Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

I actually agree with you that he was stupid for not accepting it. I also think that he should have been able to correct his mistake when it all got wahooney shaped...

Not he should not - for the same reason that you cannot take out fire insurance after your property starts burning, or buy a lottery ticket after the numbers have been drawn.
 
Congratulations, now the fire dept. revenue has been cut by $73,750 (assuming 1,000 homes and an average of one house fire a year, and also assuming the 1 person actually pays his bill).

Now you have 2 less firemen to respond to fires.

No. Their income is based on the tax payers in the city. This is an additional service they provide, not one that pays their salaries. And when faced between a simple 75$ year vs risking several thousands for a year, the vast majority are clearly going to choose the $75. The few that don't end up paying far more which equates far more people paying $75.

So it can be made so not only do they not lose money, but they make a profit for each fire outside the city line.
 
In fairness, if the guy knew about the $75 fee, you can't say "oh no, I'll do without that thanks" and then do a 180 when it turns out you actually need it.

You know that by not paying, they're not going to save your house if your house goes on fire. They took that risk, and now they're bitching afterward. There's no real excuse for complaining.

Although isn't the obvious solution just to make the payment mandatory and to take it out of taxes in some way? What's the point of making the fire service voluntary? Seems like more hassle.
 
Last edited:
I don't see how anyone can say that just putting out any fire in the covered area is unrealistic, given that five of the eight companies in the county do precisely that. I'm guessing that the marginal costs of extending service are low, on the assumption that they won't make big investments to do so. The $500 (realistically, $250) fee charged to everyone (even subscribers) might even cover it. If nobody in the rural areas will pay an essentially voluntary subscription (I don't actually believe this is true; I've lived in towns where the volunteer fire department went door to door soliciting donations, and I think most people gave at least something), oh well. That means tax rates in the municipality in question don't go down.

The real issue here is one of fairness, but we're already looking at an unfair system. A guy with a million-dollar house just outside of town pays the same $75 fee as the guy in a double-wide, despite the fact that the service is worth much more to him. Another weird consequence here: if they had just extended service everywhere within the covered area, the guy who started the fire would have billed $500. Instead, because he didn't, his neighbor gets it. I don't think the free-ridership problem has been solved.

I don't buy into this burn-the-village-to-save-the-village logic in any case. Is anyone going to have a tax revolution over a failure to decrease taxes because the town's fire department covers outlying areas? No. So just cover them, slap on a nominal fee at the 'point-of-purchase', and avoid the administrative costs (and potential liabilities) of a subscription program.
 
I believe the most Solomonic solution would have been to extinguish the fire on the house, but set fire to the homeowner. That way everything balances out nicely.
 
Congratulations, you just presumed 100% of the population is stupid and unable to recognise a good deal when they see one. Good job!

With the numbers provided the “good deal” is to pay per incident and let everyone else pay the day to day costs.


In any case this incident is a perfect example of a failed approach to the public goods problem. If you have a public good like fire service for everyone and make payment optional it always makes more sense to choose not to pay, which means you either need to charge everyone who does pay extra or have insufficient resources to cover the need. Charging everyone else extra will cause even more people not to pay and ultimately the system collapses.
A common “small government” solution is to simply exclude those who don’t pay in, which results in cases like this one. In fact this fails on 2 fronts because the fire department still needed to put out money to deploy and protect neighbours so the cost to the people who paid in went up anyway and the guy still lost his house.
 
It seems to have worked perfectly well in this case.

If by worked pretty well you mean “punish communities who buy into libertarian ideas” then yes it did. As I pointed out above this was a loose-loose situation for everyone involved, the best way to deal with the problem would have been for the county to add the $75 to the tax bill and be done with it.

I wonder if he bought insurance with the understanding that there was fire protection nearby and that when the insurance company finds out he didn't pay the fee, they turn down his claim.

I know fire protection makes a huge difference in rates in remote areas and if this guy was too cheap/stupid to pay the $75 what are the chances he would tell a little fib to save more money?

I’m guessing he doesn’t get covered even if he had insurance. At the end of the day he will likely end up declaring bankruptcy and passing on the costs to the general public.
 
I’m guessing he doesn’t get covered even if he had insurance. At the end of the day he will likely end up declaring bankruptcy and passing on the costs to the general public.

Not if they set him on fire and sell tickets to see it happen. The more I think about it, the better my solution seems. It would definitely provide much more of an incentive to pay the fee because people wouldn't think they could just pay up when and if it happens to them.
 
Yes, except in this case firemen actually were on the spot. Imagine this situation:

You are getting mugged on the street. There's a policeman nearby and sees it happening. He judges with his expert's eye that your life is not in danger. He has ultra modern mobile phone and approaches you with a question: "Excuse me, sir/ma'am, what is your name? I must check if you paid your taxes, you know."

*types in his phone, connects to server, checks database...*

"Sorry, can't help you. Says here you owe 1200$ in taxes. Unless..." turns to mugger. "Your name and social security number, sir. I must check if you paid your taxes."

*types in his phone, connects to server, checks database...*

"It says here you are due tax return of 45$, sir. Please carry on whatever you are doing." says policeman, then goes away.


That's similar to moral choice firemen had in OP... As I wrote before, they are firemen. It's their job to protect both lives and property.

But why should someone who isn't paying get the benefit of a service? If i order a pizza, i have no problem sharing that pizza with others who paid for it, but not the guy who said " i am not hungry" then decides to steal a slice.

SEeing as fear mongering is the order of the day. What about when the time comes that firemen are putting out a fire for someone who didn't pay, and are too busy to put out the fire for someone who did? Is that fair? Should those of us who chose to pay ( and i actually live in the country , had a fire, and due to paying got fire service.) just be the suckers in this situation?

The list of those who don't pay would be rather small, and could be carried around either in data, or a hardcopy format. The fear that soemone would need to wait for a search is almost unfounded. I would bet my pinky finger that the firefighters in that city knew exactly who did and didn't pay, and were waiting for the day when one of the peoplke on the " no pay " list actually had a fire.
 
In fairness, if the guy knew about the $75 fee, you can't say "oh no, I'll do without that thanks" and then do a 180 when it turns out you actually need it.

You know that by not paying, they're not going to save your house if your house goes on fire. They took that risk, and now they're bitching afterward. There's no real excuse for complaining.

Although isn't the obvious solution just to make the payment mandatory and to take it out of taxes in some way? What's the point of making the fire service voluntary? Seems like more hassle.

No. Their income is based on the tax payers in the city. This is an additional service they provide, not one that pays their salaries. And when faced between a simple 75$ year vs risking several thousands for a year, the vast majority are clearly going to choose the $75. The few that don't end up paying far more which equates far more people paying $75.

So it can be made so not only do they not lose money, but they make a profit for each fire outside the city line.

Finally, some people getting idea I proposed. Ok, proposal's so far are:

1) Make the "fee" mandatory, aka part of tax, so no one can choose to do stupid thing and not pay.
or

2) make the fee obvious choice, compared to alternative. As mentioned above, most people would choose to pay the fee compared to potentionally paying thousands of dollars. Give them choice: Either you pay these pitifull 75$ a year or you'll pay 1,5+ thousands in case of fire.

Not he should not - for the same reason that you cannot take out fire insurance after your property starts burning, or buy a lottery ticket after the numbers have been drawn.

Except, that in this case extra risk and costs for the firemen were minimal (at least until fire reached the house) compared to those of insurance company. And guy wasn't buying insurance, he was buying fire extinguishing service and firemen just didn't want to sell. Instead, they chose to out-Rod the unpaying rod which they successfully did.
 
Last edited:
But why should someone who isn't paying get the benefit of a service? If i order a pizza, i have no problem sharing that pizza with others who paid for it, but not the guy who said " i am not hungry" then decides to steal a slice.

SEeing as fear mongering is the order of the day. What about when the time comes that firemen are putting out a fire for someone who didn't pay, and are too busy to put out the fire for someone who did? Is that fair? Should those of us who chose to pay ( and i actually live in the country , had a fire, and due to paying got fire service.) just be the suckers in this situation?

The list of those who don't pay would be rather small, and could be carried around either in data, or a hardcopy format. The fear that soemone would need to wait for a search is almost unfounded. I would bet my pinky finger that the firefighters in that city knew exactly who did and didn't pay, and were waiting for the day when one of the peoplke on the " no pay " list actually had a fire.

Obviously, paying costumers should get priority, but in this case there was no paying customer to take it. Also, as mentioned before it is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem but wasn't applicable in this case.
 
If by worked pretty well you mean “punish communities who buy into libertarian ideas” then yes it did. As I pointed out above this was a loose-loose situation for everyone involved, the best way to deal with the problem would have been for the county to add the $75 to the tax bill and be done with it.

Your facts are wrong. This isn't the fire department's problem. They provided a service that required advance payment. It is the county that controls tax collection in the area of the fire. The county doesn't have fire protection for whatever reason. This is not a lose-lose situation. The only loser is the home owner who gambled with his investment and lost. It happens all the time.

I’m guessing he doesn’t get covered even if he had insurance. At the end of the day he will likely end up declaring bankruptcy and passing on the costs to the general public.

What costs being passed on are you talking about?
 
Suppose there's 1,000 properties outside the city limits that can be covered by the city for the $75 fee. In any given year, maybe one of those houses needs fire dept. response.

Now suppose it works as you describe, and the fire dept. charges a fee for their costs of fighting the fire. Why would anyone pay the $75? Now the fire dept. gets $75,000 less in revenue every year, and no way can they charge a homeowner $75,000 to fight their fire. The fire dept. will not be able to use that money to pay its firemen, maintain the equipment, or maintain the fire house. Your remedy results in cuts to the fire department.

The $75 doesn't just cover the cost of putting out a fire, it covers the cxosts of keeping a well-equipped firemen on the job 24/7/365. You can't recover those costs after the fact by charging only for fire response.

eta: and when you place a lien on a property you can't collect until the property is sold, which can take decades. And even then you have to get in line with all the other creditors, and you'll be lucky to collect pennies on the dollar.

I wish I had read this when you first posted it (not sure why I missed it). Perfect summation of the issues. Well done.
 
Suppose there's 1,000 properties outside the city limits that can be covered by the city for the $75 fee. In any given year, maybe one of those houses needs fire dept. response.

Now suppose it works as you describe, and the fire dept. charges a fee for their costs of fighting the fire. Why would anyone pay the $75? Now the fire dept. gets $75,000 less in revenue every year, and no way can they charge a homeowner $75,000 to fight their fire. The fire dept. will not be able to use that money to pay its firemen, maintain the equipment, or maintain the fire house. Your remedy results in cuts to the fire department.

The $75 doesn't just cover the cost of putting out a fire, it covers the cxosts of keeping a well-equipped firemen on the job 24/7/365. You can't recover those costs after the fact by charging only for fire response.

You're assuming every resident of the county is stupid. Most people realize it takes money to supply and man a fire station, and I bet most people would happily still voluntarily pay the $75 charge even if firefighters had to occasionally respond to a fire started by someone who hadn't bothered. Most people don't need to see somebody "taught a lesson" to understand how important it is to keep the fire dept. funded.

I don't know how wildfire-prone Mr. Cranick's area of Tennessee is, but in the area surrounding where I live, rural residents are very appreciative of firefighters because they know a very small fire can turn into a very big fire very fast, and take out a lot of peoples' homes, whether they pay into the system or not. People who don't pay still get service (from both rural volunteer depts. and the city dept.), but they get a bill later that costs a lot more than the annual fee.

It doesn't make sense to only offer fire service piecemeal in a rural area. A fire isn't going to recognize property lines and stay within the confines of a non-paying resident's land. If I paid my $75, and my neighbor hadn't, I'd still want the firefighters to hose down his house and land, since I don't want my house to burn if the fire gets out of hand, which it easily can.
 
Maybe in some states, I doubt it'd fly in AZ. I don't think the residents of Maricopa and Pima counties want to foot the bill for the other 13.

They wouldn't necessarily have to if it were structured correctly.
 
Suppose there's 1,000 properties outside the city limits that can be covered by the city for the $75 fee. In any given year, maybe one of those houses needs fire dept. response.

Now suppose it works as you describe, and the fire dept. charges a fee for their costs of fighting the fire. Why would anyone pay the $75?
For the same reason anyone buys insurance of any sort. The insurance industry existed, last time I checked... Yep.

The $75 doesn't just cover the cost of putting out a fire, it covers the cxosts of keeping a well-equipped firemen on the job 24/7/365. You can't recover those costs after the fact by charging only for fire response.
Sure you can. You just have to charge what it actually costs.

eta: and when you place a lien on a property you can't collect until the property is sold, which can take decades. And even then you have to get in line with all the other creditors, and you'll be lucky to collect pennies on the dollar.
Pennies on the dollar is more than zero, which is what they did in fact get for that house.
 
I agree and many people in htis thread want to ignore the fact that there is a system in place that works perfectly well. Pay the fee or the fire department will not fight fires on your property. How simple is that?

Exactly. Lots of folks want to be outraged at the firemen, but if that's the system, the only person to blame is this guy who let his grandson start a fire without adequate precautions (including paying for fire protection).

Under the circumstances, they cannot intervene without putting future fire protection at risk for everybody.
 
Your facts are wrong. This isn't the fire department's problem.?

I never said it was the fire departments fault, it’s clearly the fault of the county for buying into a bad solution.

This is not a lose-lose situation. The only loser is the home owner who gambled with his investment and lost. It happens all the time.

This is a net loss for everyone involved. The guy lost his house, the fire department was forced to deploy in response to a fire caused by someone not paying into their system and the neighbours land values decline because of the burnt out building near their property, the bank will be out the money it lent him to buy the house and the banks customers will be passed along this expense. It’s ridiculous to suggest the owner is the only person to pay the price here.

What costs being passed on are you talking about?

See above. Taxpayers still need to pay for the fire department to deploy, the neighbours hopuse that caught fire will have to be repaired, when the owner declares bankruptcy he will stop paying his mortgage and no longer be responsible for fixing the burnt out house on his former property. These costs will be passed along to the banks other customers and his former neighbours, they don’t vanish just because he goes bankrupt.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom