Ok, let's recapitulate points made in this thread.
One family lost their house because:
1) county, town and fire station made a deal and do not give a **** about little guy. (as befits government, public authorities).
2) Deal was made in such a way that left a "window" open for reckless and stupid behaviour, behaviour against home-owners' best interests.
3) Town doesn't give a **** about county's interests, and town firemen especially.
4) Home owner was stupid enough to "throw himself out of a window" left by point number 2).
5) Thanks to 1) and 3), firemen did absolutely nothing to prevent him from "getting spilled all over concrete", metaphorically speaking.
Did I get that right?
Now, all jokes aside, there are few sides of this issue here:
One side says firemen did the right thing. It wasn't their problem. Guy didn't pay the price (fee), so he doesn't get the service (benefit). This side says that fire department had absolutely no obligations to him.
He perfectly knew what he was doing, he knowingly gambled and lost, he was acting stupid and he SHOULD and have paid the price for his stupidity.
They say it was a rational choice the firemen made, and if you turn it to legalese (lawyer and law language, which is bare minimum of society's morality), they are probably right. It was county's problem for leaving a hole for stupid to fall in, and it was stupid's fault for falling in.
Other side says the first side is wrong on some points. They say the firemen hadn't made rational and/or moral choice. Now, there are different arguments on that side:
One argument says that as a compassionate human beings they should have helped anyway and that it was very cruel to just stand and watch. That, as a firemen, it's their job to extinguish fires and that they should do that job as a public service (serving public interest, and all that...). That argument was considered very immature, good for "perfect world/planet X" but not good for this harsh, unforgiving reality.
Second argument says that burned house was too high a punishment and that he should have been fined instead, given big bill after firemen saved his house. The first sides main problem with this argument is that no one would have paid the fee if they did so. I disagree: if firemen just did their job, they wouldn't have made it into the news and no one would have known about it.
Third argument goes at the issue from purely economic perspective. They say that albeit he didn't pay the fee, there are opportunity costs of not saving a house from fire.
The biggest one is missed property taxes, although there are costs of building new one, buying new things to replace those that were inside the house, higher insurance rates for the whole area and finally, costs of extinguishing fire on other (payer's) property. (That last one is simple logic: if they prevented fire from spreading, they wouldn't have to extinguish it on the place it had spread to).
But, as it was pointed out by the first side, it has nothing to do with fire department. It's not their problem, it's county's problem! It's their problem they have one more homeless family on the (metaphorical) shoulder and less taxes from future period. It's their problem Mr I-won't-pay-firemen will use his money on rebuilding instead on economic expansion. And they are right, as far as that counter-argument goes.
My two cents on that last, economic argument is this: Firemen were extremely unpatriotic. They have refused to protect their fellow American, American property, their county's future and present property, their state's wealth.... nah, let's try that again.
It SHOULD have been their problem. If you look at the really big picture, it WAS their problem. But, if you look at the small one, it wasn't. Why? Because the county doesn't finance them. They do not get any part of that aforementioned personal economic expansion of Mr I-won't-pay-firemen. They don't get any part of (potential) trade tax or property tax or any tax whatsoever. No, what they got was 75$ fee a year. And Mr I-won't-pay-firemen didn't pay that fee.
At the end, I can conclude that human selfishness triumphed once again in this case. Firemen didn't want to work their very dangerous job for free, for a man that haven't paid them. And he hadn't paid them because he was selfish (probably).
Blame it on the lack of human empathy and close the case. He didn't care about them and their needs so, in turn, they didn't care about HIM and his needs.
Edited by Locknar:
Moderated content removed.