom